1/79
Fall
Sole proprietorships
Simplest form of carrying on a business. Not a separate entity from the proprietor. They are owned and operated by one person who retains all profits and assumes all liabilities. Income from the business is taxed directly in the hands of the proprietor. Other than declaring a trade name, no docs are required to be filed.
Corporations
Legal entities separate from owners, which can own assets, incur liabilities, and issue stock. Corporations are subject to corporate taxes and provide limited liability protection to their shareholders with exceptions.
Registration Requirment of Corporations
Articles of Incorporation in the prescribed form must set out the corporation's name, classes, any maximum number of shares, restrictions on share transfers, number or minimum or maximum of corporate directors and any restrictions on the corp’s business. Articles of Incorporation must be submitted to a registry agent with fee, NUANS name search reserving the name, notice of directors and notice of address.
Unlimited Liability Corporations (ULCs)
An exception to the limited liability of corporations. In ULCs, owners may be personally liable for corporate debts, allowing for taxation benefits while retaining personal risk. This structure is often used for foreign corporations operating in Canada. The articles must state that “the liability of each of the shareholders of the unlimited liability corporation for any liability, act or default of the unlimited liability corporation is unlimited in extent and joint and several in nature” Corporations names must end with the words “ —-”.
Exception to the Limited Liability Principle of Corporations
A shareholder signs a personal guarantee for the corporation’s debts,
A shareholder has contracted personally without giving adequate notice to a third party that he or she was acting as an agent for the corporation,
• Loss occurs as a result of a shareholder’s personal act or negligence,
• A shareholder has not fully paid for his or her shares, to the extent of the unpaid amount,
• Personal liability is provided for by statute, for example, under s 38 of the BCA,
• A shareholder has assumed the powers of a director under a unanimous shareholders agreement (BCA, s 146),
• A shareholder has received over-payments on liquidation (BCA, s 227),
• A court has “lifted the corporate veil”
Volzke Construction v Westlock Foods, 1986, ABCA
Facts: Mr. Shefsky was the main shareholder of Westlock Foods (defendant/respondent). Volzke
Construction (plaintiff/appellant) undertook to build the Westlock Shopping Centre, which was
80% owned by Bonel Properties, and 20% owned by Westlock Foods.
- Volzke was not paid in full. It was accepted as fact that amounts went unpaid ($77,000) and a contract did exist
- Volzke brought action against Westlock, alleging that Westlock Foods is a partner of Bonel
Ratio: Control is not a factor to determine partnerships. The domain of sharing profits and interest in how the enterprise is being managed = partnership. Cannot say ‘we are not a partnership’ if they are acting like it.
McDonic estate v Hetherington (Liability of partners through authority)
Facts: Mr. Watt was a partner with at a legal firm. He was partners to Hetherington et al. (partner defendants) and was retained by Ms. McDonic and Ms. Cooper (plaintiffs) for an investment transaction. Watt made various investments for the plaintiffs. Some loans were insufficiently secured. He failed to protect their interests.
- The plaintiffs eventually lost several hundred thousands of dollars, so they bring action against Watt and all other partners
PH: At trial, partners were not liable since Watt was just an advisor, outside a law firms authority
Issue: Are the defendants, as Watt’s partners, liable to the plaintiffs for their loss based on actual or apparent authority of agency? (was there an agency relationship?)
Ratio : It is the nature of the activity, and not how it was performed, that will determine whether the activity falls in the scope of that firms ordinary business. Apparent authority is determined by a consideration of whether the person dealing with the partnership would reasonably regard the partner as acting on behalf of a partnership. Express authority can be cemented from the authorization of the other partners. Implied authority does not have to be grounded in the industry standard for ordinary business, but the ordinary business of that specific company.
- Representations to ground apparent authority don’t need to be express, but the conduct being done on the partners behalf and therefore cloaked the agent in apparent authority
Partnerships
2 or more people engaged in a business in common with the view to make profit. Partners are agents for each other and for the firm, for the purpose of the business of the partnership. Presumption that the income of the partnership is shared equally.
Joint Liability
In a partnership, each individual is liable to the full extent of the debts and obligations of the firm incurred. S.11 of the Partnership Act. This is the presumption of Partnership.
