L6: CRIME, VIOLENCE, AGGRESSION

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/75

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

76 Terms

1
New cards

What are the main questions in media psychology research on violence, aggression and crime?

Whether violent media influences aggressive behaviour, whether aggressive individuals select violent media, how crime-related media shape perceptions of danger, and which factors moderate these relationships.

2
New cards

Why must aggression, violence and crime be distinguished in media research?

Aggression involves behaviour intended to harm, violence generally involves more severe physical harm, and crime refers to unlawful behaviour.

Evidence of laboratory aggression cannot automatically establish an effect on serious violent crime.

3
New cards

What did Riddle and Martins (2022) investigate?

Changes in the prevalence and context of violence in American primetime television between 1996–1997 and 2016–2017 using comparable sampling and coding procedures.

4
New cards

What did Riddle and Martins (2022) find about the prevalence and saturation of television violence?

Programmes containing violence increased from 61% to 68%, a modest seven-percentage-point rise.

Among violent programmes, those saturated with violence increased more substantially from 32% to 56%, suggesting a greater increase in intensity than overall prevalence.

5
New cards

What did Riddle and Martins (2022) find about violence in movies?

Movies accounted for 35% of the contemporary sample compared with 25% previously.

Some 97% of movies contained violence compared with 93% previously, and movies made up 89% of the titles most saturated with violence.

This suggests changing genre composition contributed to the overall trend.

6
New cards

What did Riddle and Martins (2022) find about violence in children's and reality programmes?

Violent children's primetime programmes decreased from 80% to 38%, while violent reality programmes decreased from 46% to 31%. Trends therefore differed substantially by genre rather than showing a uniform increase.

7
New cards

How should Riddle and Martins (2022) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Using comparable sampling procedures and coding across a 20-year period makes historical changes more interpretable.

• Separating overall violence prevalence from violence saturation reveals that the increase in highly violent programming was much greater than the increase in programmes containing any violence.

LIMITATIONS:

• Streaming-only programmes were excluded, so the findings cannot represent the full contemporary viewing environment.

• Movies increased from 25% to 35% of the sample and accounted for much of the highly violent content, meaning changes in programme composition may partly explain the overall increase.

• Content analysis cannot demonstrate what viewers watched or how they responded.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Evidence of increased violence saturation in sampled primetime television should not be interpreted as evidence of a uniform increase across genres or a causal increase in audience aggression.

8
New cards

What did Martins and Riddle (2022) investigate and find?

In a separate analysis of youth-targeted and adult-targeted primetime programming, youth-targeted shows remained more violent than adult-targeted shows, although violent youth programming had declined compared with 20 years earlier.

Children's violence was equally likely to be glamorised but more likely to be sanitised and trivialised.

9
New cards

How should Martins and Riddle (2022) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Comparing youth-targeted and adult-targeted programmes reveals differences obscured by overall television averages.

• Coding glamorisation, sanitisation and trivialisation captures potentially important messages about the consequences of aggression.

LIMITATIONS:

• Streaming-only content was excluded, weakening representativeness for contemporary young audiences.

• Greater sanitisation does not establish that children perceive violence as harmless because their interpretations were not measured.

• Programme content cannot establish subsequent aggressive behaviour.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: The findings identify potentially concerning portrayals of violence in youth programming but provide evidence about media messages rather than their psychological effects.

10
New cards

Why must Riddle and Martins (2022) and Martins and Riddle (2022) be distinguished?

They are separate papers using closely related data and methods. Riddle and Martins examine overall primetime violence and historical change, whereas Martins and Riddle focus on violence in youth-targeted compared with adult-targeted programmes.

11
New cards

What did Monk-Turner et al. (2004) find about war films?

A content analysis of 12 top-grossing American war films released between 1970 and 2002 found that films released since 1990 contained more violence and more intense gore.

12
New cards

How should Monk-Turner et al. (2004) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Examines historical change in both violence and gore.

LIMITATIONS:

• Very small sample of 12 films.

• Restricted to top-grossing American war films.

