1/131
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Pharmacoeconomics definition
Identifies, measures, and compares the costs and outcomes of programs, services, or therapies and determining which alternative produces the best health outcome for the resource invested
What does cost mean in pharmacoeconomics
The value of the resources consumed by a program or drug therapy of interest
What does outcome mean in Pharmacoeconomics
The effects or outputs of a program or drug therapy of interest
Why are pharmacoeconomics important
More new, high cost, technologies, drugs, etc. Greater demand for services, competition for resources and helps pick the cheapest alternative
What is silo mentality
There is a higher population to treat due to people living longer which diminishes resources and increases competition for such resources
What does cheapest alternative mean in pharmacoeconomics
With respect to drug acquisition cost, is not always the best value for patients, departments, institutions , systems, or society
What are the four main types of Pharmacoeconomics analysis
Cost minimization, cost benefit, Cost effectiveness, and cost utility analysis
Cost minimization analysis outcomes
Drugs are proven equivalent (in both safety and efficacy drug A and B are no better than one another)
Cost minimization analysis calculation
Sum of costs 1 -sum of cost 2
Cost minimization analysis decision rule
Chose alternative with the lowest total cost
Cost minimization analysis application
Brand vs. Generic, IV vs. PO switch
Cost benefit analysis outcome
Outcomes are converted into dollars/money value
Cost benefit analysis calculation
Net benefit = sum of benefits - sum of costs to provide the intervention
If costs > benefit = bad
If benefits > costs = good
Cost benefit analysis decision rule
Chose alternative with a positive net benefit or if more than one alternative, chose the ore with the greatest net benefit assuming you can afford it
Cost benefit analysis application
Assess the return on investment of a program/therapy, or compare programs/ therapies with different outcome units
Cost effectiveness analysis outcomes
Natural units for the disease (measures output in natural input measurement that is relevant to the disease or medication, e.g. BP can be measured in mmHg, or MI, stroke)
Cost effectiveness analysis calculation
Incremental cost effectiveness ratio (ICER) = (costs of A - costs of B) / (effect if A - effect of B)
Cost effectiveness analysis decision rule
Reflects now much more it costs to gain one additional unit if outcome, chose the therapies in the willingness to pay threshold is not passed
Cost effectiveness analysis application
Assess the cost-effectivness greater than or equal to 2 therapies assessed using the same outcome
Cost utility analysis outcomes
Quality adjusted life years (qalys) which are how long someone lives x the quality of life they are living at, usually life years
Cost utility analysis calculation
ICUR= (costs A - costs of B) / (QALY A - QALY B)
Cost utility analysis decision rule
Used as a willingness to pay threshold like the cost effectiveness analysis
Cost utility analysis application
Same as cost effectiveness analysis but defined as QALY s
Willingness to pay threshold
Represents the maximum amount of money that a health system, payer, or society is willing to spend to gain one additional unit of health benefit.if the ICER< WTP threshold ,than the intervention is considered cost effective
Cost of illness studies
Identifies and estimates the overall costs of a specific disease to society. Helps policy makers prioritize funding and allocate resourcesa
What are the four types of healthcare costs
Direct medical, direct nonmedical, indirect, intangible
Direct medical healthcare cost
Incurred for medical products and services used to print, detect, and/or treat a disease. Examples include medications, supplies, lab tests, providers time, hospitalization
Direct non medical healthcare costs
Expenses for non medical services arising from illness or disease excluding medical service purchases. Examples include transportation, food, family care, home aids.
Indirect healthcare costs
Reduction of productivity like morbidity and mortality costs. Examples include post wages due to absenteeism, presenteeism, or premature death
Intangible healthcare costs
Nonfinancial outcomes of diseases and medical care. Examples include pan, suffering inconvenience, grief.
