Criminal Law Y2S1 Week 8: L15 & L16 Property Offences (Embezzlement, Robbery, Extortion, Fraud, Reset & Damage)

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/36

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

Key terms and cases from my OneNote notes. 37 cards. 'Added' notes are from outside the notes.

37 Terms

1
New cards

Embezzlement: what are the actus reus and mens rea?

ACTUS REUS: APPROPRIATION of property by a person AUTHORISED to deal with it, who owes a DUTY TO ACCOUNT for it to the owner (Macdonald, p.45). • PRIOR AUTHORISATION is essential (Kent v HMA 1950). • APPROPRIATION means a failure in the DUTY TO ACCOUNT, e.g. funds used for something they should not be. The exact moment of appropriation does not matter (Edgar v MacKay 1926). • It is typically white-collar: money, stocks and shares. MENS REA: DISHONEST INTENTION (Allenby 1938; Moore 2010). It can be INFERRED from deliberate or reckless conduct (McCraw v Murphy 2016).

2
New cards

How does embezzlement differ from theft?

• AUTHORISATION: embezzlement involves property the accused was AUTHORISED to deal with and owed a duty to ACCOUNT for. Theft involves appropriation WITHOUT consent. • PROPERTY: embezzlement can cover INCORPOREAL property, e.g. funds in a bank account or cheques (Guild v Lees 1995). Theft requires CORPOREAL moveables. • HISTORY: theft was once a CAPITAL offence and embezzlement was not, and there is a CLASS dimension: white-collar, middle-class offenders avoided the label of 'thief'.

3
New cards

Robbery: what is it, and how much violence is needed?

Robbery is THEFT accomplished by VIOLENCE or INTIMIDATION. It is a SEPARATE crime (theft transformed by the violence), not merely aggravated theft or aggravated assault, but all the ELEMENTS OF THEFT must be established. • The LEVEL of violence required is MINIMAL, and no separate free-standing ASSAULT is needed (O'Neill 1934). A bag snatch that snaps the handles is enough (Cromar 1987). • There must still be SOME violence proved. If the jury deletes all the violence libelled, robbery fails (Flynn 1995), although the precise nature of the violence need not be specified (Morrison 2010). • INTIMIDATION alone suffices: a threat that makes the victim reasonably FEAR harm if they do not comply.

4
New cards

CASE: Kent v HM Advocate 1950 JC 38

Issue: Can there be embezzlement without proof that the accused was AUTHORISED to deal with the property? Facts: There was no evidence that the accused had been authorised to deal with the property in question. Held: There was NO embezzlement. PRIOR AUTHORISATION to deal with the property is an essential element, which is what distinguishes it from theft.

5
New cards

CASE: Edgar v MacKay 1926 JC 94

Issue: When does APPROPRIATION occur in embezzlement? Facts: A SOLICITOR was instructed to recover sums owed to a client. He COLLECTED the money but never told the client or accounted for it. Held: EMBEZZLEMENT. He had prior authorisation and received the money but could not account for it. The precise moment of appropriation did not matter; the FAILURE TO ACCOUNT was enough.

6
New cards

CASE: Allenby v HM Advocate 1938 JC 55

Issue: Is it embezzlement to make unauthorised payments HONESTLY and openly? Facts: Allenby managed the sale of fish and ADVANCED money to skippers who were not entitled to it. He KEPT RECORDS of the payments, and this was common INDUSTRY PRACTICE at the time. Held: NOT embezzlement. There was no DISHONEST INTENTION. He acted openly and honestly, even if wrongly. The owners' remedy, if any, was CIVIL.

7
New cards

CASE: Moore v HM Advocate 2010 SCCR 451

Issue: What shows DISHONESTY in embezzlement? Facts: A managing director co-owned a company 50/50 with his estranged wife. He routinely withdrew company money to GAMBLE, aiming to strip assets so that his wife would not get them in the divorce. Held: EMBEZZLEMENT. The CONCEALMENT of the withdrawals supplied the element of DISHONESTY.