Several Liability
In a partnership context, several liability means that each partner is only responsible for their own share of the obligations and debts, not the entire amount, allowing for individual liability in legal claims.Separate liability based on apportionment according to fault/responsibility.
General Partnerships
Very simple form. Jointly and severally liable for the tortious activities of other partners (s. 11(2) of Partnership Act). Non-special partners of this have unlimited liability (s.51 of PA).
Limited Partnerships
A form of partnership where at least one partner has limited liability, typically involving general partners who manage the business and limited partners who contribute capital but do not participate in day-to-day operations. Think of limited partners as investors. Can be a general partner & limited partner at the same time. Limited partner only liable to the extent of their property or investment in the partnership.
S. 64 of Partnership Act
Limited partners eliminate their limited liability if he takes responsibilities of a general partner.
Limited Liability Partnerships (LLP)
Only available to certain professions. Governed by s.81-104 of the Partnership Act. If one of the LLP partners are negligent, the other partners are shielded from personal liability. It absolves you from liability of the tortious acts of your partner. Remain liable for the ordinary debts of the firm.
S.6 of Partnership Act
Each partner is an agent of the firm and of the other partners regarding the business.
Exceptions to the principle of limited liability for a corporation’s shareholders
A shareholder signs a personal guarantee for the corporation’s debts,
A shareholder has contracted personally without giving adequate notice to a third party that he or she was acting as an agent for the corporation,
Loss occurs as a result of a shareholder’s personal act or negligence,
A court has “lifted the corporate veil or pierced it”
A shareholder has not fully paid for his or her shares, to the extent of the unpaid amount,
A shareholder has assumed the powers of a director under a unanimous shareholders agreement - fiduciary duty
Personal liability is provided for by statute, for example, under s 38 of the BCA,
A shareholder has received over-payments on liquidation
s.81 of Registration of Alberta LLPs
Eligible professions means a profession or discipline that is regulated by an Act of Alberta that specifically authorizes members of the profession or discipline to carry on a business through a corporation that has the words “Professional Corporation” or “P.C” as part of its name.
Methods of Incorporation
Royal Charter/ Letters Patent
Memorandum of Association
Articles of Incorporation
Royal Charter
A historical method of incorporation. Issued by a monarch, granting rights to establish a corporation. Most famous example is the Hudson’s Bay Company.
Letters Patent
This method is a direct descendant of the Royal Charter. Involves an application made to a govt bureaucrat/ Crown rep who issues an incorporating doc. It is the constitution of the new company, contains the name, business purpose, ownership/ share structure but NOT the by-laws/ rules governing day-to-day operations. Still used in Prince Edwards Island.
Memorandum of Association
A legal document required for incorporation that outlines the company's constitution, objectives, and details about shareholders. Incorporation is achieved by registering this and articles of association. The articles set out the day-to-day operating rules. Still active in Nova Scotia and BC. In Alberta, this is used to incorporate not-for-profit corps.
Articles of Incorporation
Filed with the appropriate govt body. This serves as a legal document that establishes a corporation's existence and outlines its structure, capital structure, purpose and general matters. Used in majority of provinces including Alberta, Ontario, NL, Saskatchewan, NB and Manitoba. Must include the name of the corporation, classes and any maximum number of shares that the corp is authorized to issue, any restrictions on the transfer of shares, number of directors or the minimum & maximum number of directors, any restrictions on the business that the corporation may carry on, the registered office address, and any other provision.
Actual Express Authority
The authority which the principal has expressly given the agent by the terms of their agreement (can be written or oral)
Actual Authority
The authority which in fact the agent has been given by the principal under the agreement made between them.
Implied Authority
The authority that is not explicitly stated but is assumed to be granted to the agent to carry out their duties effectively. This includes powers that are necessary to and ordinarily incidental to fulfilling the agent's role.
Apparent Authority
Based on the doctrine of estoppel. When a principal's conduct/ representation leads a third party to reasonably believe that an agent has the authority to act on the principal's behalf, even if the agent does not have actual authority. To assert the existence of this authority, it must be proven that the third party relied on this representation and acted on it to their detriment.
