1/29
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Mission creep
The gradual expansion of police duties beyond their original law enforcement role
Because police respond it gives into the stigma that people with mental illnesses are dangerous or criminals
People with Mental health episodes say that their interactions with the police have been negative
How does a person with a mental illness come to the attention of the police?
A familiar person is concerned about them so you call the police
You may not know the person but you are concerned about them so you call the police
The person with the mental illness calls the police themselves as they don’t know what else to do or afraid that they’ll harm someone or themselves
Police encounter a person having an episode
A professional calls the police because they feel that the individual is a risk of causing harm
The police as gatekeepers
Because police are the first responders and are interact the most with people with mental health issues they choose what happens to them
The officer uses their discretion on what to do
3 possible dispositions
Informal resolution: officer will speak with individual, calm them down, moving them to another location (home or somewhere they know)
taking the person to the hospital
Arrest them
What factors might influence this decision?
Repeating encounters
Physical appearance and demeanor of the individual appear to look homelessness, acting rude leads to arrest, someone who is calm and cooperative take informal or hospital route
Severity of the incident, severity increases discretion decreases
Visibility of the incident, where does it take palace, in public or private, if it happens in the public then less discretion
Who initiated the interaction: citizen or police, the officer will have more discretion when its police initiated
Relationships between the parties involved, unfamiliar person will want it to be taken seriously and formally whereas if you know the person and express that you don’t want them to get arrested then they’ll take that into account
Perceived dangerousness of the individual, seen as too dangerous to be hospitalized, may also be seen as not dangerous enough to be hospitalized
Co-morbidity, blurs when drugs and alcohol are involved’
;likelihood of the situation recurring and escalating, if the police think its going to continue or escalate they’re going to take formal route but if they think its going to be over, a one time thing then its informal
Time and resources required to resolve the incident, formal route and hospital takes time and resources
Trans -institutionalized
individuals are now being shifted to one institution to another
Factors contributing to the criminalization of people with serious mental illness
mental illness not recognized by inexperienced police officers
Commission of lower-level offences
Public intolerance of aberrant behaviour, people may be less understanding to individuals acting in a weird or disrupting ways, causes them to call the police
Drug and alcohol use
Residence in lower SES (socio-economic status) neighbourhoods, higher contacts of running into the police due to police surveillance
Homelessness, increases the risk of being arrested
Tough on crime approaches
Arrest by default because there may not be any hospitals around or they don’t have training so they do what is most familiar to them, convenient, easiest at the time if options are limited
Mercy booking, the officer arrests and take the individual into custody but is doing it for their own good, provides them shelter, safety, form of protection or feel that they can get the mental health treatment they need
What are collateral consequences?
-difficulty getting a job
-imact relationships with children, family, partner
-difficulty renting or finding housing
-mental health decline
Why might people with mental illness be more likely to be denied bail?
Perceived flight risk, the person needs to attend court when their out in the community but any incline they won’t then denied
History of failure to appear
Transient lifestyle, no fixed address
Limited social support/lack of a surety
Concerns about public safety
Co-occurring substance use
Experiencing active symptoms
Limited insight into their illness, don’t believe their mental ill
if released the accused may be subject to mandatory and optional bail conditions
Mandatory conditions: appear in court
Optional bail conditions: personalized, staying away from certain places or people, refraining from alcohol and substances, curfews, license can be restricted
What happens if the conditions are violated?
Could be arrested or charged with failure to comply with a release order s.145 of criminal code
Not automatically arrested
Mental health act
-provincial, every province has their own
-legistation governing aspects of mental health care
-establishes the legal framework for psychiatric assessment, involuntary admission to psychiatric facilities and care in the community
provides directions regarding involuntary hospitalizations:
-when a person can be brought to hospital for a psychiatric assessment
- when a person can be involuntarily admitted and detained
- how long involuntary detention can continue
-the rights and legal protections of involuntary patients
Ontario mental health act s.15
-form 1: an application for psychiatric assessment completed by a physician
-if criteria are met, person can be involuntarily detained in hospital for up to 72 hours to undergo psychiatric assessment
-once the doctor signs this form it is valid for 7 days, has to be taken to the hospital within 7 days
Form 1
-what criteria is used to determine if the individual should be involuntarily admitted and evaluated?
- do they pose danger to themselves?
-do they pose danger to others?
