1/11
State, society, economy, HN
Utopia - definition
Perfect society
At least significantly better, if not perfect
Entails
Abolition of want
Absence of coflict
Lack of oppression and violence
Comes from Latin meaning ‘no place’ as seen as heaven on earth - unachievable and impractical (Moore)
Utopianism
Rejection of the status quo
Criticism of existing order through creation of an ideal alternative
Utopia - in the context of anarchy
Utopia is at the ❤ of anarchy
Utopia involves natural order, no laws
Gives potential for human self-development
Also allows natural goodness of humankind to come out
HN 🔗 utopia
Anarchists see HN as:
Having significant unlimited potential
Able to be deeply corrupted by one’s surroundings
Naturally good
Therefore, allowing a natural order to develop would appeal to HN (which anarchists view as positive) and lead to a better, more equal society
HN - collectivist anarchists
Humans have the capacity to be sociable and cooperative
Kropotkin - evolution
Species have to work together to survive, so this capacity to cooperate etc. is not utopian but natural
HN - individualist anarchists
Focus on human reason
Negative influence of the state
State = dehumanising
Discourages individual consideration and relatedness
Decisions made by algorithms or bureaucrats
Jobs require emotional detachment
A lot of anarchy talks about human capacity for certain positive behaviours
This is because they believe the corrupting influence of the state means humans are not this now but can if they are allowed to reach this full potential
3 criticisms of utopianism
Utopianism = delusion
Utopia is an unrealistic and unachievable goal
Anarchists have the vision of a perfect society but no detail of how to achieve it
Humans naturally have selfish impulses, so utopia wouldn’t work anyway
Response to criticism - Goldman
Any radical mvmt from the status quo is seen as utopianism (negatively)
“Every daring attempt to make great change in existing conditions, every lofty vision of new possibilities for the human race, has been labelled Utopian”
Response to criticism - Kropotkin
Liberal idea of equality of opportunity is actually not possible in capitalism
Yet not viewed as utopian…?
…is anarchism actually utopian?
Weigl argues that Kropotkin bases his theories on a thorough and detailed analysis of the historical development of human society
He’s a scientist, so it makes sense
Summary
Anarchy is utopia because it imagines a society w/out coercion, hierarchy or domiation
Seen as unrealistic by critics
Anarchists support their belief in utopia by saying HN is social and cooperative
They evidence this through examples of community living and voluntary groups