Section 12 (1) of Partnership Act
A partner in Alberta LLP is not individually liable directly or indirectly by means of indemnification, contribution, for debts, obligations or liabilities of the partnership or another partner that arise from the wrongful acts of negligence, wrongful acts or omissions, malpractice, or misconduct of another partner or employee, agent or representative of the partnership, that occur in the ordinary course of carrying on a practice in an eligible profession within the meaning of s. 81.
Business Corporations Act s. 16 (1)
The corporate has the capacity and subject to this Act, the rights of a natural person.
Salomon v Salomon
Facts: S had a sole proprietorship that he incorporated and lend his own cash to the company to become its secured debtor. Business failed and went into liquidation. S took priority in getting his assets back while unsecured creditors got nothing.
Issue: Is Mr. S personally liable for the debts of the company ? NO
Is S a genuine creditor of the company? YES
Ratio: “The company was a real one and not a fiction or a myth”, the company is a separate legal entity; distinct from shareholders, directors and incorporators.
• There was no fraud, no dishonest and not a scheme; S as a shareholder did not lose his limited liability protection.
ABCA S.46 Shareholder Immunity
Shareholder immunity. A controlling shareholder of a corporation does not have personal liability for the debts or obligations of the corporation.
Directors
Fiduciary duty owed to act in the best interests of the corporation and its shareholders, and must exercise care, diligence, and skill in their decision-making.
Special acts of incorporation
Used by fed & prof government to create a corporation for a specific & distinctly identified purposes and may only acct for those purposes.
Canadian Jorex Ltd v 477749 Alberta Ltd, 1991
Facts: The Directors of Jorex (D) called a special meeting on Dec 10, but then cancel the meeting by notice on Nov 27.
Minority shareholders (P) would lose the right to examine the auditor of the corporation if the meeting is cancelled. So, they applied for an order declaring the notice of cancellation was of no force and effect.
Issue: Do the directors of the corporation have the power to cancel a special meeting called by them in advance of its advanced date?
Ratio: Section 101 codified this: (1) Subject to any unanimous shareholder agreement, the directors shall manage or supervise the management of the business and affairs of the corps. Unless there is explicit prohibition of something by the ABCA or bylaws, residual powers include the right to do so
i. Section 17(1) shows a bylaw is not needed to give powers to directors
ii. There is no bylaw saying directors can’t cancel meetings, so they can
c. Read together, unless prohibited by bylaw or USA, provisions grant directors the power to cancel meetings under residual powers of s101(1).
Section 101 was designed to give powers to directors and not restrict it.
ABCA s. 5
One or more persons may incorporate a corporation by signing articles of incorporation and complying with section 7 (roles of incorporator)
ABCA s. 1(x)
“person” includes an individual, partnership, association, body corporate, trustee, executor, administrator, or legal representative
▪ a person under 18 can sign the documents in Alberta
CBCA s.5
One or more bodies corporate or individuals who are 18 or older, not incapable, and not bankrupt
ABCA s.7
An incorporator shall send to the Registrar the articles of incorporation and the documents required by ss 12(3) ( name of corp including NUANs), 20 (Notice of address) & 106 (notice of directors).
ABCA s. 12
A name is prohibited if it is prohibited by the regulations; “identical” to the name of an ABCA corporation, CBCA corporation, or an extra provincial corporation registered in Alberta; or if it is similar such that the use of that name is confusing or misleading.
Business Corporations Regulation s.5 (a), (b)
A name is similar if it would reasonably lead to the inference that it is associated/affiliated with another corporation or if it is so similar to another name that it creates confusion among the public (mistakenly believe it is the other corporation).
Business Corporations Regulation s.4 (1)
If name is similar to existing corporate name, consent must be obtained + filed
Business Corporations Regulation s.4 (2)
If a name is similar to name of a dissolved corporation it cannot be used unless the other corporation has been dissolved for 3 years or more.
Business Corporations Regulation s.15
In determining whether a name contravenes section 12 and the regulations, the Registrar may, without limitation, consider the following:
(a) the distinctiveness of the name or any element of it and the extent to which the name has become known;
(b) the length of time the name has been in use;
(c) the nature of the business carried on under or associated with the name, including the
likelihood of any competition among businesses using such a name;
(d) the nature of the trade with which a name is associated, including the nature of the goods or services and how they are offered or distributed;
(e) the degree of similarity between the name and another name in appearance or sound;
(f) the geographic area in Alberta in which the name is likely to be used.
