1/60
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Canada US Trade war
Canada put tariffs on all trading cards, including Magic the Gathering, in retaliation to the US
What is the strongest economic rationale for trade protectionism
Fighting unemployment
US China Trading chart
US buys significantly more goods from China than China does from the US
Tariffs: Direct Price Influencers
Tariffs are also called duty (literlaly just a tax)
Types:
Specific (Per Unit)
Ad valorem (% of value)
Compound (both)
Import Tariffs
Transport tariff (pay to cross)
Export tariff
Optimum tariff theory
Foreign producer will lower its prices if the importing country places a tariff on product, which shifts benefits to the improving country’s citizens
Non-tariff barriers
Subsidies (way to support domestic producers)
Aids and Loans (to support domestic producers)
Customs Valuation
Government decides product’s worth
Other
Custom clearance, document requests, minimum price
Non-traiff barriers - Quantity Controls
Quotas
Embargo (straight up ban)
VER - Voluntary export restraint
Specific permission requirements (licenses)
Administrative Delay (intentional)
standards and labels (instructions need to be in home country’s language)
buy local legislation
Restrictions of services (In the US, only American countries maintain the transportation)
Walmart not in India
They tried, but Indian government requires foreign retailers to source 30% of products form small and medium sized Indian businesses
(Stimulates their economy)
Walmart forces salesmen of products they sell to live in their town’s headquarters
Why do countries put restrictions on services
Essentiality: We have to have them (defense, and weapons)
Not-for-profit services
Standards
Immigration
Uber Pop
Uber tried to start up in France, but they were being protested, and drivers were harassed
How to deal with governmental trade barriers
Move into that country
lobby government
Seek other markets/niches
Internal innovations
involve other companies
public pressure
file dispute with WTO
Who wins by protectionism
Import-competing industires (companies comepting agains improtng countries)
Government (tariff revenue and political appeasement of interest groups
domestic producers
special interest groups
Who loses by protectionism
consumers
foreign producers
internal economy
efficiency loss (specialization and competition
encourages lobbying
Global economy
Loss of specialization and efficiency
Retaliation practices like trade war
Reasons against protectionism
Expensive
Creaes inefficneis
Encoruages lobbying
Encourages retaltion
Dmahaes compeititveness
On one side of the
Government has to intervene to rpotect the best interest fo domestic eocnomya nd people
But
too muhc protectionsim hurts domestic consuemrs and protect weak inefficient businesses
US embargo on Pharamceutical products
US has banned pharamceutical prodcucts, cuasing domestic drugs to be very expensive
The US Vietnamese Catfish Dispute Case
Catfish imports from Vietnam took a larger share of the US market than domestic production
Vietnam has competitive advantages that enable it to export to the US
Winterless climate
Lack of restrictions
Lower Labor costs
The US made it so that imported Vietnamese catfish coudl not be named catfish, but this didn’t stop restaurants and grocery stores form naming it catfish so that failed
The US industry tried to release a more premium breed of catfish called delcata but that ahsn’t worked yet
HUGE tariffs were placed on Vietnam in 2003
The US tried to take advanage of a safety stigma on imported goods in 2007, but that failed
The US placed hevay inspections on imported vietnamese catfish
Opposition to the US Catfish regulatory changes
Claims to protect US consumers, yet there is no evidence that Catfish-like species pose more danger than other types of imported fish
Cost of the catfish inspection program is a waste of money
Vietnam is an important economy for US trade, so regulatory changes might affect trade relationship
Eocnomic conflicts with US and Vietnam could ruin political relations
Some US catfish farmers are having issues complyign with the new restrcitons meant to affect vietnamese farmers, especially fishermen catchign them wild
Vietnam fought back
They filed a dispute with the WTO that is still being resolved
If they win, they may negate the regulatory changes and show the world that the US can’t just strongarm other countries
Stakeholders
Workers, business owners, suppliers, and local politicans are most likely to do something about trade regulations
Consumers typically do not take notice of retail price increases because those costs are spread
What could go wrong with restricting imports?
