1/158
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Rousseau | Second Discourse — What question does the Second Discourse investigate?
How inequality develops historically and becomes socially accepted and institutionalized.
Rousseau | Second Discourse — What is natural or physical inequality?
Differences such as age, health, strength, and mental capacities.
Rousseau | Second Discourse — What is moral or political inequality?
Differences in rank, wealth, privileges, and power established through convention and institutions.
Rousseau | Second Discourse — What is Rousseau's state of nature like?
Largely independent, solitary humans with few desires and little permanent dependence on others.
Rousseau | Second Discourse — What are two pre-rational natural principles?
Self-preservation and compassion/pity for others' suffering.
Rousseau | Second Discourse — What is perfectibility?
Humans' ability to change, learn, and develop new faculties; a source of both progress and corruption.
Rousseau | Second Discourse — What is amour de soi?
Natural self-concern or self-preservation that need not require dominance over others.
Rousseau | Second Discourse — What is amour-propre?
Socially comparative self-esteem based on recognition and others' opinions.
Rousseau | Second Discourse — What is Rousseau's symbolic first claim of property?
A person enclosing land and calling it theirs marks a critical step toward civil society and inequality.
Rousseau | Second Discourse — Why does private property matter in the Second Discourse?
It fosters material inequality and eventually legal institutions that entrench unequal claims.
Rousseau | Second Discourse — How does social comparison change people?
They seek esteem and status, creating vanity, competition, envy, and dependence.
Rousseau | Second Discourse — What changes when people need each other's help?
Division of labor and interdependence increase, weakening earlier independence and equality.
Rousseau | Second Discourse — What does 'to be' versus 'to seem' imply?
Social life encourages people to perform attractive appearances rather than simply be themselves.
Rousseau | Second Discourse — What is Rousseau's concluding diagnosis of inequality?
Social development, property, and laws make inequalities more powerful and legally accepted.
Rousseau | Second Discourse — What is unusual about Rousseau's Dedication to Geneva?
He praises a tempered democratic community whose people and sovereign have aligned interests.
Rousseau | Social Contract — What gives political authority legitimacy for Rousseau?
Conventions or agreements, not mere force or natural superiority.
Rousseau | Social Contract — What is the central problem of the social contract?
To unite for common protection while each member remains free through collective self-rule.
Rousseau | Social Contract — What does 'man is born free' introduce?
The problem of explaining legitimate political subordination without abandoning freedom.
Rousseau | Social Contract — What is the general will?
The sovereign people's will directed to the common interest.
Rousseau | Social Contract — What is the will of all?
The total of private wills or interests; it may not advance the common good.
Rousseau | Social Contract — What is the social compact?
Each associates their person and powers with all under the supreme direction of the general will.
Rousseau | Social Contract — Who is sovereign in Rousseau?
The people collectively considered as lawgivers.
Rousseau | Social Contract — Is sovereignty alienable or representable?
No. Sovereignty is the people's own will and cannot be sold or represented by deputies.
Rousseau | Social Contract — What does 'forced to be free' mean?
Someone refusing a valid general law can be compelled to comply with the common conditions of civic freedom.
Rousseau | Social Contract — What is natural liberty?
Freedom constrained primarily by the person's own strength and physical ability.
Rousseau | Social Contract — What is civil liberty?
Freedom under publicly established laws expressing the general will.
Rousseau | Social Contract — What is moral liberty?
Self-mastery achieved by obeying laws one prescribes to oneself as part of the sovereign community.
Rousseau | Social Contract — What is the difference between possession and property?
Possession may rely on force or occupancy; property is recognized through a lawful civic title.
Rousseau | Social Contract — Why is the general will not automatically whatever wins a vote?
The outcome may be distorted by ignorance, deception, faction, or private interests.
Rousseau | Social Contract — What is the general will's fallibility problem?
People aim at their good but may be mistaken about what truly advances it.
Rousseau | Social Contract — Why does Rousseau criticize factions?
Partial associations substitute organized private interests for independent citizen judgments about the common good.
Rousseau | Social Contract — Why does Rousseau discuss majority voting?
Voting can determine judgments about the general will, but the rule itself rests on prior convention.
Rousseau | Social Contract — What is the difference between state/sovereign and government?
The people as sovereign make general laws; government is the executive body applying them.
Rousseau | Social Contract — Can Rousseau's deputies make final laws for the sovereign people?
No. Deputies are stewards; ultimate legislative authority stays with the people.
Rousseau | Social Contract — Why is strict democratic government difficult?
It demands constant direct administration by the people, something Rousseau thinks rarely feasible.
