UK Constitutional Law & Parliamentary Sovereignty (SQE1)

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/80

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

81 Terms

1
New cards

What is the UK Parliament?

The UK's supreme legislative body, consisting of the Monarch, House of Commons and House of Lords.

2
New cards

What are the three components of Parliament?

The Monarch, House of Commons and House of Lords.

3
New cards

What are the main functions of Parliament?

Making/changing law, scrutinising Government, approving taxation/spending, debating issues, representing electorate.

4
New cards

What is parliamentary sovereignty?

The principle that Parliament is the supreme law-making authority in the UK.

5
New cards

What is the traditional Diceyan view of parliamentary sovereignty?

Parliament can make/unmake any law; no person or body can override an Act.

6
New cards

What are the two main aspects of parliamentary sovereignty?

Parliament's positive legislative power and the absence of legal limitation on that power.

7
New cards

What is Parliament's positive legislative power?

Parliament can make or repeal any law it chooses.

8
New cards

What does the absence of legal limitation mean under parliamentary sovereignty?

No other body can legally invalidate or override an Act of Parliament.

9
New cards

Can Parliament bind future Parliaments?

Traditionally, no. A Parliament cannot prevent future Parliaments from repealing legislation.

10
New cards

What is meant by implied repeal?

When a later Act conflicts with an earlier Act, the later Act prevails.

11
New cards

What is the principle of implied repeal?

Later Parliaments can modify or repeal earlier legislation without expressly mentioning it.

12
New cards

What is express repeal?

Where Parliament expressly states that an earlier statutory provision is repealed.

13
New cards

What is the significance of R v Home Secretary, ex p Simms [1999]?

Fundamental rights cannot be overridden by general or ambiguous wording; clear wording is required.

14
New cards

What is the principle of legality?

Parliament must use clear and specific language if it intends to override fundamental rights.

15
New cards

What is the relationship between parliamentary sovereignty and the rule of law?

They can conflict because Parliament can enact oppressive laws, whereas rule of law limits arbitrary power.

16
New cards

Can UK courts generally strike down an Act of Parliament?

No. Parliamentary sovereignty prevents courts from invalidating primary legislation.

17
New cards

What can courts do if primary legislation is incompatible with the ECHR?

Higher courts can issue a declaration of incompatibility under s 4 HRA 1998.

18
New cards

Does a declaration of incompatibility invalidate an Act of Parliament?

No. The legislation remains valid and binding.

19
New cards

What is the significance of R (Jackson) v Attorney General [2005]?

Obiter comments suggested theoretical limits on parliamentary sovereignty if the rule of law is undermined.

20
New cards

What is the legal status of the obiter comments in Jackson regarding sovereignty limits?

They are obiter dicta and do not give courts power to strike down Acts.

21
New cards

What is the House of Commons?

The elected chamber of Parliament, consisting of MPs representing constituencies.

22
New cards

What is the House of Lords?

The unelected chamber of Parliament, consisting of life peers, hereditary peers and bishops.

23
New cards

What is the main constitutional advantage of the House of Commons?

Democratic legitimacy because its members are elected by the public.

24
New cards

What is the main constitutional role of the House of Lords?

Scrutinising legislation, revising Bills, debating issues and providing specialist expertise.

25
New cards

What is the Salisbury Convention?

The Lords will not normally reject Bills fulfilling major Government manifesto commitments.

26
New cards

What are the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949?

Statutes restricting the House of Lords' power to block legislation passed by the Commons.

27
New cards

Can the House of Lords permanently block most public Bills?

No. The Parliament Acts limit the Lords to a delaying power.

28
New cards

What is Royal Assent?

The Monarch's formal approval required for a Bill to become law.

29
New cards

Can the Monarch normally refuse Royal Assent?

No. By constitutional convention, Royal Assent is always granted.

30
New cards

What is delegated legislation?

Law made by executive bodies using powers delegated by Parliament in primary legislation.

31
New cards

Why can delegated legislation raise concerns about parliamentary sovereignty?

It permits rule-making with less direct parliamentary scrutiny than primary Acts.

32
New cards

What are Henry VIII powers?

Statutory provisions allowing ministers to amend or repeal primary legislation via delegated legislation.

33
New cards

Why are Henry VIII powers controversial?

They allow ministers to alter Acts of Parliament without full parliamentary debate.

34
New cards

What is the role of Parliament in scrutinising the executive?

Questioning policies, debating actions, holding committees, and maintaining political accountability.

35
New cards

What is individual ministerial responsibility?

Ministers are accountable to Parliament for departmental administration and personal conduct.

36
New cards

What is collective cabinet responsibility?

Ministers act collectively and must maintain the confidence of the House of Commons.

37
New cards

What is the constitutional significance of Government controlling a Commons majority?

It generally enables the Government to pass its legislative agenda with ease.

38
New cards

Why did Lord Hailsham call the UK system an "elective dictatorship"?

A Government with a majority can pass legislation easily due to weak constraints.

39
New cards

What factors contribute to an "elective dictatorship"?

FPTP system, party discipline, whips, Government control of timetables, and weaker Lords powers.

40
New cards

What is the role of Government whips?

To enforce party discipline and ensure MPs vote in line with Government policy.

41
New cards

What is the significance of the first-past-the-post electoral system?

