1/84
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Although the Supreme Court of Canada identified Indigenous over-representation as a crisis in R. v. Gladue (1999), the problem has persisted despite decades of awareness and efforts to address it. In 2016–2017, Indigenous adults represented only 4.1% of Canada's adult population but accounted for 27% of admissions to federal correctional services and 28% of admissions to provincial and territorial correctional services. Furthermore, while overall incarceration declined between 2000 and 2014, the proportion of prison admissions involving Indigenous peoples increased.
Why do David and Mitchell argue that the over-representation of Indigenous peoples in the Canadian criminal justice system remains a pressing issue
The authors explain that most research on Indigenous over-representation has focused on correctional facilities, particularly prisons. Comparatively little research has examined Indigenous peoples' involvement at earlier stages of the criminal justice system, especially their interactions with police. This is partly because correctional data on Indigenous identity are more readily available than reliable police and court data. The authors address this gap by examining whether disproportionate involvement begins at the initial stage of police contact.
What gap in the existing research are David and Mitchell attempting to address
Police officers occupy an influential position because their decisions can determine whether individuals enter the criminal justice process. They decide where to conduct surveillance, whom to arrest, when to lay charges, and what charges to lay. These decisions shape how individuals become involved in the criminal justice system from the very beginning. Consequently, understanding Indigenous over-representation requires examining police practices rather than focusing exclusively on incarceration.
Why do the authors David and Mitchell describe police officers as “gatekeepers” of the criminal justice system
The study examines whether Indigenous peoples in Canada experience disproportionately high levels of police contact compared with non-Indigenous people. Using self-reported encounters from the 2014 General Social Survey, the authors investigate six different reasons for police contact. Their broader objective is to understand whether Indigenous over-representation develops partly through unequal levels of police interaction before individuals reach the courts or correctional facilities.
The authors divide police encounters into three categories. Enforcement contacts involve traffic violations and arrests. Non-enforcement contacts involve encounters where someone is a victim or witness to a crime. Behavioural health-related contacts occur when an individual or a family member experiences emotional, mental health, or alcohol/drug-related problems. This classification demonstrates that police involvement extends beyond encounters involving suspected criminal activity.
The authors argue that police involvement should not be understood exclusively through criminalization or punitive outcomes. Encounters involving victimization, witnessing a crime, or seeking assistance for mental health and substance-related problems also represent significant forms of interaction with the criminal justice system. These encounters shape Indigenous-police relations and may sometimes become precursors to further criminal justice involvement, particularly if an interaction escalates.
Settler colonialism is understood as an ongoing project of colonization in which the objective is to eliminate or displace Indigenous populations and replace them with a sovereign settler collective. It is not simply a historical event that ended in the past. Instead, it is a continuing structure of policies, attitudes, and social mechanisms that shape Indigenous peoples' experiences and relationships with Canadian institutions, including the police and criminal justice system.
The authors argue that the consequences of colonial policies continue to influence Indigenous peoples' lives today. Historical practices such as land dispossession, residential schools, cultural suppression, and the removal of Indigenous children have produced intergenerational disadvantage and trauma. These conditions continue to affect socioeconomic circumstances, mental health, substance use, and relationships with state institutions. Therefore, contemporary police encounters cannot be fully understood without considering the continuing effects of colonialism.
Why do the authors David and Mitchell emphasize that settler colonialism must be understood as an ongoing process rather than a historical event
Settler colonial relations were influenced by beliefs that settlers represented civilization, while Indigenous peoples were portrayed as primitive, degraded, or savage. These racist distinctions justified policies intended to control, assimilate, and displace Indigenous populations. The authors explain that such attitudes have also contributed to negative stereotypes that can influence how Indigenous peoples are perceived and treated by police and other institutions.
