1/26
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Article 1305 of the Civil Code
A ________ is a meeting of minds between two persons whereby one
binds himself, with respect to the other, to give something or to
render some service.
Under Philippine civil law
(Article 1159),
obligations arising from
contracts have the
force of law between
the contracting parties
and should be complied
with in good faith.
contract
A _____ is inherently
relational and economic.
It establishes a juridical
tie where one party
assumes a passive
subject role while the
other party assumes an
active subject role.
contract
Contracting parties may establish such stipulations, clauses,
terms, and conditions as they may deem
convenient, a _______ is fundamentally limited
by law.
Consent
(1) ____ of the contractingparties;
Object certain
(2)______ which is the subject matter of the contract;
Cause of the obligation
(3)___________which is established.
Contract of adhesion
is defined as one in which almost all the provisions have been drafted
only by one party (such as corporation or insurance company). The only
participation of the other party is the signing of his signature or
adhesion. The party who adheres to it is in reality free to reject entirely;
but if he adheres, then he gives his consent.
Nature & Validity
Provisions are drafted entirely by one
party. The customer’s participation is
signing or adhering (“take it orleave”).
Autonomy of Contracts
Contracting parties may establish such stipulations,
clauses, terms, and conditions as they deem
convenient, provided they are not contrary to law,
morals, good customs, public order, or public policy.
Consensuality (Perfection
by mere consent)
In general, contracts are perfected by mere consent
(Article 1315). Consent requires: capacity, intelligent
and free will, and agreement on the object and cause
Mutuality of Contracts
A contract must bind both
parties; its validity or compliance cannot be left to
the will of one of them (Art. 1308).
Relativity of Contracts
Contracts take effect only between the parties, their assigns
and heirs, except in cases where rights and obligations are
not transmissible by nature, stipulation, or provision of law
(Art. 1311).
Vices of Consent under Article 1330
A contract where consent is given through mistake, violence,
intimidation, undue influence or fraud is voidable.
Mistake
May be attributed to the nature of
human to commit error whether
in fact or in law. Mistake of fact
may arise if there is an ignorance
or lack of knowledge on the
object of the contract
Violence
For a violence to be considered as
a vice of consent that could vitiate
consent, it must be serious or
irresistible. The contract would
have been a void contract if the
consent is obtained only because
of the use of violence.
Intimidation
The use of intimidation by one of
the parties to the contract to
obtain the consent of the other
party can vitiate the consent if
there is an infliction of mental
pain.
Undue influence
Undue influence is a direct
influence that overpowers the mind
of the party to decide based on the
ideas and principles of the others.
There must have a proof that the
one induced to perform an
obligation was a weaker party; that
influence is improperly exerted.
Fraud
The presence of fraud is evident if there are insidious words or
if there is a scheme or machination which induces the other
party to enter into a contract. Casual fraud is committed by
one party in order that the other party would agree to the terms
and conditions of the contract. It may be committed through the
concealment or non-statement of the material facts. Incidental
fraud on the other hand pertains to the fraud without which
consent would have still been given but the person giving it
would not have agreed. This fraud is incidental to the
performance of an obligation.
Defective Contracts
Defective contracts are those that suffer from some flaw or imperfection from the
very beginning, or affect the interests of third parties or justice, making them
susceptible to different degrees of legal sanction.
Rescissible Contracts
These are contracts that are
validly agreed upon because
all essential elements are
present and there is no defect in
consent, but they cause
economic damage or lesion to
one of the parties or to a third
person (like a creditor).
Voidable Contracts
These contracts are binding and
valid until they are annulled by
a competent court. The defect
stems from a flaw in consent
(vitiated by mistake, violence,
intimidation, undue influence, or
fraud) or incapacity of one party
to give consent (such as minors
or insane persons).
Unenforceable Contracts
These contracts cannot be
enforced by a court action
unless they are first ratified. They
are valid in terms of having all
essential elements, but they lack
certain legal requirements (such
as being in writing under the
Statute of Frauds)
Void Contracts
These are absolute nullities. They produce no legal effect
whatsoever from the beginning (quod nullum est nullum producit
effectum) and cannot be cured or ratified.
They cannot be ratified, the action to declare them void does not
prescribe, and anyone interested (or even the State) can invoke
their nullity.
CATHAY PACIFIC AIRWAYS, PETITIONER, VS. JUANITA REYES, WILFREDO REYES,
MICHAEL ROY REYES, SIXTA LAPUZ, AND SAMPAGUITA TRAVEL CORP., RESPONDENTS
Summary of Facts: In March 1997, Wilfredo Reyes purchased four round-trip airline tickets
from Manila to Adelaide, Australia (via Hong Kong) for himself, his wife Juanita, their son Michael
Roy, and his mother-in-law Sixta Lapuz, through Sampaguita Travel Corp., utilizing flights
operated by Cathay Pacific Airways.
The family completed the outbound trip without issue. However, prior to their return flight, multiple
Passenger Name Records (PNRs) and booking complications arose due to conflicting entries and
failure to properly input ticket numbers within the required system windows. Although a Cathay
Pacific staff member in Adelaide verbally assured Wilfredo that their return reservations were
secure, upon arriving in Hong Kong for their connecting flight to Manila, three members of the
family (Wilfredo, Juanita, and Michael Roy) were denied boarding because the flight was fully
booked, forcing them to wait overnight and fly back the following day.
The passengers filed a complaint for damages against both Cathay Pacific and Sampaguita Travel
Corp. for breach of contra
The Legal Issue
1. Whether Cathay Pacific is liable for breach of contract of carriage for disallowing the
passengers to board.
2. Whether Sampaguita Travel Corp. (the travel agency) is likewise liable for damages due to
booking negligence.
The Ruling
As to Cathay Pacific (The Airline): Yes, Cathay Pacific is liable. Under Article 1305 and the
laws governing common carriers, the issuance of confirmed tickets creates a binding contract of
carriage. Cathay Pacific breached this contract when it unjustifiably denied the passengers
boarding on their scheduled return flight despite holding valid tickets and receiving assurances
from airline personnel.
As to Sampaguita Travel Corp. (The Travel Agency): Yes, it is also liable. While a travel
agency is not a common carrier (its relationship with the passenger is a contract for service,
governed by ordinary obligations under Article 1173), Sampaguita Travel was negligent in failing to
properly input correct ticket numbers and managing the electronic booking records (PNRs), which
directly contributed to the reservation chaos.
Damages Awarded: Because the passengers did not suffer actual or substantial monetary losses
(having only experienced inconvenience and an overnight delay), the Supreme Court ruled that
they were only entitled to nominal damages. Furthermore, because the combined negligence of
both the airline and the travel agency served as the proximate cause of the technical injury, Cathay
Pacific and Sampaguita Travel were held jointly and severally (solidarily)