Part 2:

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/27

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

28 Terms

1
New cards

PART 1: IMPLIED TERMS 

1. Recap: Terms of a Contract 

A contract is made up of terms, which create legally enforceable obligations between the parties. 

Key points: 

  • Contracts can be written or verbal. 

  • Terms can be express (specifically agreed by the parties) or implied (inserted into the contract by law). 

  • Express terms can be incorporated through signature or previous contractual dealings. 

  • Oral modifications to contracts are possible, although courts can be reluctant to uphold them. 

  • Courts generally do not protect parties from making bad bargains. 

  • However, particularly onerous terms may require clear notice before they can be incorporated. 


2
New cards

2. Why Are Terms Implied into Contracts? 

Even detailed contracts cannot cover every possible situation that might arise. 

Therefore, courts sometimes need to fill gaps by inserting additional terms into the agreement. 

There are two main ways terms can be implied: 

Type 

Meaning 

Terms implied by statute 

Parliament inserts terms into certain types of contracts through legislation. 

Terms implied at common law 

Courts develop and insert terms based on legal principles and the circumstances of the contract. 


3
New cards

3. Terms Implied by Statute 

Statutes can regulate how contracts operate by automatically introducing certain terms. 

Main example: Sale of Goods Act 1979, as amended by the Consumer Rights Act 2015. 

The legislation contains terms concerning: 

  1. Title to goods: The seller must have the legal right to sell the goods. 

  2. Description of goods: Goods must correspond with their contractual description. 

  3. Quality and fitness: Goods must meet the relevant standards of quality and be fit for their intended purpose. 

The precise statutory rights depend on the type of transaction and the applicable legislation. 

4
New cards

4. Terms Implied at Common Law 

Courts can imply terms into contracts for three main reasons: 

  1. Trade custom: To reflect established practices within a particular industry. 

  2. Intention of the parties: To give effect to what the parties objectively intended when making the agreement. 

  3. Public policy: To regulate particular types of contracts, such as employment or landlord and tenant agreements. 

Important principle: Courts do not imply terms simply to improve a contract or produce a fairer outcome. 

A term will not be implied unless: 

  • It is sufficiently certain. 

  • It does not contradict the express terms of the contract. 


5
New cards

5. Terms Implied Through Trade Customs 

Some industries have established practices that are commonly understood and followed by people working within that trade. 

Courts may imply these practices into contracts, even where they have not been expressly written down. 

Case: Hutton v Warren (1836) 1 M&W 460 

Principle: Evidence of established trade customs can be used to add terms to a written contract where the contract is silent. 

The court recognised that commercial agreements may be understood in light of established industry practices. 

Legal rule: Trade customs can become implied contractual terms where the parties operate within the relevant trade. 

Case: Cunliffe-Owen v Teather & Greenwood [1967] 1 WLR 1421 

The case established requirements that must be satisfied before a trade custom can be implied into a contract. 

A trade custom must be: 

Requirement 

Meaning 

Certain 

Clearly established, identifiable and consistent. 

Notorious 

Well known among people operating in the particular trade and location. 

Recognised as binding 

Those working in the trade understand that they are obliged to follow the practice. 

Reasonable 

The custom must be reasonable. 

Consistent with the contract 

It must not contradict the express terms or nature of the agreement. 

Remember: A practice being common in an industry does not automatically make it an implied contractual term. It must satisfy the relevant requirements.

6
New cards

6. Terms Implied Through the Intention of the Parties 

Sometimes a contract does not expressly include something that is necessary to give effect to what the parties objectively intended. 

Courts may therefore imply a term to complete the agreement. 

The courts are not rewriting the contract. They are identifying something that would clearly have been contemplated when the agreement was made. 

Two traditional tests developed to establish whether a term should be implied: 

  1. The business efficacy test. 

  2. The officious bystander test. 

The Supreme Court subsequently clarified how these principles operate. 

6.1 The Business Efficacy Test 

Case: The Moorcock (1889) 14 PD 64 

Facts: 

  • A shipowner contracted with a wharf owner to unload a ship at a wharf on the River Thames. 

  • The ship became grounded and damaged when the tide went out. 

  • The shipowner argued that the wharf owner had an implied obligation to ensure that the vessel could remain safely docked. 

Judgment: 

The court recognised that a term could be implied where necessary to give the contract business efficacy. 

Bowen LJ explained that courts should imply terms necessary to make the commercial agreement work as the parties must have intended. 