The authors identify several practices, including the dispossession of Indigenous lands, the criminalization of spiritual and cultural practices, the forced removal of Indigenous children into residential schools, and the widespread removal of children into child welfare services. These policies disrupted Indigenous cultural traditions, languages, spirituality, family relationships, and sense of belonging. They also caused physical, sexual, psychological, spiritual, and financial harm.
What historical settler colonial practices does the reading David and Megan Mitchell (2021), “Contacts with the Police and the Over-Representation identify as contributing to Indigenous marginalization
Residential schools attacked and denigrated Indigenous cultures, languages, and spirituality while subjecting children to widespread physical and sexual abuse. The authors explain that these experiences produced lasting psychological and physical harm. Some survivors turned to alcohol and drugs as coping mechanisms to numb their trauma. The consequences were transmitted across generations, affecting the health, well-being, and family relationships of Indigenous communities.
The authors connect historical colonial policies to continuing inequalities in education, employment, income, housing, and health. Indigenous peoples are more likely to experience lower educational attainment, unemployment, homelessness, mental health difficulties, and substance abuse than non-Indigenous Canadians. These disadvantages are not presented as isolated individual problems; rather, they are understood within the broader historical and structural consequences of colonial policies.
Criminogenic needs refer to circumstances commonly associated with an increased likelihood of criminal activity or victimization. The authors identify factors such as intergenerational trauma, physical and sexual abuse, mental illness, substance abuse, homelessness, unemployment, and lower educational attainment. They argue that settler colonial policies have contributed to the disproportionate experience of these conditions among Indigenous peoples, potentially increasing their likelihood of encountering police for different reasons.
Historically, police enforced laws and policies designed to control Indigenous populations and promote forced assimilation. Their activities included enforcing the pass system, restricting Indigenous peoples' freedom of movement and gathering, criminalizing cultural and spiritual practices, and forcibly removing Indigenous children from their families and communities to attend residential schools. The police therefore played an instrumental role in implementing colonial policies.
Over-policing refers to the disproportionate imposition of policing and surveillance on particular populations or communities. Under-policing refers to providing inadequate or inferior police services, where requests for assistance and community needs are dismissed or ignored. The authors emphasize that Indigenous communities can experience both conditions simultaneously: they may face excessive surveillance while receiving insufficient protection and assistance when they need it.
Stereotypes such as the “uncivilized savage” and the “drunken Indian” can create assumptions that Indigenous peoples are more likely to engage in criminal activity or require police intervention. These beliefs may encourage police to interpret Indigenous behaviour as threatening or disorderly, even when similar behaviour might not generate the same response toward members of the dominant population. Such attitudes can contribute to disproportionate surveillance and police encounters.
Indigenous communities may receive inadequate police assistance because their members are sometimes treated as less-worthy victims than individuals from the dominant society. The authors discuss reports of Indigenous families being dismissed or ignored when contacting police about violence, including the physical and sexual victimization of Indigenous women and girls. Therefore, a high frequency of police contact does not necessarily mean Indigenous communities receive appropriate protection or support.
Why do the authors David and Mitchell argue that Indigenous peoples may experience under-policing despite being over-represented in police encounters
The National Inquiry documented instances in which police acted inappropriately or failed to respond adequately to requests for assistance involving Indigenous women and girls. Family members and friends described being dismissed or ignored when reporting incidents of physical and sexual victimization. These experiences demonstrate how Indigenous peoples can be over-policed in certain circumstances while simultaneously being denied appropriate protection when they are victims.
Hostile, discriminatory, or involuntary police encounters can weaken Indigenous peoples' trust and confidence in law enforcement. The authors refer to research demonstrating that Indigenous peoples are more likely to experience involuntary police contact and that such experiences are associated with lower confidence in the police. Negative perceptions may also discourage Indigenous individuals from voluntarily contacting police, including when they experience victimization.