Business Corporations Regulation s.6
Unless a proposed name through use acquired a distinctive meaning, the name may not be used if :
The name is too general, is only descriptive of goods and services,
Is primarily or only the name (or surname) of an individual who is living or died within 30 years of incorporation or name of a geographical area
ABCA s.10
the word “Limited”, “Limitée”, “Incorporated”, “Incorporée” or “Corporation” or the abbreviation “Ltd.”, “Ltée”, “Inc.” or “Corp.” shall be the last word of the name of every corporation…”
An Alberta Corporation Name must have these 3 elements
Distinctive: A distinctive element is a unique word or location that makes your corporation name unique from others.
Descriptive : A descriptive element conveys the nature of the business or its services.
Legal Element: All Alberta corporations are required to have a legal element at the end of their name like Ltd.
Test of Confusion : Aquatera Utilities Inc. v Aquaterra Water Management Inc
Whether the names of two companies side by side either visually or orally appear the same or similar in the sense that the similarity of the names would probably not possibly deceive.
Paws Pet Food and Accessories Ltd V Paws and Shop Inc
Facts: Paws Pet Food and Accessories Ltd. (Applicant) was formed in 1987 under the ABCA
- Paws and Shop Inc. (Respondent) was formed in 1991 under the ABCA
- Both corporations operated retail shops in Calgary and sold the same types of products
Issue: Should the Registrar force R to change its name? YES
Holding: the fact that customers believed R was a second store means that they were misled and confused. Reasonable inference that they are affiliated. Directed the registrar to require the respondent to change its name.
Stenner
Facts: P, committed to sell his book of business to his daughter with a phased retirement but later due to a fall out, daughter moved to their competitor’s company. Then started to use her last name Stenner in ads and promotions, which led to confusion in the marketplace. P sued competitor for passing off. The court ruled that she could not use the name to benefit from the goodwill of the business she was supposed to inherit. P had also trademarked the name.
Passing off vs Trademark infringement
This one: Allows for exclusive use but requires confusion of public, existence of good will (benefit of a good name, reputation and connection of business) from P and actual or potential damages to P.
Vs
The other one: Allows for exclusive use but does not require confusion.
Unanimous Shareholder Agreements (USAs)
s. 146 of the ABCA.
146 (1): An agreement among all shareholders that provide for any or all of the following:
a) regulation of the rights and of the shareholders and any other party to the agreement
b) the regulation of the election of directors
c) the management of the business and affairs of the corporation, including the powers and duties of officers and directors, and restrictions on powers (of the directors as well).
d) any other matter that may be contained in a unanimous shareholder agreement pursuant to any other provision of this Act.
146 (2): If this is in effect at the time a share is issued by a corporation to a person other than an existing shareholder,
(a) that person is deemed to be a party to the agreement whether or not the person had actual knowledge of it when the share certificate was issued,
Cicco v 609940 Ontario Inc (Trustee of) : USA is an internal doc, not binding to a third party
Facts: 609 carried on a business as a Five Star Auto. B = director and 50% shareholder.
B + C enter into USA which states decisions affecting the corporation shall be made only consent of B+C personally
B+C have a falling out where C resigns as a director and B carries on business as a director. B assumes liability and responsibilities of C, who transfers his shares to B, but he is still party to USA.
B, without C’s consent, adopts a director’s resolution to make an assignment in bankruptcy (transfers all assets to an insolvency trustee).
Ratio: USA is an entirely internal matter between the director and the shareholders (or a third party when they agreed to it), it does not disentitle a trustee to rely on the assignment.
Holding: Here, the bank had no notice of the USA and was not privy therefore, B’s actions cannot be undone even if the USA did not allow his actions.
Corporate Shares
Intangible property, a company can issue a common divided right to profits (participation interests of the company). Shareholders do NOT have assets to the corporate assets, those belong to the company. If a corporation is dissolved then the shareholders are only entitled to a proportional value of those assets and not the specific assets (and only what remains after debt repayment and the money owed to bond holders, who technically lent money). Issued by a director but a person may acquire shares through another shareholder transferring the shares.
