1/82
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Tort
An act or omission that gives rise to injury or harm to another, a civil wrong which for which courts impose liability (breaks down into intentional, negligent, and strict liability torts)
Palsgraf v. Long Island Railroad Co.
Cardozo created the “foreseeability” test of negligence, deciding when to cut off a chain of actions
Summers v. Tice
When a plaintiff can’t figure out which defendant was liable for harm, either or both can be liable
MacPherson v. Buick Motor Co.
Contract of privity extends to the ultimate consumer of the product
Garratt v. Dailey
An intentional act is one substantial certainty of resulted harm
United States v. Carroll Towing Co.
Applied cost-benefit analysis (hand formula), stated that cost of potential damage multiplied by probability of damage was greater than expense to take adequate precautions (B < CP)
Economic purpose of tort liability
Induce injurers and victims to internalize the costs of harm (externalities) that can occur from failing to take care
Elements present for recovery by plaintiff in torts
1) Plaintiff must have suffered harm, 2) Defendant’s act or failure to act must cause the harm, 3) Defendant’s act or failure to act must constitute a breach of duty
Negligence
When a duty of care is not executed correctly, making victim entitled to take legal action
Elements for legal action in negligence
1) Victim suffered an injury, 2) defendant owed them a duty of care, 3) defendant did not provide that duty of care, 4) lack of care was the legal cause of injury
Gross negligence
Reckless behavior that a reasonable person would not commit (often used in medical malpractice)
Contributory Negligence
A defense where the negligent injurer can escape liability by proving that the victim’s precaution fell short of the legal standard of care.
Comparative Negligence
Divides the cost of harm between the parties in proportion to the contribution of their negligence to the accident
Vicarious Negligence/Liability
When someone is indirectly responsible (e.g. a dog bite), applies to employers being liable for employee torts if they were acting within the scope of their employment
Harm
A downward shift in the victim’s utility or profit function, includes both tangible (e.g. medical bills) and intangible losses (emotional distress, “pain and suffering”)
Perfect Compensation
A sum of money sufficient to make the victim of an injury equally well off with the money and the injury as they would without the money or the injury
Liability Disparity
Same court awards different amounts of compensation to victims who suffered the same injury (economics suggest better ways to reduce disparity by more grounded intangible compensation calculations)
Cause
Defendant must have caused plaintiff’s harm, only the person who actually caused the harm is liable, use the “but-for test”and proximate cause standard
Breach of duty
Defendant breached a duty that they owed to the plaintiff, breach caused the plaintiff’s harm
Duty of reasonable care
Compares defendant’s actual care and the care that a reasonable person would have taken
Strict Liability
Proof of harm and causation is a necessary condition for liability, but proof of negligence is unnecessary
Precaution
Any behavior reducing the probability or magnitude of an accident, is cost-justified when cost of precaution is less than cost of expected harm
Bilateral/Joint Precaution
Victim and the injurer can take precaution, and efficiency requires both of them to take it
Unilateral Precaution
Only one party to an accident can take precaution against it
Liebeck v. Mcdonalds
Woman who spilled hot coffee on herself, suffered third degree burns, Mcdonalds liable for having coffee 30-40 degrees higher than regular.
The Hand Rule
1) Probability that the injurious activity will occur, 2) gravity of the resulting injury, 3) burden of adequate precautions
Errors
If the damages awarded by court fall short of perfect compensation, injurer will take deficient precaution. If the damages awarded by court exceed perfect compensation, injurer will take excessive precaution.
Administrative costs
a rule of strict liability lowers administrative costs relative to a rule of negligence by simplifying the adjudicator’s task
Rationality
A central assumption in economic theory where decision makers are rationally self-interested, but humans are generally unable to calculate the probability of things correctly
Moral Luck
Agent is assigned moral praise or blame for actions that are largely out of their control
Regulations
An ex ante enforcement by administrators, taking safety precautions to prevent accidents
Insurance
A private system of liability law that reallocates costs of accidents according to contracts between insurer and insured
Subrogation
Insurance company stands in place of the insured in the tort suit for the harm covered in the insurance claim
Bankruptcy
Potential damages to tort victims exceed the firm’s net worth, firm escapes liability
Product Liability
Product related accidents have strict products liability, where the product must be defective
Three forms of product defect
A defect in design, a defect in manufacture, a defect in warning
Incompensable Losses
Damages that cannot be tangibly calculated, courts have no formula for determining the amount of loss (e.g. wrongful death of a child), scholars have suggested using the hand formula
Punitive Damages
Damages given to the plaintiff as a way of punishing the defendant, can be awarded when the defendant’s behavior is (malicious, oppressive, gross, willful and wanton, or fraudulent)
Punitive Damages in California Law
Clear and convincing standard of evidence, has no fixed cap but bears some relation to the size of economic and non-economic compensation. Medical malpractice cases are limited to 250,000 dollars in non-economic damages.