• Cannot establish effects on audiences.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Suggests increasing graphic violence within the sampled genre but has limited generalisability.

13
New cards

What is the General Aggression Model proposed by Anderson and Bushman (2002)?

A framework proposing that personal and situational inputs influence cognition, affect and arousal, shaping appraisal and behavioural responses.

Repeated experiences may gradually alter aggressive scripts and beliefs.

14
New cards

How does the General Aggression Model explain short-term media violence effects?

Violent media may activate aggressive thoughts and scripts, influence hostile interpretations or increase anger and arousal, potentially making an aggressive response more likely.

15
New cards

How does the General Aggression Model explain long-term media violence effects?

Repeated exposure may strengthen aggressive cognitive scripts and normative beliefs and contribute to desensitisation, potentially making aggressive responses more accessible or acceptable over time.

16
New cards

How should the General Aggression Model be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Integrates cognitive, emotional and situational mechanisms.

• Explains possible short-term and long-term effects.

LIMITATIONS:

• Proposed mechanisms are not always directly measured.

• Broad predictions can be difficult to test precisely.

• Laboratory aggression may not generalise to violent crime.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Provides plausible pathways but does not establish that violent media produces uniform or serious behavioural effects.

17
New cards

What is the uses and gratifications perspective associated with Katz, Blumler and Gurevitch (1974)?

An approach emphasising that audiences actively select media to satisfy needs such as entertainment, excitement or emotional regulation.

It challenges the assumption that media exposure is simply imposed on passive viewers.

18
New cards

What is the downward spiral model associated with Slater et al. (2003)?

A reciprocal process in which existing aggressive tendencies may encourage selection of violent media, while continued exposure may reinforce aggressive attitudes or behaviour.

19
New cards

How do the General Aggression Model, uses and gratifications, and downward spiral model differ?

The General Aggression Model emphasises mechanisms of media influence, uses and gratifications emphasises audience selection, and the downward spiral model combines selection and media effects in a reciprocal process.

20
New cards

What did Coyne (2015) investigate?

Longitudinal relationships between televised relational and physical aggression and adolescents' corresponding aggressive behaviour, using 467 adolescents assessed at three time points.

21
New cards

What did Coyne (2015) find about televised relational aggression?

Viewing relational aggression predicted later relational aggression, but adolescents' earlier relational aggression did not significantly predict later exposure to televised relational aggression.

The association was therefore not bidirectional.

22
New cards

What did Coyne (2015) find about televised physical violence?

Television violence and adolescents' physical aggression showed a bidirectional longitudinal relationship, consistent with both media influence and selective exposure.

23
New cards

How should Coyne (2015) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Three-wave longitudinal measurement allows tests of whether exposure precedes aggression and whether aggression precedes exposure.

• Separating relational and physical aggression reveals different patterns that a single overall aggression measure would obscure.

LIMITATIONS:

• Longitudinal prediction remains observational and cannot eliminate unmeasured family or personality influences.

• The relatively affluent and homogeneous sample limits generalisability.

• Coding a limited number of favourite programmes may not represent total exposure.

• Aggressive scripts and desensitisation were proposed but not directly tested as mediators.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Findings support content-specific media influence for relational aggression and reciprocal selection for physical aggression, but do not establish the proposed mechanisms or universal causation.

24
New cards

What did Anderson et al. (2017) conclude about violent media?

Their review argued that violent media is a causal risk factor for aggression, particularly in the short term, while recognising the need for stronger evidence concerning long-term effects and more serious outcomes.

25
New cards

How should Anderson et al. (2017) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Synthesises research across methods.

• Considers theoretical mechanisms and causal evidence.

LIMITATIONS:

• Conclusions depend on the quality and validity of included studies.

• Evidence about serious violent crime is less direct.

• The field remains contested.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Supports considering violent media as a possible aggression risk factor rather than a deterministic cause of violence.

26
New cards

What did Ferguson (2015a) investigate and conclude?