The authors suggest that socioeconomic disadvantage and limited access to alternative support systems may leave Indigenous individuals with few options. When someone experiences victimization or a behavioural health crisis, they may have no accessible social or health services to turn to. Consequently, individuals may contact the police out of necessity, even when they distrust law enforcement or have previously experienced discriminatory treatment.
When communities lack adequate mental health services, substance abuse treatment, and culturally appropriate social support, police may become the primary available response to situations that are not inherently criminal. This is particularly relevant in rural and remote Indigenous communities, where resources may be scarce and mental health challenges and suicide rates may be elevated. As a result, police may become involved in situations that could otherwise be addressed through specialized support services.
The authors review international research, primarily from Western countries, suggesting that racial and ethnic minority populations are generally more likely to experience police encounters than majority populations. Much of this research focuses on traffic stops and pedestrian stops, particularly in relation to racial profiling. However, David and Mitchell argue that examining only these forms of contact overlooks other significant interactions, including victimization, witnessing crimes, and behavioural health-related encounters.
Conflict theories and minority threat theories suggest that the state uses policing to maintain the power and social position of dominant groups while suppressing populations perceived as threats to the existing social order. From this perspective, marginalized groups may experience more aggressive or disproportionate policing because their presence or behaviour is perceived as challenging the dominant group's interests and authority.
Social disorganization theories suggest that crime and violence are more prevalent in communities experiencing poverty, unemployment, substance abuse, property damage, and other forms of physical and social disorder. These communities may also have weaker social cohesion and limited collective efficacy. Police consequently concentrate their attention on areas perceived as having higher crime rates, increasing the likelihood that residents will encounter law enforcement.
Although these theories help explain why marginalized communities may experience increased policing, they do not adequately account for the specific historical and political circumstances of Indigenous peoples in Canada. In particular, they overlook how settler colonialism created and continues to reproduce Indigenous socioeconomic marginalization and distrust toward state institutions. The authors therefore argue that settler colonialism offers a more historically grounded explanation.
The authors do not reject conflict theory or social disorganization theory. Instead, they argue that settler colonialism provides the deeper historical and political context necessary to understand why Indigenous communities experience the conditions described by these theories. It explains how colonial policies contributed to socioeconomic disadvantage, marginalization, and unequal power relations, which can subsequently influence policing practices and police contact.
The authors used the 2014 Canadian General Social Survey (GSS) on victimization. The survey collects information about victimization, perceptions of the criminal justice system, and police contacts among Canadians aged 15 and older living in private households. The authors accessed the data through the Canadian Research Data Centres Network, allowing them to examine information from both the provinces and territories. This was particularly important because a significant portion of the Indigenous population, especially Inuit peoples, lives in the territories.
A total of 35,167 individuals completed the survey, representing a response rate of approximately 50%. Statistics Canada required the researchers to apply sampling weights to account for the survey's sampling design and the different probabilities of respondents being selected. This weighting expanded the analysis to represent an estimated population of 29,516,669 people while maintaining the original sample size for the regression analyses.
What was the sample size, and how did the researchers David and Mitchell account for sampling weights
Police contact was measured by asking respondents whether they had interacted with police during the preceding 12 months for six specified reasons. These included traffic violations, arrests, being a victim or witness to a crime, and personal or family mental health and substance-related problems. Indigenous identity was measured through self-identification as First Nations, Métis, or Inuk (Inuit), including both Status and Non-Status First Nations respondents.
How did the researchers David and Mitchell measure police contact and Indigenous identity
The researchers controlled for sex, age, educational attainment, employment status, and area of residence. These variables were included because previous research suggests that younger males and individuals from disadvantaged socioeconomic backgrounds may be more likely to encounter police. Controlling for these factors allowed the authors to examine the relationship between Indigenous identity and police contact while accounting for these other characteristics.
What socioeconomic and demographic variables did the researchers David and Mitchell control for in their analysis
The authors used logistic regression to assess the likelihood of experiencing each type of police contact while accounting for other socioeconomic and demographic factors. Simple cross-tabulations would show differences between Indigenous and non-Indigenous respondents but would not adequately account for these other characteristics. Regression allowed the researchers to examine the unique statistical association between Indigenous identity and each type of police encounter.