What are the 3 types of outcomes in the echo model
Economic, clinical, humanistic
What are the economic outcome in the echo model
Healthcare resource utilization. An example is reduction in the number of hospitalizations
Clinical outcome in the echo model
Efficacy/effectiveness in surrogate or terminal outcomes, adverse events. An example is a a reduction in hemoglobin A1C, MI, stroke, death
Humanistic outcome in the echo model
Patient reported outcomes, activities of daily living. An n example is improvements inpatient quality of life or disease state preference
What are the 4 common methods for assigning costs of drugs
Average wholesale price, average manufacture price, actual acquisition cost, and cash or copay
What is the average whole sale price ((AWP) for drugs
Average price payed by a retailer to buy a drug from the wholesaler but it is not a true market price and may be inflated
What is the average manufacture price (AMP) for drugs
Average price paid to the manufacturer for the drug in the United States by wholesalers
What is the actual acquisition cost (AAC) for drugs
Actual prices paid by a provider to acquire drug products. This includes 340B drug discounts, negotiated manufacture discounts and rebates, wholesaler contracts
Cash or copay method of costs for drugs
Fixed amount that a patient pays out of pocket for a drug ( with a portion paid or not paid by health insurance)
Common method for assigning cost for office visits and clinician time
Use the current procedural terminology codes which are standardized set of codes used to describe medical, surgical, and diagnostic services in both in and out patient settings
Methods for assigning costs personnel time
Use the time in motion study and is used when CPT codes are inadequate or donot exist cost= time to perform task x wage rate
Types of Methods for assigning cost hospitalizations
Diagnosis related group codes, perdiem, or microcosting
diagnosis related codes (DRG)
used to classify hospital cases into groups that are expected to has similar hospital resources use and costs by the prospective payment system they are based on icd-10 codes
Perdiem hospitalization costing
least used method but for each day a patient is in the hospital, and an average cost per day for av cause hospitalizations or for a specific condition is used
Micro costing method for hospitalization costing
Invokes collecting information on resource use for each component of a hospitalization. Is a labor intensive process, very precise, itemized patient bills
What is a cost to charge ratio
Charges are the amount hospitals bill patients or insurance companies for services provided. Charges are converted to costs
Cost to charge ratio equation
Total costs for providing care (expenses) / total charges for providing care (revenue)
Valuing indirect costs using the human capital approach
Attempts to value indirect costs due to morbidity and mortality. Estimates wage and productivity losses due to illness, disability or death. Uses two components which are missed work time because if illness or death (days/years) and wage rate. Simple to apply but undervalues those with pay inequity, children, and elderly and does not take intangible costs into account.
How to value intangible cost
The willingness to pay threshold values both the indirect and intangible aspects of a disease or condition. Asks the question now much are they willing to pay to avoid spending time being sick.
Consumer price index for medical care
Tracks changes in the prices of medical goods and services over time allowing for the standardization of historical costs to reflect current day values (brings past costs to present day)
Discussing price adjustments
Done to determine the present value of all costs and to incorporate society's time preference for money now vs. later. This is performed if costs are estimated based on dollars spent or saved in future years. (Brings future costs to present day values)
Discounting formula
PV = (FV) / (1+r)t
FV = future valve
r= discount rate
t= number of years in the future
Sensitivity analysis definition
The what if analyses that systematically vary key variables within plausible ranges to determine if the results of an analysis changes conclusion. Tests the robustness if the analysis to assumptions
What are the four sensitivity analyses
Oneway, threshold, multiple way, probabilistic (Monte Carlo simulation)
One way sensitivity analysis
Varies one cost or outcome at a time with a plausible range. Example is drug cost as AWP or AAC
Threshold sensitivity analysis
Varies one cost or outcome at a time until the breakeven point is acceded, meaning therapy is no longer cost effective, beneficial, neutral vs alternative. Example is increase drug costs until ICER> willingness to pay threshold
Multiple way sensitivity analysis
Varies 2 or more costs or outcomes at a time. Example is any costs + /- 25% AND efficacy across upper and lower bounds of 95% CI
Probabilistic (Monte Carlo) sensitivity analysis
Varies multiple costs or outcomes at the same time based upon values chosen randomly within an assigned distribution. Examples are drug costs, hospitalization costs, effectiveness, quality of life (healthy unity), using such as beta, gamma, normal, triangle,uniform
Tornado diagram
One way sensitivity analysis
Threshold sensitivity analysis
monte carlo simulation sensitivity analysis loss known as an ICE plane
What is a humanistic outcome
Health-related quality of life, preference based measure (health utilities), patient reported out measures (PROMS)
Reasons to measure humanistic outcomes
important for terminal outcomes, represent a patient of proxy viewpoint, patient adherence, many therapies main effect is to improve quality of life, some therapies may improve effectiveness but decrease quality of life
Important uses of humanistic outcomes
Outcomes of cost effective or cost utility analysis, formulary decision making, monitor comically based services or programs, assist patient response to therapy, and assess patient adherence