-a lack of competence to care for themselves ex: unable to feed themselves, don’t trust food as they believe its poisonous, not dressing appropriately for winter, not taking care of personal hygiene due to psychosis (not showering for a month because they think the landlord put cameras in the shower)
Form 1
-the serious harm test, form that the doctor uses to make their decision if they should be detained for up to 72 for an evaluation
The past/present test
Need evidence of risk (recent or present)
The future test
Need evidence of mental disorder not a diagnosis
Ontario mental health act s.16
-form 2: a member of the community (social worker, mother, boyfriend) is concerned about an individual's mental health and provides a sworn information to justice of the peace
-the person they’re concerned about is not there, doesn’t have to be
-if the JP is satisfied that legal criteria are met (from before) a form 2 is issued and is valid for 7 days
Form 2 authorizes police to apprehend and transport the person to hospital for a psychiatric examination
-it does not authorize involuntary detention in hospital
-once at hospital, a physician will assess the individual and may issue a form 1 if criteria is met
what happens if after being detained on a form one, release is not granted?
Ontario Mental health act s.20
Form 3
certificate of involuntary admission
if this is issued the person can be kept in the hospital for an additional 2 weeks, could be released early but a two week cap
upholding due process, people’s rights aren’t abused
same physician that signed form 1 cannot sign form 3 as a safe guard/second opinion
Patient can challenge a form 3
The right to request a review of their involuntary admission by the consent and capacity board
Patient must submit a Form 16 (want their form 3 reviewed)
Form 16 cannot be used with a form 1
Form 16
a form a patient can submit to have their involuntairly admission from form 3 reviewed
What if further treatment is needed?
-Form 4, s.20: certificate of renewal, more time for the person to be detained
-1st time: valid for one month (starts after the two weeks)
-2nd time: valid for 2 months
-each following time - valid for 3 months
- patient can request a review of their involuntary status by consent and capacity board (form 16)
-as long as the criteria is being met it can be renewed x amount of times
Gone AWOL
-code yellow means missing patient
-what happens if a patient on a Form 1,3 or 4 leaves the hospital unauthorized?
-police will be contacted and can return the patient within 24 hours without a form
-after 24 hours, a Form 9 is issued to police
-police can return patient as an involuntary patient, valid for one month
-if they find the person after a month they cannot bring them to the hospital involuntarily unless certain criteria are met
-The MHA is provincial, what implications does this have?
-if the person crosses a provincial border the police cannot do anything even if they have a form 9
Can someone who is experiencing mental health issues be involuntarily brought to the hospital by the police without a form 1 or form 2
Section 17 of the Ontario MHA gives police the authority to apprehend an individual and transport them to hospital for an assessment
Section 17
Disorderly behaviour: the officer has reasonable and probable grounds to believe that the person is acting or has acted in a disorderly manner - not required in a form 1
The officer is of the opinion that it would be dangerous to proceed under section 16 (form 2) - not required in a form 1
Can someone be legally required to follow a psychiatric treatment plan even if they are not in a hospital?
community treatment order (CTO), s.33.1
Form 45 issued by physician after patient is discharged
purpose of CTO
Purpose: to prevent ‘revolving door’ patients
-to encourage treatment adherence while respecting independence
-to provide structure and support
-to enhance individual and public safety
CTO
-who is eligible?
- during the last 3 years, the individual must have:
Been a patient in a psychiatric facility on two or more separate occasions
Been a patient in a psychiatric facility for a cumulative total for at least 30 days
Previous been on a cto
One of these three things needs to be present to issue a form
Is a CTO voluntary or involuntary?
Requires consent because the person is not going to get help if they don’t want to, it’s not going to work
If the patient is capable of giving consent then they have to consent, if they don’t then it can’t happen
If the patient is not capable of giving consent then there is a person who is a substitute decision maker legally they can give consent
What does a treatment plan entail?
Various conditions
Attending psychiatric appointments, follow a prescribed medication plan, required to meet with mental health worker, cannot consume alcohol, living in community housing
How long does it last?
CTO is good for 6 months
Can it be renewed?
-yes
-every 6 months the doctor has to renew it
-no limit on how many times it can be renewed if the person meets criteria and doctor thinks it would benefit them
What happens if the person does not follow the plan?
-when you initially agree to it you have to follow it for 6 months but if the person stops following orders a form 47 can be issued so the police can take the person to the doctor and then the doctor tries to persuade the person for the benefits of the CTO