Why did David and Megan Mitchell (2021), “Contacts with the Police and the Over-Representationuse logistic regression instead of relying only on cross-tabulations
The results showed that Indigenous respondents were more likely than non-Indigenous respondents to experience police contact for five of the six reasons examined, even after controlling for sex, age, education, employment, and residence. The only exception was traffic stops, for which the results were not statistically significant. This suggests that disproportionate police involvement extends beyond arrests and includes victimization, witnessing crimes, and behavioural health-related encounters.
What was the general finding of the study by David and Mitchell regarding Indigenous peoples' police encounters
The study found no statistically significant difference between Indigenous and non-Indigenous respondents in their likelihood of experiencing a traffic stop. However, Indigenous respondents were 2.89 times more likely to report police contact resulting from an arrest. Although the relative likelihood of arrest-related contact was substantially higher, the authors emphasize that arrest-related encounters remained relatively uncommon in the overall population.
What did the study by David and Megan Mitchell (2021), “Contacts with the Police and the Over-Representation find about traffic stops and arrests
Indigenous respondents were 1.94 times more likely to encounter police as victims of crime and 2.16 times more likely to encounter police as witnesses to crime compared with non-Indigenous respondents. The predicted probability of victim-related contact was 13.63% for Indigenous respondents compared with 7.53% for non-Indigenous respondents. For witness-related contact, the probabilities were 10.30% and 5.05%, respectively.
What did the researchers David and Megan Mitchell (2021), “Contacts with the Police and the Over-Representation find about police contact involving victims and witnesses of crime
Indigenous respondents were significantly more likely to encounter police because of their own mental health or alcohol/drug-related problems, as well as those of a family member. The odds of personal behavioural health-related contact were 2.87 times higher for Indigenous respondents, while the odds of family-related contact were 3.03 times higher. The authors connect these findings to the intergenerational effects of colonial trauma and the limited availability of alternative social and health services.
What did the study by David and Mitchell find about behavioural health-related police encounters
Odds ratios compare the relative likelihood of an outcome between Indigenous and non-Indigenous respondents, after controlling for the selected demographic and socioeconomic variables. Predicted probabilities estimate the actual probability of experiencing that outcome under specified conditions. For example, the study found that Indigenous respondents had 2.89 times the odds of arrest-related police contact, but the predicted probability for the hypothetical Indigenous respondent used by the authors was still only 2.30%. This distinction demonstrates that a substantially higher relative likelihood does not necessarily mean an event is common overall.
What is the difference between odds ratios and predicted probabilities in the study by David and Megan Mitchell (2021), “Contacts with the Police and the Over-Representation
The authors want to broaden the understanding of Indigenous over-representation beyond criminalization and punishment. Police encounters as victims or witnesses are more common than arrest-related encounters, meaning that a significant portion of Indigenous-police relations involves individuals seeking or receiving police attention without necessarily being suspected of a crime. These interactions are important because they shape relationships with law enforcement and contribute to the overall frequency of Indigenous peoples' involvement with the criminal justice system.
Why does david and mitchell emphasize that Indigenous peoples are more likely to encounter police as victims or witnesses than as a result of arrest
One limitation is that the researchers cannot determine the circumstances surrounding each police encounter. They cannot establish who initiated the interaction, why police were contacted, whether alternative forms of assistance were considered, or whether the intervention was legitimate or discriminatory. Another limitation is that the survey measures whether respondents experienced a particular type of contact, but not the total number of encounters. Consequently, it cannot determine how frequently individuals experienced repeated police interactions during the 12-month period.
