1/59
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Profession
Used to be related to monks. Professionals must uphold a stringent moral code and way of life with higher expectations.
The sociological account of professionalism
Professionals need a extensive training period, Vital social function, autonomy, and ethical standard.
The social contract account of professionalism
An implicit agreement between citizens and professionals. professionals provide competent, ethical service, and society grants them autonomy and trust.
Micheal Davis on professionalism
professions serve a moral idea beyond law and market.
What is the argument for NOT requiring licensure for engineering
Increased costs due to covering the cost of registration, Registration would prevent non engineers from doing engineering work regardless of ability, Engineers are already required to "sign off" on work affecting the public.
What is the argument FOR requiring licensure for engineering
Some countries already require licensure and the No arguments propositions have not proved to be a serious issue. Work that does and does not affect the public is a difficult line to draw. Registration could allow for more autonomy for engineers allowing for greater control.
Prohibited actions in engineering
relates to actions that are not allowed under the code of professional engineers that encourage a higher standard of work and morality.
Prohibited actions in engineering examples
Examples:
Do not reveal privileged information
Do not associate with dishonest professionals
Do not aid in the unlawful practice of engineering
Do not give bribes
Preventitive actions in engineering
Preventing harm involves identifying and disclosing potential harms, as well as making an attempt to prevent them. Engineers should at all times prioritize the safety of people in their products and should prioritize preventing harm.
Promoting wellbeing Aspirational ethics
Engineers without borders is a good example of aspirational ethics because it promotes unity, peace, and does good for the global community.
Metaphysics
the branch of philosophy that deals with the first principles of things, including abstract concepts such as being, knowing, substance, cause, identity, time, and space.
Philosophy of the mind
a branch of philosophy that explores the nature of the mind, consciousness, and mental processes, particularly their relationship with the body
Ethics
the systematic study of moral principles, values, and conduct, focusing on questions about what is right and wrong, good and bad, and fair and unfair in human behavior and society
Standard of Care
Although some errors in engineering judgment are expected to arise as a matter of course, not all errors are acceptable. A standard of care is expected either by following the expectations of an engineering society or the expectations of government organizations that set an expectation of public safety. There is no set standard of care, but there are lawful expectations of what a reasonable error is and what an error you are liable for is
Intententional Harm
To knowingly or deliberately cause harm in some serious manner
Recklessness
To not directly intend to cause harm but to intentionally behave in a manner that puts yourself and others at risk. These individuals are both morally and legally liable for their actions
Negligence
To not directly intend to cause harm or engage in dangerous behavior but to lack a standard of care that is expected to prevent harm.
Kansas City Hyatt Regency Case:
The project manager in charge of the construction of building a walkway in the Hyatt hotel showed conscious indifference of his professional duties resulting in the death of 114 people. The chief engineer also inadequately supervised the project managers work. This case showed that engineers can be held accountable for negligence and failing to supervise others.
Citycorp case
the 1978 engineering crisis of the Citicorp Center building in New York City, where the building's chief engineer, William LeMessurier, discovered a flaw that made it vulnerable to collapse from high winds. They secretly hired a contractor to fix the building at night to prevent panic.
Columbia Accident Investigation Board
A space shuttle disintegrated as the result of ignored safety concerns due to a work culture that did not allow for proper dissent toward higher ups. This taught engineers the lesson that they must speak up in order to uphold public safety and creating a culture where it is expected that you have dissenting opinions and challenging perspectives is essential for upholding public safety
Factual Issues
it is impossible to have a morally intelligent discussion without the facts bearing on a problem. However, facts are not beyond dispute. EG. Many moral agreements are disagreements over what facts are relevant. Factual issues can be difficult to resolve or determine the accuracy of. Sometimes moral decisions must be made even though some of the relevant facts are not yet available. (using cadavers is disrespectful to dead bodies but can be potentially used to decrease car deaths even without the data proving they can decrease car deaths a decision must be made.
Conceptual Issues
It is impossible to resolve conceptual issues without an agreement of what terms such as "bribery" or "extortion" mean thus paradigms are used to create clear cut examples of what we have in mind.
