1/171
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is a constitution?
A body of fundamental principles or established precedents according to which a state or other organisation is acknowledged to be governed.
What type of constitution does the UK have?
Unwritten - there is no single authoritative document however the UK constitution is written down in various places.
Flexible - no lengthy process to alter the UK constitution although may be challenging from a political perspective. Written constitutions are rigid and have strict procedures to amend.
Unitary - the legislative powers are the central organs of the state. In a federal state primary legislative power is divided between national and regional authorities.
Monarchical - monarch is the head of state. In a republican the president is head of state.
Informal separation of powers - a state with formal separation has clear distinctions between the executive, legislative and judiciary. There is a high degree of overlap of personnel in the UK
Name the three core principles of the UK constitution
1. the Rule of Law
2. Parliamentary Supremacy
3. Separation of Powers
Name the four principle sources of the UK constitution
1. Statute (acts of parliament)
2. Case law
3. the royal prerogative
4. constitutional conventions
Describe some key acts of parliament that make up the UK constitution
The Magna Carta 1215 - first time powers of the monarch were limited
Bill of Rights 1689 - Removed power of Monarch to suspend acts of parliament
Acts of Union 1706 -7 - united England and Scotland under single Parliament
Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949 - altered relationship between Lords and Commons
PACE 1984 - deals with civil liberties
Human Rights Act 1998 - incorporate ECHR into domestic law.
Acts of devolution - devolved power to wales NI and Scotland
Constitutional Reform Act 2005 - removed lord chancellor as head of judiciary and created Supreme Court
EU Withdrawal Act 2018 and EU withdrawal act 2020 - dealt with withdrawal and supremacy of EU law.
How does primary legislation interact with judicial decisions?
The government can introduce any primary legislation including legislation which will effectively overturn judgements of the court. This can also operate retrospectivly.
Describe some key examples of case law which make up the UK constitution
Residual freedom
Actions of the state must have legal authority
Legal disputes should be resolved by the judiciary
Habeas corpus and individual liberty
Right to a fair hearing
What is the royal prerogative?
Residue of discretionary / arbitrary authority which at any given time is legally left in the hands of the Crown
Every act the executive can do without authority of an Act is done by prerogative.
Derive from common law and exercised by or in the name of the Monarch (often by the Government on the Monarch's behalf).
Give some examples of prerogative powers
Foreign affairs
- declarations of war
- making treaties
- recognising foreign states
Domestic affairs
- summoning parliament
appointment and dismissal of PM
- giving of Royal Assent to bills
- defence of the realm
- granting public honours
- setting up of public bodies to disburse funds made available by Parliament
Where there is conflict between Statute and the Royal Prerogative, which prevails?
Statute.
How does the royal prerogative interact with statute?
Acts of parliament can remove prerogative powers but not add to them.
Define constitutional conventions
Non-legal source of the constitution recognised but not enforced by the courts.
Rules of constitutional behaviour which are considered to be binding on those who operate the constitution which are not enforced by the courts.
Describe some important constitutional conventions
The monarch plays no active role in matters of government.
The monarch will never withhold royal assent to a bill passed by the houses of commons and lords
Individual ministerial responsibility - ministers are responsible for the running of their departments and their personal conduct.
Collective ministerial responsibility - the cabinet is collectively responsible to Parliament and must maintain the confidence iof the commons. Cabinet must be united in public support of government policy. Cabinet discussions must be kept secret.
Unelected HoL will not reject manifesto legislation.
The Sewel convention re Scottish legislation.
Why have constitutional conventions developed?
To limit the powers of the Monarch.
To limit the powers of unelected Lords.
To maintain the Separation of powers.
How do the courts respond to constitutional conventions?
Non-legal so non-enforcable.
The courts will recognise conventions but will not refuse to apply legislation that is incompatible with a convention.
What is Parliament? Describe its main functions.
Parliament is made up of:
1. House of Commons
2. House of Lords
3. Monarch
Key functions include
- scrutinising the work of the Government
- passing legislation
- approving funding necessary for the Government to carry out duties and legislative proposals
- providing personnel for Government
Describe the legislative process
First reading - purely formal, the bill is read out.
Second reading - main debate in HoC
Committee stage - 16-50 committee members in a proportional representation to the division of parliament discuss the bill. The bill is debated and amended.
Third reading - bill as amended is considered. Final chance to vote on the bill.
Proceedings in the HoL - don't start until after third reading in the commons. Procedure is similar to the above. After the third reading if the Lords have made amendments the bill must be passed back to the commons.