What are two important limitations of the study by David and Mitchell
Although the findings show that Indigenous peoples are more likely to experience most types of police contact, the data do not establish whether those encounters were justified or discriminatory. Some interactions may reflect over-policing and systemic racism, while others may result from higher rates of victimization, socioeconomic disadvantage, or the absence of alternative social services. Additionally, the survey includes contacts with First Nations police services as well as conventional police services. Therefore, higher contact rates alone cannot establish that every encounter represents inappropriate police intervention.
Why do the authors David and Mitchell caution against interpreting higher police contact rates as definitive evidence of over-policing
The authors argue that understanding Indigenous over-representation requires examining every stage of the criminal justice process rather than focusing exclusively on correctional facilities. Police contact is particularly important because it occurs early in the process and can increase the likelihood of subsequent arrest, charges, and incarceration. They also emphasize the need for better data collection on Indigenous identity, developed in consultation with and for the benefit of Indigenous and racialized communities. Ultimately, understanding how ongoing settler colonial processes contribute to police encounters is essential for addressing the broader problem of Indigenous over-representation.
Policing, Indigenous peoples and social order by Cunneen
Indigenous political activism in the early 1970s sought to draw attention to the discriminatory treatment of Indigenous peoples by state police and the criminal justice system. These concerns became more urgent during the 1980s as governments adopted increasingly punitive approaches to law and order. Indigenous communities challenged the way policing reinforced colonial control and demanded greater accountability and recognition of their rights.
In response to Indigenous political pressure, several major inquiries were established in the late 1980s and early 1990s. These included Australia's Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody (RCADIC), Canada's Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples (RCAP), the Nova Scotia Royal Commission on the Donald Marshall Jr. Prosecution, and Manitoba's Aboriginal Justice Inquiry. These inquiries investigated discriminatory treatment and systemic problems within the criminal justice system.
In Aotearoa New Zealand, Moana Jackson's 1988 report to the Department of Justice was an important step because it examined the relationship between Māori people and the criminal justice system from a Māori perspective. In the United States, the struggle was particularly influenced by the case of Leonard Peltier, an American Indian Movement member convicted of murdering two FBI agents in 1975. His conviction and imprisonment generated widespread criticism and an ongoing campaign for his release.
State policing developed as part of the colonial process of controlling Indigenous populations, enforcing the laws of colonising governments, and protecting settler interests. Police were not simply established to maintain public safety; they also enforced colonial authority and supported assimilation. Consequently, contemporary Indigenous concerns about police discrimination, racism and violence cannot be understood without considering these historical relationships.
In the United States, policing included Indian constables, police forces designed to protect settlers from American Indians, and police forces in the southern states that developed from slave patrols. In Canada, the North West Mounted Police, which later became the RCMP, was established partly to control the Indian and Métis populations. In Australia, Indigenous resistance contributed to the development of border police, mounted police and native police forces.
Criminalisation has historically been used as a means of controlling Indigenous populations by portraying their actions, resistance and political claims as criminal threats. This process legitimises excessive policing, state violence, imprisonment and restrictions on Indigenous people's social and economic participation. It also obscures the historical and political context of Indigenous rights by replacing discussions of sovereignty and self-determination with concerns about law and order.
Criminalisation transforms Indigenous peoples from political communities with inherent rights into racialised groups perceived as threats to public order. By associating Indigenous identity with criminality, the state diminishes recognition of Indigenous political authority and their right to govern their own communities. Their claims to self-determination are consequently treated as criminal justice problems rather than legitimate political demands.
Decolonising criminal justice involves addressing both the institutional practices that reproduce colonial power and the wider narratives that portray Indigenous people as inherently criminal. It requires changing how criminal justice institutions operate while challenging the racialised assumptions that justify discriminatory policing. This process is directly connected to Indigenous self-determination and the recognition of Indigenous political and legal authority.
