1/3
Looks like no tags are added yet.
para
icj
succuess of un special tribunals
un tribunals developed international law thru precedent
icj
yes: article 94 of un charter lays down all member of un should comply w court decision. if state doesnt comply w icj, can approach unsc to enforce. costa rica v nicaragua: resolved long running territorial and maritime boundary dispute ordered nicaragua to pay env reparations. austrailia v japan: japan whaling programme violated internaitonal convention on regulation of whaling led to japan ending arctic whaling programme. 2019-2025 uk chagos islands hand islands back to mauritius.
limitations: all 193 ms of un r members of icj only 73 agreed in advance tb bound by judgements of court. conflict w realist state egoism. cannot initiate cases only try cases that r brought. states sometimes ignore or undermine rulings eg russia refused to participate or comply in politically sensitive cases ukraine territorial dispute
succuess of un special tribunals
yes: punish those guilty of hr abuses, made public extent of genocide, war against humanity by 2017 icty convicted + sentenced 90 war criminals incl high profile radovan karadzic and ratko mladic. un tribunals over 200 convictions for genocide, war crimes, crimes against humanity. rwanda tribunal convicted 62 individuals 4 genocide
no: victors justice. hussien not tried by int court in iraq liable 4 death penalty which un tribunals cant deliver if no consistency in determining when they set up then adds 2 victors justice. rwandan tribunal predominantly tried hutus 4 genocide and few if any members of tutsi patriotic front. 2026 unlikely us and israel will face int legal scrutiny over bombing of skl in iran 2026. nato pwrs not held acc for serbian tv and radio hqs in 1999 during kosovo misson
un tribunals deveolped int law thru precedent
yes: UNT-yugoslavia 1998-99 milosevic accused of instigating ethnic cleansing in kosovo (died during trial) 1st for a former head of state and set imp precedent in int law. rwanda est precedent rap could be used as perp genocide and media could be held legally responsible for encouraging genocide . sierra leone 1st even conviction of former head of state int court convicted former president of libya 2012-even sitting or former heads of state not immune from prosecution. ECHR fedotova v russia 2023 russias refusal to legally recognise same sex partnership protection
no: icc (perm court est in response to succuess of un special tribunals) juristictional limitations: 70% wrld pop is outside juristiction of court. china russia us (Most pwrful members of unsc) dont accept icc juristiction over their internal sovereign affairs. not required to cooperate w court in handing over us citizens to juristiction. lack of coercive enforcement pwr-relies on ms to arrest defendants bc kein police force eg putin and netanyahu evade icc warrants. only 10 convictions so far bc of complexity of int crimes percieved bias on african countries