1/137
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Why are definitions of society and culture problematic in the social sciences?
They reduce complex, changing social realities to static, simplified statements that do not give a true picture; a fully comprehensive definition would be too long to be a definition
What is meant by "dynamic" when describing society?
Having an innate tendency to change – society is constantly changing, interacting and reconfiguring
What is the common simple definition of society?
A collection of people living in the same area over time
What is the common simple definition of culture?
The ways of life of a people
What is only inferred but not stated in simple definitions of society?
That for a society to exist there must be arrangements, interactions and relationships that make social life possible
What is meant by "social construction"?
The ways people give meaning to something and then come to believe in it – e.g. the different meanings of "society" are social constructions
Give the four everyday meanings of "society" in the chapter?
(1) A group living together in a defined territorial space with continuity over time; (2) a group sharing a common purpose that structures relationships; (3) the experience of citizenship within a space; (4) an ideal a group is striving to achieve
What are the limitations of defining society as a group in a defined territorial space?
It ignores members who live elsewhere (e.g. the Caribbean diaspora), and sees society as "contained"
What are the limitations of defining society by common purpose?
It suggests consensus, harmony and order, but plural societies may have deep-seated tensions because groups have conflicting purposes
What is the limitation of defining society as citizenship within a space?
It ignores citizens who live abroad but keep their citizenship, and others who belong to the society without formal citizenship
What does it mean to see society as "an ideal"?
Society is always becoming and never fully achieved – e.g. civil society and the learning society
What is the information society?
A society where maximum use is made of information and communication technologies (ICTs), which influence and alter relationships among groups
What is the digital divide?
The gap between the "haves" (computer-literate, with access) and "have-nots" (little access or skills) in society – a widening gap, not a continuum
Who is disadvantaged by the digital divide?
The elderly, the poor, technophobes and citizens of countries with low per capita income
What is a learning society?
A society that actively promotes and enhances learning throughout life – everyone sees themselves as a learner in work, church, media, health and government
What is civil society?
A vision of society where citizens operate in and benefit from lawful and just relationships
What is an NGO?
A non-governmental organisation – any non-profit group organised on a local, national or international level
What is the "Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals" an example of?
Society used in the narrow sense of an association with a common purpose
Why is "society" called a contested concept?
There is no single agreed definition – any definition is a choice reflecting a person's social location
What is "social location"?
The group or position in society from which a person views and understands the world
How does geography view society?
As people whose ways of interacting are influenced by the place they live and who adapt to and adapt the environment (ecological perspective) – blurring society and culture
Give an example of ecological adaptation in the Caribbean?
The Dutch used land reclamation skills on the low-lying Guiana coastlands to create conditions for society to develop
How does history view society?
As located in time (a period) – a set of dynamic relationships between and within groups, with emphasis on social formation and how society changes
Why does Roman culture persist when Roman society does not?
Roman cultural forms survive in language (Latin), drama, law, government and engineering although the relationships that structured Roman society are gone
How do Marxist historians view society?
Following Marx, as progressing from feudal arrangements to capitalist exploitation of workers to revolutionary socialism
How does anthropology view society?
As the study of societies from earliest times to now, with the main interest in culture – making virtually no distinction between society and culture
How does political science view society?
As bounded by the state – a "container" for power relationships among interest groups; society is a defined territorial space or citizenship within a space
How does sociology view society?
As the study of society, focusing on social structure and social organisation, and the only discipline that tries to distinguish society from culture
What is social structure?
The organised patterns, arrangements and interactions between groups who make up the social institutions and social organisations of a society
Give examples of social institutions and social organisations?
Institutions – religion, economy, politics, education, health; Organisations – churches, the labour market, political parties
What is the functionalist view of society?
Social structure works to ensure peace, stability and consensus; norms, laws, roles, values and sanctions discourage undesirable behaviour, taught through socialisation and education (e.g. churchgoing as a Caribbean norm)
What is the Marxist view of society?
Society is dominated by one institution – the economy; structures enable the wealthy and coerce the poor, creating gross inequality, supported by socialisation and education
Contrast functionalism and Marxism?
Functionalism sees harmony and stability among institutions; Marxism sees conflict and inequality dominated by the economic base
Why does each discipline emphasise different aspects of society?
Scholars are socialised into their discipline and downplay others – e.g. political scientists stress the political system while Marxists stress the economy
Which discipline separates society from culture?
Sociology is the only discipline that seeks to differentiate between them; others conflate or fuse them
What does "sociocultural" mean?
