1/42
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Sec. 13 of CA 46, as amended — a public utility refers to a public service that operates, manages or controls for public use any of the following: (6)
Distribution/transmission of electricity
Petroleum/products pipeline transmission systems
Water/wastewater pipeline distribution systems (including sewerage)
Seaports
PUVs
Sec. 13, CA 146 — All concessionaires, joint ventures and other similar entities that wholly operate, manage or control for public use the sectors above are public utilities ___
No other person shall be deemed a public utility unless otherwise subsequently provided by law.
Distribution of electricity [Sec. 2(f), R.A. 11659]
the conveyance of electric power by a distribution utility through its distribution system
Transmission [Sec. 2(n), R.A. 11659]
The conveyance of electricity through the high voltage backbone system.
Petroleum and Petroleum Products Pipeline Transmission System[ Sec. 2(i), R.A. No. 11659]
the operation and maintenance of pipeline transmission systems to ensure an uninterrupted and adequate supply and transmission of petroleum and petroleum products to the public.
Water Pipeline Distribution Systems and Wastewater Pipeline Systems, including Sewerage Pipeline Systems [Sec. 2( o ), R.A. No. 11659]
the operation and maintenance of water pipeline distribution systems to ensure an uninterrupted and adequate supply and distribution of potable water for domestic and other purposes and the operation and maintenance of wastewater pipeline systems to ensure public health and safety.
Exclusions for Petroleum pipeline systems
Petroleum pipeline systems operated exclusively for private or own use,or incidental to the operations of a distinct business
Exclusions: water Pipeline Distribution Systems and Wastewater Pipeline Systems
Desludging companies and septic tanks [Sec. 2( o ), R.A. No. 11659]
Seaports
a place where ships may anchor or tie up for the purpose of shelter, repair, loading or discharge of passengers or cargo, or for other such activities connected with water-borne commerce, and including all the land and water areas and the structures, equipment and facilities related to these function
PUVs — internal combustion engine vehicles that carry passengers and/or domestic cargo for a fee, offering services to the public, namely: (8)
1.Trucks-for-hire;
2. UV express;
3. Service;
4. Public utility buses (PUBs);
5. Public utility jeepneys (PUJs);
6. Tricycles;
7. Filcabs;
8. Taxis
Transport vehicles accredited with and operating through transport network corporations shall ___
Not be considered public utility vehicles
[ Sec. 2(k) RA 11659]
Luzon Stevedoring Co., Inc. v. PSC, DEFINING public utility
Public utility, even where the term is not defined by statute, is not determined by the number of people actually served. Nor does the mere fact that service is rendered only under contract prevent a company from being a public utility.
Luzon Stevedoring Co., Inc. v. PSC, causal or incidental services—
devoid of public character and interest is not brought within the category of public utility.
The demarcation line is not susceptible of exact description or definition; each being governed by its circumstance.
Luzon Stevedoring Co., Inc. v. PSC, public character/interest
If the service is casual or incidental, it does not fall under the category of public utility. Causal or incidental service devoid of public character and interest is not a public utility.
What is a public service? (OOMC HC POA B)
Every person who may own, operate, manage or control in the Philippines,
For hire/compensation
General/limited Clientele
Permanent, occasional/accidental
For General Business Purposes
Listed services in CA 146. Sec. 13(b)
Any common carrier, railroad, street railway, traction railway, subway MV;
Freight/passenger/both
with/without fixed route
W/N may be its —
classification
Freight/carrier service of any class
Express service
Steamboat/ship line
Pontines
Ferries; and
Watercraft
CA 146/PSA Sec. 13 — engaged in (5/15)
Transportation of passengers or freight or both;
Shipyard;
Marine railways;
Marine repair shop;
[Warehouse] Wharf or dock;
CA 146/PSA Sec. 13 — engaged in (10/15)
Ice plant;
Ice-refrigeration plant;
Canal, irrigation system;
Gas;
Electric light;
CA 146/PSA Sec. 13 — engaged in (15/15) 🧊 ♒ ⚡
heat & power/water supply
petroleum
sewerage
Wire/less communications system
Wire/Less broadcasting station/other similar services
XPNS: Any person engaged in agriculture, not o/w a public service who —
Ownes a MV and uses it personally
and/or enters special contract where MV is offered for
a. Hire
b. compenation to 3rd party/ies engaged in agriculture not in itself a public service for operation for —
a limited time and specific purpose directly connected with
Cultivation (farm)
Transpo
Processing
Marketing of agricultural products
When are common carriers considered public service?
