1/161
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Globalization has made it possible for terrorists to communicate transnationally, recruit, transport arms
terrorist groups usually operate in failed states
what is the Westphalian system
political system is nationstates
the global political system is nationstates under the Westphalian system
what are the four principles under the westphalian system
soverignty
territorial integrity
equality of states
non-interference
soverignty under the westphalian system
states have supreme authority over their own territory and population
territorial integrity under the westphalian system
defined boundaries establish the limits of a state’s jurisdiction
equality of states under westphalian system
regardless of size or power, all states are legally equaly under international law
non-interference under the Westphalian system
one state cant legally interfere in the domestic affairs of another
does the westphalian system extend to the rest of the world
no, it doesn’t it is just between european countries
referent object = what we are talking about or referring to
what does the traditional notion of secrutiy entail
it is state-centric
need to protect the state and also be protected from other states
focus on material sources of power
military and economy
what is the human security concept
now we are more concerned about the people’s actual safety
freedom from fear and freedom from want
how are we protecting the people’s quality of life
and protection from disruptions to daily life
with this shift of the referent object also comes with broadening secuity concerns
with the increase of information technology people know about problems happening everywehre and how problems elsewhere will cause poltical issues at home
examples of non-traditional security threats
migration, global crime, trafficking, instability in financial markets
external soverignty
have the recognition of soverignty by other states rather than actually have the ability to fulfill the functions of a state
externally they are recognized as a soverign but internall there is no real guy
what are the three types of deficienies in weak states
security
unable to protect its citizens (military, court)
particpation
polticial particpation is often absent and civil society is usually dysfunctional
but need this and democracy for governing institutions to do what people want
infrastructure
can’t collect taxes so have bad physical infrastructure
external soverignty and the westphalian system
they are directly connected but it ends up being an issue in the global world when there are groups organizing in the weak state but due to external soverignty you can’t come and interfere
under westphalian beliefs where does loyalty lie
in the nationstate
what are the three other political subjectivities mention that a person could have other than the nationstate after globalization
democracy
religion
nationalism
fukuyama and his views
said that western liberal democracy is the right model
world would be more secure/safe if liberal democracy is spread
can attain security through the promotion of democracy
Globalization drives [some forms of] cultural homogenization, but it simultaneously reinforces nationalist and ethnic sentiment as it compels people to promote and defend their ethnic, religious, and/or linguistic identities in response to the homogenizing effect of globalization.
what was a challenge to westphalian soverignty
the R2P doctrine (responsibility to protect)
what is the responsibility to protect doctrine
R2P
states have to protect their people
have to assist other states to protect the people of that state
have to police and monitor what other states are doing and bring it through the UN if things need to change
in traditional modes of security what is the referent object that requires protection and how do they protect
the state
what requires protection
and the threat is other states
through military and things like that
military is sole grantor of secuirty
in the human security concept what is the referent object that requires protection and how do they protect
the human/people themselves need protecting AND the state
they need to be protected from fear (wars) and want (threats to daily existence)
they protect by having economic secruity, social movements etc
Diverse Agents of Security
what causes this shift from the state as the referent object to the people
globalization
because there were issues of migration and crime and that couldn’t just be solved with the military
also the rise of technology and orgs saw this destruction and knew that the military wouldn’t suffice
why did laura bush give her address
to show that with the spread of terrorism comes the spread of VAW
where did the terms 1st,2nd,3rd world come from
the cold war
1st = europe and the US (democracy and capitalism)
2nd = socialism and communism (USSR)
3rd = not explicitly aligned with either
where saw proxy wars
how are democracy, religion, and nationalism ideas of secrurity threats
democracy
fukuyama says it is the best and everyone should move towards it but there is friction and resistance and that can cause a threat to arise
religion
will put their religion first and create groups that will attack
nationalism
fiercely reasserts state borders, mobilizing anti-immigrant and populist sentiment against perceived globalizing threats
what is the bad explanatory model mamdani discusses
good muslim/bad muslim
what makes up the bad explanatory model
a cultural has “essential” characteristics
think of cultural in political terms
erase history and context of how these people became the way they are polticially (ex afghanistan and 911)
dehistoricizes the construction of political subjectivities
sees “traditional peoples” as conforming to lifeless custom and lack creative capacity
have literal interpreation of their texts so can’t operate in society
but then also goes to say yes they are passive but can destruct
because one person did something wrong justify collective disicipline and punishment
what is culture talk
we have identified national identities, boiled them down to inherent characteristics, and then imagine this is how they will behave politically
erasing context
Culture talk is a broad, flawed analytical model that seeks to explain political behavior and outcomes primarily through cultural and religious identity rather than history or politics
political subjectivity definition
your understanding of your own primary loyalty
Culture Talk misuses culture as an all-encompassing explanatory frame for political behavior
In short, Mamdani emphasizes that Culture Talk is an anti-knowledge project that hides how global power operates, replacing genuine historical and political analysis with cultural stereotypes
Mamdani says that culture talk sees muslims as resisntance to modernity (not to imperalism)
In other words, instead of recognizing that people might be fighting because they don't want to be controlled, their resistance gets portrayed as a cultural problem.