Royal Assent - then the bill becomes law.
What is a public bill?
Alter the general law affecting the public as a whole.
Government bills - submitted to Parliament as part of Government's legislative programme.
Private members' bills - introduced by MPs, or Lords who are not ministers.
Besides financial measure bills, bills can be introduced in either house first.
What is a private bill?
Bills relating to matters of individual, corporate or local interest.
What are hybrid bills
Mix the characteristics of public and private bills. The changes to the law proposed by a hybrid bill would affect the general public but would also have a more significant impact on specific individuals or groups.
e.g. laws created for the HS2 project
What is the Salisbury Convention?
The House of Lords will not reject any measure that was in a winning party's manifesto.
What was the impact of the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949?
The bills ensure the will of the Commons prevails.
term-20
A money bill passed by the commons can be presented for Royal Assent one month after being sent to the Lords and can become law without Lords' consent.
For other public bills rejected by the lords in two successive sessions can be sent for Assent if one year has passed between the second reading in the commons and the first session
What is delegated legislation?
Acts of parliament can give ministers power to make delegated legislation.
HoL or HoC cannot amend delegated legislation however it can be scrutinised by the following methods:
Affirmative resolution procedure - instrument cannot come into effect unless one of the houses passes a resolution approving the legislation.
Negative resolution procedure - Government is required to 'annul' the instrument.
What are the key aspects of Parliamentary Supremacy
1. Parliament is the supreme law making body.
2. No Parliament can be bound by a predecessor or may bind a successor.
3. No one can challenge the validity of an act of Parliament.
What is the Enrolled Act rule?
The courts have rejected challenges to Acts of Parliament based on alleged irregularities in the procedure by way Parliament passed the legislation.
Courts will not question the validity of an Act or hold the Act void.
What does the unlimited legislative competence of Parliament mean?
There are no limits to Parliament's legislative power.
Statute may override international law.
Statute may override constitutional conventions.
Statute may alter the constitution.
Statute may operate retrospectively - Burmah Oil Co.
Statute may abolish or curtail aspects of the RP.
Describe the doctrine of express repeal
If a later Parliament expressly repeals the contents of an act made by an earlier Parliament then the earlier act will no longer be valid.
The new act does't need to state that it repeals the name of the statute but if it expressly repeals the content of the statute then it will be repealed.
Describe the doctrine of implied repeal
Ellen Street - the provisions of an earlier act which is 'so far as inconsistent with the new act shall cease to have or shall not have effect'
Parliament cannot bind itself as to the form of subsequent legislation as a later act with conflicting content will impliedly repeal the provisions of an earlier act.
Implied repeal does not apply to constitutional statutes.
Describe some of the Domestic limits on Parliamentary Supremacy
Acts of Union / Devolution
- Parliament cannot legislate on devolved matters.
- Scottish Government may not be abolished unless voted for in a referendum.
- Acts of independence - parliament could overturn these but due to political pressure this is unlikely.
- Limits on the doctrine of implied repeal - it has been suggested implied repeal will not work for constitutional statutes. For one to be repealed there must be 'express words' or 'words so specific'
What is the Sewel Convention?
Westminster Parliament shall not legislate on areas of devolved power unless they are given permission to do so by the devolved assemblies.
What is the test for a constitutional statute
1. The statute must condition the legal relationship between the citizen and the state in some general overarching manner.
2. The statute must change the scope of fundamental constitutional rights.
What is the entrenchment theory / manner and form debate
Express and implied repeal prevent Parliament from binding future Parliaments on the content of legislation, can this apply to the procedure used to pass future legislation?
Can Parliament be bound as to the procedure used to pass legislation.
Discuss some arguments in favour of the manner and form theory.
The Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949 made it easier to legislate so no reason they could not make it harder.
An act could be entrenched.
Rules for identifying an Act of Parliament come from the common law. Statute overrides common law.
Discuss some arguments in against of the manner and form theory.
The Trethowan case is persuasive only and covers NSW not UK law.
Some argue that the meaning of Parliament was fixed following constitutional restructuring after the bill of rights.
What are Henry VIII powers?
Powers permitting the relevant government minister to amend or even repeal statute by delegated legislation.
Derive from the RP
Describe some European Limitations on Parliamentary Supremacy.
Supremacy of EU law
- during the UK's membership of the EU the UK was required to give supremacy to EU law.
- the withdrawal agreement is supreme to UK legislation. The Act recognises that Parliament is sovereign but this sovereignty exists notwithstanding anything in the act giving direct effect to the withdrawal agreement.