Legal principle: 

A term may be implied where it is necessary to make the contract commercially workable and give it practical effect. 

Key point: The court does not imply a term merely because it would be convenient. It must be necessary for the contract to function effectively. 

6.2 Clarification of the Business Efficacy Test 

Case: Reigate v Union Manufacturing Co (Ramsbottom) Ltd [1918] 1 KB 592 

Facts: 

  • C entered into a seven-year contract to act as D's sole agent. 

  • D subsequently went out of business and entered liquidation. 

  • D argued that the contract had been terminated. 

  • C brought a claim for breach of contract, arguing that the contractual obligations continued. 

Judgment: 

Scrutton LJ explained that a term could only be implied where it was necessary in the business sense to give efficacy to the contract. 

The term must be something that both parties would clearly have regarded as obvious when negotiating the agreement. 

Legal principle: 

A term will only be implied where it is necessary to make the contract commercially effective, rather than simply desirable. 

Remember: Business efficacy = the contract must work in a practical and commercial sense. 

6.3 The Officious Bystander Test 

Case: Shirlaw v Southern Foundries [1940] AC 701 

Facts: 

  • A director had been appointed for a period of ten years. 

  • A dispute arose over whether the company could remove him during that period. 

Judgment: 

MacKinnon LJ developed the officious bystander test. 

He explained that a term could be implied if it was so obvious that, had an outsider suggested including it during negotiations, both parties would have responded: 

"Oh, of course!" 

Legal principle: 

A term may be implied where it is so obvious that both parties would have regarded it as an obvious part of their agreement. 

Remember: Officious bystander = would both parties have considered the proposed term so obvious that it did not need to be written down? 

7
New cards

7. The BP Refinery Test 

Case: BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Ltd v President, Councillors and Ratepayers of the Shire of Hastings (1977) 52 ALJR 20 

Facts: 

  • A dispute concerned an earlier agreement about the rates payable on a refinery in Australia. 

  • The issue was whether the agreement would continue to apply following the restructuring of the company. 

Judgment: 

Lord Simon established five conditions that should be satisfied before a term can be implied into a contract. 

The five BP Refinery requirements 

  1. Reasonable and equitable: The implied term must be fair and reasonable. 

  2. Necessary for business efficacy: It must be necessary to make the contract work effectively. 

  3. Obvious: It must be so obvious that it goes without saying. 

  4. Capable of clear expression: The proposed term must be capable of being clearly formulated. 

  5. Consistent with express terms: It must not contradict any express term of the contract. 

Importance: This case provided a structured approach to deciding whether a term could be implied into a contract. 

8
New cards

8. Attorney-General of Belize v Belize Telecom Ltd [2009] UKPC 10 

This case created uncertainty about the legal test for implying terms. 

Facts: 

  • Belize Telecom Ltd (BTL) was established to manage the privatised national telecommunications service. 

  • The government retained certain rights through a special shareholding. 

  • A dispute arose over whether, when the special shareholder resigned or was removed, there was an implied term that the relevant class of shareholding would be removed. 

Judgment: 

The Privy Council, through Lord Hoffmann, explained that the role of implying terms was to establish the objective meaning of the contract. 

The court should consider what a reasonable person, with the relevant background knowledge, would understand the agreement to mean. 

Lord Hoffmann's main principles 

  • Courts cannot improve a contract to make it fairer or more reasonable. 

  • The court must identify the objective meaning of the agreement. 

  • The contract must be considered as a whole. 

  • The relevant background circumstances must be considered. 

  • The BP Refinery requirements should not be treated as five separate tests that must all independently be passed. 

Key legal principle: The central question is whether the proposed implied term represents what the contract, read as a whole and against its relevant background, would reasonably be understood to mean. 

Concerns about Belize Telecom 

Some legal commentators believed that the judgment had changed the law. 

The concern was that Lord Hoffmann appeared to combine two separate legal processes: 

Contractual interpretation 

Implying terms 

Determines what the existing contractual words mean. 

Adds a term that is not expressly included in the agreement. 

Examines the meaning of the existing agreement. 

Considers whether something missing from the agreement should be inserted. 

The distinction became important because implying terms had traditionally been treated as a separate exercise from interpreting the contract. 

The Supreme Court clarified the position in 2015. 