A meta-analysis of 101 studies involving children and adolescents found generally small or minimal relationships between violent video games and aggression-related outcomes, raising concerns about whether methodological biases inflate effects.

27
New cards

What methodological criticisms did Ferguson (2015a) raise?

Publication and citation bias, flexible aggression measures, inadequate control of confounding variables, poorly matched violent and nonviolent games, and questionable ecological validity of laboratory aggression tasks.

28
New cards

How should Ferguson (2015a) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Synthesising 101 studies provides a broad basis for examining average associations.

• Criticism of publication bias, game matching and aggression measures directly challenges whether apparent effects can be attributed to violent content.

LIMITATIONS: • Meta-analytic conclusions depend on which studies and outcome measures are included.

• Combining heterogeneous measures may obscure differences between aggressive thoughts, laboratory behaviour and real-world aggression.

• Small average associations do not necessarily mean effects are absent for every individual.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: The study challenges inflated or overly general causal claims, but its findings are best interpreted as evidence about average effects across varied research designs.

29
New cards

How do Anderson et al. (2017) and Ferguson (2015a) differ?

Anderson et al. emphasise evidence that violent media contributes causally to aggression, whereas Ferguson argues that effects are often small and potentially inflated by methodological weaknesses.

Their disagreement concerns the strength and interpretation of the evidence rather than whether aggression and serious crime are identical.

30
New cards

What did Devilly et al. (2023) investigate?

Immediate anger and aggression following violent and nonviolent video games, violent reading material and violent television, alongside individual psychological predictors.

31
New cards

What did Devilly et al. (2023) find?

Media conditions did not produce significant differences in anger or aggression.

Impulsivity, frustration and emotional reactivity predicted anger, while trait anger predicted aggression, suggesting individual characteristics may be more informative than exposure condition alone.

32
New cards

How should Devilly et al. (2023) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Compares several media formats.

• Includes individual psychological predictors.

• Provides important null findings.

LIMITATIONS:

• Short-term results cannot exclude long-term effects.

• Conclusions depend on the sensitivity of aggression measures and chosen stimuli.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Challenges uniform immediate-effects claims and supports attention to individual differences.

33
New cards

What is the Individual Moderation Perspective associated with Unsworth et al. (2007)?

The proposal that responses to violent media depend on individual characteristics and initial emotional states rather than following the same pattern for every viewer.

34
New cards

What did Unsworth et al. (2007) find?

Some aggressive or emotionally labile participants with low initial anger became angrier after violent-game exposure, while those already highly angry could become less angry.

Participants low in trait aggression tended to show more stable responses.

35
New cards

How should Unsworth et al. (2007) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Tests variation by trait aggression and starting mood.

• Challenges a uniform exposure-effects model.

LIMITATIONS:

• Short-term anger does not establish aggression or crime.

• Subgroup findings need careful interpretation and replication.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Media effects may differ substantially according to the viewer's initial state.

36
New cards

What did Ferguson (2015b) investigate and find?

Historical comparisons of movie violence with homicide and video game trends with youth crime found no consistent meaningful positive relationship across the periods examined, challenging claims that increasing violent media necessarily increases societal crime.

37
New cards

How should Ferguson (2015b) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Examines real-world crime trends rather than laboratory proxies.

• Tests broad claims about societal consequences.

LIMITATIONS:

• Population-level data cannot establish individual effects.

• Crime has many social determinants.

• Historical exposure measures may be imperfect.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Weakens simple media-causes-crime narratives but cannot rule out individual-level effects.

38
New cards

What is the ecological fallacy in media violence research?

Inferring individual-level relationships from population-level patterns.

For example, a lack of correlation between national media violence and crime rates does not prove that media exposure has no effect on any individual.

39
New cards

What is cultivation theory in relation to media violence and crime?

The theory that repeated exposure to recurring media portrayals can gradually shape perceptions of social reality, including beliefs about how common crime and danger are.

40
New cards

What is the mean world syndrome?

A perception that the world is more threatening or dangerous than it actually is, potentially associated with repeated exposure to threatening media portrayals.