Describe the types of EU legislation
Regulations - directly applicable and automatically binding in all member states without the need for any further legislation in the member states.
(directly applicable means they apply directly to individuals in member states)
Directives - set out objectives to be achieved and oblige member states to pass domestic legislation to implement the objectives.
Decisions - directly binding in the same way as regulations but only on those who they address (specific individuals or member states).
Recommendations and Opinions - not binding
What is direct effect?
Derives from Van Gend - states that claimants can rely on EU Articles in their national court.
Vertical direct effect - EU law can be enforced against a state or state body.
Treaty articles can have horizontal direct effect and be enforced against private bodies - Defrenne.
Articles, Regulations and Decisions are capable of having horizontal and vertical direct effect.
Directives can only have vertical direct effect - they can only be enforced against the state or an emanation of the state.
The EU law must also be clear, precise and unconditional (Van Gend criteria)
For a directive to have direct effect the time frame for implementation must have passed (Ratti).
Describe some key provisions of the ECA 1972
1. directly effective rights arising under EU law should be enforceable in UK courts
2. the government can make delegated legislation to implement EU law
3. UK legislation should be construed and have effect to EU law.
4. UK courts should apply EY law in accordance with principles of the CJEU.
What is indirect effect?
Courts should read UK legislation in a way to make it compliant with EU law. Adopting a purposive approach to give rise to the meaning of the EU law via the UK law.
What happens when EU law and UK law conflict?
In some cases it might be impossible for the courts to interpret UK statute in line with EU law - as was the case in Factortame.
In Factortame an injunction was awarded to the provisions of directly effective EU law took precedent in line with s2(4) of the ECA 1972.
What is state liability?
An individual who has suffered loss due to UK law being incompatible with EU law or a state has failed to implement a directive may obtain damages - Francovich.
How has EU law been retained post Brexit?
Under the EUWA 2018 all law in force at the end of the transition period has been converted into domestic law and labelled retained EU law.
The principle of supremacy still applies to retained EU law.
UK legislation enacted after the transition period will prevail over any retained EU law.
How has the ECHR been incorporated into domestic law?
By the HRA 1998.
Supposedly a weak method of incorporation vs EU law.
Section 2 - domestic courts must take into account judgements of ECtHR they are not binding.
Section 3 - Primary and secondary legislation must be interpreted in accordance with Convention rights so far as possible to do so.
Section 4 - where legislation contradicts with the rights, courts may make a declaration of incompatibility. Does not invalidate the act.
Section 10 - when a declaration of incompatibility has been made a fast track procedure is unlocked where they government can amend the legislation.
Section 19 - ministers introducing the bill should make a statement of compatibility before the second reading. If not compatible must state this and say they wish to proceed.
How does the HRA impact Parliamentary Supremacy?
Section 3 - Courts stretch to make legislation fit in with HRA. Adopt a purposive approach which can take the UK statute beyond its original meaning and the intention of parliament.
Section 4 - Declarations of incompatibility. When one is made there is considerable pressure for Parliament to amend the legislation e.g. after the Belmarsh case
Express repeal of the HRA - nothing stopping this
What makes up Parliamentary Privilege?
1. Freedom of Speech
2. The right to control its own composition ad proceedures.
Freedom of Speech
MPs and Lords have immunity from legal proceedings and contempt of court over things said in proceedings in Parliament. Courts have interpreted the scope of this widely. Where there is a connection to proceedings in Parliament this can also extend to communication between MPs and constituents.
Control
P has sole control over its own affairs and whether any procedures have been breached.
In theory P can punish contempt by imprisonment.
What is the exclusive cognisance of Parliament?
Parliament can make its own rules as to how it conducts business. The courts will not challenge the procedure of parliament, even if it appears a bill has not been passed correctly.
What power does the Westminster Parliament have to legislate over the four devolved countries?
In theory, it can legislate in any way it likes over the whole of the UK.
UK Parliament can override the devolved legislatures.
How can the Scottish Parliament and Scottish Government be abolished?
Only if voted for by the people of Scotland in a referendum.
What is the voting age in Scotland?
16.
What voting powers are devolved to the Scottish Parliament?
All powers besides reserved powers. These are powers expressly retained by the UK government.
For example, responsibility for the constitution, foreign policy and defence are reserved powers.
What is the Sewel Convention?
A convention explaining that the UK Parliament will not normally legislate for Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland, in matters not-reserved, without the consent of the relevant legislature
The Sewel Convention is referred to in the Scotland Act 2016. Is the Sewel Convention legally enforceable?
