1/117
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is the principal difference between law and equity
the type of remedy: law gives money damages, equity gives an injuction
Who decides an equitable claim, and how is it it enforced?
A judge (no jury), enforeced by contempt (civil and/or criminal)
What are the 3 questions to ask about any remedy?
Legal or equitable
is there a jury
how much in damages
Can a court award both legal and equitable relief
yes, in the same case
What are the 4 prerequisites for an injuction
no adequate legal remedy
irreparable harm
balancing of the equities
likelihood of success on the merits
What does a court weigh when balancing the equities
Public policy, hardship to the parties, and the defendant’s fault
Which prerequisite applies specifically to premilinary injuctions?
Likelihood of success on the merits
Can a TRO issue without hearing the other side? Why?
Yes, when harm is imminent. It holds things as they are until both sides can be heard
Preliminary vs. Permanent injuction
preliminary: temporary, while the suit is pending (a longer TRO)
Permanent: final order after trial, usually prohibitory
mandatory vs. prohibitory injuction
mandatory: must do something
prohibitory: must not do something
What are the two purposes of pleading?
fair notice, and the opportunity to respond and defend
What is the discovery dilemma?
You need facts to plead, but the other side doesn’thave to disclose them until the suit starts
what does Rule 8(a)(2) require?
a short and plain statment of the claim showing that the pleader is entitled to relief
which rule defines a pleading and what are the 7 types
Rule 7(a): a complaint; an answer to a complaint; an answer to a counterclaim; an answer to a crossclaim; a third-party complaint; an answer to a third-party complaint; and a reply to an answer, if the court orders one.
What was the statutory basis of Twombly, and what does it require?
Section 1 of the Sherman Act, which requires a comibinatin (conspiracy) in restarin of trade
What did the Disctrict Court and Court of Appeals do in Twombly
The Disctrict Court dismissed (more than parallel counduct needed). The Court of Appeals reversed (parallel conduct could be plausible), relying on Conley
What was the Conley v Gibson standard and waht happened to it?
No dismissal unless there is “no set of facts” that could support the claim. Twombly dismissed it as best forgotten
What is the Twombly pleading standard?
Plausibillity; more than labels, conclusions, or a formulaic recitation of the elements. The facts must raise the right to releif above the speculative level
Rule 8(a)(2); Possibility, plausibility, or probability?
plausibility. mere possibility is rejected, and probability isn’t required
Did Twombly change Rule 8?
no it only reinterpreted “short and plain”
Why did the Twombly complaint fail?
parallel conduct alone doesn’t plausibly suggest conspiracy. It needed “plus factors” pointing to an agreement rather than independent self-interested decisions
What is an amicus brief?
a brief form a non-party, giving the court information or arguments on the issue
What does a Rule 12(b)(6) motion challenge?
Failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted. It tests the legal sufficiency of the complaint, not whether the allegations can be proven
How does the court treat factual allegations on a 12(b)(6) motion?
As true, for purposes of the motion
When can a 12(b)(6) defense be raised?
usually before the responsive pleading, but its preserved and can be raised as late as trial
Is a 12(b)(6) dismissal usually with out without prejudice
without prejudice, so the plaintiff can re-plead
Are complex cases or pre se cases held to a different pleading standard
No. Transubstantivity means all pleadings are held to the same standard
What was Twombly’s effect on dismissal rates?
It required more rigorous pleading - enough facts for a plausible claim - and dismissal rates increased
What is a Rule 12(e) motion and when must it be made?