What does the chapter by Cunneen mean by decolonising criminal justice institutions and the construction of Indigenous people as criminal
During the latter half of the twentieth century, explicitly discriminatory legislation denying Indigenous people active citizenship was replaced by formal recognition of equality. This meant Indigenous people were theoretically entitled to equality before the law and non-discriminatory treatment. However, the formal appearance of racial neutrality did not necessarily eliminate the colonial practices embedded within policing institutions.
“Deep colonising,” developed by Rose, describes how colonial practices and relationships continue to operate within institutions even after formal colonial arrangements have changed. Although Indigenous people may possess formal citizenship and equality rights, institutional practices can continue to reproduce colonial inequalities. In policing, this means contemporary institutions may maintain colonial forms of control while presenting themselves as racially neutral.
Quijano's concept of the “coloniality of power” explains how colonial relationships continue to be reproduced through contemporary institutional processes. Colonialism does not necessarily disappear when formal colonial laws and arrangements change. Policing and the criminal justice system contribute to this process by continuing to construct Indigenous peoples as a colonised and criminalised population.
The inquiries recognised that systemic discrimination could not be properly addressed without Indigenous communities having control over decisions that affected them. Self-determination meant Indigenous peoples should participate in designing and implementing policies and programmes affecting their communities. It also involved recognising their inherent right to establish and govern their own justice systems rather than remaining dependent on colonial state institutions.
Recommendation 188 required governments to negotiate with appropriate Aboriginal organisations and communities when developing or substantially modifying policies and programmes that particularly affected Aboriginal people. Its significance was that self-determination was not supposed to be an optional consideration. Instead, Indigenous participation and decision-making were intended to guide the implementation of the Commission's recommendations.
The Manitoba Inquiry recommended that federal and provincial governments recognise the right of Aboriginal peoples to establish their own justice systems as part of their inherent right to self-government. This recommendation challenged the assumption that justice must be administered exclusively through state institutions. It recognised Indigenous communities as legitimate authorities capable of developing their own systems of law and social control.
The Manitoba Inquiry argued that the justice system had failed Aboriginal peoples on a massive scale because it was insensitive, inaccessible and responsible for disproportionately high arrest and imprisonment rates. Aboriginal people were more likely to be denied bail, spend longer periods in pre-trial detention, have less time with their lawyers and receive custodial sentences. These disparities demonstrated that inequality existed throughout the criminal justice process rather than at only one particular stage.
Institutional racism refers to the way an institution's rules, practices and established habits systematically discriminate against or disadvantage Aboriginal people. It is not limited to the prejudiced attitudes or actions of individual employees. The RCADIC emphasised that racism can exist within individual institutions and in the relationships between different institutions, producing widespread and interconnected disadvantages.
Police discretion influences almost every stage of the criminal justice process, including whether someone is stopped, searched, arrested, charged, diverted or imprisoned. These decisions can determine whether an individual receives a criminal record or has access to alternatives to formal court proceedings. Because discretion is exercised repeatedly, discriminatory decisions can accumulate and contribute to the disproportionate criminalisation of Indigenous peoples.
First, police discretion determines an individual's pathway into and through the criminal justice system, influencing their criminal record, access to diversionary programmes and likelihood of imprisonment. Second, experiences such as arrest, detention, bail and pre-trial custody are themselves punitive, even before a person is convicted. The chapter describes this as a form of “summary justice,” in which individuals experience punishment through the criminal process itself.
Racial profiling occurs when police target individuals based on racial characteristics rather than reasonable grounds for suspicion. The expression “Driving While Indian,” or DWI, describes Indigenous people's experiences of being disproportionately stopped and searched while driving, particularly on roads leading to and from reservations. In South Dakota, Indigenous people reported being targeted based on their race, religious objects hanging from their rearview mirrors and licence plates identifying them as reservation residents.
In New South Wales, police frequently used stop-and-search powers to search young people for prohibited implements such as knives. These searches occurred much more frequently in Aboriginal areas, with some towns reporting that 90–95% of searches were unsuccessful. This suggested that police were using the legislation to target young people, particularly Indigenous youth, without forming reasonable suspicions that they possessed prohibited items.