9
New cards

9. Marks & Spencer v BNP Paribas (2015) 

Case: Marks & Spencer Plc v BNP Paribas Securities Services Trust (Jersey) Ltd [2015] UKSC 72 

Important Supreme Court authority 

Facts: 

  • Marks & Spencer leased floors in a building owned by BNP Paribas. 

  • The lease contained a break clause allowing M&S to end the lease early. 

  • If the break clause was not exercised, a deduction of £150,000 would be made from the next quarter's rent. 

  • M&S exercised the break clause but had already paid the next quarter's rent. 

  • M&S argued that an implied term required the landlord to reimburse the rent covering the period after the lease ended. 

Judgment: 

  • M&S initially succeeded in the High Court. 

  • The Court of Appeal overturned that decision. 

  • The Supreme Court also rejected the argument that the reimbursement term should be implied. 

The Supreme Court considered that the term was not necessary to give the contract business efficacy. 

Lord Neuberger's six comments 

Lord Neuberger clarified how the BP Refinery principles should be applied. 

1. Objective assessment: Reasonableness must be judged objectively, from the perspective of reasonable people in the parties' position when the contract was made. 

2. Fairness is insufficient: A term cannot be implied simply because it seems fair or because one party would have agreed to it. 

3. Reasonableness and equity: The separate requirement that a term must be reasonable and equitable is unnecessary if the other requirements are satisfied. 

4. Cumulative requirements: The BP Refinery requirements generally operate together. However, business efficacy and the officious bystander tests may operate as alternatives, meaning only one needs to be satisfied. 

5. Careful application: Judges must formulate the question asked by the hypothetical officious bystander very carefully. 

6. Commercial and practical coherence: Business efficacy is better understood as requiring that the contract would otherwise lack commercial or practical coherence. 

Overall legal principle: Courts take a restrictive approach to implying terms. A term must be necessary, not merely reasonable, desirable or fair. 

Exam tip: Marks & Spencer is particularly important when explaining the modern approach to implied terms and the distinction between interpretation and implication. 

10
New cards

10. Terms Implied at Law 

Terms can also be implied into particular categories of contracts as a matter of public policy. 

Unlike terms implied through the intention of the parties, the court is not asking whether a particular term is necessary for one individual contract. 

Instead, it considers whether a term should be implied into all contracts of a particular type. 

Examples include: 

  • Landlord and tenant contracts. 

  • Employment contracts. 

  • Certain contracts for the sale of goods. 

Key points: 

  • These terms establish common standards for particular contractual relationships. 

  • They develop through judicial decisions on a case-by-case basis. 

  • They are different from terms implied by statute. 

Case: Liverpool City Council v Irwin [1977] AC 239 

Facts: 

  • Liverpool City Council owned an apartment block that was in poor repair. 

  • Residents refused to pay rent. 

  • Their tenancy agreements did not contain an express obligation requiring the council to maintain communal areas. 

Judgment: 

The House of Lords held that there was an implied term in the tenancy agreements requiring the council to take reasonable steps to maintain the communal areas in a reasonable condition. 

Legal principle: 

Courts may imply terms into particular categories of contracts as a matter of law, based on the nature of the contractual relationship. 

Case: Scally v Southern Health and Social Services Board [1991] 4 All ER 563 

Facts: 

  • Employment benefits had been negotiated by an employee representative body. 

  • The benefits were incorporated into employees' contracts by reference. 

  • The employer did not bring the existence of the new rights and benefits to the employee's attention. 

  • The employee was unlikely to know about the benefits unless they were specifically communicated. 

Judgment: 

The House of Lords implied an obligation on the employer to bring the relevant employment rights and benefits to the employee's attention. 

However, the court adopted a restrictive approach. 

Lord Bridge warned against creating an implied term that was too wide to be applied generally. 

Legal principle: 

An implied term may require employers to inform employees of particular contractual rights where the circumstances justify it. 

Remember: Courts will not automatically imply broad obligations into every employment contract. The approach remains restrictive. 

11
New cards

11. Comparing the Different Types of Implied Terms 

Type 

Why is the term implied? 

Main authority 

By statute 

Parliament regulates particular contractual relationships. 

Sale of Goods Act 1979 

Trade custom 

To reflect established industry practices. 

Hutton v Warren 

Intention of parties 

To give effect to the objective meaning and practical operation of the agreement. 

The Moorcock 

At law 

To regulate particular categories of contracts as a matter of public policy. 

Liverpool City Council v Irwin 

Important distinction: 

  • Terms implied by statute come from legislation. 

