1/33
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What was Harold Berman's crisis? And what was his solution?
Berman predicament crisis of the WLT era was coming to an end.
Look to history for a solution.
Law is a matter of practicality or convenience, and religion is private. Berman saw believers who believe law comes from an external source of value, while skeptics understand law to come from taste or preference, will, power, or politics.
What are the obstacles to the Western legal tradition?
1) A narrowness of thought, knowledge, and action in law. 2)Laws reduced to technical devices to get things done. 3)Law's separation from history and focus on the present and immediate past. 4) Identification of the law in particular nations.
What are the 3 fallacies in the schools of thought?
A) LP- Exclusively political and analytical jurisprudence, B)NL Theory -Exclusively philosophical and moral jurisprudence, C)Historical and Social Theory of Law-Exclusively historical and socio-economic jurisprudence.
What is Berman's integrative jurisprudence?
His integrative jurisprudence integrates the 3 traditional schools and extends them to allow us to believe in law. Integrative jurisprudence informed by history incorporates reason, will, emotion, intuition, and faith.
Berman wanted to view law form a larger vision based more on technical devices.
What is Alschuler's thought on skepticism?
Skepticism is the modern way of thinking now.He dislikes moral subjectivism/moral relativism based on society's view of what is right or wrong. Skepticism unites contemporary legal thought. Does not agree with the growing skepticism.Instead, believes in inherent moral truths that right and wrong are part of moral realism or moral objectivism, and it is based on a moral fact, not a personal or group preference. Moral considerations are relevant in law.
What is Blackstone's definition of law?
Blackstone's definition of law: a rule of action that is prescribed by some superior and that the inferior is bound to obey.
What are Blackstone's types of law?
1) Natural Law-This type of law is the will of the Maker of humankind that is discovered by the faculty of reason. This law is a certain and unchangeable law that regulates and restrains human will. 2)The revealed or divine law- Law in holy scripture and God's direct and immediate revelation, expressly declared by God. It is more authentic than natural law. All human laws depend on these 2 types of law, so no law should contradict them. 3) Law of Nations- This law regulates the interactions among separate nations. NL is the only law common to all nations. 4)Municipal Law- is a rule of civil conduct prescribed by the supreme power in a state, commanding what is right and prohibiting what is wrong.
What are the 2 types of rights under Blackstone's view of law?
1) Absolute Rights- Belong to a particular person as an individual. Everyone has these, and they exist in the state of nature. 2) Relative Rights- These rights are numerous and complicated and are rights by law based on being a member of a society.
What Blackstone's Fundamental Rights?
Blackstone's 3 Fundamental Rights: 1) Personal Security - right of God to bodily autonomy. 2) Personal Liberty- right to move freely and not be restrained unless by due process. 3) Private Property-free use and enjoyment, selling property according to the laws of the land.
What are the principles of popular sovereignty?
1) Rule of Law- The people are sovereign, and law is supreme because the people have the power to make it that way. 2)Limited Government- The people are sovereign, not the government. The people do not serve the government; the government serves the people. 3)Inalienable Rights- Every person has these, and the civil government is bound to respect them (Individual sovereignty). 4)Equal Political Rights- each person has an equal right to participate in government as a sovereign. 5)The Power of the National Government over the States-The people are sovereign, not the states. The states retain only those powers not granted to the federal government or reserved to the people. 6)Separation of Church and State- The people are sovereign, not God. Laws reflect the will of the people, not the presumed will of God. 7)National Independence and the Limited Authority of International Law-The American people as a whole are sovereign and independent and are not subject to any foreign law or power.
What are the 3 themes of natural law?
The necessary connection between Law and Morality, a Higher Law that should inform human law and provide a basis for evaluating the justness of human laws, Principles Accessible to Reason-right and wrong are understood to exist independent of human positive law and independent of us, Universal Validity - Higher law transcends time, culture, politics, and geography, Standard of Justice- against which human positive laws, judicial decisions, and legal institutions can and should be judged. NL thinkers examine the overall purpose of a law based on the broader theme of justice.
What is Thomas Aquinas definition of law?
Thomas Aquinas' definition of law: an ordinance of reason for the common good, made by him who has care of the community, and promulgated.
What were Thomas Aquinas' 4 primary categories of law?
1)Eternal Law-involves the mind or character of God and the principles by which God made and governs the universe. It does not change or shift; it is the reality of God's purpose and plan. 2) Natural Law- It is the reflection of the eternal law in the rational mind of humans, and it dates back to creation. 3)Divine Law-God's special revelation in scripture. It is the reflection of the eternal law in the Bible. 4)Human Positive Law- Applications of NL to the needs of human societies. Human law comes from outside a person and is enforced externally using coercive powers.
What is the framework for Human positive law under Aquinas point of view?
1)Fundamental Principle (universal and self-evident)-Good is to be done and evil is to be avoided. 2)Primary precepts-Protection and preservation of life, Procreation, rearing, and educating children, Pursuit of knowledge, truth, God, and ordered society/social life. 3) Secondary Precepts (derivative)-No murder, adultery, harm to neighbors, respect property. 4)Determinations- Need for defined punishments, private property rules, prohibition of theft, and speed limits.
How does Aquinas feel about the justness of law?
Just and Unjust Laws- Positive law is either just or unjust. Unjust laws are more like violence.
What are the 8 ways that law could validated according to Lon Fuller?