Move-on powers allow police to direct individuals to leave particular public areas. These powers have been criticised because they can be used against Indigenous people who are simply gathering in public spaces, even when they are not engaging in unlawful behaviour. In New South Wales, Indigenous people represented 22% of those receiving move-on directions despite comprising approximately 2.2% of the state's population. In some areas with large Aboriginal populations, move-on orders were issued at 30 times the state average.
Public order offences can transform Indigenous demonstrations and assertions of political rights into matters of policing and public safety. The chapter uses the Oka crisis in 1990 and the Ipperwash crisis in 1995 as examples in Canada. In both cases, Indigenous peoples asserting rights over land and resources were treated as public order problems, resulting in significant police responses involving riot police, tactical units and, at Oka, the military.
Alcohol restrictions and protective detention have created additional opportunities for police to detain Indigenous people, sometimes for minor conduct that would not otherwise result in imprisonment. In Australia, certain restrictions apply specifically to designated Indigenous communities, with criminal penalties for violations. In Canada, protective detention has disproportionately affected Aboriginal people who are intoxicated in public. These practices have also contributed to deaths in police custody.
These offences are broadly defined, leaving considerable discretion to police officers to decide whether behaviour or language is offensive. This creates opportunities for discriminatory enforcement against Indigenous people. The RCADIC observed that attempts to arrest Aboriginal people for offensive language could escalate into additional charges, such as resisting arrest, assaulting police or hindering police. In some cases, these further offences might never have occurred if the initial arrest had not been attempted.
Indigenous young people are less likely than non-Indigenous youth to receive alternatives to formal court processing. In Aotearoa New Zealand, Māori youth are less likely to receive diversion or be referred to family group conferences. Similarly, Australian studies have found that Indigenous youth are less likely to receive police cautions or referrals to restorative justice youth conferences. This is particularly concerning because these programmes were partly introduced to provide culturally sensitive responses to offending.
Proceeding by arrest involves taking an individual into police custody and potentially requiring a bail determination. Proceeding by summons or a court attendance notice is less punitive because it generally allows the individual to attend court without being detained. The distinction matters because Indigenous people are more likely to be arrested rather than summonsed, exposing them to additional custody, bail restrictions and potential pre-trial detention.
Research in Canada found that Aboriginal youth were approximately 20% more likely to be charged when apprehended than non-Aboriginal youth. In Queensland, most Indigenous young people charged with offences were proceeded against by arrest, while most non-Indigenous youth received notices to appear in court. Similar differences have also been identified among Indigenous adults in Australia.
Research suggests that courts are more likely to impose custodial sentences on individuals who are brought before them through arrest rather than summons, even when the seriousness of the charge and criminal history are considered. Arrest and remand can influence how courts perceive the seriousness of an offence. Additionally, defendants held in custody may feel pressured to plead guilty and have fewer opportunities to prepare their legal defence.
Bail is intended to ensure that defendants appear in court and to protect victims or the community from further offences. However, Indigenous people are more likely to be arrested, meaning they are more likely to face bail determinations in the first place. Research in Canada and Australia suggests that Indigenous people are more likely to be refused bail or unable to meet imposed conditions, resulting in higher rates of pre-trial detention.
Indigenous defendants may experience difficulties because of limited transportation, communication barriers with legal representatives, insufficient understanding of the bail process, unemployment, poverty and physical or mental disabilities. Previous offending histories may also affect their ability to obtain or comply with bail. Additionally, restrictive conditions such as curfews, residential requirements and non-association orders can be difficult to satisfy, potentially causing individuals to be repeatedly returned to court or prison.