  • Terms implied in fact (including trade custom and intention) concern the particular agreement. 

  • Terms implied in law apply to particular categories of contractual relationships. 


12
New cards

PART 2: CATEGORIES OF CONTRACTUAL TERMS 

…

13
New cards

12. The Nature of Contractual Terms 

Not all contractual terms have the same legal importance. 

Contract law recognises three main categories: 

  • Conditions. 

  • Warranties. 

  • Innominate (or intermediate) terms. 

The classification matters because it determines the remedies available when a term is breached. 

14
New cards

13. Conditions 

A condition is a fundamental or particularly important term of a contract. 

If a condition is breached, the innocent party has the right to: 

  • Claim damages. 

  • Terminate the contract if they choose. 

Important: The innocent party does not have to terminate the contract. They can choose to continue with it and claim damages. 

15
New cards

14. Warranties 

A warranty is a contractual term of lesser importance. 

If a warranty is breached, the innocent party can: 

- Claim damages. 

However, they cannot terminate the contract solely because of that breach. 

16
New cards

15. Conditions vs Warranties 

Condition 

Warranty 

Fundamental contractual term. 

Less important contractual term. 

Breach allows damages. 

Breach allows damages. 

Breach allows termination. 

Breach does not allow termination. 

Easy way to remember: 

  • Condition = damages + possible termination. 

  • Warranty = damages only. 


17
New cards

16. Distinguishing Between Conditions and Warranties 

It is not always easy to determine whether a contractual term is a condition or a warranty. 

Courts examine the contract, surrounding circumstances and intentions of the parties. 

Case: Bentsen v Taylor, Sons & Co [1893] 2 QB 274 

Facts: 

  • A vessel was described as having already sailed or being about to sail. 

  • This statement was untrue. 

  • The vessel had not yet been loaded and would take several weeks before it could sail. 

Judgment: 

The term was held to be a condition. 

Bowen LJ explained that the court must examine the contract and surrounding circumstances to determine whether the parties intended the promise to be a condition or a warranty. 

Legal principle: 

The classification depends on the intention of the parties as objectively understood from the contract and surrounding circumstances. 

18
New cards

17. The Waller Test: Identifying Conditions 

Case: BS & N Ltd v Micado Shipping Ltd (The Seaflower) [2000] EWCA Civ 296 

The Court of Appeal recognised four situations where a contractual term is likely to be treated as a condition. 

The four categories 

1. Expressly designated by statute 

Legislation identifies the term as a condition. 

2. Established by previous judicial decisions 

Courts have already classified the particular term as a condition. 

3. Designated as a condition by the contract 

The contract expressly identifies the term as a condition or provides a right to terminate if it is breached. 

4. Nature of the contract and circumstances 

The subject matter or circumstances indicate that the parties intended the innocent party to be released from their obligations if the term was breached. 

The following cases explain these four categories. 

17.1 Conditions Provided by Statute 

Certain legislation identifies particular contractual terms as conditions. 

Example: Sale of Goods Act 1979 (non-consumer contracts). 

A breach can allow the innocent party to reject the goods and terminate the contract, even where the breach is relatively minor. 

Case: Arcos Ltd v E A Ronaason & Son [1933] AC 470 

Facts: 

  • Timber was supplied that was 1/16 of an inch thicker than the contractual description. 

  • The timber was still perfectly usable. 

  • However, it did not correspond with the agreed description. 

Judgment: 

The House of Lords treated the relevant term as a condition. 

Legal principle: 

Even a relatively minor breach of a condition can give the innocent party the right to terminate the contract. 

Importance: 

  • Promotes legal and commercial certainty. 

  • However, it can produce harsh outcomes where the breach has little practical effect. 

17.2 Conditions Established by Previous Judicial Decisions 

Courts may classify certain terms as conditions because of previous decisions. 

This is particularly important in industries using standard contractual clauses, such as shipping and construction. 

Case: Bunge Corporation v Tradax Ltd [1981] 1 WLR 711 

  • A notice of readiness clause in a charterparty was treated as a condition. 

  • This established a common understanding of the contractual obligation. 

Case: The Mihalis Angelos [1970] 3 WLR 601 

- A contractual clause concerning when a vessel was expected to be ready to load was treated as a condition. 

Importance: 

These decisions promote commercial certainty by ensuring that standard contractual terms have a consistent legal meaning. 

