1/63
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Court Process
U.S. Supreme court established by Article III (3) section 1 of constitution.
Judicial review
Allows higher courts to review the decisions of lower courts
Seperation of powers
ensures justices are free to make decisions w'/out political limitations, BUT POTUS nominates and Senate confirms. many decisions split Liberal V. Conservative.
Moderates
Avoid espousing a particular political philosophy and devolp or maintain centrism.
Judicial interpretation
justices interpet law (either by strict interpretation or interpretation with context), they don’t write the laws.
Strict interpretation
plain language, original intent, literal meaning.
Interpretation with context (judicial activism)
interpet the doc within the context of historical events, societal changes, and technological advances, broad interp.
Judical activism rulings examples
Brown V. Board of education (1954)- precedent established in plessy v ferguson (1896). overturned a legal precedent set over 50yrs prior.
Separate-but-equal doctrine
determined racial segregation was constitutional was if services were comparable in quality. overturned unanimously in Brown.
Roe V. Wade (1973)
Federal, cons. overturned state laws prohibiting abortion. est. a federal privacy right under the Due Process Clause; conservative justices voted liberally. Overturned Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization (2022). Roe. was JA bcus it wrote into the constitution, the cons never said anything about abortion so it couldn’t get writinen into.
Dobbs V Jackson Women’s Health organization (2022)
State, returned the power to regulate abortion to the states, overtuned Roe and almost 50yrs of legal precedent. Was considered JA bcuz it overturned a legal precedent set 50yrs prior.
Obergefell V. Hodges (2015)
Established a constitutional right to marriage-for anyone under the 10th AM. considered JA bcuz “it wrote into the constitution”
Dual court system
seperate system for federal and state levels.
Writ of certiorari
order to send documents from a lower court to an appellate court for review- death penalty aromatically appeals.
Jurisdiction
a courts authority to hear certain types of cases. federal court has limited jurisdiction. crime on federal property, crimes that cross state lines, fed issues: taxes, mail, currency.
US Supreme court
highest court, lifetime appointment, great deal of discretion. Rule of 4, En Blanc, and Court of last resort
Rule of 4
Cases will be heard if at least 4 of the justices agree to hear.
En blanc
a case is heard by the full court unless a justice specifically says “no”- usually if they have specific ties to the case like if the case is on oil and they have stock in oil.
Court of last resort
the final court with appellate authority.
Us. Court of appeals
appeals from Federal district court. 12 circuits and appeals from specialty courts. 3 judge panels (rarely en blanc) often considered last resort.
Federal district courts
federal trial courts, 94 districts, civil and criminal cases.
state court systems
similar to the federal system. most include Supreme courts (at the state level)-court of last resort- for most state laws- appeallate courts, trial and courts.
State trial courts
trial courts may be:
General jurisdiction- serious criminal and civil cases
Limited Jurisdiction-(magistrate, municipal, city, county)- misdemeanors
Differences between federal and state courts
Fed: all felony prosecutions, must be intiated by an indictment (presented by a grand jury and then they get more info on the case).
State: May start with info or with a complaint (IE a cop writing a ticket).
Justice delayed is Justice denied
0
6th am
guarantees the right to a speedy trial
Federal speedy trial act (1974)
indictment within 30 days of arrest, trial within 70 days of indictment, state courts may adopt fed time or set their own time (6-12 months), many defendants waive the trial dates if it is in their best interest to do so.
Specialized courts
handle specific offenses and offenders, drug courts, domestic violence cases. veterans treatment courts.
Drug courts
Started in 1989, and has grown in popularity, offender assessment and treatment, judical interaction, monitoring and supervision.
Domestic violence courts
victim safety and offender accountability (rehab and deterrence). for intimate partners of domestic violence, created in the 90’s.
Veterans treatment courts.
holistic treatment plan, goal is to assist veterans with mental health disorders who are charged with crimes.
Alternate dispute resolution (adr)
means of settling cases without costly litigation.
negotiation-adr
meeting of disagreeing parties to work towards a solution
mediatiation-adr
informal process using a neutral 3rd party that encourages parties to settle their dispute to everyone’s satisfaction.
arbitration-adr
similar to trial proceeding but with less discovery and fewer rules of evidence.
role of judges
determine appropriate conduct what evidence may be introduced and correct procedures. oversee courts proceedings and trials sentencing.
Bench trials
judges hear the evidence without a jury present and make a ruling on guilt or innocence.
selection of judges
missouri plan. must meet: state residency, license to practice law, member of state bar, age of 25 to 75.
Women in the judiciary
late 1800s women began to fight to attend law school, to be admitted to the bar, and to serve as judges.
Bradwell V. Illinois (1873)
courts denied Bradwell’s claim that denial for bar violated her 14th am right (all citizens deserve equal protection of the law)