ABCA S. 26 (3) (Classification of shares)
If a corporation has only one class of shares, the rights of the shareholders are equal in all respects and include the rights
a) to vote at any meeting of shareholders
b) to receive dividends declared by the corporation
c) to receive the remaining property of the corp on dissolution.
ABCA S.26(4): Classification of shares
If a corporation has more than one class of shares, the rights of each class may differ but they must be set out in the articles.
b) the rights set out in subsection (3) shall be attached to at least one class but all of those rights does not need to be attached to one class.
Common Shares (equity shares)
Confers full rights to participate in the Corp, including unrestricted voting rights, dissolution and dividends.
Since holders of common shares only get paid dividends after satisfaction of other claims against corps (including debtors and preference shares) its great when company is growing but risky when Corp gets dissolved.
Preference Shares
Special shares with a preferential right which causes it to get priority over common shares in terms of dividend payments and asset distribution upon dissolution.
Non-preference Special Shares
Subject to a limitation rather than a right
Canadian Securities Regulation: relates to the distributing corporation only, which must file with the securities registry
Securities are provincially regulated, however, the federal government still has the jurisdiction of criminal enforcement in those areas (though there will be a federal securities regulator at some point)
Pre-Incorporation Contracts
A contract that is entered into the name of, on behalf of or in trust for, a corp that is yet to be incorporated.
OLD LAW (NOW CHANGED)
Liability under these contracts are governed by 2 rules (kelner v Baxter)
Person who signed contract on behalf of yet to be incorporated company was personally liable for the contract and
after the company gets incorporated, the corporation could not ratify the contract and relieve the person from personal liability.
Issues with Kelner approach: The courts could therefore not overcome the conceptual difficulty that a non-existent person could agree (by subsequent ratification or adoption) to become subject to obligations incurred on its behalf before its creation.

ABCA S. 15(2) (pre-incorporation contracts)
If a person enters into a written contract on behalf of a body incorporate before it comes into existence, that person will be a promoter. That person is deemed to warrant to the other side that; the corporation will come into existence within a reasonable amount of time AND that the contract will be adopted within a reasonable amount of time =
you’re not liable on the contract, but liable for the breach of the warranty
ABCA S. 15 (3) :
Corporation may, within reasonable time of coming into existence, ratify the contract o When it does so, the promoter gets released and the corporation is bound by the contract and is entitled to the benefits of the contract as if it had been in existence the whole time and had been a party to it.
ABCA S. 15(4)
A person can apply to the court for an order that the corp return any benefits they received under the contract if they ended up not ultimately adopting the contract - indicates corporation came into existence
ABCA S. 15 (6)
A person who enters, or purports to enter, a contract on behalf of a body corporate before it comes into existence is not liable if the contract expressly states that they are not liable.
Wickberg v Shatsky et al - How we measure damages of warranty under the ABCA
Facts: Shatsky’s (D) became directors of Rapid Addressing Systems Ltd
P was hired to be the new manager for the business.
May 9, 1999: P received employment contract on Rapid data letterhead.
It was signed by Lawrence Shatsky as President of rapid data.
Later, P was told that RD is dropping Ltd from its name and fired P for not working on purely commission basis.
Issue: Whether Lawrence is personally liable
Analysis: No personal liability under contract, but breach of warranty established
- Nominal damages awarded for breach of warranty
The fact that Rapid Data (Western) Ltd. was not incorporated and the fact that Rapid Data (Western) Ltd. was not the operator of the business did not cause the plaintiff’s loss.”
- Takeaway: the damages contemplated by section 15(2)(c ) that can be received would be nominal.
Corporate Veil
It represents the corporation as separate from shareholders & other stakeholders (i.e directors and officers). This is not impenetrable.
Yaiguaje v Chevron Corporation: Cannot pierce Corp veil
Facts: Chevron Corporation damaged lands in Ecuador and caused health problems to citizens. The citizens sued the main company in the US and got a judgment against it but had to enforce it elsewhere. They tried to enforce it against Chevron Canada (a subsidiary of Chevron US). They tried to lift the corporate veil between the subsidiary and parent company to access the assets.
Holding: Unsuccessful in lifting the corporate veil because both companies maintained corporate separateness.