41
New cards

What did Weaver and Wakshlag (1986) contribute to research on television and fear of crime?

Their work highlights that relationships between viewing and fear may vary according to personal vulnerability, victimisation experience and programme type rather than being identical for all viewers.

42
New cards

How should Weaver and Wakshlag (1986) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Considers audience vulnerability and viewing patterns.

LIMITATIONS:

• Survey evidence cannot establish causal direction.

• Existing fear and personal experience may influence viewing choices.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Cultivation relationships should be interpreted in light of audience characteristics and media content.

43
New cards

What did Baranauskas and Drakulich (2018) investigate and find?

Using national survey evidence and contextual information, they found relationships between local crime news, crime dramas and crime perceptions.

Local news was also associated with punitive criminal justice attitudes, with some relationships varying by racial and neighbourhood context.

44
New cards

What was the importance of race and neighbourhood context in Baranauskas and Drakulich (2018)?

Associations involving local crime news and punitive attitudes were particularly relevant among White respondents living in neighbourhoods with more Black residents, suggesting that social context may shape interpretations of crime coverage.

45
New cards

How should Baranauskas and Drakulich (2018) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Combining national survey evidence with contextual information moves beyond simple correlations between total media use and fear.

• Distinguishing local news from crime drama and examining racial neighbourhood context identifies possible differences in how crime messages are interpreted.

LIMITATIONS:

• Existing political beliefs or punitive attitudes may influence crime-news consumption rather than result from it.

• Neighbourhood racial composition may be associated with other social conditions that influence attitudes.

• Survey associations cannot establish that news exposure caused punitive preferences.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Crime-media relationships are embedded in social and racial context, making a universal cultivation explanation insufficient.

46
New cards

What did Iqbal et al. (2024) investigate and find?

A cross-sectional study of 518 students from 12 Pakistani universities found that violent news exposure was associated with fear, anxiety, mistrust, insecurity and depressive symptoms, with stronger reported responses among women.

47
New cards

How should Iqbal et al. (2024) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Examines several psychological outcomes.

• Includes multiple institutions in a non-Western context.

LIMITATIONS:

• Cross-sectional design cannot establish causality.

• Self-report may introduce bias.

• University students may not represent the wider population.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Supports an association between violent news and distress but not proof that exposure causes it.

48
New cards

What news values did Chibnall (1977) identify?

Immediacy, dramatisation, personalisation, simplification, titillation, conventionalism, structured access and novelty.

These help explain why some crimes are selected and presented as newsworthy.

49
New cards

What crime newsworthiness factors are associated with Jewkes (2004)?

Factors include risk, sex, proximity, violence, spectacle, graphic images and children.

Such features help explain why unusual or emotionally engaging crimes may receive disproportionate attention.

50
New cards

How can news values contribute to distorted perceptions of crime?

Selection criteria favour dramatic and unusual incidents rather than a representative sample of offences.

Repeated coverage may therefore make exceptional crimes appear more typical, although audience effects must be tested rather than assumed.

51
New cards

What did Hust et al. (2013) investigate and find?

Among 508 American undergraduates, crime drama viewing was associated with stronger intentions to intervene in sexual assault situations after accounting for other predictors, suggesting crime-related media may also relate to prosocial responses.

52
New cards

How should Hust et al. (2013) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Examines a potentially beneficial media association.

• Considers relevant additional predictors.

LIMITATIONS:

• Survey design cannot establish causation.

• Intervention intentions do not necessarily translate into behaviour.

• Undergraduate sample limits generalisability.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Crime dramas may be associated with prosocial intentions, but actual behavioural effects remain uncertain.

53
New cards

What did Coyne and Padilla-Walker (2015) find about song lyrics?

Longitudinal exposure to aggressive lyrics predicted greater aggression and less prosocial behaviour, while sexual lyrics were associated with earlier sexual intercourse.

Prosocial lyrics did not show the expected longitudinal association with later prosocial behaviour.

54
New cards

How should Coyne and Padilla-Walker (2015) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Longitudinal design.

