1/7
Looks like no tags are added yet.
the heritability of schizophrenia & candidate genes
Gottesman (1991) conducted research into the heritability of schizophrenia and found a concordance rate of 48% between MZ twins and 17% between DZ twins
Supports the idea that there is a genetic explanation as MZ twins are more likely to develop schizophrenia than DZ twins
However, Gottesman found a concordance rate of 9% between siblings, yet they have the same genetic makeup as DZ twins at 17% - which introduces the idea of an environmental factor in the development of schizophrenia
There is no single gene that has been identified as causing schizophrenia; rather, it is thought that the condition is polygenic
Salleh (2004) conducted research into molecular genetics, identifying some candidate genes of schizophrenia
Neuregulin 1, dysbindin and proline dehydrogenase
These candidate genes are all implicated in the production and regulation of key mood-related neurotransmitters dopamine, serotonin and glutamate
Hong et al. (2001) discovered that the TPH gene variation was significantly more common in schizophrenics than non-schizophrenics
mccarroll et al. (2016)
McCarroll et al. (2016) analysed the genomes of 65,000 people and 700 postmortem brains
Found that the strongest known genetic risk of schizophrenia comes from the gene C4
heston (1966)
Heston (1966)
Studied 47 adopted children (now grown up) of schizophrenic mothers, which he matched with 47 adopted children whose mothers weren’t schizophrenic
All participants were interviewed
10% of the children with schizophrenic mothers developed schizophrenia
None of the control group developed schizophrenia
Heston controlled for any impact adoption might have caused
The results could indicate self-fulfilling prophecy as some of the children with schizophrenic mothers might have been aware of their family history and this may have had an impact on their own development of schizophrenia
heston (1966)
Heston (1966)
Studied 47 adopted children (now grown up) of schizophrenic mothers, which he matched with 47 adopted children whose mothers weren’t schizophrenic
All participants were interviewed
10% of the children with schizophrenic mothers developed schizophrenia
None of the control group developed schizophrenia
Heston controlled for any impact adoption might have caused
The results could indicate self-fulfilling prophecy as some of the children with schizophrenic mothers might have been aware of their family history and this may have had an impact on their own development of schizophrenia
gurling et al. (2006)
Gurling et al. (2006)
Found that if a mutation of PCM1 (gene encodes the PCM1 protein) is inherited, then the risk of developing schizophrenia was found to be 68%
strengths of genetic basis of schizophrenia
Methods used to measure a genetic explanation for schizophrenia are clinical, objective and not affected by sources of bias such as individual differences, which means that they have good reliability and validity
There is now a huge and compelling body of research evidence which points to genetics playing a key role in the development of schizophrenia
A genetic basis of schizophrenia means that it may be possible to offer genetic counselling to people with schizophrenia who are carriers of the PCM1 mutation
Genetic counselling involves discussing with carriers the likelihood of passing the gene on and educating them about the medical intervention that might be indicated
weaknesses of genetic basis of schizophrenia
Genetics is only one explanation of schizophrenia
If schizophrenia was purely biological, then concordance rates for MZ twins would be 100%, which no research has ever found
The symptoms of schizophrenia are varied and will not present in the same way per person - the absence of a biomarker means that from a genetic perspective, it is very difficult to know definitively if a patient actually has schizophrenia or if they have another disorder altogether
link of genetic explanation for schizophrenia to issues & debates
The genetic explanation exemplifies the nature side of the nature-nurture debate, suggesting schizophrenia is largely inherited through candidate genes and thus the relative contribution of nature is higher
The fact that MZ twins only show a 48% concordance rate (Gottesman, 1991) suggests that environmental factors must also play a key role
The most valid explanation is likely to be interactionist, combining genetic vulnerability with environmental triggers (diathesis-stress model)
Focusing on candidate genes as an explanation for schizophrenia is biologically reductionist
This is because it simplifies a complex disorder to genetic and neurochemical factors alone
This ignores psychological, social, and environmental influences, such as trauma, family, dynamics, or life stress, which can also contribute to the disorder