Ratio: Out of the three reasons to lift a corporate veil (construing a statute, the company is a mere facade, and the company is an authorized agent of its controllers - Transamerica). The court will regard a company as a mere facade when 1) The company is completely dominated and controlled (by the parent company or shareholders) AND 2) The corporate structure is being used as a shield for fraudulent or improper purposes/conduct.
Not applicable here.
Big Bend Hotel Ltd v Security Mutual Casualty Company 2018
Facts:
Fort Hotel was destroyed by fire. Kumar was the sole shareholder and President of K & S Enterprises Ltd which operated the Fort Hotel.
Kumar purchased all shares of Big Bend Hotel (P) and soon sought to increase the insurance on the hotel. Kumar never disclosed the previous insurance claim for Fort Hotel fire to the insurance company. Later, P is burned down, and the insurance company denies coverage on the basis of Kumar failing to disclose (lifting the corporate veil)
Ratio: Courts would lift the corporate veil where it was incorporated for improper purposes or used for improper conduct
Holding: Corporate Veil lifted. Kumar was using the P corporation to conceal the prior insurance claims of his previous corporation → He was using the corp for an improper conduct.
Jin v Ren (2015) : Lifting the Corp Veil
Facts:
Ren, director of Hart Fibre Ltd, approached Jin to invest in the company.
Jin invested 300k for a controlling interest in the company.
Ren kept Jin’s money but never provided proof of Jin’s interest in the company + refused to return Jin’s investment.
Jin brings an action to seek 300k investment from Ren (lifting the corp veil).
Holding: Corporate veil lifted even though Hart Fibre Ltd was never incorporated for fraud reasons, since it was used for improper purposes.
Ratio: The courts will disregard the corporate veil if the corporate entity is being completely dominated and controlled + its being used for fraudulent (incorporated for fraud) purposes or as a shield for improper conduct.
Aubin v Petrone : Corporate veil in Family Law
Facts: A+P were married and incorporated Quantium Ltd. P was the majority shareholder and director while A was the minority shareholder.
A filed for divorce
P instructed Quantium to demand repayment of loan (A+P were also equal shareholders of another company which borrowed money from Quantium).
P also instructed Quantium to foreclose their house.
A sold shares back to Q under USA but P still refused to release A’s proceeds.
The court wants A to get spousal support. P argues that he can not give cash since he has no money. That he cannot extract funds from Q in any way ( the shareholders were him and his BFF).
Holding: Corp veil is lifted.
Ratio: Modified Transamerica test based on Arsenault :
Wrongdoer must have complete control of corp’s finance, business decisions or policy
De facto control is included: Where a person has the right and ability to change the company’s directorship or influence the shareholders.
Control was used to commit a fraud/ wrong that would unjustly deprive the claimant of their rights
Conduct must be the reason for C’s loss of rights (can be preventative or responsive measure)
Rockwell Developments v Newtonbrook Plaza Ltd : Veil not pierced
Facts:
Rockwell Developments Ltd. (Plaintiff) & Newtonbrook Plaza Ltd. (Defendant)
Plaintiff corporation entered into agreement to purchase real estate from Defendant
Litigation arose as a result of the real estate deal; D was awarded costs against P Corp in the amount of 4k. P corp only had $31.85
D corp brings application to collect costs from the director and majority shareholder Sam (lifting corp veil)
Holding: Can’t pierce the veil. There was no allegation of any misconduct on part of Sam even though no director’s resolution authorized Kelner to enter into the purchase on P’s behalf. The deposit was advanced by Sam from their own funds.
The contract was between the P and D corporations + everyone knew Sam was acting in the corporate capacity and not his personal capacity.
The corp was not a mere facade.
Walkovszky v. Carlton (USA CASE): Corp structure to avoid Group liability
Facts: W (p), Carlton (Individual Defendant) - Seon Cab Ltd (D’s corp)
C was a principal shareholder of 10 corps, each of which had 2 cabs registered under its name.
One of the corps, Seon, was the employer of the negligent cab driver who severely injured the P. This corp held minimum automobile liability insurance of 10k.
P brings an action against C, Seon and all other corps. P claimed the corp veil should be lifted.