No as s28(7) of the 1998 Act provides the creation of the Scottish Parliament does not affect the power of the UK Parliament to legislate for Scotland.
The convention is not legally enforceable.
An act is made outside of the legislative competence of a devolved nation. What is the effect of the act?
It is not valid law.
What statement must a minister introducing a bill on a devolved matter make?
Must make a statement that the provisions in the bill are within their legislative competence.
How can a bill on a devolved matter come before the Supreme Court?
Through reference by devolved or UK law officer.
Through appeal from certain higher courts.
Through reference from certain appellate courts.
What are some key elements of the rule of law?
Equality before the law.
Right to a fair hearing.
Right to liberty.
Access to justice.
Equality before the law
Legal certainty.
What are the three branches of state?
Executive
Legislative
Judiciary
Does the UK follow a strict separation of powers model?
No. There is a great deal of overlap between the members of each branch.
Which members of the executive are limited by statute on being members of the legislature?
Police officers, civil servants and members of the police.
How many government ministers can sit in the House of Commons?
95
What is the convention of individual ministerial responsibility?
Ministers are responsible to Parliament for both the running and proper administration of their respective departments and personal conduct.
What is the convention of collective ministerial responsibility?
The cabinet is collectively responsible to Parliament and the government must retain the confidence of HoC.
Minister must resign if they wish to speak out against government policy.
The PM can suspend the operation of the convention as DC did during run up to EU referendum.
What is the convention in relation to the deployment of troops?
That before troops were committed the Government should let the House of Commons have an opportunity to debate the matter.
But scope of this is unclear
If there is an emergency.
HoC might not be consulted - as was the case in Syria in 2018.
What is the convention in relation to ratifying treaties?
Ratification remains a prerogative power but HoC can prevent government from exercising it.
What was the effect of the constitutional reform act in relation to maintaining the separation of powers between the executive and the judiciary.
Created the role of Lord Chief Justice - not a member of the government.
Created the Judicial Appointments Committee - means judges are appointed only on merit - ensures judiciary are an independent body
Created the Supreme Court to replace Committee of House of Lords.
Where does the executive derive its power from?
Statute and the Royal Prerogative.
How does the court asses the extent of the royal prerogative?
Through Judicial review.
The courts are only examining the legality of a decision NOT its merits.
The court can only decide on the extent of the royal prerogative, not how the powers are exercised/
Which prerogative powers are non-justicable?
Making international treaties.
Control of armed forces
Defence of the realm.
Dissolution of Parliament
Prerogative of mercy.
Granting public honours.
Areas of 'high politics' such as conduct of foreign relations, national security and defence of the realm.
Where does the sub judice rule originate from?
It is a law and custom of parliament - NOT constitutional convention.
Describe some ways in which the legislature and judiciary are kept seperate?
Holders of judicial officer are prevented from being members of HoC.
MPs won't criticise judges.
Sub-judice rule - politicians don't talk about cases before the court.
MPs cannot be subject of legal sanction by courts for comments made in Parliament.
Describe some theories relating to the 'legislative function' of the judiciary.
Argument that common law is judge made.
However there is the theory of judicial restraint - judges won't develop common law in an area that Parliament intends to consider or will not legislate as it is happy with current state of the law.
What rights under the the ECHR are relevant in the context of public order law?
Article 10 - freedom of expression
Article 11 - freedom of assembly and association
These are qualified rights to can be limited if prescribed by law and necessary in a democratic society - the POA comes under this limitation.
What is a procession in relation to public order offences?
A public procession in a public place.
A procession includes a gathering of people moving through a place to demonstrate support for or opposition to views or actions of any person or body, publicise a cause or campaign or mark or commemorate an event.
A public place is any highway or other place that the public may lawfully access on payment such as football grounds and theatres (so does include privately owned places).
What is the notice requirement for a procession?
Notice must be given of the date, time and route of the proposed procession 6 clear days before the procession.
NOT permission - notice
When is notice not required for a procession?
For processions customary or commonly held in a given area, the police should be aware this is a common occurrence or for funeral processions.
What are the two offences in relation to processions?
1. Not giving required notice
2. Procession differs from what the notice specified
What are the defences in relation to the offences for processions?
If the organiser didn't know or had no reason to suspect the notice requirement / conditions hadn't been complied with.
When can conditions be imposed on processions?
1. When the officer thinks the march will result in serious public disorder, serious damage to property, serious disruption to the life of the community; or
2. The purpose of originators is to intimidate.
Intimidate means more than cause a nuisance - putting people in fear or discomfort
Who can impose conditions on the procession?
