1/13
Vocabulary flashcards covering key methods, case law, and principles regarding the identification of the accused in criminal law, including Muldoon v Herron, Ralston v HM Advocate, and the Howden principle.
Identification of the Accused
A core element of the case against the accused which must be proven by corroborated evidence.
Dock Identification
The most common method of identifying the accused as the perpetrator in court.
Identity Parade
The second most common method of identification of the accused, cited in cases such as Britz v HM Advocate 2007 SLT 78.
Muldoon v Herron 1970 JC 30
Case establishing that prior identification at the scene confirmed by two police officers provides two independent sources of evidence, upholding conviction even when eyewitnesses cannot identify the accused at trial.
Gubinas v HM Advocate 2018 JC 45
Case holding that a fact finder is entitled to form their own view on video evidence to determine whether an image is the accused or resembles the accused to provide corroboration of a single identification.
De Recenti Statement
A statement made by a complainer which, confirmed by a bench of 9 judges in Lord Advocate's References (Nos 2 and 3 of 2023) 2024 SLT 1207, can corroborate both the fact of occurrence of the crime and the identity of the perpetrator.
Ralston v HM Advocate 1987 SCCR 467
Case establishing that where there is one emphatic positive identification, little else is required, and evidence that an accused resembles the perpetrator is generally sufficient to corroborate an explicit identification.
Farmer v HM Advocate 1991 SCCR 986
Case determining that when a witness identifies the accused and adds the words "I think", the identification may still be treated as a positive identification.
MacDonald v HM Advocate 1998 SLT 37
Case ruling that an identification attempt where the witness stated the accused "doesn't look unlike" the perpetrator did not constitute a positive identification.
Nelson v HM Advocate 1998 SLT 215
Case affirming that identification by build or stating that a person resembled another is capable of corroborating another witness's positive identification if the jury regards it as having sufficient weight.
The Howden Principle
A legal principle providing that if the court is satisfied the accused committed one charge, and similarities between offences prove the same person committed both, there is sufficient identification evidence for both charges.
Howden v HM Advocate 1994 SCCR 19
Leading case where circumstantial similarities between two robberies in Edinburgh within 12 days allowed the jury to convict the accused on both charges despite lacking positive witness identification for the second charge.
Townsley v Lees 1996 SCCR 620
Case which approved and applied the Howden principle based on similarities in dress, hairstyle, and behaviour between offences.
Gillan v HM Advocate 2002 SLT 551
Case in which the Howden principle was not applied because the similarities between the offences were not relevant to the identity of the accused or of a modus operandi special enough to justify that inference.