Retaliation either with reciprocal quotas or just buying fewer goods from us
Fewer imports mean loss of import related jobs
By restricting imports of a good, you can cause the costs for other industries to increase
By restricting imports, you reduce foreign income so they can’t buy your goods
While protectionism is used to increase or protect employment…
There is evidence that government policies can better handle that
Protectionism can be used to Protect Infant Industries
Governments should protect their emerging industries from foreign competition
Risks with Protecting Infant Industries
Identifying successful industries is difficult
Limiting imports might enable domestic firms to be lazy
If the protected industry fails, we just limited imports that benefit consumers
Someone has to bear a high cost whether it be consumers, government, or entrepreneurs
Protectionism can be used to Develop an Industrial Base
More workers mean more manufacturing output
Import restrictions cause companies to try and build inside of the country (FDI) which provides manufacturing jobs
By relying on industrialization instead of agricultural products, the economy becomes more stable because those goods have volatile prices
Markets for industrial goods grow faster than agriculture and raw materials
Issues with using Protectionism to develop an industrial base
A large shift of workers from agriculture to industry can result in surplus and underemployment
With technology replacing unskilled industrial labor, developing an industrial base does not necessarily translate to more employment
Shifting away from agriculture does not always help the economy
Improving Comparative economic positions
If a government imports more than it exports
A government can depreciate or devalue its currency to make its products cheaper in relation to foreign products
Use policies to bring lower price increases
If a government does not have equal access to a competitor market, it will be disadvantaged in gaining sales and becoming cost competitive
Import restrictions and bargaining
If a country is putting import restrictions on a good to bargain
it must be believable that they have access to the good elsewhere
The good must be important enough to the producer country
Export restrictions
A country can place export restrictions on a good to raise prices abroad due to less available supply
Dumping
Exporting a good below home-country price
Typically, at home consumers will have to pay an additional price so that the exported good will be cheaper
Optimum Tariff Theory
Theoretically, foreign producers should lower export prices when a tax is placed on their good
Sometimes though, they don’t completely lower the price so domestic consumers pay more, or they cut wages and affect foreign workers
Maintaining essential indsutries (non-economic)
Implement protectionism to avoid dependnecy on foreign nations for indsutries necessary in times of crisis
For example, a country would not want to rely on another country’s steel imports during time of war
Promoting acceptable practcies abroad (non-economic)
By limiting a foreign country’s access to goods through export limits, we can coerce them to change their practices on issues like human rights or environmental protection
Maintaining or extending spheres of influence (non-economic)
Encouraging imports from certain countries can make them political allies or get them to vote a preferred way
Preserving national culture (non-economic)
Prevent trade so that foreign goods cannot influence or conflict domestic values
Also prevent exporting goods to keep culture unique
Tariffs as sources of rveenue (Trade Control Instrument)
Typically, only developing countries use tariffs as a major source of revenue
Agricutlural subsidies
Governments typically subsidize food production because the risk of not having enough food is very bad
Tied aid or loans(Trade Control Instrument)
When a foreign country gives a country money but requires them to spend it on foreign services or goods
Can be bad for the country receiving money, because they are relying on foreign suppliers instead of supporting their own
Customs Valuations (Trade Control Instrument)
Since tariffs are based off a product’s price, value, or origin, government’s might misrepresent these factors to alter tariffs
Voluntary Export Restraint (VER)
A type of quota where a country will agree to reduce its exports without a trade restriction being officially placed
Does less damage to political relations than an import quota and is easier to “switch off”
Embargo (Trade Control Instrument)
A quota that straight up bans trade
“Buy Local” Legislation (Trade Control Instrument)
Rules that favor domestic production, whether that be price mechanisms that make domestic cheaper, or literal requirements forcing consumers to buy certain products locally
Standards and Labels (Trade Control Instrument)
Labels that indicate where products’ originate from
Often used to promote safety or health or just protect domestic producers
Licensing requiremnts (Trade Control Instrument)
Countries can make importers or epxorters pay for a license in order to trade
Administrative Delays
The government can intentionally slowdown the processing of imports, making local goods more competitive since they are more readily available
Reciprocal Requirements
Barter trade
Basically, trade us goods in exchange for goods instead of straight up money
Four options to deal with Import Competition
Move operations to another country
Concentrate on market niches that aren’t as competitive globally
Start innovating to stand out from foreign firms
Try to get governmental protection
If a company is strong enough to stand against foreign competitors
It would actually prefer foreign competition to be open so that weaker companies lose to both the stronger company and the foreign firms
General agreement on Tariffs and Trade
A group formed to liberalize world trade, abolish quotas, and reduce tariffs
Eventually became the world trade org
Word Trade Organization
Replaced the GATT
Expanded policies to cover trade in:
Services
Investment
Intellectual Property
Governments can file disputes with WTO over unfair trade
Cuba and the US
We have very limited trade with them, not a total embargo but the stuff we can do is limited
Iran
Embargo on all US goods except dental, medical, and food related goods
North Korea
US can make ifnancial investments in them, thats it though
Walmart fail in India
Indian government is forcing foreign companies to source 30% of their products from small and medium sized local businesses
Governments will intervene to?
Protect the interests of their people and domestic economy
But too much protectionism can hurt domestic consumers by protecting inefficient domestic businesses
Import Prescription Case from Canada
US Drug prices are raising way too fast, and the US is NOT allowed to negtoiate drug prices with companies
The US does not allow drug imports from anyone except drug companies (so distributors or pharmacies can’t sell to US)
Canada gets the exact same drugs for cheaper because they can negotiate
Canada can’t import their cheaper drugs to US
Technically, US consumers are subsidizing cheaper Canadian drugs by paying higher prices
Also, Domestic pharmaceuticals are overcharging hella because of lack of foreign competition
There are so many variities of drugs and prices that we aren’t exactly sure how much US consuemrs would save if buying form Canada instead
FDA cannot regulate saefty of drugs from Canda
Development costs for Drugs are high, but Pharma has to burdne US consuemrs with high costs, because other governments negotiate drug prices which prevents the cost from spreading
To combat this, we are slowly allowing negotiation of drug prices
US-China Trade War: Tariffs Explained
China stopped buying soybeans from the US after we put tariffs on them, and it screwed soybean farmers in the US
EU tariffs on U.S. goods go into effect
The US put tariffs on steel so the EU put tariffs on a bunch of US goods like motorcycles, clothes, and steel
Trump and Juncker ease US-EU trade tensions
After a bunch of trade barriers, Trump and the EU worked towards zero tariffs and barriers on non-auto industrial goods
The Chicken Tax
Europe put tariffs on US chicken, so the US put tariffs on trucks form Germany so American trucks started performing really well