Creative MIddle-Way Solutions
Middle way solutions are used to resolve issues related to multiple conflicting values and obligations. For example if Brad is given multiple time consuming and difficult jobs and he becomes aware that his work is not being sufficiently second checked for safety. Bringing up his concerns about safety may cause issues with the company he works for, but with the level of difficulty he is encountering it is impossible for him to guarantee safety of the public.
Normativity
the standards and values that guide engineering practice, encompassing both what engineers ought to do (ethical and moral codes) and the desirability of artifacts (how a designed object "ought to" function)
morally permissible
One is morally permitted, but not morally required, to perform an action.
An engineer might decide to take a job with Company X rather than Company Y, but
both actions are permissible. It would also be permissible to take neither job
Impermissible
An action that one is morally required not to do. An engineer must
not be a part of an undisclosed conflict of interest.
Obligatory
An action one is morally required to do. An engineer must disclose an
actual or a potential conflict of interest.
Supererogatory
An action that is praiseworthy if one does it, but not morally required.
An engineer designs a parking lot for a nonprofit organization without charging a fee.
Sometimes we call these actions ones that go above and beyond the call of duty.
What is Utilitarianism?
Utilitarianism is a model of common morality focused on maximizing overall wellbeing of a chosen audience. Any action that maximizes wellbeing is seen as moral.
John Stuart Mill
It is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied. Utilitarianism.
"The greatest happiness principle"
An action is morally right if it produces the greatest amount of happiness for the greatest number of people and wrong if it produces the opposite. Proposed by philosophers like Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill.
Consequentialism
The view that the morality of an action is determined by its results or consequences
Difference between act and rule utilitarianism
Act utilitarianism evaluates the consequences of each individual action to maximize happiness, while rule utilitarianism judges the morality of an action by seeing if it conforms to a general rule that would lead to the greatest good if followed consistently
What is Deontology?
Deontological ethics judges the rightness or wrongness of actions based on adherence to rules or duties, rather than consequences.
Immanuel Kant
Kant wrote about the supreme principle of morality, the categorical imperative, which he believed is derived from reason and must be followed regardless of consequences. He argued that actions are morally right if they are done out of a sense of duty and are based on maxims that can be universally applied to everyone, treating humanity as an end in itself, never just as a means to an end
Reason, duties
In deontology, reason is the tool used to determine moral duties, which are absolute rules that must be followed regardless of the consequences. Duties are determined through rational thought, such as Kant's categorical imperative.
The categorical imperative
Demands that one act only on rules that can be universally applied without contradiction.
What is Care Ethics?
A moral theory that emphasizes the importance of relationships, compassion, and responsibility in ethical decision-making, rather than focusing on abstract principles like justice or rights.
Focus on familial relations e.g parent/child, family/elderly
Care ethics prioritizes personal connections and feelings like love, empathy, and compassion over impartiality and abstract principles, which makes it particularly relevant to family life.
However a focus on close relationships can lead to bias in decision making.
Focus on dependence, inequality
Care ethics focuses on dependence and inequality by prioritizing relationships and mutual care over individualistic principles, recognizing that humans are fundamentally interdependent and vulnerable.
Virginia Held, care & justice
arguing it is a distinct moral theory based on the universal experience of caring for others, and not just a feminist concern. She explored its implications for personal, social, and global issues, suggesting it can coexist with traditional values like justice and rights. Held also championed care as a practical and moral value, emphasizing the importance of relationships, mutual consideration, and meeting human needs
What is Virtue Ethics?
Virtue ethics emphasizes the type of person one should be rather than merely the right actions to take.
Aristotle
Aristotle wrote that virtue ethics is a framework for a good life, focusing on character rather than rules. He explained that virtues are cultivated through habit, and are the "golden mean" between two extremes, such as courage being the mean between cowardice and recklessness. In his work Nicomachean Ethics, he explored how developing moral and intellectual virtues leads to happiness, which he considered the ultimate human good.
Virtues, Character, how to acquire them
A virtue is a positive trait between two extremes such as courage being between cowardice and rashness. Virtues are developed through practice and habit, not just adherence to rules. A person's character is their distinctive set of moral qualities, values, and virtues that shape their thoughts, feelings, and actions in ethical contexts.
Virtue Ethics not about individual Choices
Virtue ethics is not about individual choices, but rather focuses on a person's character and moral development over the long term. Instead of asking "what should I do?", it asks "what kind of person should I be?".