A term recognising that society and culture are embedded in each other and cannot be separated
What composite definition of society does the chapter suggest?
A group of people who have interacted over time in a specific place, developing certain shared purposes, goals and senses of belonging that structure their relationships in dynamic ways
Why do scholarly disciplines portray themselves as societies?
They have journals, associations, conferences, shared language and norms about valid knowledge – forming a community of discourse (e.g. National Geographic Society)
What is "culture as ways of life"?
The best-known definition – the ways of worshipping, celebrating, voting, earning a living and interacting; an "omnibus" view that reduces culture to behaviour patterns
What is popular culture?
Music, visual and performing arts, literature, festivals, cuisine, poetry and designer creations promoted mainly through mass media (even foreign media)
What is mass culture?
The lifestyles and values promoted through the mass media
What is global culture?
The idea that through ICTs and globalisation people everywhere are becoming increasingly alike
What is high culture?
An elitist idea put forward by Matthew Arnold in the nineteenth century – the best thoughts and arts (classical ballet, western classical music, literature, sculpture) believed to transform society
Why is high culture ethnocentric?
It values only the cultural products of Western society, mainly the legacy of Greece, Rome and Europe
What is "culture as ordinary" and who proposed it?
Raymond Williams (1958) – culture is the process by which common meanings are accepted, debated and modified by people; it develops in every individual through experience and is symbolic, not tangible
Give a Caribbean example of culture as ordinary?
Crowding around rather than forming orderly lines for service – "first come, first served" is valued less than the ability to flout rules to get ahead
What is culture as "learned behaviour"?
Culture is learned and shared – people develop symbols (language, gestures, habits, religion) that carry shared meanings which each member must learn
Why is a word an arbitrary symbol?
A word like "house" has no real connection to a building; shared understanding gives it meaning, so communication is possible
What is enculturation?
The process through which we learn our culture – part of the wider process of socialisation
What is socialisation?
The continuing process whereby individuals learn the norms and behaviours required of them in society (through which some believe we become human)
What is cultural reproduction?
Teaching the culture to members so that shared values and norms are constantly reproduced
What is diffusion?
The spread of culture from one society to another – through migration and the mass media
Why are shared meanings "negotiated"?
Individuals can reject or alter them, so shared meanings change (e.g. if a whole class of agriculture graduates became farmers, the meaning of "farmer" would change)
What is a subculture?
A characteristic set of values and attitudes shared by a specific group within a larger group (e.g. organisational culture, drug culture, cyber culture, examinations culture)
What is the geographical view of culture?
Culture is the ways people adapt to and adapt the environment – so the location (natural environment) causes culture
How does history study culture?
As part of social organisation in a particular period (e.g. political, religious, economic life), studying how cultures change and adapt over time
How does evolutionary biology view culture?
As an adaptive mechanism – culture (mainly language) enabled early humans to survive, communicate and pass on knowledge, giving better health and survival
What is culture as an adaptive mechanism?
Culture helps people adapt to changing conditions by passing on and improving technical and other knowledge across generations
Name the two main branches of anthropology that study culture?
Social anthropology and cultural anthropology
What is material culture?
The objects a group produces – clothing, art, architecture, fashion, technology and utensils (e.g. artefacts that differentiate Ostionoid and Barrancoid peoples)
What is non-material (symbolic) culture?
The ideas, beliefs, values, assumptions and behaviours of a people, including language and forms of interaction – the group's meaning systems
Distinguish ideal culture from real culture?
Ideal culture – the ideal values and norms of a society; real culture – the actual behaviours, which may fall short of the ideals (e.g. valuing democracy while some groups remain unrepresented)
What is Clifford Geertz's view of culture?
Culture is the interpretation of meaning systems – the signs and symbols we learn, share and adapt in everyday life, and we exist within "webs of significance" that we help to spin
What are "webs of significance"?
Geertz's idea that a person lives within layers of meaning which he or she has helped to create and which are significant to him or her
What is a belief?
Deep faith and trust in something with utter conviction that it is certain (e.g. high marks show one is bright; Sunday churchgoing shows a family is good)
What are values?
How qualities, acts or behaviours are ranked or judged by people sharing a culture (e.g. theft is judged negatively; punctuality is rewarded)
Why are beliefs and values at the heart of culture?
They confer meaning on acts and behaviours and let people interpret one another; they encourage a society to adapt, change or stand still
Give an example of Caribbean beliefs and values about hospitality?