Transport freight/passengers or both
With/out fixed route
Classification freight/carrier, express service, steamboat/ship etc.
Legal basis/rationale for regulation — plenary police power/promoting general welfare & ensuring fair and equitable service:
1987 Constitution, Art. XII, Sec. 6: The use of property bears a social function, and all economic agents shall contribute to the common good.
New Vision Satellinte Network Inc. v. Provincial Govt. of Cagayan
Issuance of a franchise, certificate or other form of authorization for the operation of a public utility does not solely depend on Congress. There are laws that grant specified agencies in the Executive Branch the power to issue such authorization for certain classes of public utilities by virtue of the principle of subordinate legislation or delegation of legislative power.
RP v. Meralco — Rates must be reasonable and just.
The State protects the public against arbitrary and excessive rates while maintaining the efficiency and quality of services rendered.
However, the power to regulate rates does not give the State the right to prescribe rates which are so low as to deprive the public utility of a reasonable return on investment.
Albano v. Reyes — MICT admin franchise
Franchises issued by Congress are not required before each and every public utility may operate.
Art. XII, Sec. 11 of the Constitution does not necessarily imply that only
Congress has the power to grant such authorization.
Thus, the law has granted certain administrative agencies the powe
KMU Labor Center v. Garcia — Admin franchise, fill in details, not further delegate
The power to regulate public utilities resides in the State and is exercised through specialized regulatory bodies such as the LTFRB, which are delegated authority by the Legislature to implement and enforce the law.
Includes route-fixing and rate-making, which require sound discretion, careful judgment, and the balancing of public and operator interests.
While the LTFRB may “fill in” statutory details, it cannot further delegate this power to private carriers or transport operators, as doing so would constitute an abdication of the State’s inherent police power and undermine the public’s right to just and reasonable rates.
Proper notice, hearing, and evidence-based procedures are essential, ensuring that regulation serves both public convenience and the stability of the transport system.
NAPOCOR v CA - rate-fixing function of the ERB (now DoE)
The determination of which of 2 public utilities has the right to supply electric power to an area which is within the coverage of both is certainly not a rate-fixing function which should remain with the ERB.
It deals with the regulation of the distribution of energy resources which, under EO 172, was expressly a function of ERB.
However, with the enactment of RA 7638, the Department of Energy took over such function.
Batangas v. CA — Cable TV, EO 205 general law > municipal ordinances
Municipal ordinances are inferior in status and subordinate to the laws of the state. An ordinance in conflict with a state law of general character and statewide application is universally held to be invalid.
In every power to pass ordinances given to a municipality, there is an implied restriction that the ordinances shall be consistent with the general law.
Oroport Cargohandling v. Phividec Industrial Authority - MCT operated by PPA as Admin Agency
SC: Congress are not required before each and every public utility may operate because the law has granted certain administrative agencies the power to grant licenses for or to authorize the operation of certain public utilities.
Art. XII, Sec. 11 of the Constitution does not necessarily imply that only Congress can grant such authorization.
NOTE: can also issue franchise by contract.
What happened to the PSC?
(KMU Labor Center v. Garcia)
PD 11 → abolished: 3 specialized boards (Transpo, Coms, power & Water Works)
+13 yrs → EO 1011: abolished, merged into LRTC
+2yrs → EO 125: abolished → EO 202, LTFRB.
Tatad v. Garcia (EDSA MRT III) — right to operate separate from ownership.
What constitutes a public utility is not their ownership but their use to serve the public. The right to operate a public utility may exist independently and separately from the ownership of the facilities thereof.
The Constitution distinguishes between ownership and operation of a public utility.
The Constitution, in no uncertain terms, requires a franchise for the operation of a public utility, but not for mere ownership of facilities.
The Iloilo Ice and Cold Storage Company v. PUB (COMPARE with Teresa Electric)
Why Not a Public Utility: Does not offer the property to the public indiscriminately.