8
New cards

CASE: McCraw v Murphy 2016 SCL 383

Issue: Can dishonest intention be inferred from RECKLESS conduct? Facts: The accused used a COMPANY CREDIT CARD erratically and could not account for the spending. He argued that erratic spending was not dishonesty. Held: Dishonest intention can be INFERRED from acts that are DELIBERATE or RECKLESS. On the facts, his inability to account for the spending supported the inference.

9
New cards

CASE: Guild v Lees 1995 SLT 68

Issue: Can misuse of a company's CHEQUES be theft, given that funds are not corporeal? Facts: The accused used company CHEQUES to pay his own ELECTRICITY BILL and argued that this was not theft of corporeal property. Held: It was EMBEZZLEMENT. This shows that embezzlement covers INCORPOREAL property such as funds, which theft cannot.

10
New cards

CASE: O'Neill v HM Advocate 1934 JC 98

Issue: Can an accused be ACQUITTED of ASSAULT but CONVICTED of ROBBERY on the same facts? Facts: The accused was charged with both. The jury found no assault proved but convicted of robbery, and he appealed. Held: Conviction UPHELD. Robbery needs only the FORCE used to achieve the theft. It does not require a separate free-standing assault, so the failure of the assault charge did not mean the force was insufficient for robbery.

11
New cards

CASE: Cromar v HM Advocate 1987 SCCR 635

Issue: Is SNATCHING a bag from someone's hand enough violence for robbery? Facts: The accused pulled a plastic bag from the victim's hand, and the handles SNAPPED. He argued that a snatch was not violence. Held: ROBBERY. The snapping of the handles showed that SUFFICIENT FORCE was used. Only minimal violence is needed.

12
New cards

CASE: Flynn v HM Advocate 1995 SLT 1267 and Morrison v HM Advocate 2010 JC 174

Issue: What happens to a robbery charge if the jury rejects the violence libelled? Facts: • FLYNN: the indictment specified robbery by CHOKING the complainer and throwing them to the ground. The jury DELETED all references to violence. • MORRISON: the complainer was thrown to the ground and kicked. There was clear evidence of some violence. Held: • Flynn: with no violence left in the libel, robbery could not stand, and he was convicted of THEFT instead. • Morrison: DISTINGUISHED Flynn. There must be SOME violence, but the Crown need not prove the specific nature of the violence libelled.

13
New cards

Extortion: what is it, and why is it wrong to threaten someone into paying what they really owe?

Extortion is DEMANDS backed by THREATS (the legal term for blackmail). • Even a LEGITIMATE claim cannot be backed by threats. The only legitimate means to force payment is DUE LEGAL PROCESS, e.g. raising a court action or using a contractual lien or retention, or threatening to do so (Black v Carmichael 1992). • The threat need NOT be of something unlawful. Threatening to REVEAL true information is enough when it is coupled with a demand (Marion Macdonald 1879; Rae v Donnelly 1982). • The demand need NOT be FINANCIAL (Rae v Donnelly: dropping a tribunal claim). • Rationale: COERCION, i.e. removing the victim's free choice, and undermining the legal system's CONTROL over dispute resolution.

14
New cards

Fraud: what are its elements?

A common law crime: INDUCING a person, by FALSE PRETENCES, to do something they would not otherwise have done, achieving a DEFINITE PRACTICAL RESULT. ACTUS REUS:

  1. A false pretence as to a MATERIAL (not COLLATERAL) matter (Tapsell v Prentice 1910). It can be a false statement of PRESENT INTENTION (Richards 1971), or non-disclosure where there is a DUTY TO DISCLOSE (Strathern v Fogal 1922).
  2. A DEFINITE PRACTICAL RESULT. No financial loss or gain is needed (Adcock v Archibald 1925; Whyte 2017; G v HMA).
  3. A CAUSAL LINK between the pretence and the result (Mather 1914). MENS REA: KNOWLEDGE of the falsity and INTENTION to bring about the practical result. Mere CARELESSNESS is not enough (Mackenzie v Skeen 1971). Criticism: fraud is very broad. Chalmers suggests a legally protected INTEREST should be required.
15
New cards

Reset: what are its elements?

