1/45
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Plato’s Puzzle of Non-Existent + 3 Possible Solutions
How can we talk about something that doesn’t exist? — Existence, Subsistence, Social Conventions
What does Russell suggest to make sense of non-existents?
Distinguishing between names and descriptions
Logically Proper Names
Always have individual reference, theoretically unstructured, succeed in referring through an act of naming
Definite Descriptions
Describe w/o always referring, theoretically structured, grammatical form of “the ‘x’” (x being a singular common noun (phrase))
Indefinite Descriptions
Have grammatical form “an ‘x’” (x being a singular common noun (phrase)), fail to refer
Russell’s Theory of Ontologically Innocent
Names / descriptions rely on (real-world) properties and relations, not non-existing objects
What does Aristotle say about characteristics?
They can be either essential or accidental
12 Traditional characteristics of (a mono-theistic) God
Personal, immaterial, omnipotent, omniscient, omnibenevolent, holy, eternal, omnipresent, infinite, self-sufficient, sovereign, immutable
What do theists and atheists have in common?
Trust in reason and observation (logic vs transcendental / natural theology)
Paley’s Teleological Argument
Just as a watch has order, complexity, and purpose, so too do “works of nature”
Paley’s Teleological Argument Version 1
Individual works of nature — we should conclude that these individual parts have been designed and created (eg. the eye, the hearts, etc.)
Paley’s Teleological Argument Version 2
The universe as a whole — should conclude that the world as a whole has been designed and created (the entire universe)
Darwin’s Evolution Objection
Abiogenesis has no creator, neither does random changes in population + natural selection — result is a high level of complexity, order, and purpose, so not everything with high complexity needs to have been designed
Darwin’s Inconsistency Objection
God has high order, complexity, and purpose, but no creator — therefore, not everything with high complexity needs to have been designed
Darwin’s Theory of Natural Selection
Organisms w/ favourable traits will survive and pass on heritable traits to offspring, potentially leading to new species over generations
Modern Evolutionary Synthesis
Natural selection (phenotypes) + genetics (both visible characteristics and info at molecular level)
Anselm’s Ontological Argument
For God to remain the greatest conceivable being, he must exist not only in the mind, but also in reality (reality existence > understanding existence)
Lost Island Objection
Using Anselm’s logic, could argue existence of any “perfect” thing (eg. island) — Anselm counters that God has a necessary, unique perfection unlike any contingent thing
Moore’s Belief
Existence is not a property
Problem of Evil
If God is said to be omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent, then how does evil still exist?
Deism
View that there is a God(s) who created, but no longer interacts w/ world
Theism
View that there is a God(s) who created and maintains relationship w/ world
Fate
Ordering of world due to natural processes
Providence
God’s continuous sustaining of, and intervention in, the natural world
Purpose of Providence
W/o challenge of evil, we couldn’t exercise the good
Lactantius’s Earlier View
God could remove evil but chooses not to — provides wisdom instead, which is more valuable than the absence of evil, as it leads to knowledge of God and immortality
Boethius’s Proposition
Foreknowledge is distinct from cause — just because you can see things of the present, does it mean anything?
Criticism of Boethius’s Proposition
Since God is a necessary being, then everything he does is from necessity — if God necessarily has divine foreknowledge, then the present must happen necessarily (no free will)
Hume’s Thought Experiment
A being unfamiliar with the universe would not predict a world full of wrong, misery, and disorder, even considering human-caused evils
Hume’s 4 Sources of Misery (in addition to free will)
Pain and struggle for survival, governance by general laws, limited powers and faculties, inaccurate workmanship of nature
Pain and Struggle for Survival
Since people pursue pleasure as much as avoiding pain, wouldn’t pleasure alone be sufficient? Wouldn’t the absence of both be possible? (i.e plants)
Governance by General Laws
Perfect being could eliminate all evil and create all good w/o need for general laws / progression of causes and effects
Limited Powers and Faculties
Some harms unavoidable due to susceptibility to pain and general laws, worsened by limited distribution of powers and faculties —slight increase in human abilities and desire for work could significantly reduce prevalence of evils
Inaccurate Workmanship of Nature
Imperfect workings of nature’s principles — essential elements may be necessary for life, but often become harmful / excessive
Hume’s Conclusion
Universe appears to be governed by blind nature, lacking discernment / care
Leibnizian Optimism (modern views)
Concludes our world is the best God could’ve created — any world lacking particular evil would have to have even greater evils
Russell’s Conclusion (modern views)
Any God who’s a creator would be responsible for his creation
Swinburne’s Theodicy
Evil provides opportunity to show good
Dawkins’s Criticism (of Swinburne)
Idea that intentional suffering to exercise good virtue is grotesque — faith an evil itself as it has no justification / argument
3 Kinds of Errors
Factual, Logical, Conceptual / Category Mistakes
Factual Errors
Mistaken claims about facts in world typically justified through experience (eg. Plato lived in London (when he lived in Athens))
Logical Errors
Mistaken claim about which propositions follow from / implied by other propositions (eg. Plato didn’t have a sibling (even though he had a brother))
Conceptual / Category Mistakes
When properties / concepts applying to things in one logical category are incorrectly applied to things in a different logical category (eg. claiming happiness has a colour or justice has a mass)
Factual Claims
True → Plato lived in Athens
False → Plato lived in London
Typically justified through experience
Logical Claims
True → “Plato had a brother” implies “Plato had a sibling”
False → “Plato had a sibling” implies “Plato had a brother”
Typically justified through reason
Conceptual Claims
True → a paediatrician is a kind of medical doctor
False → a medical doctor is a kind of paediatrician
Typically justified through experience or reason (eg. science vs. math)