17.3 Conditions Expressly Designated in the Contract 

Parties can identify particular terms as conditions in their contracts. 

If the parties clearly indicate that the innocent party can terminate the contract following a breach, the term may be treated as a condition. 

Case: Lombard v Butterworth [1987] QB 297 

Legal principle: 

A contractual term may be treated as a condition where the contract clearly provides a right to terminate if it is breached. 

However, simply labelling a term a condition is not always sufficient. 

Case: Schuler v Wickman [1974] AC 235 

Facts: 

  • The contract contained a requirement for weekly visits. 

  • The term was described as a condition. 

  • A dispute arose over whether failure to comply with the requirement allowed termination. 

Judgment: 

The House of Lords refused to treat the term as a condition merely because it had been labelled one. 

The consequences of treating every failure as grounds for termination would have been unreasonable. 

Lord Bridge explained that the more unreasonable the result, the less likely it is that the parties intended that result without making their intention abundantly clear. 

Legal principle: 

Courts consider the substance and consequences of a contractual provision, not simply the label attached to it. 

17.4 Nature of the Contract 

The nature of the contract, its subject matter and the surrounding circumstances may indicate that a term should be classified as a condition. 

This is particularly relevant in commercial contracts. 

Examples: 

  • The Mihalis Angelos. 

  • Bunge Corporation v Tradax. 

Importance: 

In shipping and construction, commercial certainty is important because delays or failures to comply with contractual obligations can have significant consequences for other parties. 

19
New cards

18. Breach of a Warranty 

A breach of warranty allows the innocent party to claim damages but does not allow them to terminate the contract. 

Case: Bettini v Guy (1876) QBD 183 

Facts: 

  • Bettini agreed to provide exclusive musical services to the Royal Italian Opera for three months. 

  • He was required to arrive in London six days before rehearsals started. 

  • He arrived only two days before rehearsals began. 

Judgment: 

The breach did not justify termination of the contract. 

Blackburn J explained that the breach must go to the root of the contract, making the remaining performance substantially different from what the other party had agreed to receive. 

Legal principle: 

A breach of a minor contractual obligation does not automatically justify termination. 

Importance: 

The case illustrates the distinction between important contractual obligations and less significant obligations. 

20
New cards

PART 3: INNOMINATE TERMS 

…

21
New cards

19. What Are Innominate Terms? 

Innominate terms are also known as intermediate terms. 

They form the third category of contractual terms, alongside conditions and warranties. 

They developed because the traditional distinction between conditions and warranties could be too rigid. 

Why were innominate terms introduced? 

The traditional approach could produce unfair or commercially undesirable outcomes. 

Problems included: 

  • A party could terminate a contract because of a relatively minor breach of a condition. 

  • Parties could use minor breaches to escape contracts when market conditions changed. 

  • Termination could disrupt wider commercial arrangements and contractual chains. 

  • The traditional categories did not always reflect commercial reality. 

Innominate terms provide greater flexibility by allowing courts to examine the actual consequences of the breach. 

22
New cards

20. Hong Kong Fir Shipping v Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha [1962] 2 QB 26 

Essential case – innominate terms 

Facts: 

  • The parties entered into a charterparty agreement to hire a vessel for two years. 

  • The contract required the vessel to be seaworthy and suitable for ordinary cargo services. 

  • The vessel was old and required skilled maintenance. 

  • It had an incompetent and understaffed crew. 

  • The captain was also described as a notorious alcoholic. 

  • The vessel experienced several breakdowns while travelling from Liverpool to Osaka. 

  • It required five weeks of repairs during the voyage. 

  • A further 15 weeks of repairs were needed in Osaka. 

  • The charterers attempted to terminate the contract. 

  • By this point, the market price for hiring a vessel had fallen dramatically. 

Initial decision 

The High Court held that a condition had been breached. 

Court of Appeal decision 

The Court of Appeal overturned the High Court's decision. 

Although seaworthiness was an important contractual obligation, the court considered the actual consequences of the breach. 

Diplock LJ recognised that not every contractual obligation fits neatly into the traditional categories of condition or warranty. 

Therefore, the consequences of the breach should determine whether termination is justified. 

23
New cards

21. The Deprivation of Benefit Test 

Diplock LJ established the test for determining whether a breach of an innominate term justifies termination. 

The central question is: 

Does the breach deprive the innocent party of substantially the whole benefit they were supposed to receive under the contract? 