A motion for a more definite statement against a pleading so vague or ambiguous that the party can’t reasonably respond. It’s made before the responsive pleading and must point out the defects and the details wanted
Why is 12(e) less harsh than 12(b)(6)?
the pleader restates the claim more definitely instead of losing it
What is the danger of pleading too much information
it shows your hand, and new evidence can later conflict with what you pleaded
What does Rule 8(d)(1)
each allegation must be simple, concise, and direct, with no technical form required
What does Rule 8(d)(2) allow
Alternative or hypothetical statments of a claim or defense. If any one is sufficient, the pleading is sufficient
What does Rule 9(d)(3) allow
as many separate claims or defenses as a party has, regardless of consistency
What does Rule 10(b) require
Numbered paragraphs, each limited to a single set of circumstances. If it promotes clairty, each claim from a separate transaction or ooccurrence goes in a separate count
What does Rule 9(b) require
fraud or mistake must be pleaded with particularity. State of mind may be alleged generally
What are the 3 purposes of Rule 9(b)
adequate notice and deterring complaints filed as a pretext to discover unknown wrongs
protecting reputations
stopping plaintiffs from imposing enormous costs without a factual basis
What did Kearns v Ford hold
Rule 9(b) applies to claims grounded in fraud even if not labeled fraud/ the plaintiff must plead who, what, when, where, and how
Do the Federal Rules apply to a state-law claim in federal court
Yes. Kearns: 9(b) applied even though the claim arose under state law
What is de novo review
the court decides the issue fresh, without deference to the lower court’s decision
Why may state of mind be alleged generally
a general allegation of state of mind isn’t as damaging to reputation as a fraud allegation
What is scienter
the defendan’t knowledge of wrongdoing and intent to act despite it. It’s part of mens rea in most crimes and required when alleging fraud in tortsW
What does the PSLRA show about the federal rules
they are default rules that more specific legislation can modify. The PSLRA imposes a super-heightened standard: specify each misleading statment
What is the Tellabs standard for scienter
the inference must be cogent and at least as compelling as any opposing nference, based on all the facts taken together
What did Scalia and Alito say is Tellabs
the inference of scienter should be more likely than not correct
What does Rule 9(g) require?
If an item of special damages is claimed, it must be specifically stated
What are general damages
Damages that flow directly from the wrong and can be alleged generally
What are speical damages
unusual or unforeseen damages so they must be spefically pleaded
What happens if you fail to plead special damages
generally, you’re barred from proving them at trial
What happened in Ziervogel v. Royal Packing
the plaintiff raised unleaded special damages (blood pressure, shoulder injury) at trial. That was improper, and a new trial on liability and damages was ordered, even though the defendant wasn’t truly surprised
What recurring principle does Ziervogel show
The law abhors surprise, meaning anything new that keeps the other side from preparing
Why must special damages be specifically alleged
Without the allegation, there’s no remedy. If they aren’t you’re generally barred from proving them at trial
What does Swanson v. Citibank illustrate?
How courts apply Twombly in practice
What claims did Swanson bring
Racial discrimination against Citibank (loan rejection, under two federal statutes), racial discrimination against the appraiser, and fraud against Citibank
Why did Swanson’s discrimination claims survive?
They were plausible. The complaint identified what (racial discrimination), who (Citibank and the appraiser), and when (2009, while seeking the loan)
Do extra facts undermine a complaint
No, proven by Swanson
Why might pleading be easier in Swanson than Twombly
Facts are easier to state in cases that aren’t complex
Does the court decide whehter the complaint’s facts are true at the pleading stage?
No , only whether the claim is plausible
Why was Swanson’s fraud claim dismissed?
She failed to allege losses. She needed to allege a monetary loss and state a number
What was Posner’s dissent in Swanson an example of?
Arithmetic in decisions: he did wuick math on the loan figure and found the claim umplausible
Why is a complaint broken into small, separate paragraphs?
So the defendant has to address each piece on its own
Can a complaint seek an injuction and money damages together?
Yes. An injunction request must be more specific, and the court may award more or less than requested
What does Rule 8(b)(1) require in an answer?
State defenses to each claim in short and plain terms, and admit or deny each allegatoin
What does Rule 8(b)(2) require of a denial?
It must fairly respond to the substance of the allegation
When is a general denial allowed (Rule 8(b)(3)?
Only if the party in good faith denies everything, including jurisdiction. Otherwise, deny specific allegations, or generally deny all except those specifically admitted
How do you deny part of an allegation (Rule 8(b)(4)?
Admit the part that’s true and deny the rest
What if the defendant lacks knowledge to admit or deny (Rule 8(b)(5)?