imperalism of indirect rule
Indirect imperial rule encouraged Western powers to explain people's behavior through their culture and religion instead of recognizing the political power dynamics behind it.
because they were assigning people based on the characterisitcs they wanted
why do we have the bad explanatory model
According to Mahmood Mamdani, we have this "bad explanatory model" (Culture Talk) because it performs specific political functions: it legitimizes foreign intervention, provides a moral pretext for collective punishment, and erases the historical responsibility of modern imperial powers
When these legacy networks later turned against the West, Culture Talk allowed Western powers to depict phenomena like the Taliban or al-Qaeda as leftover "premodern residues" of an ancient, fanatical culture
.
Erasing this modern political context masks the reality that these movements were modern ensembles created in service of modern political projects, allowing foreign powers to walk away from the destruction caused by their Cold War operations
mamdami in his quote is saying they make it seem like muslims just conform to culture and they don’t have any history or debates (making us seem lifeless)
says they make it seem incapable of transforming their culture
and it makes it seem like they need saving
premodern vs modern
premodern
prisoner of culture
destructive
moment of creativity was only in the past in ancient texts
literal reading of texts (interuppting their civic life)
no history/politics/debates
savior must come from the outside
modern
makes culture
creative
constanty moving to the future
secularism/metaphorical understadning of religious texts
change and innovation
white man’s burden
political subjectivity and modern and premodern
you are modern if you know that the nationstate is your loyalty
America cultivated terrorism in countries it considered pro-soviet
how did the drive for junior partners drive the afghan jihad
the US didn’t want proxy wars but wanted regional powers as junior partners
the US made it seem like communism was a threat to their civilization so they have to fight against them
they brought people from all around the world to fight in the war against the soviets
Arab-Afghans
heroin consumption and production (in the US, afghanistan and pakistan) was used to fund the giving of weapons to the afghans
afghan jihad
a just war with religious sanction
the tradition of jihad that used to be nonexistent was revived with American help
how does mamdani say we should understand terrorism
that it is actually a modern project in service of modern goals
it isn’t due to the residue of premodern culture in modern poliitcs
terrorism is a modern construction
“even when it harnesses one or another aspect of tradition and culture, the result is a modern ensemble at the service of a modern project
what should we look at in this new explanatory model
from looking at doctrine and culture to looking at hisotry and politics
to broaden the view of Islam to include larger historical encounters
culture talk offers a "good" (moderate, compliant) and "bad" (radical, literalist) actors, while dividing the world into "modern" (creative, dynamic) and "premodern" (petrified, museumized) subjects
what are the two intra community schisms that Mamdani sees as more historically accurate in response to imperalism and the cold war
radical islamist social movements
state-driven neo-fundamentalist
radical islamist social movements
began as building a supranational muslim umma or community, but turned into radical ismamism adapted to the antion state
and made different versions of Islamism
rejuventate islam as a political idelogy and not just a religion
emerged as a result of imperalism
Adapted to the nation-state; formed national political agendas
state-driven neo-fundamentalist
conservative agenda
strictly wanted to implement sharia
didn’t want shias or womens rights
emerged from the cold war and US involvement in afghanistan
how does the islamist social movement and the conservative neo-fundamentalist overturn the good muslim bad muslim narrative
it says that both are not premodern but came about due to modern things (cold war and imperialism)
political violence is not from premodern texts but by these modern things that have happened
the student podcast summary
the world is bigger than the us
our lives are bound to people outside the us
culture talk = religion is culture, culture is politics
america made the political subjectiviites to be willing to do work for their beliefs
According to the sources, tolerance of religious difference is made possible not by erasing religious convictions or demanding secular conformity, but through historical traditions of coexistence, internal doctrinal principles of non-compulsion, and the construction of inclusive political communities
mamdani says that just because you have traditional beliefs does not mean you are not capable of being tolerable
The main idea is that people do NOT have to give up their religious beliefs or become secular in order to tolerate people who believe differently from them.
Mamdani is challenging the assumption that someone who strongly believes in their religion cannot coexist peacefully with people of other religions.