It often produces single-party Commons majorities without requiring a majority of national votes.

42
New cards

What is parliamentary privilege?

Legal immunities ensuring Parliament and its members can operate freely without external interference.

43
New cards

What does Article 9 of the Bill of Rights 1689 protect?

Freedom of speech and proceedings in Parliament from being questioned in court.

44
New cards

What is the sub-judice rule?

Parliament avoids debating active court cases to avoid influencing judicial proceedings.

45
New cards

What is the relationship between parliamentary sovereignty and judicial review?

Courts review executive actions, but cannot invalidate primary Acts of Parliament.

46
New cards

What is judicial review?

The process by which courts examine the lawful exercise of power by public bodies.

47
New cards

Does judicial review normally consider the merits of an executive decision?

No. It assesses legality, rationality, and procedural fairness, not policy merits.

48
New cards

What are the main sources of executive power reviewed by courts?

Statutory powers and royal prerogative powers.

49
New cards

What is the royal prerogative?

Residual historical powers originally held by the Monarch, now exercised mainly by ministers.

50
New cards

Can Parliament abolish or limit a prerogative power?

Yes. Primary legislation overrides and restricts royal prerogative powers.

51
New cards

What did the Case of Proclamations (1611) establish?

The Crown cannot create new prerogative powers by executive decree.

52
New cards

What did BBC v Johns [1965] establish?

Existing prerogative powers cannot be expanded into new areas.

53
New cards

What did CCSU v Minister for Civil Service [1984] establish?

Prerogative powers are subject to judicial review if the subject matter is justiciable.

54
New cards

What was the significance of Miller (No 2)/Cherry [2019]?

Prorogation advice was held unlawful because it frustrated Parliament's constitutional duties.

55
New cards

Which principles limited the prorogation power in Miller (No 2)/Cherry?

Parliamentary sovereignty and parliamentary accountability.

56
New cards

Which prerogative powers are traditionally non-justiciable?

Foreign affairs, national security, defense, and treaty-making.

57
New cards

What did Miller (No 1) [2017] establish about treaty-making?

Treaty-making is a prerogative power generally not subject to judicial review.

58
New cards

What is the constitutional importance of parliamentary scrutiny?

It secures political and democratic accountability for executive actions.

59
New cards

What methods does Parliament use to scrutinise Government?

Questions, debates, select committees, opposition days, and legislative scrutiny.

60
New cards

What are select committees?

Parliamentary bodies examining departmental spending, policies, and administration.

61
New cards

What is the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman?

An independent officer investigating complaints of public administration maladministration.

62
New cards

Are the Ombudsman's decisions binding on ministers?

No.

63
New cards

What is the significance of the Constitutional Reform Act 2005?

It reinforced judicial independence, reformed the Lord Chancellor, and created the Supreme Court.

64
New cards

Why is the UK constitution described as having parliamentary sovereignty?

Parliament is the supreme legal authority and primary legislation cannot be invalidated by courts.

65
New cards

How does parliamentary sovereignty differ from popular sovereignty?

Parliamentary places supreme legal power in Parliament; popular places ultimate power in voters.

66
New cards

What is the difference between legal and political limits on Parliament?

Legal limits are enforceable by courts; political limits arise from elections, conventions, and public opinion.

67
New cards

What are examples of political constraints on Parliament?

Elections, public opinion, party discipline, conventions, and international relations.

68
New cards

Why is parliamentary sovereignty a legal principle rather than unlimited political power?

It defines legal supremacy, but real-world exercise is constrained politically.

69
New cards

What is the key SQE distinction between Parliament and Government?

Parliament makes law (legislature); Government enacts and administers law (executive).

70
New cards

Can Government ministers also be members of Parliament?

Yes. Executive ministers sit in either the Commons or the Lords.

71
New cards

Why does executive-legislative overlap create constitutional concerns?

Government majorities in Parliament reduce independent oversight of executive actions.

72
New cards

What is the tension between parliamentary sovereignty and the rule of law?

Parliament can pass oppressive laws legally, violating rule of law values.

73
New cards

What is the tension between parliamentary sovereignty and judicial power?

Courts interpret statutes but cannot strike down primary laws even if problematic.

74
New cards

What is the SQE rule on Acts of Parliament and courts?

Courts must enforce primary Acts due to parliamentary sovereignty.

75
New cards

What is the SQE rule on s 4 HRA 1998?

Declarations of incompatibility do not invalidate or disapply primary legislation.

76
New cards

What is the SQE rule on the principle of legality?

Clear and express statutory language is required to override fundamental rights.

77
New cards

What is the SQE rule on prerogative powers?

Courts determine their existence/scope and can review their exercise if justiciable.

78
New cards

How do UK and US approaches to judicial review of primary legislation differ?

US courts can strike down unconstitutional statutes; UK courts cannot.

79
New cards

What is the significance of Marbury v Madison (1803)?

It established US Supreme Court authority to strike down unconstitutional laws.

80
New cards

What is the primary definition of parliamentary sovereignty for SQE1?

Parliament is supreme law-maker; courts cannot strike down primary Acts.

81
New cards

What are major SQE1 traps regarding parliamentary sovereignty?

Courts cannot invalidate primary Acts; s 4 HRA doesn't void laws; implied repeal applies; prerogatives are reviewable.