Say so. It has the effect of a denial
What is the effect of failing to deny (Rule 8(b)(6)?
The allegation is admitted, except the amount of damages, if a responsive pleading is required
What are the 3 possible responses to each allegation?
admit, deny, or state insufficient knowledge
Can an admission in an answer be undone?
No, not at trial or on appeal, unless the court allows withdrawal
What is the common practice in drafting an answer
Deny everything generally, then admit what must be admitted. Never volunteer information
What are the risks of a true general denial
It also denies jurisdiction, and a court may reject it as an insufficient response
When can a court extend a deadline under Rule 6(b)?
For good cause: before it expires (with out without a motion or notice), or after it expires on a motion, if the failure was due to excusable neglect
Must a plaintiff amend the complaint because facts were denied in the answer
No
What is an affirmative defense Rule 8 (c)
A defense that defeats the claim on grounds other than the mertis, even if everything in the complaint is true. It must be affirmatively stated in the answer
What happens if you don’t plead an affimative defense
You can lose it. It must be raised on time so the other side has notice
What is the most common affirmative defense
statute of limitation
What is laches
The equitable version of the statute of limitations. It’s more flexible: the judge decides if the delay was unfair, considering prejudice to the defedant and whether evidence and witnesses are still available
What is the statute of limitations
A time limit to file suit. It defeats the claim regardless of the merits
What is duress
the party acted only because the other side forced them, such as being coerced into signing a contract
What is fraud
A false representation that another party relied on to their detriment
What is the statute of frauds
certain contracts must be in writing to be enforceable such as contracts for the sale of land
What was the fellow servant rule
Mostly obsolete. It shielded an employer from liability when one employee injured another
What is Res Judicata
A matter already decided by a court can’t be pursued again by the same parties
What are the two ways to extend the time to answer
by the court Rule 6(b) or be stupulation of the parties
How does a stipulation to extend time work
it’s very common to immediately ask the other side. Both parties sign it and file it with the court
What is contributory negligence
An affirmative defense asserting that the plaintiff’s own failure to use reasonable care contributed to their injury or loss
What is estoppel
A doctrine that prevents a party from asserting a claim, right or fact that contradicts their prior words, conduct, or a prior court ruling
What is illegality
An affirmative defense: a court won’t enforce a claim, contract, or right that stems from, requires, or seeks to profit from unlawful conduct or conduct contrary to public policy
What is waiver
The intentional andvoluntary giing up of a known right, defense, or claim
When can a party amend as a matter of course Rule 15 (a)(1)
Once without permission, within 21 days after serving the pleading, or if a response is required, 21 days after the responsive pleading or a 12(b), (e), or (f) motion, whichever is earlier
How can a party amend after the free amendment Rule 15 (a)(2)
only with the opposing party’s wriiten consent or the court’s leave, which should be freely given when justice so requires
Why would an opposing party consent to an amendment
Judges don’t like getting involved. If the judge would likely allow it anyway, refusing just annoys the judge
What does Foman v. Davis say about leave to amend
it should be freely given but is within the district court’s discretion. Grant it unless there’s an apparent reason to deny, such as undue delay, bad faith, or undue prejudice
What are the key factors in deciding whether justice so requires an amendment
prejudice and good faith
What is the rule from Moore v Moore
Issues not in the pleadings may be added by amendment if they were tried with the parties’ express or implied consent Rule 15 (b)
What was allowed and not allowed in Moore v Moore
Allowed: child support, visitation, and attorney’s fees, those which were natural consequences of the custody action
Not allowed: seprarate maintenance, no proof of consent and allowing it would’ve been an abuse of discretion
What happened in Beeck v. Aquaslide
The defendant amended its answer to deny making the slide after the statute of limitations had run. Thr trial court did not abuse its discretion in allowing it, because leave is freely given when justice requires and no prejudice was shown
Why couldn’t Beeck use relation back?
The statutory-predicate option 15 (c)(1)(A) didn’t exist yet at the time
Why does relation back matter
an amendement that relates back to the original pleading’s date gets around the statute of limitations