Culture Talk assumes that:
- Religious people who follow their scriptures literally are intolerant.
and to become tolerant they have to give up the reading of their religious texts or interpret them metaphorically
proxy wars vs junior partners
proxy wars = first and second world countries having third world ones fight on their behalf
junior partners = the arabs and other people that were helping the US fight in afghanistan
terrorism is a modern response to contemporary context even though they are using historical texts as justification
refugee definition
flee their homes, cross an international border, and can’t return because they fear their lives are in danger
Internally Displaced Person (IDP)
flee their homes fort he same reasons as refgugees but have not crossed an international border
aslyum-seekers
flee their homes and claim they are refugees, but their status has not yet been definitively determined
migrats
voluntarily leave their homes to settle permanetly in another region or country for a number of reasonss
cantant argues that migration might be a crisis but it isn’t always or never
europe and migration crisis
localized migration events turned into a generic european narrative of border disorder
framed human mobility as a secuirty threat
border externalization
making walls, expanding security
need to define every part of a crisis (is it by how fast they are moving, where they are moving) before saying it really is a crisis
Declaring a situation a "crisis" provides political actors with moral panic narratives that justify exceptional, ad-hoc measures
what three dimensions does migration as crisis framework integrate
events, discourses, and governance
migration is not inherently crisis-producing; crisises are constructured through representation and response
people have always moved and the fact that they are moving isn’t a crisis
the way crisis is defined at times makes it sound so panicky and a huge issue
who defines crisis
the state, media, and international orginzations
langugage choices establish moral hierachies and guide governance logics
whose benfiting from crisis narratives and how they are sustained
decisions can easily be made if there is a crisis
can be poltically useful
policy makers and media shape these narratives
political usefulness of crisis narratives
depliticies root causes (like inequality and climate vulnerability)
what is actually pushing people away is depliticed and it is blamed on something else rather than there is inequality or a climate issue
reinforces control and misgovernance
positions migration as external threat and distracts people from the reason why they left
makes people forget that these people might have actually ran away from war but instead that they are taking up our space and jobs
its just that these people are coming for our jobs!
ligitimizes harsh border and asylum policies
authorizes violence
framing migration as crisis justifices meaures and suspends normal politics
there isn’t time for normal procedures or they justify more violence and certain measures that need to be done (ex. using force at borders)
moral panic
emotional engagement with a question that drives us beyond the emprirical reality and respond to things as if they were a crisis
militarization vs externatilization of a border
militiarization = military
externalization = beyond; think not just at the us mexico border but initiatives in mexico as well
xenophobia
not wanting other people in your country
part of the moral panic = people who don’t belong in our nation don’t belong in our state
to have moral panic you need people making the conditions of it
In summary, xenophobia provides the ideological content (fear of the foreign "other"), while moral panic acts as the political vehicle that mobilizes that fear to reassert state authority, restrict human mobility, and alter legal and political norms
empirical reality, representation, governance
empirical reality
what is actually happening
how many people are moving, where are they coming from
representation
how are people protroay the empriical reality
what language are they using
governance
what polices and actions are governments doing in response to migration
cyclic nature
seven tactics of authroitanism
politicizing indepdnet insittutions
trying to capture these insituttions (like police and stuff)’
spreading disinformation
amplify falsehoods (yes politicans lie, but here they do it 10 fold)
aggrandizing (increase) executive power
even though we are supposed to be separate
quashing dissent
silence the press that comes with strong democracies (because in strong democracies there is oppsiition, debate)
scapegoating vulnerable communiities
get people to turn on the small groups
corrupting elections
stoking violence
actively inflame violence to stoke/stir up fear and insecurity so they can be okay with the government taking increased power
democractic backsliding
when a state becomes gradually less democractic over time
happens by democractic leaders
when elected leaders gradually weaken democracy from within, while still appearing to operate within a democracy
doesn’t mean state is failing
attack the truth and minority populations so people trust the government more
breakdown norms
make it seem like the other political parties are not real (us vs them)
do it with more rule breaking and sabatoge
Motchoulski and his article
saw that there is a lot of definitions of authoritarianism
new concept of justificatory authorianism
petty authoritaianism
personal gratification for using power against other people
ex. ticketers
bald coercion
no justification justing saying you have to do it because i said so
what is downward accountability
people who are under the power are able to constrain the power of the people above them
consent of the governed
authorianism sabatoge downward accountability
want to dismantle getting voted out of office, legal accountability
want to control information
does Motchoulski see authoritianism as antithetical to democracy
no!
grassroots authoritarianism
in an establish democracy when a party with authroitian aims wins popular support
imposes power but through institutionally legitiimate means
and not sabatoge
ex. going through the courts to control them
have to have public support to keep doing
goal of grassroots authroitarianism
to maintain the facade of indepdent institutions but actually bring them under conttrol of the authrotian figure
right-wing authrotianian
see the world as unstable and dangerous
wants individuals to conform to authorty, norms, and punishment to deviance
to respond to the world being a scary place have to conform
following norms keep us safe
social dominance orientation
view society as a competitive hierarchy
world is naturally some are at the top, some at the bottom
inclines individuals to prefer group based dominance and status preservation
to make the world less scary our group has to maintain their position
justificatory authoritarianism meaning
a justificatory framework that licenses exercising unconstraitned power over others
bypasses constraints by saying they are doing it for collective benefit
isn’t just bald corecion, give them reasons why they should trust them
how is power constrained
by being held accountable to norms
how do you remove constraints
censory people
take punitive measures against those who oppose you
suppres votes and voices