• Distinguishes aggressive, sexual and prosocial content.

LIMITATIONS:

• Observational associations remain vulnerable to selection effects and confounding.

• Listening does not necessarily mean attending to lyrics.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Associations depend on lyrical content and cannot automatically be interpreted as causal.

55
New cards

What did Wright et al. (2016) investigate and find?

A meta-analysis of 22 studies across seven countries found an association between pornography consumption and sexual aggression, with stronger associations for verbal than physical sexual aggression and particular concern about violent sexual content.

56
New cards

How should Wright et al. (2016) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Synthesises evidence across studies and countries.

• Distinguishes forms of sexual aggression.

LIMITATIONS:

• Much evidence is correlational.

• Definitions and measures vary.

• Pre-existing attitudes and selection effects may confound associations.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Identifies an important relationship without establishing simple causal determinism.

57
New cards

What is the Final Girl convention in slasher films?

A recurring pattern in which a female character survives and often confronts the killer, sometimes distinguished from other characters through sexuality, prosocial behaviour or agency.

58
New cards

What did Weaver et al. (2015) investigate and find?

A content analysis of 226 characters across 30 top-grossing slasher films found that Final Girls were generally less sexual or nude and more prosocial, agentic and androgynous than other characters.

59
New cards

How should Weaver et al. (2015) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Systematically examines a substantial number of characters and multiple traits.

LIMITATIONS:

• Top-grossing films may not represent the genre.

• Remakes and recurring characters may affect independence.

• Content analysis cannot establish audience interpretations.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Supports identifiable gendered survival patterns without demonstrating psychological effects on viewers.

60
New cards

What did Welsh (2009) find about slasher films?

Women were more likely to be victims in slasher films, providing a concise example of gendered victimisation in horror media.

61
New cards

What did Welsh (2010) investigate and find?

A content analysis of 50 randomly selected English-language North American slasher films from 1960–2009 found that sexually active female characters were less likely to survive and had longer death scenes.

62
New cards

How should Welsh (2010) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Random selection within defined film criteria.

• Covers a broad historical period.

• Examines survival and death-scene duration.

LIMITATIONS:

• Restricted to English-language North American films.

• Character associations may reflect other narrative factors.

• Cannot establish audience effects.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Supports an association between female sexuality and punishment within the sampled slasher films.

63
New cards

How do Welsh (2009), Welsh (2010) and Weaver et al. (2015) contribute to an essay on gendered violence?

Welsh (2009) identifies female victimisation, Welsh (2010) links female sexual activity to lower survival and longer death scenes, and Weaver et al. (2015) identifies distinctive Final Girl characteristics. Together they support discussion of gendered representation without proving audience effects.

64
New cards

What did Gibson et al. (2014) investigate and find?

An experiment comparing aggressive reality television, supportive reality television and violent crime drama found greater noise-blast aggression after aggressive reality television than either comparison condition.

Violent crime drama also produced more aggression than supportive reality television, while ego threat did not significantly moderate effects.

65
New cards

How should Gibson et al. (2014) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Experimental comparison of different programme types.

• Includes a supportive-content comparison.

LIMITATIONS:

• Noise blasts are an indirect proxy for aggression.

• Programmes may differ in features beyond aggression.

• Immediate laboratory effects do not establish long-term violence.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Suggests genre and context may influence short-term responses, but real-world implications remain uncertain.

66
New cards

What did Krahé et al. (2012) investigate and find?

In a three-wave study of 1,715 German secondary-school students over two years, violent media use predicted later self-reported physical aggression and teacher-rated overall aggression after controlling for initial aggression and other factors.

Nonviolent media use was unrelated to aggression.

67
New cards

How should Krahé et al. (2012) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Three waves across two years establish temporal ordering.

• Controlling baseline aggression and several competing predictors reduces some selection-based explanations.

• Teacher ratings provide evidence independent of participants' self-reports.

LIMITATIONS:

• Most measures were self-reported, creating potential shared method bias.

• Teacher aggression ratings relied on a single general item, which may be less sensitive to specific physical aggression than the self-report measure.