"Doctrine of the Mean"
It proposes that virtue is a mean state, or balance, between two extremes of vice: one of excess and one of deficiency. For example, the virtue of courage is the mean between the vice of rashness (excess) and the vice of cowardice (deficiency).
Shannon Vallor
Argues that social media changes how we form and maintain friendships, and she examines this through Aristotle's idea of virtue ethics. Platforms like Facebook can support aspects of friendship—like empathy and reciprocity—but they rarely foster the deep, "complete" friendships that help people grow in virtue and truly flourish.
The Social Construction of Technology
A theory in Science and Technology Studies that argues social factors, not inherent technological capabilities, primarily shape how technology is developed and used.
SCOT Main Claims:
Technology's design and use are not determined by its own internal logic but are shaped by social, cultural, and political factors
Pinch & Bijker "The Social Construction of Facts and Artifacts"
Argues that technology is not developed in a linear, technical progression but is socially constructed through the "interpretive flexibility" of different social groups. In the early stages, an artifact has multiple designs and meanings until a specific design and meaning stabilizes through a process of social negotiation and "closure" among these groups.
Interpretive Flexibility
The idea that an object, text, or concept can be understood and used in multiple ways depending on a person's perspective, experiences, and social context.
SCOT Interpretive Flexibility Examples
Bicycle: groups like racers saw it as a tool for speed, while commuters viewed it as a convenient mode of transportation, and producers focused on its economic viability.
Moog: Moog's design was interpreted as a new instrument that used a familiar keyboard, allowing musicians to create and play new electronic sounds. Buchla's design, which lacked a keyboard, was interpreted differently by many users as a complex electronic instrument that was less intuitive and more of a "boundary-transgressing" tool between music and sound.
Oral Contraception: Different interpretations of the pill's purpose based on different social groups.
What is ANT?
A theoretical and methodological approach that examines how human and non-human actors, such as people, objects, and technologies, form and maintain relationships in shifting networks. It proposes that social phenomena are created through these dynamic associations and that all actors, whether living or non-living, are equally important in shaping outcomes.
What can count as actors in networks?
Any human or non-human entity that influences or perturbs a system, and is not limited to intentional, human agents.
Human actors: This includes individuals, groups, and organizations.
Non-human actors: This is a broad category and includes a wide range of entities:
Technologies: A personal computer, a software program, or an electrical network.
Objects: Physical items and tools.
Institutions: Concepts like "management" or "policy".
Natural elements: The weather, microbes, or the environment.
What's the difference between ANT and SCOT?
ANT sees humans and non-humans (like technology) as equally capable actors in a network, while SCOT focuses primarily on the social groups of humans who shape technology.
Latour "Technology is Society Made Durable"
Instead of seeing objects and society as distinct, Latour argues that both are intertwined and mutually shape each other.
Key chain and speed bump examples
A large, heavy keychain can influence hotel guest behavior to make them return their keys better than simple verbal instruction.
Speed bump influences drivers to slow down by translating the "slow down to not endanger people" into "slow to to protect your car's suspension"
D.P. Williams "Bias Optimizer" Case
In "Bias Optimizers," Damien Patrick Williams argues that AI systems like ChatGPT amplify human biases because they're trained on biased data. These systems reinforce sexism, racism, and ableism while presenting their outputs as objective. Williams calls for redesigning AI to actively check and correct bias, use ethical data, and include marginalized voices—otherwise, it will continue to automate inequality.
Shannon Vallor on Social Media Case
In "Flourishing on Facebook," Shannon Vallor argues that social media changes how we form and maintain friendships, and she examines this through Aristotle's idea of virtue ethics. Platforms like Facebook can support aspects of friendship—like empathy and reciprocity—but they rarely foster the deep, "complete" friendships that help people grow in virtue and truly flourish. Vallor concludes that while social media can strengthen bonds, it often replaces genuine shared living with surface-level connection, making moral growth and true friendship harder to achieve online.
The Pinto Case
The Ford Pinto case shows how Ford chose profit over safety after discovering the car's gas tank could explode in rear-end crashes. A cost-benefit analysis found it cheaper to pay lawsuits than fix the flaw, leading to deaths and injuries. The case is a classic example of unethical corporate behavior, showing the dangers of valuing money over human life and moral responsibility.