Holding: No corp veil lifted. P had 2 arguments: 1) Fraud argument: P argued that the multiple corps were used to defraud members of the public by separating the corporations + thus separating their liability. Court held that thin capitalization does not amount to fraud. W argues that corporations were undercapitalized (not enough insurance and not enough capital to make good claims of injuries that are reasonably foreseeable in their business), Court said since they all complied with the minimum, statutory req, no need to do more.
2) Group enterprise argument: P claimed the corps operated as a single entity without corporate separateness. The court said no.
Wolfe v Moir: Must comply with ABCA to Gain Personal Liability Protection
Facts: M carried was involved in carrying out the business of Fort Whoop Up (owned by Chinook Ltd).
Whenever M carried on a business such as iterating tickets, he used names such as Fort Whoop up or Moir’s Sportsland. Any one dealing with Fort Whoop up through him knew there was a corp.
W was injured at Fort Whoop UP and brought personal actions against M. M argued that he was acting in his capacity as an agent for the corporation Chinook who owns Fort Whoop Up and should not be personally liable.
Holding: The court held that M's failure to properly comply with the regulations of s. 10 (8) of the Alberta Business Corporations Act (ABCA) meant he could not escape personal liability. s. 10(8) of ABCA : A corp shall set out its name in legible characters in all contracts and documents issued by the corporation, or made by or on behalf of the corporation and any failure to do so results in personal liability for individuals acting on behalf of the corporation.
If a person chooses to advertise and hold himself out to the public without identifying the name of a corp with which he is associated, he runs the risk of being held personally liable.
Vallis v Prairie Alternative Energy Solutions (PAES)
Facts: PAES (D) is an incorporated company where M was the sole director, shareholder and president.
V (P) contracted with PAES to install a geothermal heating system. K was the only person P came into contact with. PAES ended up being liable for $4k for breach of contract.
K did not represent that his business was incorporated in email correspondence or invoices, and he had no business cards + the truck did not have a business name. K stated that he didn’t have Ltd, corp or inc in this correspondence because he didn't know it was relevant.
Holding: K was personally liable. K's failure to use ltd or other corporate designation contravenes s.10(1) of the ABCA and SKBCA.
It was an honest mistake but failing to accurately represent the corp statute of his business led to personal liability.
Ratio: Just lacking the legal element in the corp name is sufficient to lift the corp veil.
Caja v Garcia: KNOWING ASSISTANCE & KNOWING RECEIPT
Facts:
Caja (the “Pension Fund”)
Defendants: Mr Garcia - original trustee of the Pension Fund and Catan Inc - Corp that was used as a trustee to hold money
Ms Duscio : Director, officer and sole shareholder of Catan
Mr. Duscio : Husband of Ms. D & de facto controlling mind of Catan.
The D Garcia directs fraud against Caja
Mr. Dusco helped reroute 7 million. 3 millions of those were filtered through Catan Inc.
TJ finds Ms. Dusco also liable for knowing assistance in funnelling money through Catan.
Holding: TJ misapplied the law for Knowing assistance, which requires actual knowledge which is a subjective standard. TJ applied an objective standard.
Preconditions of knowing assistance = 1) a fiduciary duty 2) a fraudulent and dishonest breach of that duty by the fiduciary. 3) ACTUAL (or willful blindness or recklessness) knowledge by the stranger (person behind the corp) about the fiduciary duty and the fiduciary’s fraudulent conduct AND 4) participation by or assistance of the stranger in the fiduciary’s fraudulent conduct.
Evidence for Knowing Receipt was insufficient. Legal test for Knowing Receipt : 1) Stranger receives trust property 2) For his/her own benefit or in his/her personal capacity 3) with actual OR CONSTRUCTIVE knowledge (reasonable person standard).
Aquino v. Bondfield Construction Co. 2024 (Corp attribution)
Facts: Mr. Aquiono, the directing mind of Bondfield and Forma-Con, intended to defraud, defeat or delay creditors of Bondfield and Forma-Con through a false invoicing scheme; he acted in his assigned sector of corporate responsibility of engaging with suppliers and overseeing the provision of services and materials.
Holding: A’s scheme was attributed to both Bondfield and Forma-Con under s.96 (1) (b) (ii) of the BIA. (
a) As a general rule in COMMON LAW, a person’s fraudulent acts may be attributed to a corporation if two conditions are met: (1) the wrongdoer was the directing mind of the corporation at the relevant times; and (2) the wrongful actions of the directing mind were performed within the sector of corporate responsibility assigned to them.