Rousseau | Social Contract — What does Rousseau say about the English parliament?
Voting for representatives alone does not provide continuous direct political freedom.
Rousseau | Social Contract — What is civil religion?
A small set of shared civic beliefs intended to reinforce duties, loyalty, and public morality.
Rousseau | Social Contract — What is Rousseau's view of religious tolerance?
Tolerate faiths compatible with civic duties and tolerant of others; exclude intolerance.
Rousseau | Social Contract — What is the difference between sovereign action and executive action?
Sovereign acts are general laws; executive acts apply law to particular situations.
Kant | What Is Enlightenment? — What is Enlightenment for Kant?
Emancipation from self-incurred immaturity through independent reasoning.
Kant | What Is Enlightenment? — What is immaturity?
Inability or unwillingness to use one's understanding without another person's direction.
Kant | What Is Enlightenment? — What does 'Sapere aude' mean?
Dare to know; have courage to use your own understanding.
Kant | What Is Enlightenment? — Why do many remain intellectually immature?
Laziness, fear, custom, and reliance on guardians to think for them.
Kant | What Is Enlightenment? — What is the public use of reason?
Reasoning openly as a scholar addressing the reading public; Kant says it must be free.
Kant | What Is Enlightenment? — What is the private use of reason?
Reasoning within an assigned office or civic function, where obedience to operational rules may be required.
Kant | What Is Enlightenment? — What is Kant's example of taxes?
A citizen must pay lawful taxes but can publicly argue as a scholar that the tax policy is unjust.
Kant | What Is Enlightenment? — Can revolution alone create Enlightenment?
No. It may replace rulers without replacing habits of prejudice or intellectual dependence.
Kant | What Is Enlightenment? — Is Kant's age enlightened?
He distinguishes an 'age of enlightenment' (progress underway) from a fully enlightened age.
Kant | What Is Enlightenment? — Why can public criticism coexist with obedience?
It permits institutional order while leaving open the public examination and reform of ideas.
Hume | Original Contract — What is Hume's main criticism of social contract theories?
They overstate genuine consent as the historical and ongoing basis of political obligation.
Hume | Original Contract — How did many real governments originate, according to Hume?
Through conquest, usurpation, force, inherited authority, and gradual habit.
Hume | Original Contract — Does Hume completely deny that consent ever matters?
No. Early voluntary association may matter, but it rarely explains modern citizens' duties.
Hume | Original Contract — Why is tacit consent questionable for Hume?
Remaining under a government often reflects necessity or lack of realistic alternatives, not a free promise.
Hume | Original Contract — Why do people generally obey political authority?
Government supplies order, stability, and usefulness to society.
Hume | Original Contract — What is the 'original contract' problem?
A hypothetical or ancient promise cannot easily bind people who never agreed to it.
Hume | Original Contract — Why does Hume question promises as the deepest foundation?
The duty to keep promises itself needs explanation; social utility can explain both promise-keeping and allegiance.
Hume | Original Contract — Why does Hume emphasize history and experience?
Actual institutions often differ from philosophers' ideal accounts of their creation.
Hume | Original Contract — What kind of theory does Hume challenge?
He challenges contract theories that treat real individual consent as the foundation of all political allegiance.
Hume | Original Contract — What is a one-sentence account of Hume's political obligation?
We obey because stable government is socially necessary and beneficial, not because everyone personally contracted.
Burke | Bristol Speech — What is Burke's trustee model of representation?
An elected official owes constituents careful service and independent judgment rather than blind obedience.
Burke | Bristol Speech — What should representatives do with constituents' views?
Listen respectfully and seriously while retaining responsibility for their own judgment.
Burke | Bristol Speech — Why does Burke oppose binding mandates?
They make legislators follow instructions even when reason and conscience indicate another course.
Burke | Bristol Speech — What is parliament for Burke?
A deliberative assembly serving the interests of the whole nation.
Burke | Bristol Speech — What is the difference between delegate and trustee?
A delegate follows constituents' instructions; a trustee uses independent considered judgment.
Burke | Bristol Speech — Why does Burke emphasize deliberation?
The best decisions emerge from discussion and weighing arguments, not a predetermined vote.
Burke | Bristol Speech — Why is national interest more important than local narrow interest?
Representatives owe their legislative judgment to the community as a whole, not just a single district.
Burke | Bristol Speech — Does Burke say a representative should ignore voters?
No. He stresses communication and consideration but not surrender of conscience.
Olympe de Gouges | Rights of Woman — What is de Gouges' central argument?
Universal rights are inconsistent unless women receive the same civil and political rights as men.
Olympe de Gouges | Rights of Woman — Which revolution is she addressing?
