1/47
Looks like no tags are added yet.
power
a ability to make others do what you want with a sanction if not. can be either economic sanctions or physcial coercein.
authority
capacity to affect another’s behaviour in a intended manner though recogination of your rights to undertake some actions- both form of power and regonitiaon of poltical legimitacy.
max weber on 3 diff types of legitmate rule/authority
charasmtic- based on character, herosim, leadership and relgion.
traditional- heridtary and solidffaction of status quo.
legal rational- derived from law and bureacracy
3 diff approaches to poltics
1- old way, assume power as law dictates.
2- poltical economy/ marxist dervired theory, economy drives poltics but the neo-liberialist paradgim most important.
3- behavioural poltical science, non paritisan and ‘sciene’ approach to studying poltical behaviour- emperical evidence generates theory.
Poltics as a science- Minogue (1995)
application of sciences to politics is a “great but limited achievement of our century”
-science should lack emontial attachment.
relatvists stance on poltics as a science
no one poltical reality as world complex, so wider social structures emphaised.
logical consistency- science
theories must be falisble when tested aganist the ‘real world’ of emperical evidence e.g. class voting in the UK a thing up to the 70s but not now.
evidence must be both relevent and orgianting from a diversty of sources- quan and qual.
B.W.Hogwood and K.Gunn- concepts of poltical science
“we create ‘reality’ rather than simply observe it’
diff interpretions of same events, e.g. poltical media.
poltical science a heuristic tool- one which helps you understand the world better e.g. subway maps.
devolpmental state
strong relations between private economic insitiions and state- japan or s.korea
social democratic states
aim to tackle social and economic ineqaulties so post war consensus a example- failed devolpmental aspcet.
liberal democracies
domiant poltical state with free/fair elections and universal sufferage
illiberal democracrys
little rights protection, elections and state controlled media- russia
authoristian regimes
no elections- china
robert dahl’s view of power and defining it
“poltical analysis deals with the power, rule or authority”
indivdual gov constitons determines levels of power.
Foucault on power
overcompliacted power’s conceptualistion as it “needs to be considered as a productive network which runs though the whole social body”.
power depdent on the image of the action, and those effected.
charles wright mills (1956)- the power elite
echoed other social scienteists findings about national power- poltics was elitest at state and local level.
power elite now bankers, tech ceos- more actual poltical power than polticians.
Pluist responce to power- New haven: Dahl (1957).
-peak cold war america had no apsirations to change so worse than USSR
-scienteif approach best as the methodolgy is ‘perfectley congruent with the established methodological canons of social science’.
-behavioulst approach needed to explain how ‘things actually are’.
Schnattsneider
pluarism:
“the pluarist choir sings with a distinictley middle class accent”
class divides in politics
mobilisation of bias:
“organisation is the mobilisation of bias”
when anything is organised with the intent of mobilisng certain groups for poltical favour.
nelson polsby
poltical systems open to active groups IF they organise, but new haven is ‘fractured into … hundreds of small special intrest groups … with widely diffused power’.
neo-elitest view of power: Bachrach and Baratz
non-decision: “a choice that results in suppression or thrawting of a latent or manifest challange to values or interests of the decision makers”- still observable as reflcets the powerful’s wants.
decision: “a choice among alternative modes of action”
power is exercised when “creating or reinforcing social and poltical values and institiuional practises which limit the scope of poltical process to public consideration.”
-plusism weak as limits politcal agenda and non-issues still a issue.
Steven Lukes and the three dimensons of power
involves shaping perceptions, cogintions, and preferances w. acceptance being seen as natural and benefical.
people can act aganist objective intrests (power of media)
SO- today’s consensus understanding of modern reality are fundamental and unchallening features of reality. new media assits this as meant to be addictive.
third dimenson of politics
power charactrised by harmony as its a subtle force not linked to the actions of specif indiviuuals
thomas hobbes view of power/state
power something intinuatve- a hierarchal view.
conforrms to social contract theory as a unconstrinaed freedom life would be “solitary, poor, nasty, brutish and short”.
Hannah Arendt ‘On Violence’ (1970)'; power
power is the ‘ability to not just to act, but to act in concert’
-power is about being able to act as a group.
