1/22
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Argument
A set of statements, one of which (the conclusion) is claimed to follow from the others (the premises). Example: 'All humans are mortal. Socrates is a human. Therefore, Socrates is mortal.'
Premise
A statement in an argument that is offered as evidence or reasons in support of the conclusion. Example: In 'Grass is green; therefore, grass has color,' 'Grass is green' is the premise.
Conclusion
The statement in an argument that the premises are claimed to support or demonstrate. Example: In 'All cats are animals. Felix is a cat. Therefore, Felix is an animal,' the conclusion is 'Felix is an animal.'
Statement
A sentence that has a truth value (i.e., it is either true or false). Example: 'Paris is the capital of France' is a statement.
Statement Test
A method to check if a sentence is a statement by asking whether it makes sense to put 'It is true that' in front of it. Example: Applying the test to 'Close the door' yields 'It is true that close the door,' which is nonsense; thus, it is not a statement.
Nonstatements (Questions and Commands)
Sentences that lack a truth value and cannot be true or false. Example: 'What time is it?' is a question and not a statement.
Identifying Arguments vs. Nonarguments
Arguments must contain at least one premise and a claimed conclusion, whereas nonarguments include reports, conditional statements, or illustrations without support claims. Example: 'If it rains, the ground gets wet' is a single conditional statement, not an argument.
Conclusion Indicators
Words or phrases that typically signal the presence of a conclusion. Example: Words like 'therefore,' 'thus,' 'consequently,' and 'so.'
Premise Indicators
Words or phrases that typically signal the presence of a premise. Example: Words like 'because,' 'since,' 'for,' and 'given that.'
Limitations of Indicators
Indicator words can sometimes appear in nonarguments or fail to indicate what they normally do, meaning context is always required. Example: 'Since 1990, the population has grown' uses 'since' as a time marker, not a premise indicator.
Standard Form
A structured layout of an argument listing the premises sequentially (P1, P2...) followed by a horizontal line and the conclusion (C). Example: P1: All dogs are mammals. P2: All mammals are warm-blooded. C: All dogs are warm-blooded.
Putting Arguments in Standard Form
The process of identifying, clarifying, and rewriting each premise and conclusion as a separate, declarative statement. Example: Rewriting 'Cats purr because they are happy' into standard form requires separating the claim and reason into distinct numbered lines.
Deductive Validity
An argument property where it is logically impossible for all the premises to be true while the conclusion is false. Example: P1: All bachelors are unmarried. P2: John is a bachelor. C: John is unmarried. (Valid)
Testing for Validity (Counterexample Method)
Imagining a scenario where all premises are true and checking if you can still conceive of the conclusion being false. Example: If you can imagine true premises leading to a false conclusion, the argument is invalid.
Invalidity
A property of deductive arguments where the truth of the premises does not guarantee the truth of the conclusion. Example: P1: All dogs are animals. P2: All cats are animals. C: All dogs are cats. (Invalid)
Soundness
A property of a deductive argument that is both valid and has all actually true premises. Example: An argument with true premises and valid structure guarantees a true conclusion.
Testing for Soundness
A two-step process: first check if the argument is valid, then check if all its premises are factually true in the real world. Example: An argument can be valid but unsound if one premise is factually false.
Valid and Sound Argument
An argument that has valid logical structure and entirely true real-world premises. Example: P1: All humans are mortal. P2: Socrates is human. C: Socrates is mortal. (Sound)
Valid and Unsound Argument
An argument with correct logical form but at least one false premise. Example: P1: All birds can fly. P2: Penguins are birds. C: Penguins can fly. (Valid, Unsound)
Invalid Argument Example
An argument where premises fail to logically support the conclusion. Example: P1: If it's raining, the street is wet. P2: The street is wet. C: It is raining. (Affirming the consequent, invalid)
Truth Value vs. Validity
Validity is about the logical relationship between premises and conclusion, not the actual truth values of the individual statements. Example: An argument can be valid even if every single statement in it is completely false.
Conditional Statements vs. Arguments
A conditional ('if-then') statement is a single complex sentence, whereas an argument consists of multiple independent statements acting as premises and a conclusion. Example: 'If P then Q' is a single premise-like statement, not a standalone argument.
Evaluating Deductive Success
The overall assessment of a deductive argument asking whether the form is valid and whether the premises are true. Example: A successful deductive argument must pass both the validity test and the factual truth test.