Showing hospitality to friends, neighbours and relatives, rooted in values of family, friendship, an ethic of helping and enjoyment of oral communication and humour – though visiting is declining with urban life and foreign influences
How does sociology view culture?
As a social phenomenon influenced by social location – culture reflects social structure (e.g. the rich experience a different culture from the poor)
What are the three aspects of the sociological view of culture?
Reducing complexity (e.g. "ways of life", "high culture", "culture of poverty"), social constructions that reflect social structure, and multiple perspectives
What is the "culture of poverty"?
A social construction describing the culture of the poor, shaped by those who emphasise social distinction
What does "culture is ineffable" mean?
Culture is indescribable and elusive – we never fully grasp it because we are embedded in it
What is a gendered society?
A society that uses the biological division between men and women as the basis for social roles
What is a patriarchal society?
One where men are dominant – "rule by the father", with descent and inheritance reckoned in the male line
What were traditional Caribbean gender roles?
Men as breadwinners and heads of household; women caring for children and home – though women have always earned money and many head households
Why are Caribbean societies called matrifocal?
The focus of the family is on the matriarch or senior woman
What is feminism and when did it emerge?
A movement from the 1960s that contests patriarchy and seeks more opportunities for women in careers and life choices
Name feminist perspectives in sociology?
Radical, liberal, Marxist and black feminism
What do feminists say about society and culture?
Both undervalue women's contributions, and traditional femininity and masculinity constrain men and women (e.g. men feel unmasculine in childrearing or homemaking roles)
What is the glass ceiling?
An invisible barrier that prevents women from rising above a certain level in an organisation
What do feminists call for to help working women?
Better childcare provision and maternity leave
What did V.S. Naipaul say about Caribbean society?
That Trinidad has "no society" – people are transients who have created nothing of value and always hanker after what others have (The Loss of El Dorado, The Mimic Men)
What did Derek Walcott say about Caribbean society?
It is a creative society, uniquely so – nothing is like what Caribbean people will and can create
What did Edward Kamau Brathwaite say about Caribbean society?
It is a creole society – different groups came from elsewhere, met, mixed, developed and transformed their original ways of interacting
What did R.T. Smith say about Caribbean society?
It is a plural society – different ethnic groups met but led separate lives under an ethic of toleration
What did George Beckford say about Caribbean society?
It is a plantation society – highly stratified, with elites resisting social mobility, groups of similar ethnicity, wealth and education intermarrying, a legacy of colonial structure (a Marxist-like view)
How does Beckford see culture?
As mirroring social structure – the culture of elites differs from that of lower socioeconomic groups, reflecting beliefs and values at each level
What beliefs do lower socioeconomic groups hold about mobility?
That social mobility is necessary for a better life – parents work hard for their children's standard of living, stemming from ancestors' menial colonial positions
What beliefs do wealthier classes hold?
Strategies to consolidate their position and exclude others, with marriage and hiring linked to caste and class
What are limitations of the "plural society" and "no society" views?
They underemphasise dynamism and change
What did Rex Nettleford argue about Caribbean identity (document study)?
Identity goes beyond calypso, reggae and dreadlocks (exoticism for outsiders) to self-determination, sovereignty and independence; popular cultural expression, creolisation and history, geography and colonisation shape it
What is cultural sensitivity?
The ability to understand our own and others' cultures by recognising our views are partial, withholding judgement and acknowledging social location
What does "understand our understandings" mean?
Acknowledging how partial and incomplete our views of culture are because we are deeply embedded in it
Why does cultural insensitivity close down communication?
Groups treat their own beliefs as universal and superior, so what others say is screened through those beliefs and no one can hear each other
Why do anthropologists find it harder to observe a culture the longer they stay?
As they become comfortable they find it difficult to make insightful observations about it
Why is "society" and "culture" separation only useful as a study strategy?
In real life they are embedded in each other – to study Caribbean society means to study its culture
How do you analyse "Those children only interested in wearing fancy footwear" (Table 3.1)?
It merely states a behaviour – an example of "ways of life"
What is an "insider's perspective" on culture?
Describing how someone feels and the meanings they attach to an act, referring to their webs of significance
What are norms?
Accepted standards or rules that guide how people behave in a society (e.g. queuing, greeting elders, churchgoing)
What are sanctions?
Rewards or punishments used to encourage conformity to norms – positive (praise, rewards) or negative (disapproval, fines, imprisonment)