At the march - most senior officer present.
Before - chief of police
Before - must give written notice but at the procession can be oral.
What power do the police have to prohibit processions?
Police have power to apply for prohibition order if they reasonably believe the s12 powers are insufficient to prevent serious risk of public disorder.
The chief police applies to LA which makes order with Home Secretary's consent.
What offences are there under s12 POA in relation to processions
S12(4) - organising public procession and failing to comply with condition under s12(1) where person ought to have know the condition had been imposed
o Sanctions imprisonment not exceeding 51 weeks, fine not exceeding L4 on standard scale
S12(5) - taking part in public procession and failing to comply with condition imposed under s12(1) where person ought to have known the condition had been imposed
o Sanction fine not exceeding L3
S12(6) inciting participant in public procession to commit an offence under s12(5)
o Sanctions imprisonment not exceeding 51 weeks, fine not exceeding L4 on standard scale
What is the main difference between the police's powers in relation to meetings and processions?
The police have the power to ban processions but CANNOT ban meetings.
Notice is also not required for meetings.
Note there are some places which need permission such as public parks or busy public spaces - Trafalgar Square.
What is a meeting?
A group of 2 or more people who are gathered for a shared purpose in an open or partly open air space.
When can conditions be put in place over meetings?
When the most senior police officer at the scene considers intervention necessary to avoid serious public disorder or disruption to the community or the purpose is to intimidate.
Directions can also be given to one-person protests where noise may have significant impact on those in the vicinity.
What offences are there under s14 POA in relation to meetings?
S14(4) organising public assembly and failing to comply with condition
o Sanctions - imprisonment not exceeding 51 weeks or fine of level 4
S14(5) taking part in public assembly and failing to comply with condition where reasonably knew of condition
o Sanctions - level 3 fine max
S14(6) inciting participant to commit offence under s14(5)
o Sanctions - imprisonment for term not exceeding 3 months or L4 fine.
What is a trespassory assembly?
Assembly of 20 or more persons on land in the open air.
What is a common law breach of the peace?
When harm done, or likely to be done to a person or in his presence to his property or a person is in fear of being so harmed through assault, affray, riot, unlawful assembly or other disturbance.
Not a criminal offence but gives the police powers to prevent the breach.
The police do not need to wait for violence to occur before they take action.
Can the police arrest someone when they suspect breach of the peace?
Yes but conduct must be proportionate to avoid breaching convention rights.
What are the three grounds of judicial review?
1. Illegality
2. Irrationality
3. Procedural impropriety
When would a person be acting without legal authority
When they lack the authority to make a decision, they exceed statutory powers.
What is the rule against delegation?
The basic rule is that you cannot delegate your power to make decisions.
There are exceptions such as the Carltona principal - ministers can sub-delegate their work to civil servants and local government can delegate decisions to committees if there is a formal resolution to do this.
What if fettering of discretion?
Can occur in two ways:
1. acting under the dictation of another; or
2. applying a general policy in a too strict manner.
Cannot make decisions due to irrelevant objections of another.
Policy - first need to ensure the policy is made consistent with the statute then that is has not been applied too rigidly.
What is an improper purpose?
Usually comes with irrelevant consideration - public bodies may only use their powers for purposes set out in the act.
Where there is a dual purpose the decision maker must consider the 'primary purpose' if the primary purpose was lawful and the main reason the decision was made then the decision still stands.
Also consider whether the improper purpose materially influenced the decision.
What are irrelevant considerations?
Where considerations which are not relevant to the statute are incorrectly taken into account?
What is an error of law?
When the decision maker has incorrectly interpreted the statute. Errors of law are always justiciable.
What is an error of fact?
When the decision maker wrongly interprets the facts of the case.
Must be a jurisdictional error of fact to be reviewable
How is the irrationality ground applied?
Wednesbury Principle
- Lord Greene in Wednesbury Corporation, whether 'having regard to relevant considerations only, the decision-maker came to a conclusion so unreasonable that no reasonable authority could ever have come to it
CCSU v Minister for Civil Service
- "so outrageous in its defiance of logic or of accepted moral standards that no sensible person could have arrived at it" - tougher than previous
Explain the rule against bias.
Depends on whether interested is direct or indirect
Direct - decision maker in own cause, any financial interest will always be direct. The decision is disqualified.
Indirect interest - Would a fair-minded and impartial observer conclude that there had been a real possibility of bias? The presence of someone interested could be indirect bias.
What is a forfeiture case?
Where the claimant has the most to lose, being deprived of something they previously enjoyed