Teresa Electric & Power Co. v PSC — Cement Factory’s exclusive-use electric plant NOT a public utility
An entity operating an electric plant exclusively for its own use in connection with its primary business, is not considered to be operating for "business purposes" in the sense of a public utility. Therefore, such an entity does not need to secure a municipal or legislative franchise as required by Act 667.
While operators of public convenience and service deserve some protection from unnecessary or unlawful competition, yet the rule is that nobody has any exclusive right to secure a franchise or a CPC.
Above any or all considerations, the grant of franchises and certificates of public convenience and service should be guided by the primordial considerations of public service and interest
XPN, JG Summit Holdings, Inc. v. CA — PHILSECO Shipyard not public utility (cited Iloilo Ice)
The fact that a business is affected with public interest does not imply that it is under a duty to serve the public. While the business may be regulated for public good, the regulation cannot justify the classification of a purely private enterprise as a public utility.
The legislature cannot, by its mere declaration, make something a public utility which is not in fact such;
A private business operated under private contracts with selected customers and not devoted to public use cannot, by legislative fiat or by order of a public service commission, be declared a public utility, since that would be taking private property for public use without just compensation, which cannot be done consistently with the due process clause.
WHY? it serves a limited clientele and does not offer its services to the public as a legal right, consistent with the doctrine in Iloilo Ice v. Public Utility Board that public use requires service to the indefinite public, not merely incidental public benefit.
Hicap et al vs. The Energy Regulatory Commission — Sec. 6 Sec. 7 of EPIRA constitutional
SC: generation and supply companies are not public utilities because they do not directly serve the general public and have no legal duty to serve the public indiscriminately, unlike distribution utilities, which are obligated to provide electricity to end-users and require a franchise.
SUPPLY & GENERATION:NOT PUBLIC UTILITIES
Does not directly serve the general public and have no legal duty to serve the public indiscriminately, unlike distribution utilities, which are obligated to provide electricity to end-users and require a franchise.
DISTRIBUTION & TRANSMISSION: PUBLIC UTILITY
Not covered by definition of public service/CA 146 — (5)
Warehouses
Animal-drawn vehicles/sailboats, tugs, lighters
Airships within PH
Radio companies
Public services owned/operated by any instrumentality of the government
4-5, XPN — rate fixing
Sec. 29, EPIRA — Supply of electricity
requires a license from ERC, demonstrating technical, financial ability and creit worthiness
NOT a public utility, not required to secure a franchise
Not subject to ERC regulation, but must comply with rules on market power abuse/anticompetition.
RA 10668, Sec. 4 - Carriage of Foreign Cargo by Foreign Vessel
Foreign port → PH:
allowed to carry foreign cargo to PH final destination after being cleared at port of entry
Carry foreign cargo by foreign vessel calling at the same port
PH → elsewhere: foreign cargoes by foreign vessel thru domestic transshipment port and transferred to its final destination
EMPTY FOREIGN CONTAINER (COMING/GOING/TRANSHIPPED PH) = OK
RA 10668 Sec. 7 — Carriage by Foreign Vessels
Not a Public Service, Foreign Vessels Not Common Carriers.
Republic Act No. 11659 Act Amending the PSA (2022)
Several key industries no longer have a 40% cap on foreign equity, as part of the Duterte administration's contentious bid to attract more investors
The amendments allowed foreigners to fully own companies in the telecommunication, shipping, airline, railway, toll road, and transport network vehicle industries. Previously, these industries had a 40% cap on foreign equity, as they were considered public utilities.
Companies involved in power, water, and petroleum pipelines, public utility vehicles, and seaports continue to have foreign equity restrictions and are considered public utilities.
A concession agreement is —
A contract between a government entity and a private concessionaire, granting the latter the exclusive right and privilege to operate, manage, and/or maintain a public project or service for a specified period.
a legal contract where a government or property owner gives a private company the right to operate a business or public service on their land or property for a set time
Maynilad v NWRB — MW and Maynilad public utilities because they operate MWSS facilities and are thus subject to the 12% cap.
The supply of water is not a governmental but a proprietary function of the State.
The business of providing water supply and sewerage service, as "may, for all practical purposes, be likened to an industry engaged in by coal companies, gas companies, power plants, ice plants, and the like."
These are but mere ministrant functions of government which are aimed at advancing the general interest of society