(b) Attribution will generally be inappropriate when: (1) the directing mind acted totally in fraud of the corporation (the fraud exception); or (2) the directing mind’s actions were not by design or result partly for the benefit of the corporation (the no benefit exception) (
(c) In addition to the fraud and no benefit exceptions, courts have discretion to refrain from attributing the actions, knowledge, state of mind, or intent of the directing mind to the corporation when this would be in the public interest, in the sense that it would promote the purpose of the law
The test for s.96 of the BIA only requires whether the person was the directing mind and whether it was within the scope of their authority. If these criteria are met, the actions of the directing mind should be attributed to the corporation, regardless of whether the fraud and no benefit exceptions are engaged. Court agreed with this.
The Rhone v The Peter A.B Widener ( directing mind)
Facts: Ds:
Great Lakes (Corp D) owned Barge
Captain Kelch (Individual D) employee of Great Lakes, de facto master of Barge (ship)
The Rhone (P) was struck by the Barge – collision was caused in part by Captain Kelch’s negligence.
Shipping Act s.647(2): owner of a ship has the benefit of limited liability concerning acts or omissions in the navigation of the ships that occur without the owner’s “actual fault or privity”
Question: Did the accident happen without the corporation’s actual fault or privity? The determination lies on whether the accident occurred with the corporation’s actual fault or privity depends on whether Captain Kelch was a directing mind of the corporation such that his acts and state of mind should be attributed to the corporation.
Holding: Captain K was NOT a directing mind and hence limited liability of the owners. For a corporation to be criminally liable under the identification theory, the employee who physically committed the crime must be a directing mind of the corp.
Directing mind must have governing executive authority over an area of the corp’s business to design and supervise the implementation of corporate policy rather than simply to carry out such policy.
The key factor that distinguishes directing minds from normal employees is the capacity to exercise decision-making authority on matters of corporate policy rather than give effect to such policy on an operational basis.
Deloitte & Touche v Livent Inc : Strict Application of Corporate attribution not needed due to public policy reasons
Facts:
Livent hired Del as auditor to audit its books. Del conducted an audit and negligently overlooked that two Livent Directors were defrauding Livent.
Livent sued Del in negligence, arguing that its incompetent audit led to Livent’s liquidation deficit being larger than it otherwise would have been. Del was found to be negligent and then raised the defence of illegality.
Del argued that defence of illegality bars an otherwise valid action in tort on the basis of P engaging in illegal or immoral conduct and therefore, should not recover. Here, the two directors’ illegal conduct should be attributed to Livent itself.
Holding: Defence not applicable. Even though the court affirms the Canadian Dredge test (must be a directing mind + acting within scope) and can’t attribute due to fraud and no benefit exceptions, court stated that the strict application of Canadian Dredge is not applicable here due to public policy reasons. Here, it would render the purpose for which duty of care is created, meaningless.
If a professional undertakes to provide a service to detect wrongdoing, the existence of that wrongdoing will not normally weigh in favour of barring civil liability for negligence through the corporate identification doctrine.
s. 22.1: Criminal Negligence Causing Death - Crown has to prove the Corporate Mind
If an offence requires the prosecution to prove negligence, an organization is liable if:
a) In acting within the scope of their authority
One of its representatives OR
Two or more of its representatives engage in conduct, whether by act or omission such that if it had been the conduct of only one representative, that representative would have been party to the offence AND
b) the SENIOR OFFICER/S who is responsible for the aspect of the organization’s activities that is relevant to the offence depart markedly from the standard of care that in the circumstances could reasonably be expected to prevent the commission of the offence.
S. 22.2 : Other Offences - Organizations
In respect of an offence that requires the prosecution to prove fault - other than negligence — an organization is liable if with the intent to at least benefit the organization, one of its senior officers
a) acting within the scope of their authority, is party to an offence and
b) having the mental state required to be a party to the offence and acting within the scope of their authority, directs the work of other representatives of the organization so that they do the act or make the omission specified in the offence OR
c) Knowing that a representative of the organization is or about to be a party to the offence, does not take all reasonable measures to stop them from being a party.