Law Paper 2- Law making.

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/52

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

Vocabulary flashcards covering the components of UK Parliament, stages and evaluation of the legislative process, parliamentary influences, and the Law Commission.

53 Terms

1
New cards

House of Commons (Role in Parliament)

A body where MPs make and review laws, monitor taxation and government spending, and represent the public.

2
New cards

House of Lords (Role in Parliament)

An unelected body containing bishops and hereditary peers that makes, scrutinises, shapes, and debates laws.

3
New cards

The Crown (Role in Parliament)

The monarch whose constitutional duties include granting royal assent, appointing the Prime Minister, and opening parliamentary sessions.

4
New cards

Green Paper

A consultative paper that proposes rough ideas and sketches of bills before receiving feedback.

5
New cards

White Paper

An official document detailing a bill following feedback and scrutiny, acting as a statement of intent.

6
New cards

Private Members' Bill (PMB)

A bill introduced by individual MPs to change the law as it applies to the general population, such as the David Steel abortion act.

7
New cards

Public Bill

A bill introduced by the Government that applies to the entire country, such as the Equality Act 2010.

8
New cards

Private Bill

A bill that only affects specific companies or institutions, such as the Railway Act 1969.

9
New cards

First Reading

The initial stage of the legislative process where the bill is read out and announced to the House of Commons.

10
New cards

Second Reading

The stage in the legislative process where the bill is opened to debate.

11
New cards

Committee Stage

The legislative stage where the bill is read, changed, and scrutinised by the House of Lords.

12
New cards

Whole House (Report Stage)

The stage in the legislative process where the entire house reads the amended bill and MPs can speak and vote for changes.

13
New cards

Third Reading

The final opportunity for debates on the bill in that house, during which no amendments can be made.

14
New cards

mischief rule

type of interpretation where parliament aims to look at the main reason why the law was created + what the old law failed to adress

15
New cards

Heydon’s case

judges examine 4 main issues when dealing with mischief rule

  • previous law

  • gap in old law

  • solution

  • reason


16
New cards

Royal Assent

The final stage of the legislative process where the monarch formally agrees to make a bill into law.

17
New cards

mischief rule - smith vs hughes

soliciting from the street was illegal but women were doing it from windows - fount guilty as it called disruption to public

18
New cards

purposive approach - interpretation

what is the main purpose/aim of the law was trying to get at

19
New cards

purposive approach interpretation - jones v towerboot

an employee experienced harassment at work and the employer argued it was not part of their job -

judge argued purpose of legislation is to protect workers against discrimination so they were liable ( could have)- race relations act.

20
New cards

Legislative Process (Advantages)

Democratic because MPs are elected by the public; power is not confined in one place due to several checks; ensures thorough scrutiny through debates and examination of bills.

21
New cards

Legislative Process (Disadvantages)

Undemocratic because the House of Lords is not elected and the public has no direct say; excessive Government control in the House of Commons can make voting against bills difficult; slow and time-consuming.

22
New cards

literal rule

When words are to be taken by their literal, grammatical meaning such as


DPP vs cheeseman (Cheeseman was caught masturbating in toilets by 2 undercover policemen and under the ‘town police clauses act 1847 he was illegally causing annoyance to passengers. court found him not guilty as the policemen didnt count as passengers. word interpretatated was ‘passengers’ as policemen didnt count as passengers.

23
New cards

golden rule

when the law is bypassed to stop absurd outcomes such as -

rv allen (a man tried to get married but was already married, it wasnt allowed/didnt count as it never was legal but was still punished to avoid absurd result)( narrow, word interpretated ‘marry’ and judge got to pick meaning.

re sigdworth - a son killed his mum but had her inheritance, law was bypassed as murder couldnt be rewarded. ( broad, the word ‘issue’ was changed as it had 1 meaning to avoid absurd outcome, as she had no will her ‘issue’ would mean he gets inheritance

24
New cards

Political Parties (Influence on Parliament)

Influences legislation because manifesto commitments and party policies require new or amended laws, with the House of Commons holding significant power over what passes.

25
New cards

Media and Public Opinion (Influence on Parliament)

Draws attention to major issues requiring statutory solutions (e.g., press coverage leading to intense restrictions on dangerous dogs); can be biased or unfair, but remains very democratic.

26
New cards

Sarah's Law

Legislation introduced following the murder of an 8-year-old girl and subsequent press attention, allowing individuals to ask police about previous sex offenses if someone works with children.