Humanistic related quality of life (HRQOL) terms
Questionnaire= instrument =tool
Questions= items
Domains=scale
What are the general profile measures for HRQOL
Short form (SF -36) or SF-12
What are the disease specific profile mesas for HRQOL
Dermatology life qualify index (DLQI)
functional assessment of cancer therapy colorectal scale (FACT-C) scale
Asthma quality of life questionnaire (AQLQ)
Advantages of generic HRQOL (SF-36/12)
Broadly applicable and comparable across many disease states and conditions, summarizes ranges of domains, may detect unanticipated effects
Disadvantages of generic HRQOL (SF-36/12)
May not be relevant for specific populations, results maybe more difficult to interpret, and may not be responsive ts changes in health for every disease or condition
Advantages to disease specific HRQOL (DLQI)
Me relevant for specific populations and more response to changes in health
Disadvantages to disease specific HRQOL (DLQI)
Cannot compare across populations and less likely to detect unanticipated effects
SF -36 / SF -12
Common generic health survey instrument used, takes about 5-10 minutes, reliability and validity have been recorded in clinical situations and disease states, contains physical and mental component scores (PCS and MCS)
SF-12 /36 domains
There are eight domains: physical functioning, vitality, bodily pain, role limitation attributed to physical problems, genera health, social functioning, role imitations attributed to emotional problems, mental health
What are the types of psychometric statistics
Reliability, validity, and responsiveness/sensitivity
What is psychometrics
Science of quantifying characteristics of people based on their response to a test or survey
Psychometric statistic reliability
The extent to which measures give accurate and consistent results. Consists of internal consistence and test retest reliability
What is internal consistency
Type of reliability that assesses the performance of items within a scale (Cronbach's alpha coefficient)
What is test retest
Type of reliability that refers to the relationship between scores obtained from the same instrument on greater than or equal to 2 separate occasions when all pertinent conditions remain relatively unchanged (Interclass correlation (efficient)
Vanity psychometric statistic
Does it measure what it is supposed to measure? Uses content validity ( correlate scores with theoretical concepts or other questionnaires) and face validity ( whether an instrument appears to measure the most important aspects of health
Responsiveness/sensitivity psychometric statistic
Ability to detect change over time
Health utility scoring: 1
Perfect health
Health utility scoring: 0
Death
Health utility scoring:<0
Worse than death
What are health utility scores used for
To calculate qualify adjusted life years (QALYs) which are the outcomes of interest in cost utility analysis
Direct methods fir eliciting health utility scores
Visual analog scales
Game theory (time trade off and standard gamble)
Time trade off
Type of method for eliciting health utility score that reflects the remaining life expectancy that a person may be prepared to trade diff to avoid remaining in a sub perfect health state
Standard gamble
Type of method used for eliciting health utility scores by reflecting the chance that someone is willing to gamble on to avoid remaining in a sub perfect health state
EQ-5D
Most used method fir eliciting health utility scores indirectly and each health state is associated with a heath utility score derived from using a time trade off method
what are the five domains in the EQ-5D
Mobility, self care, usual activities, pain/discomfort, anxiety/depression
Minimal important difference
Represents a threshold value of change in PROM score deemed to have an implication in clinical management and is calculated by either anchor or distribution based
Distribution based MID
defined based on statistical parameters reflecting statistical spread/ variation and measurement accuracy of the PROM. An example is standard deviation
MID standard deviation range
0.33 to 0.5
Anchor based MID
Uses a transition rating scale know as the anchor, which is applied at the post treatment time point to patients. Serves as an external standard against which changes in the PROM score can be compared.
Patient satisfaction
A humanistic outcome to consider to evaluate the extent to which the individuals wants and needs are met. There is an increasing important of patients satisfaction as an indicator of quality of care in medicine. Example include PSQ-18 and SWiP scale
Caregiver burden
A type of humanistic outcome to consider, at high levels of stress that ma g be experienced by some people who are caring for another person with some kind of illness.
Financial strain, managing persons symptoms, dealing with crisis, loss of friends, loss of intimacy. Example tools are caregiver self assessment questionnaire and caregiver reaction assessment
Cost effectiveness analysis
Most common type is Pharmacoeconomics study performed
Compares cost and effectiveness outcomes (measured in natural units)
Use when effectiveness outcomes are measurable but not really preference weighted
Outcomes must be in the same unit to compare interventions
Advantages of cost effective analysis
That health units are common outcomes practitioners can readily understand and these outcomes as si nit need to be converted to monetary values
Incremental cost effectiveness ratio (ICER)
refers to the additional cost required to gain one addition unit of outcomes when choosing one intervention over another
Highlights trade offs between cost and effectiveness
Average cost effectiveness ratio
Calculated as the cost of n intervention divided by its effective’s outcome are nit used for decision making in cost effectiveness analysis due to that they are calculations to doing nothing/no treatment, not used to compare standard of care vs interventions, decision making must be comparable not if the drug is affordable and effective