• Associations were generally stronger for self-reported aggression, raising questions about measurement dependence.

• Remaining unmeasured influences prevent definitive causal inference.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Provides comparatively strong longitudinal support for violent media as a possible aggression risk factor, although the strength of evidence varies by outcome measure.

68
New cards

What did Dillon and Bushman (2017) investigate and find?

In a randomised experiment involving 104 children aged 8–12, those who watched a film containing guns handled a concealed disabled real handgun for longer and pulled its trigger more often than children who watched the same film with gun scenes removed.

69
New cards

How should Dillon and Bushman (2017) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Random assignment and gun-present versus gun-removed versions of the same film help isolate the immediate influence of gun portrayals.

• Observed gun handling and trigger pulling provide behavioural outcomes rather than self-reported intentions.

LIMITATIONS:

• Only one modified real handgun was available but two Nerf guns were provided, potentially encouraging cooperative play with the Nerf guns and changing how children interacted with the handgun.

• The stationary camera could not capture every action.

• Previous firearm exposure and safety training were not assessed, potentially affecting children's curiosity or responses.

• Handling a disabled gun in a laboratory does not establish intent to harm or real-world violent crime.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: The experiment supports an immediate behavioural effect of gun depictions while leaving the generalisability and broader significance of that effect uncertain.

70
New cards

What did Collier et al. (2016) investigate and find?

Three meta-analyses covering 57 studies examined restrictive mediation, active mediation and coviewing.

Restriction and coviewing showed small overall associations with child outcomes.

Active mediation was nonsignificant overall but individually associated with lower aggression, sexual behaviour and substance use.

71
New cards

How should Collier et al. (2016) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Synthesises 57 studies.

• Distinguishes three parental mediation strategies and several outcomes.

LIMITATIONS:

• Average associations are small.

• Definitions of mediation vary.

• Parents may change their practices in response to existing child behaviour.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Parental mediation may be helpful, but effectiveness depends on the strategy and outcome.

72
New cards

What did Romer et al. (2014) investigate and find?

In an experiment involving approximately 1,000 American parents, repeated exposure to violent and sexual movie clips reduced the minimum ages parents considered appropriate for viewing such content.

For violent content, the reported minimum age fell from 16.9 to 13.9 years, a three-year decrease consistent with desensitisation.

73
New cards

How should Romer et al. (2014) be evaluated?

STRENGTHS:

• Repeated exposure within an experimental procedure provides evidence that viewing violent or sexual clips can change immediate parental judgements.

• A national sample of approximately 1,000 parents gives the findings broader relevance than a small student experiment.

• The reported decrease from 16.9 to 13.9 years for violent content illustrates a substantial change in stated age appropriateness.

LIMITATIONS:

• A lower recommended viewing age is an immediate judgement rather than evidence that parents actually permit younger children to watch violent films.

• Short clips may not reproduce how parents assess complete films with narrative context.

• The study does not establish whether the changed judgements persist.

OVERALL IMPLICATION: Supports desensitisation of parental age-rating judgements without demonstrating lasting changes in parenting behaviour.

74
New cards

Why is the distinction between correlation and causation central to media violence research?

People may select media according to existing traits, while unmeasured social or psychological factors may influence both exposure and aggression.

Experimental and longitudinal methods improve inference in different ways but do not automatically eliminate every alternative explanation.

75
New cards

Why is ecological validity important when evaluating media aggression experiments?

Laboratory measures such as noise blasts or handling a disabled handgun may capture immediate responses under controlled conditions but cannot automatically be generalised to sustained interpersonal aggression or serious violent crime.

76
New cards

What is the strongest overall essay conclusion about media violence, aggression and crime?

Some experimental and longitudinal findings support media-related changes in aggression or behaviour, while other studies find small, null or context-dependent effects.

Audience selection, individual differences, media context and methodological limitations complicate causal claims.

Media violence may be one risk factor, but evidence about aggression, fear and attitudes should not be equated with proof that media causes serious violent crime.