Reset is the handling of stolen goods: 'knowingly receiving articles taken by theft, robbery, embezzlement, or fraud… or being PRIVY TO THE RETAINING of property that has been dishonestly come by' (Macdonald, p.67). It extends to the proceeds of embezzlement and fraud under the Criminal Law (Consolidation) (Scotland) Act 1995 s.51. ACTUS REUS: POSSESSION is not necessary. Being PRIVY TO THE RETENTION is enough, e.g. a PASSENGER in a stolen car (McCawley 1959; HMA v Browne 1903; McNeil 1968). It is MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE with theft: the thief cannot reset the same goods (Druce v Friel 1994). MENS REA: KNOWLEDGE that the goods were dishonestly obtained, or WILFUL BLINDNESS (Latta v Herron 1967), plus an INTENTION to keep them from the owner. Mere SUSPICION is not enough, but knowledge can be inferred from incriminating circumstances (Forbes 1995).

16
New cards

Malicious mischief: what are the actus reus and mens rea?

ACTUS REUS: DAMAGING or DESTROYING property belonging to another. Minor damage suffices in principle. • It is EXTENDED to non-destructive interference that causes PATRIMONIAL (economic) LOSS (HMA v Wilson 1984). • But the loss must be TANGIBLE and measurable. A loss of use, or a risk of crime, is not enough (Bett v Hamilton 1998). MENS REA: INTENTION or RECKLESSNESS ('malice' means deliberate or reckless disregard for another's property rights). No SPITE is needed (Clark v Syme 1957). There must be more than accident (Ward v Robertson 1938). • A belief in a LEGAL right to damage the property is a MISTAKE OF LAW and NO DEFENCE (Clark v Syme). A mistake of FACT (e.g. believing the sheep were your own) could be a defence.

17
New cards

Vandalism (s.52 Criminal Law (Consolidation) (Scotland) Act 1995): how does it differ from malicious mischief?

s.52(1): 'any person who, WITHOUT REASONABLE EXCUSE, WILFULLY or RECKLESSLY destroys or damages any property belonging to another shall be guilty of the offence of vandalism'. Differences from malicious mischief: • It is STATUTORY, and it has an extra DEFENCE of REASONABLE EXCUSE. • It requires physical DESTRUCTION or DAMAGE, so it does NOT cover pure PATRIMONIAL loss (MacDougall v Ho 1985; John v Donnelly 1999; PF v Elrick (No 2) 2017). • They are separate offences (Black v Allan 1985), so you cannot charge both for the same conduct. • Damage by FIRE is charged as FIRE-RAISING, not as vandalism or malicious mischief.

18
New cards

Fire-raising: what are the two crimes?

Leading case: Byrne v HM Advocate 2000 JC 155. There are TWO separate crimes:

  1. WILFUL FIRE-RAISING: the mens rea is INTENTION to set fire to the property in question.
  2. CULPABLE AND RECKLESS FIRE-RAISING: the mens rea is RECKLESSNESS (Carr v HMA 1995; Thomson v HMA 1995). • NEGLIGENCE is NOT sufficient. • Added: in Byrne, intention cannot be 'transferred'. An intention to set fire to one property does not make spread to other property wilful; for that property it may be culpable and reckless. • Fire damage cannot be charged as vandalism or malicious mischief.
19
New cards

CASE: Marion Macdonald (1879) 4 Coup 268

Issue: Is it extortion to threaten to do something LAWFUL in order to obtain money? Facts: The accused threatened to REVEAL the complainer's IMMORAL conduct to his friends and family unless he paid her. Held: EXTORTION. Revealing the information was not unlawful in itself, but COUPLING the threat with a DEMAND for money made it criminal.

20
New cards

CASE: Silverstein v HM Advocate 1949 JC 160

Issue: Is it extortion to threaten action to recover money that is genuinely OWED? Facts: The accused approached the manager of a tenant company and said that unless he paid a sum owed, he would get the LANDLORDS to EVICT the tenants. Held: EXTORTION. Even where money is due, threats other than DUE LEGAL PROCESS cannot be used to obtain it.