The court examines the practical consequences of the breach rather than simply the importance of the term itself. 

Application to Hong Kong Fir 

  • The vessel required extensive repairs. 

  • However, the vessel was repaired and given a new crew relatively early in the two-year agreement. 

  • The charterers still had approximately 17 months of exclusive use of the vessel. 

  • Therefore, they had not been deprived of substantially the whole benefit of the contract. 

Judgment: 

The charterers were entitled to substantial damages for the losses and inconvenience suffered. 

However, they were not entitled to terminate the contract. 

Legal principle: 

A breach of an innominate term allows termination only where its consequences are sufficiently serious to deprive the innocent party of substantially the whole benefit of the contract. 

24
New cards

22. Advantages and Disadvantages of Innominate Terms 

Advantages 

Disadvantages 

Provides flexibility for courts. 

Reduces legal certainty. 

Allows courts to consider the actual consequences of a breach. 

Parties may not know in advance whether a breach will justify termination. 

Prevents parties from escaping contracts because of trivial breaches. 

Can create uncertainty over the available remedies. 

Allows commercially workable contracts to continue. 

A party may wrongly believe that a contract has ended and become liable for refusing to perform. 


Commercial importance 

Innominate terms can prevent sharp practice. 

For example, a party might try to terminate an otherwise useful contract because market prices have changed and they can obtain a better deal elsewhere. 

The Hong Kong Fir approach prevents this where the breach has not substantially deprived the innocent party of the benefit of the contract. 

25
New cards

PART 4: COMPARISON AND EXAM REVISION 

…

26
New cards

23. The Three Categories of Contractual Terms 

Conditions 

Termination available 

  • Fundamental contractual terms. 

  • Breach allows damages. 

  • Innocent party can also terminate. 

Warranties 

Damages only 

  • Less important contractual terms. 

  • Breach allows damages. 

  • Innocent party cannot terminate solely because of the breach. 

Innominate terms 

Depends on consequences 

  • Intermediate contractual terms. 

  • Breach allows damages. 

  • Termination is available if the breach deprives the innocent party of substantially the whole benefit of the contract. 


27
New cards

24. Key Cases to Memorise 

Case 

Main legal principle 

Hutton v Warren (1836) 

Trade customs can be implied into contracts. 

Cunliffe-Owen v Teather (1967) 

Requirements for implying trade customs. 

The Moorcock (1889) 

Business efficacy test. 

Reigate v Union Manufacturing (1918) 

Necessity for business efficacy. 

Shirlaw v Southern Foundries (1940) 

Officious bystander test. 

BP Refinery (1977) 

Five requirements for implying terms. 

Belize Telecom (2009) 

Objective interpretation and implication of terms. 

Marks & Spencer v BNP Paribas (2015) 

Modern restrictive approach to implying terms. 

Liverpool City Council v Irwin (1977) 

Terms implied at law. 

Scally v Southern Health Board (1991) 

Employer's obligation to inform employees of certain benefits. 

Bentsen v Taylor (1893) 

Distinguishing conditions and warranties. 

The Seaflower (2000) 

Four categories for identifying conditions. 

Arcos v Ronaason (1933) 

Minor breach of a condition can justify termination. 

Bunge v Tradax (1981) 

Commercial certainty and conditions. 

Schuler v Wickman (1974) 

Labelling a term a condition is not necessarily decisive. 

Bettini v Guy (1876) 

Breach of warranty does not justify termination. 

Hong Kong Fir (1962) 

Innominate terms and deprivation of benefit test. 


28
New cards

25. Important Distinctions for Exams 

1. Implied terms vs express terms 

  • Express terms are specifically agreed by the parties. 

  • Implied terms are inserted through legislation or common law. 

2. Terms implied in fact vs terms implied in law 

  • In fact: concern what is necessary to give effect to the particular contract. 

  • In law: concern terms implied into a particular category of contracts. 

3. Interpretation vs implication 

  • Interpretation establishes the meaning of existing contractual wording. 

  • Implication inserts a term that is not expressly included. 

4. Conditions vs warranties 

  • Conditions allow damages and possible termination. 

  • Warranties allow damages only. 

5. Conditions vs innominate terms 

  • Conditions generally allow termination following breach. 

  • Innominate terms require examination of the consequences of the breach. 

6. Warranties vs innominate terms 

  • Warranties do not allow termination. 

  • Innominate terms may allow termination if the breach is sufficiently serious.