Core value - utopianism

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/11

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

State, society, economy, HN

12 Terms

1
New cards

Utopia - definition

  • Perfect society

    • At least significantly better, if not perfect

  • Entails

    • Abolition of want

    • Absence of coflict

    • Lack of oppression and violence

  • Comes from Latin meaning ‘no place’ as seen as heaven on earth - unachievable and impractical (Moore)


2
New cards

Utopianism

  • Rejection of the status quo

    • Criticism of existing order through creation of an ideal alternative


3
New cards

Utopia - in the context of anarchy

  • Utopia is at the ❤ of anarchy

  • Utopia involves natural order, no laws

    • Gives potential for human self-development

    • Also allows natural goodness of humankind to come out


4
New cards

HN 🔗 utopia

  • Anarchists see HN as:

    • Having significant unlimited potential

    • Able to be deeply corrupted by one’s surroundings

    • Naturally good

  • Therefore, allowing a natural order to develop would appeal to HN (which anarchists view as positive) and lead to a better, more equal society


5
New cards

HN - collectivist anarchists

  • Humans have the capacity to be sociable and cooperative

  • Kropotkin - evolution

    • Species have to work together to survive, so this capacity to cooperate etc. is not utopian but natural


6
New cards

HN - individualist anarchists

  • Focus on human reason


7
New cards

Negative influence of the state

  • State = dehumanising

    • Discourages individual consideration and relatedness

    • Decisions made by algorithms or bureaucrats

    • Jobs require emotional detachment

  • A lot of anarchy talks about human capacity for certain positive behaviours

  • This is because they believe the corrupting influence of the state means humans are not this now but can if they are allowed to reach this full potential


8
New cards

3 criticisms of utopianism

  1. Utopianism = delusion

  • Utopia is an unrealistic and unachievable goal

  1. Anarchists have the vision of a perfect society but no detail of how to achieve it

  2. Humans naturally have selfish impulses, so utopia wouldn’t work anyway


9
New cards

Response to criticism - Goldman

  • Any radical mvmt from the status quo is seen as utopianism (negatively)

  • “Every daring attempt to make great change in existing conditions, every lofty vision of new possibilities for the human race, has been labelled Utopian”


10
New cards

Response to criticism - Kropotkin

  • Liberal idea of equality of opportunity is actually not possible in capitalism

    • Yet not viewed as utopian…?


11
New cards

…is anarchism actually utopian?

  • Weigl argues that Kropotkin bases his theories on a thorough and detailed analysis of the historical development of human society

    • He’s a scientist, so it makes sense


12
New cards

Summary

  • Anarchy is utopia because it imagines a society w/out coercion, hierarchy or domiation

    • Seen as unrealistic by critics

  • Anarchists support their belief in utopia by saying HN is social and cooperative

    • They evidence this through examples of community living and voluntary groups