21
New cards

CASE: Rae v Donnelly 1982 SCCR 148

Issue: Must the extortionate DEMAND be for money? Facts: An employee brought an UNFAIR DISMISSAL claim against a company. The managing director threatened to REVEAL an AFFAIR the employee had been having at work unless the claim was dropped. Held: EXTORTION. The demand need NOT be FINANCIAL, and threatening to reveal true information to back up a demand is enough.

22
New cards

CASE: Adcock v Archibald 1925 JC 58

Issue: What is a 'DEFINITE PRACTICAL RESULT' in fraud? Must there be financial loss? Facts: A coal miner put his own identifying token on a hutch of coal dug by ANOTHER miner, so that it was credited to him. Under the minimum wage arrangement, the false credit may not have changed what either was paid. Held: FRAUD. The mine owners were induced to CREDIT the wrong miner with the coal. That was a definite practical result, and no financial loss had to be proved.

23
New cards

CASE: Tapsell v Prentice (1910) 6 Adam 354

Issue: Is a lie about a COLLATERAL matter enough for fraud? Facts: The accused adopted a false identity and made false statements to encourage the complainer to buy a RUG. There was no false representation about the rug itself or its value. Held: NOT fraud. The false pretences were COLLATERAL, not MATERIAL to the transaction, so the deception did not concern the matter that produced the result. Contrast Richards.

24
New cards

CASE: Richards v HM Advocate 1971 JC 29

Issue: Can a false statement about FUTURE intentions be a false pretence? Facts: The seller of a house did not want it used commercially. Richards said he would NOT use it for commercial purposes, then did so. He argued he had simply changed his mind. Held: FRAUD. A person's PRESENT STATE OF MIND (their current intention) is a matter of FACT. On the evidence he was lying about his intention at the time he spoke.

25
New cards

CASE: Strathern v Fogal 1922 JC 73

Issue: Can NON-DISCLOSURE amount to a false pretence? Facts: The accused failed to disclose income for tax purposes, so false sums were recorded on the forms. Held: FRAUD (both statutory and at common law). Where there is a DUTY TO DISCLOSE, failing to do so can be a false pretence that produces a definite practical result.

26
New cards

CASE: McKenzie v HM Advocate 1988 SLT 487

Issue: Is there a practical result in fraud where the victim has not yet LOST any money? Facts: Three accused made false representations to SOLICITORS so that bogus civil claims (e.g. for unpaid wages) were raised against a company. They argued it was only an incomplete plan, because no money had been lost or gained. Held: APPEAL REFUSED. Causing civil actions to be raised, and the company to prepare to DEFEND them, was a definite PRACTICAL RESULT. The steps also went well beyond preparation, so ATTEMPTED fraud of the ultimate financial aim was also relevant.

27
New cards

CASE: Whyte v HM Advocate 2017 JC 262

Issue: Must the Crown prove actual FINANCIAL LOSS in fraud? Facts: Whyte induced the TRANSFER OF A MAJORITY SHAREHOLDING through false representations. A plea to the relevancy argued that the seller suffered no financial loss. Held: APPEAL REFUSED (Lady Dorrian), following Adcock. NO proof of loss or gain is needed. Inducing the share transfer was a clear definite practical result.

28
New cards

CASE: Mather v HM Advocate (1914) 7 Adam 525

Issue: Must the false pretence CAUSE the result? Facts: The accused obtained CATTLE and paid with a worthless CHEQUE, but the cattle were DELIVERED BEFORE the cheque was handed over. Held: NOT fraud by the cheque. The false pretence (the bad cheque) did not CAUSE the result (delivery of the cattle), so there was no CAUSAL LINK.