The use of excessive force against individuals based on perceived racial characteristics demonstrates how racial profiling and institutional racism can operate through policing. Indigenous people have reported experiencing police violence, racial slurs, intimidation and harassment. Australia's 1991 National Inquiry into Racist Violence found that racist violence against Indigenous people was widespread and severe, with police involvement identified as a major concern.
Deaths in custody reveal the consequences of excessive police discretion, institutional racism, inadequate duty of care and the historical relationship between colonial violence and contemporary policing. Many Indigenous people have died while being detained for relatively minor offences, including public drunkenness and unpaid fines. These deaths demonstrate how ordinary police practices can produce serious and sometimes fatal consequences for Indigenous communities.
The “violence of neglect” refers to the failure of authorities to provide proper care to individuals in their custody, despite having specific responsibilities toward them. It highlights how harm can result not only from deliberate physical violence but also from institutional inaction and negligence. The RCADIC found that custodial authorities often lacked an adequate understanding of their duty of care, and that failures to provide proper care directly contributed to some deaths.
The Saskatoon freezing deaths involved police officers in Saskatchewan arresting Aboriginal people for minor public order offences, driving them outside the city and abandoning them during winter. Several victims died from hypothermia, although one survivor, Darrel Night, was able to provide evidence about the practice. Two police officers were convicted as a result. The cases demonstrate that police violence can involve deliberate actions that place Indigenous lives at risk, rather than simply excessive force or negligence during detention.
Cameron Doomadgee died in police custody on Palm Island in 2004 after being arrested for a minor public order offence. His post-mortem examination revealed serious injuries, including four broken ribs, a ruptured spleen and severe liver damage. His death led to a protest during which the local police station was extensively damaged and the courthouse was burned. The chapter also references the Redfern riot following the death of TJ Hickey. Both cases demonstrate how deaths in custody can expose deeper historical grievances and lead to widespread community resistance.
Under-policing refers to situations in which police fail to respond adequately to crimes and safety concerns affecting Indigenous communities. While Indigenous people may experience excessive surveillance, stops, arrests and enforcement for minor offences, they may simultaneously receive inadequate protection when they are victims of crime. This contradiction demonstrates that Indigenous communities can be over-policed in relation to social control while being under-protected in relation to their safety.
Indigenous women have frequently experienced inadequate police responses to domestic violence, sexual assault, disappearances and murders. In the United States, restrictions on tribal jurisdiction historically prevented tribal police and courts from prosecuting many non-Native offenders who committed violent crimes against Indigenous women. In Canada and Australia, reports have documented failures to investigate disappearances and provide adequate protection. These experiences create distrust of police and discourage Indigenous women from seeking assistance, leaving them more vulnerable to continued violence.
Indigenous community policing refers to approaches to maintaining community safety and social order that are developed and operated by Indigenous communities themselves. These initiatives emerged partly because state police were often ineffective in providing safe communities and were viewed as oppressive. Indigenous community policing is connected to broader demands for sovereignty and self-determination because it allows communities to exercise greater control over their own systems of governance and social order.
In Canada, First Nations self-administered police services allow communities to develop and manage their own police forces, although funding and institutional support remain concerns. In Aotearoa New Zealand, Māori wardens are volunteers who provide community support, assist with patrols and help maintain safety under Māori community institutions. In Australia, Indigenous community police operate under local by-laws, although their powers, training and independence are often limited by state police supervision. In the United States, tribal police departments represent tribal sovereignty, but they frequently face inadequate funding, understaffing, low pay, poor training and restrictions imposed by federal and state jurisdictional arrangements.
Night patrols are Indigenous-led initiatives that operate at the local community level to assist people in need and maintain social harmony. Their activities include dispute resolution, safe transportation, removing people from dangerous situations, connecting individuals to services, preventing family violence and diverting people away from the criminal justice system. Unlike conventional state policing, night patrols rely on Indigenous cultural authority, mediation and persuasion rather than force. They prioritise prevention, assistance and community needs, representing what Porter describes as a form of “counter-policing.”