Mass tort/Class action
A large number of tort claims arise from a single incident or use of the same product, one plaintiff represents an entire class
Contingency Fee Litigation
Attorneys are only paid if they successfully resolve the litigation, such as winning at trial or obtaining a settlement from the defendants
Champerty
Third parties unrelated to a litigation provide material support to litigants in exchange for consideration contingent on the outcome of the litigation
Allocation of Trial Costs
American rule, each person pay their own legal costs, English rule, loser pays all legal costs
Administrative Costs
Sum of the costs to everyone involved in passing through the stages of a legal dispute (e.g. filing a claim, exchanging info with other party, bargaining, litigating, appealing)
Computing Value of a Legal Claim
A rational plaintiff compares the cost of the complaint and the expected value of the legal claim
Game Theory in Exchange of Information
Plaintiff expects liability and large judgment, defendant expects no liability or a small judgment, they go to trial
Discovery
Production of documents, written questions submitted, depositions, can be misused to increase litigation costs (discoveries are unique to american litigation)
Settlement
Less than five percent of cases go to trial, a settlement uses lower transaction costs to achieve the result as expected at trial
3 Kinds of Trial Costs
Fees from lawyers, delays in court, uncertainty of court resolution imposes unpredictable costs
Two Distinct Functions of Appeal Courts
Correct mistakes in decisions in lower courts, make law through common law or statutory interpretation
Renting a Judge
Parties agree to rent a retired judge, informal procedure, judge’s decision is registered with the state court and has full effect of a public court decision (Los Angeles)
Dispute Resolution Program (DRP)
Third party mediation to assist parties in resolving conflicts with specific communication and negotiation, guiding parties towards a mutually agreeable and sustainable resolution
Benefits of DRP in LA
No cost (mediators are volunteers), saves time, unbiased, confidential, voluntary
Who has the right to appeal
In a civil case, both parties can appeal to a higher court, but in a criminal case, only the defendant has the right to appeal (prosecution appealing would be double jeopardy). Appeals are based on errors in trial procedure or errors in judge’s interpretation of law.
Benefits of Advertising Legal Services
Increased visibility, branding and image building, informative, competitive advantage, targeted marketing
Cons of Advertising Legal Services
Ethical concerns, credibility issues, costly, negative feedback, client expectations, overemphasis on sales
Due Process of Law
Prohibits the government from depriving someone of their life, liberty, or property, without due process of law
Cruel and Unusual Punishment
Punishment that fails to meet social decency standards or is grossly disproportionate to the crime committed
Economic Theory of Crimes
Law should minimize sum of the costs of crime and its prevention, yielding the optimal amount of crime
Social Costs of Crime
The sum of the cost of the harm from the crime and the cost of its prevention
Utilitarian thought of crime
An act should be treated as a crime and punished if soing so reduces social costs
Retributivism
Criminal law and policy should do what is morally right, regardless of whether doing so minimizes social costs
Intent in crime
The explicit and conscious desire to commit a dangerous or illegal act
Knowledge in crime
If a person is aware that his or her actions will have certain results but does not seem to care
Recklessness in crime
The decision to commit a certain action despite knowing about associated risks
Negligence in crime
When someone fails to meet a reasonable standard of behavior for their circumstances
Public Prosecution
Plaintiff in criminal case is the government, as a crime is a harm on society/the public (no such thing as a victimless crime)
Inchoate Crimes
Attempted crimes or unsuccessful crimes don’t harm the victim, but harm society by instilling fear into the public, so it must be punished as well
Use Tax
Paying for a product in another state with a different sales tax isn’t permitted, but is especially difficult to enforce
Reasons for Criminal Punishment
Retribution, restraint, rehabilitation, deterrence
Deterrence
Requires a deliberate act to receive harsher punishment than the same act done spontaneously, and harsher punishment for a repeat offense.
First Law of Deterrence
A proposition where an increase in expected punishment causes a decrease in crimes
Imprudent Lapses
Imprudence gives unreasonably little weight to future events, causing crime. Increasing severity of punishment in cases of imprudence is not an effective deterrent, but increasing certainty and immediacy of punishment is effective.
Insanity Defense
When rationality diminishes too far, a person is insane and legally incapable of committing a crime
California Law of Insanity
Judge has to find by a preponderance of the evidence that dfendant is unfit to stand trial, using court-appointed psychiatrist
Fines
Are cheap to collect for the state and incarceration is very expensive, large fines with low probability more efficient than low fines with high probability
Criminal Corporations
Hard to establish mens rea in a corporation, due to crimes typically requiring an intent to do wrong and cause harm