The French Revolution and its unequal application of proclaimed rights.
Olympe de Gouges | Rights of Woman — How does she redefine national sovereignty?
The nation is the union of women and men, so both are sources of political authority.
Olympe de Gouges | Rights of Woman — What does Article I declare?
Women are born free and equal in rights to men.
Olympe de Gouges | Rights of Woman — What does Article VI demand?
Men and women should contribute to making laws and be eligible for public offices based on ability.
Olympe de Gouges | Rights of Woman — What does Article X imply about women's political voice?
If women bear the harshest consequences of law, they must also be allowed a public political voice.
Olympe de Gouges | Rights of Woman — What right is emphasized in Article XI?
Freedom to communicate opinions, including women publicly asserting family-related truth.
Olympe de Gouges | Rights of Woman — What is her taxation argument?
Women who share tax burdens should also share authority over public finances and offices.
Olympe de Gouges | Rights of Woman — What does she say about property rights?
Women and men both have inviolable rights to property, individually and together.
Olympe de Gouges | Rights of Woman — Why is education politically important in her argument?
Excluding women from learning and public life perpetuates their unequal civic status.
Olympe de Gouges | Rights of Woman — How does de Gouges reveal a contradiction in revolution?
A movement claiming universal equality still leaves out half the population.
Wollstonecraft | Vindication Ch. I-II only — What is Wollstonecraft's central argument?
Women should develop rational independence and virtue; inequality is reinforced by bad education and social expectations.
Wollstonecraft | Vindication Ch. I-II only — Why is reason important in Chapter I?
It is the distinctively human capacity underlying moral development and virtue.
Wollstonecraft | Vindication Ch. I-II only — What is virtue in Wollstonecraft's argument?
Moral excellence achieved through rational judgment, education, and disciplined conduct.
Wollstonecraft | Vindication Ch. I-II only — How does she criticize inherited privilege?
Rank, title, and wealth can shelter prejudice and obstruct genuine virtue.
Wollstonecraft | Vindication Ch. I-II only — Why does she criticize Rousseau's idealization of nature?
She values rational development and argues that a better civilization is possible rather than glorifying primitive simplicity.
Wollstonecraft | Vindication Ch. I-II only — What is her main criticism of women's upbringing in Chapter II?
Girls are trained for charm, obedience, and attractiveness instead of self-directed reasoning.
Wollstonecraft | Vindication Ch. I-II only — What does she criticize in Rousseau's portrayal of Sophie in Emile?
Education designed to make a woman pleasing and dependent on a man rather than rationally autonomous.
Wollstonecraft | Vindication Ch. I-II only — Are supposed differences in intellectual ability necessarily natural for Wollstonecraft?
No. Unequal experience, education, and opportunities help produce those differences.
Wollstonecraft | Vindication Ch. I-II only — What would improve women's social condition?
Strengthening education, independent judgment, and equal moral expectations.
Wollstonecraft | Vindication Ch. I-II only — Why does she compare women with soldiers?
Both may appear superficial when trained for obedience and appearances instead of critical thought.
Wollstonecraft | Vindication Ch. I-II only — What does she mean by one standard of virtue?
The standards of reason and moral character should apply fundamentally to women and men alike.
Madison | Federalist No. 10 — What is a faction?
Citizens united by a passion or interest adverse to others' rights or the community's permanent interests.
Madison | Federalist No. 10 — What is Madison's main constitutional concern?
Preventing factions, especially majority factions, from violating rights and the common good.
Madison | Federalist No. 10 — What are two broad ways to address faction?
Remove its causes or control its effects.
Madison | Federalist No. 10 — Why not abolish liberty to abolish factions?
Liberty is essential to political life; removing it is worse than the problem.
Madison | Federalist No. 10 — Why can't society eliminate all differences of interest?
Human opinions, capacities, and property holdings are inherently diverse.
Madison | Federalist No. 10 — What does Madison call the most common durable source of faction?
Unequal distribution of property.
Madison | Federalist No. 10 — Why are majority factions especially dangerous?
They can use legal majorities to injure minorities and the public good.
Madison | Federalist No. 10 — Why does Madison distrust pure democracy?
A small directly governing public can coordinate majority oppression without adequate filters.
Madison | Federalist No. 10 — How does a republic differ from pure democracy?
A republic governs through elected representatives; a pure democracy governs directly.
Madison | Federalist No. 10 — What is the effect of representation?
Representatives may refine and enlarge public views, though poor choices are still possible.
Madison | Federalist No. 10 — Why can an extensive republic be better?
More diverse interests and candidates make coordination of oppressive majorities harder.