Principle Standards of Legality: 1)Existence of Legal Rules, 2)Publication, 3)Prospective effect, 4)Intelligibility, 5)Non-contradictory Status in the same Legal System, 6)Possibility of Obedience, 7)Stability, 8)Congruence and their Administration
What are the principles of legal positivism?
General Principles (LP)- LP is a jurisprudential response to the interconnection of law and morality. Themes: Separability- Rules are social facts, and they are separate from morality. Source/Pedigree- If the law originates from a lawmaking authority, then it is valid regardless of whether it is moral or of merit. Neutrality/ Minimal Discretion, a legal decision is proper when it is neutral or when it is compelled by logic, with limited discretion exercised. Neutral decisions occur when the rule is applied to the facts without bias, political motivation, or personal preference (syllogism).
What is formalism?
Formalism encouraged judges should be tightly constrained by the objectively determinable meaning of a statute.
How does John Austin define law?
Austin- defining law as the command of the sovereign backed by sanction or force (gunman model)-command theory of law. The law is set by political superiors to political inferiors.
The law is set by political superiors to political inferiors.
What is Austin's 3 aspects of the term command?
1)Wish/desire-This is conceived by a superior that an inferior shall do. 2) Sanction-Evil proceeds from wishes or desires and is incurred by sanctions. If someone does not comply with the wishes, they can face sanctions. The evil is noncompliance. 3)Expression-An expression of the wish by words or other signs. Commands correlate with duties.
What are the 2 kinds of commands?
1) General commands and 2) Particular commands
What is Hans Kelsen's conception of law?
Hans Kelsen's Conception of Law: Built around a system of norms that ultimately rest on a basic or ground norm (grundnorm) that is self-evident and not derived from a superior norm. All the other norms in a system are derived from another norm, and their legitimacy rests on the norms from which they were derived (dynamic). Norms are either valid or invalid
What are the 2 normative systems?
2 Normative Systems: In a Static normative system, the basic norm is valid, and all of the particular norms in the system are derived from the basic norm by intellect. In a dynamic normative system, the norms must be created through acts of will by authority figures who create norms. So the basic norm is a fundamental rule to which the norms of the system are to be created
What is a legal norm?
A legal norm is dynamic, and to Kelsen, law is always positive law, and its positivity lies in the fact that it is created and annulled by acts of human beings.
What are HLA Hart's critiques of Austin?
4 Failures of Austin's theory: Criminal statutes apply to all, although they are backed by threats; some laws do not appear to be orders backed by threat, some legal rules are not explicitly prescribed, and it doesn't work in the modern legal system. Proposed a fresh start, focusing on the idea of a rule.
What are HLA Hart's primary and secondary rules?
Primary and Secondary Rules: Primary Rules-rules are basic rules of obligation that impose duties (what to do and not do).Secondary Rule- rules dependent or secondary to primary rules, and they introduce, extinguish, or modify, determine, or control primary rules.
What is being obliged versus obligated ?
Being obliged is subjective based on the threat of harm compelling one to obey based on psych motives. Being obligated is based on an objective psych motive, not needed. Agrees with the internal perspective of an obligation to obey, not an external perspective that one can only feel obliged to obey. Obligation is favorable because the rules are used as standards for their own and others' behavior. Rule of recognition (backed by pressure), Rule of change of rules, Rule of adjudication (authority
what art the skepticisms posed by legal realism?
Any notion of justice could be universally accepted, rules are determinate and neutral, judges are as constrained by rules, little to learn from social sciences, facts are hard realities.
What are the 2 types of legal realist skeptics of?
Fact skeptics-doubt about the ability of any judge or jury to determine the material facts. Instead, sift through facts and determine what happened in the case. Rule Skeptics doubt that judges are meaningfully constrained by legal rules; instead, they pick among the competing rules. Decisions are determined by some amalgam of reason, hunches, predispositions, intuitions, and other factors.
What is soft legal realism versus hard legal realism?
Soft legal realism: Accepts some political factors in judicial decision-making based on ideology and idealized pictures of society, rather than a desire to do political favors. Hard legal realism: reflects raw partisan politics and has nihilistic overtones.
What are the 2 strands of American legal realism?
Strands of American Legal Realism: Old-style legal realism- values or commitments of judges not rules or legal principles were understood to be decisive in cases. Empirical inquiries into facts and outcomes of cases (unsuccessful).
New-style legal realism (Miles and Sunstein). In this strand, scholars have undertaken to understand the sources of judicial decisions on the basis of testable hypotheses and large data sets. New legal realists take the personality of the judge in Llewellyn's thinking to mean the observable, personal characteristics of judges, such as their political affiliations, demographics, and prior professional experiences.
What is the Idiosyncrasy of Jerome Frank?
Idiosyncrasy with Jerome Frank posited that individual judges decided cases based upon their own individual biases, emotional maturity, and personal hunches.
What is the Sociological Wing of LLwellyn?
Sociological Wing of Llewellyn wanted to reform law by applying social scientific methods to find patterns of judicial behavior on the assumption that social factors led to judicial decisions.
What are Jospeh Singer's 4 broad propositions?
1)impossible to use a unique set of legal rules from existing precedents, 2) General propositions or concepts do not decide concrete cases. 3) Rather than deciding cases based on general principles, judges should use situation-sense, meaning the ability to fit the law to social practice and to satisfy the felt needs of society to achieve a satisfying working result. 4) Judges should balance pragmatically competing interests in light of policies, principles, and values.