27
New cards

Pressure Groups and Lobbyists

Organised groups that use campaigns and protests to pressure MPs into changing or introducing laws, providing specialist information but potentially exerting unequal influence or bias.

28
New cards

Snowdrop Campaign

A pressure group campaign formed after a shooting in 1996 that successfully pressured Parliament to tighten gun laws.

29
New cards

Law Commission

A statutory body of barristers, solicitors, and a chair established under the Law Commission Act 1965 to review and modernise the law, abolish old laws, and propose reforms via referral, research, and consultation.

30
New cards

Law Commission (Advantages and Disadvantages)

Advantages: independent from government (provides impartial recommendations) and staffed by legal experts producing well-researched proposals. Disadvantages: Parliament is not obliged to enact recommendations and legal reform can take years.

31
New cards

Homicide Act 1957 (Law Commission Example)

A statute where unclear and unhelpful wording led the Law Commission to suggest reforms to its provisions.

32
New cards

Delegated Legislation

Law created by an external individual or body using powers granted to them by Parliament rather than going through the standard parliamentary bill stages.

33
New cards

Parent Act (Enabling Act)

An Act of Parliament that grants legal authority to a minister or body to create detailed delegated laws, such as a hypothetical 'Free Buses for All Students' Act authorizing the Transport Secretary to enact regulations.

34
New cards

By-laws

Local rules introduced by local authorities or public corporations to address specific local concerns, such as Leeds council passing rules regarding bicycles, which are enforceable as offences in magistrates' courts.

35
New cards

By-laws

Local rules introduced by local authorities or public corporations to address specific local concerns, such as Leeds council passing rules regarding bicycles, which are enforceable as offences in magistrates' courts.

36
New cards

Privy Council

A formal body of advisors to the monarch, including the Cabinet and the Prime Minister, that assists the monarch in making and approving major legal decisions.

37
New cards

Orders in Council

A form of delegated legislation formally enacted by the monarch acting on the advice of the Prime Minister and the Privy Council to implement legal decisions without going through Parliament.

38
New cards

Delegated Legislation and Parliamentary Sovereignty

The constitutional debate where allowing outside bodies to make law appears to contradict parliamentary supremacy, but Parliament preserves sovereignty because it holds the exclusive power to grant, define, and revoke that authority.

39
New cards

What is delegated legislation?

A law made by a person or body given by Parliament through a parent act


40
New cards

What is a parent act?

An act of parliament which gives delegated bodies power to make laws and set limits on those powers

41
New cards

how do parliament committees scrutinise delegated legislation?

Examine statutory instruments and flag legal concerns or issues

42
New cards

What is substantive ultra vires? (judical)

When a delegated body makes laws outside their power granted by parent act

43
New cards

what is procedural ultra vires? (judical)

when a delegated body fails to follow the methods required when making a law

44
New cards

Aylesbury Mushrooms (1972) — Procedural ultra vires (juducal)

when a body failed to consult mushroom growers when introducing a law which effects them - they had to authority but missed crucial step of speaking with them.

45
New cards

what are the strengths and weaknesses of parliamentary controls?

strengths - negative resolution - can reject if they want + has limits due to parent act

weakness - cant ammend just reject or accept, some SI can become laws without check from government

46
New cards

advantages and disadvantages of delegated legislation

+saves time, allows experts input and locals needs to be met

-less democratic and risk of exceeding powers


47
New cards

advantages and disadvantages of delegated legislation



48
New cards

why is delegated legislation needed?

allows parliament to save time and experts opinions are needed and allows for quickness in emergencies

49
New cards

example of substantive ultra vires (judical)

Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants (1996) — Substantive ultra vires

Regulations removed certain asylum seekers' entitlement to benefits. The case examined whether ministers had exceeded their delegated powers by interfering with statutory right



50
New cards

pros and cons of judicial controls

cons - can be expensive and unreasonable such as wednesbury unreasonable

pros - prevents unlawful use and protects citizens - aylesbury mushrooms

51
New cards

parliamentary controls - affirmative resolution

legislation can become law without objection from parliament normally within 40 days

52
New cards

parliamentary controls - affirmative resolution

parliament must actively approve of legislation before it becomes a law

53
New cards

parliamentary controls - scrutiny by committee

joint committee on SI check legal issues to make sure its appropriate and within power