29
New cards

CASE: G v HM Advocate

Issue: Can a NON-FINANCIAL result be a 'practical result' in fraud? Facts (your notes): G conceived a child with N and, with Y, carried out a scheme to DECEIVE someone about the child's PATERNITY, altering official status and relationships. Held: FRAUD. Deceiving someone into believing they are a child's biological parent, or altering official status, is a sufficient NON-PECUNIARY practical result. She received three years' imprisonment. Your notes give no citation, so check it.

30
New cards

CASE: Mackenzie v Skeen 1971 JC 43

Issue: Is CARELESSNESS enough mens rea for fraud? Facts: Added: a butcher's scales or weights gave false readings, and he was charged with fraud on customers. Held: NO. Fraud requires KNOWLEDGE of the falsity and an INTENTION to bring about the practical result. Mere carelessness is not enough.

31
New cards

CASE: McCawley v HM Advocate (1959) SCCR Supp 3

Issue: Can a person who does not POSSESS stolen goods commit reset? Facts: The accused was a PASSENGER in a car he knew was STOLEN. Held: This could be RESET. Possession is not necessary; being PRIVY TO THE RETENTION of the property (keeping it from the owner) is enough.

32
New cards

CASE: Latta v Herron (1967) SCCR Supp 18

Issue: Can WILFUL BLINDNESS satisfy the mens rea of reset? Facts: Latta, a solicitor and firearms collector, bought guns from a client at about HALF their value and claimed he did not know they were stolen. Held: RESET. He had WILFULLY SHUT HIS EYES to the obvious. Knowledge can be established by incriminating circumstances, but mere suspicion is not enough.

33
New cards

CASE: Forbes v HM Advocate 1995 SLT 627

Issue: How can KNOWLEDGE in reset be proved? Facts: The accused said he did not know a very VALUABLE stolen PAINTING was in his car. Held: On the facts the jury was entitled to INFER the relevant knowledge from the circumstances. Knowledge is usually proved by inference.

34
New cards

CASE: HM Advocate v Wilson 1984 SLT 117

Issue: Is non-destructive interference that causes ECONOMIC LOSS malicious mischief? Facts: The accused deliberately pressed an EMERGENCY STOP button in a POWER STATION, halting generation and causing a loss of about £147,000. Nothing was physically damaged, and the sheriff dismissed the charge. Held: CROWN APPEAL ALLOWED. Interfering with property so as to DERANGE its function and cause PATRIMONIAL loss satisfies the actus reus of malicious mischief, even without physical damage.

35
New cards

CASE: Bett v Hamilton 1998 JC 1

Issue: Is it malicious mischief to cause only a LOSS OF USE or an increased RISK? Facts: The appellant used a pole to push a bank's SURVEILLANCE CAMERA so that it pointed away from the entrance, without damaging it. The Crown said the bank lost the benefit of its running costs and faced a higher risk of crime, and the sheriff held the charge relevant. Held: APPEAL ALLOWED; the charge was IRRELEVANT. Malicious mischief requires physical damage or a TANGIBLE patrimonial loss. Fixed running costs would have been paid anyway, and the lost security benefit or increased risk was too SPECULATIVE (Lord Sutherland).

36
New cards

CASE: Clark v Syme 1957 JC 1

Issue: Does a belief that you are legally ENTITLED to damage property negate 'malice'? Facts: A farmer repeatedly warned a neighbour about stray sheep eating his crops, then SHOT one. He said he believed the law entitled him to kill trespassing animals. Held: CROWN APPEAL ALLOWED; the acquittal was overturned. 'Malicious' does not require SPITE. It means deliberate or reckless disregard of another's property rights. His belief was a MISTAKE OF LAW, which is no defence (unlike a mistake of fact, such as thinking the sheep were his own).

37
New cards

CASE: Byrne v HM Advocate 2000 JC 155

Issue: What are the fire-raising crimes and their mens rea? Facts: The accused was charged with WILFUL fire-raising. Added: a fire he set spread to other property. Held: There are two crimes: • WILFUL fire-raising, which requires INTENTION to set fire to the particular property; and • CULPABLE AND RECKLESS fire-raising, which requires RECKLESSNESS. Intention does NOT transfer between properties, and the old 'malicious mischief by fire' approach was reject