Clarence stone (1989) on power
‘the power struggle concerns, not control and resistence, but gaining and fusing a capacity to act- power to, not power over’
power assumed to have leaked from existing democratic institiions
Heywood (1994) on the state
its a ‘poltical association which exercises sovergin power within a defined territoral area’.
theortical approach to the state
1.idealist: hegel. there are 3 moments of social existence. family, civil society and the state.
Capitalist theories of the state- marxist
Gramsci- bourgeoeisie domiantant in language and culture of socierty. the ISA.
Marx- state can be used to manage transition between capitalism and communisum.
John Locke on the state
supports idea of social contracts and control, as suggsts “night-watchman” as to maintain domestic order.
jonathon swift on democracy
“all government without the consent of the governered is the very defention of slavery”.
democracy intergal to freedom.
Arblaster (1987) on democracy
democracy’s oppostion is “not as moribund as public rhetoric might lead us to suppose.
democracy a relatively new thing as voter suppresion has been a thing for years- N.Ireland and now.
Abraham Lincoln 1864
government of the people, by the people, and for the people is best BUT issues with who the people are, how they should rule and to what length should popular rule extend.
Jeremy Bentham on unilitrasm and democracy
populised ulitirsiaism as it would “ensure the happiness of the greatest number”, but not the protection of the minorty.
John Stuart Mill ‘On Liberty’ (1859)
democracy only way to rightfully express power is to “prevent the harm of others. His own good, either physical or moral, is not sufficent warrant”.
democracy also widens partipcation oppo and chances for citzens to be educated in gov practise.
Rousseau on representive democracy
no representives mean no democracy, leading to democratic eltiism.
very important.
Lijphart (1999)- 2 types of democracys
1- a ‘majoritian’'
exclusive and compeitive system
power concentrated in minorty
first past the post systems grants majorty of seats to parties who don’t have that much support- UK.
2- a consensus democracries
‘share, disperse and limit power’
propontial elecotal system which producses no overall majorty w. power dispersed across all parties- so coalition on common aims encouraged.
european norm.
‘inclusiveness, barganing and comprise’ attidue common extentending to group-govermental relations w. corpatist alliances less likely to join than groups and govs.
critera for democracy- Barrington Moore
‘no bourgeoisie, no democracy’. free press essential for a virbant civil society w. voluntary associations not state controlled a impertive. but bourgoies owned press means high concentrain of ownership.
elections and Duverger’s stuff
Duverger’s law: singel member district leads to 2 party systems with mechanical and pyschological effects.
Duverger’s hypothesis: Proporitnal rep leads to a multi-party system.
Class cleavage and Pulzer (1967)
‘class is the basis of British poltics, all else is embellishment and detail’.
now difference in voter’s patterns between objective and subjective class.
Leach 2009 on Ideagoly
its a coherent system of beliefs or views on poltics and society as a connected set of beliefs.
they provide a coherent pov by which we can see the world.
Freeden 2003 on ideagoly
ideagolies inform poltical actions e.g. policy and rhetoic
Gellner (1983) on nationalism
‘nationalism is primarly a principle which holds that the poltical and national unit should be cogruent’.
Rousseau on nationalism
a healthy poltical system demands national pride w. patrosim being key to this. USA needed to ‘americanise’ its citzens for instance.
Kellas 1991 on nations
its a group of people who have ‘ties of history, culture, and common ancestry’.
Guibernau (1996) on nationalism
nationlism has 4 core dimensions-
historical
poltical
terrorital
cultural
physchological
Edmund Burke (1770) on poltical parties
“a party is a body of men united for promoting by their joint endeavours”.
Kay Lawson (1988) on parties
parties connect voters and poltical systems, with a notion of accountability coming along with it.
Durverger (1954) on party orgins
Intra-parlimentary orgin:
british parliment in c18th, and est of upper middle and upper classes.
social democratic party formed by labour party offshot in 1981- with old liberals created lib dems in 1987.
extra-parlimentary orgin:
universal sufferage in c19th/20th
middle, lower, and working classes
explantions are social cleavages and insititional.
class based in UK.
cleavage theory
society divided into groups, and those social fractures are the genesis of poltical parties.