Lecture 3: Actors in digital platform ecosystems

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/24

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

25 Terms

1
New cards

What are actors in a digital platform ecosystem and what is their relationship?

  • platform owner : Value co-creation and value-capture (goal)

    • desines the platform (the core interaction)

    • capturing value

      • offering boundary resources (e.g. SDK, API) for complementors to co-create value-adding complements

      • provides value-creating services (e.g. payment functionalities, recommender systems) on the platform

      • can use customers´ data to improve the platform

    • establish governance mechanism that define rules for orchestrating interactions/ faciliating transactions between autonomous complementors and consumers in the ecosystem

    • defining openness


  • (platform = modular architecture comprising a core and a flexible periphery)

    • provided by the platform owner

    • acts as an intermediary between users and complementors

    • no actor


  • complementors (e.g. Developer)

    • co-creating complementary products or services

    • autonomously decide to join an ecosystem


  • users

    • use the products/services, (pay for it)

    • creating value by providing data and feedback


<ul><li><p><strong>platform owner : Value co-creation and value-capture (goal)</strong></p><ul><li><p>desines the platform (the core interaction)</p></li><li><p>capturing value</p><ul><li><p>offering boundary resources (e.g. SDK, API) for complementors to co-create value-adding complements</p></li><li><p>provides value-creating services (e.g. payment functionalities, recommender systems) on the platform</p></li><li><p>can use customers´ data to improve the platform</p></li></ul></li><li><p>establish governance mechanism that define rules for orchestrating interactions/ faciliating transactions between autonomous complementors and consumers in the ecosystem</p></li><li><p>defining openness</p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p><ul><li><p><strong>(platform</strong> = modular architecture comprising a core and a flexible periphery)</p><ul><li><p>provided by the platform owner</p></li><li><p>acts as an intermediary between users and complementors</p></li><li><p><strong>no actor</strong></p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p><ul><li><p><strong>complementors</strong> (e.g. Developer)</p><ul><li><p>co-creating complementary products or services</p></li><li><p>autonomously decide to join an ecosystem</p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p><ul><li><p><strong>users</strong></p><ul><li><p>use the products/services, (pay for it)</p></li><li><p>creating value by providing data and feedback</p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
2
New cards

How actors in digital platform ecosystem interact?

  • Platform/Platform Provider: enable access to platform for complementors and end-users

  • End Users: gives financial compensation (Entschädigung) to platform provider and complementors

  • Complementors:

    • gives financial compensation to platform provider and/or contribution (Beitrag) of “App”

    • gives complements to end-users


<ul><li><p><strong>Platform/Platform Provider:</strong> enable access to platform for complementors and end-users</p></li><li><p><strong>End Users: </strong>gives financial compensation (Entschädigung) to platform provider and complementors</p></li><li><p><strong>Complementors:</strong></p><ul><li><p>gives financial compensation to platform provider and/or contribution (Beitrag) of “App”</p></li><li><p>gives complements to end-users</p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
3
New cards

What strategies in the platform markets firms have to approach (annähern) platforms?

  • Build your own platform ecosystem

  • buy the platform ecosystem

  • Belong to the platform ecosystem as a partner


4
New cards

How platform owners managing partners in platform ecosystem during structural core change (e.g. from PS4 to PS5)?

  • Platform owner

    • faciliate governance for partners on the old core (e.g. Apple continues software-updates)

      • reason: otherwise partners may leave the ecosystem before the new platform is ready

    • reinforce (verstärken) governance between the partner dynamics of partners on the old and the new core

      • e.g. Apple works on old and new devices

      • instead of making partners directly switch, owner helps them work across both platforms

      • reason: smooth transition

  • Options of Partners on the old core:

    • wait & See → only changed when new core is successfull

    • embrace partners on the new core → stay on the old platform but start collaborating with the new ecosystem

    • jump to the new core → partners completely switch to the new platform

  • criteria for partners to jump:

    • Revenue, size, focus, resources & capabilities, Embeddedness in network


<ul><li><p><strong>Platform owner </strong></p><ul><li><p><u>faciliate governance</u> for partners on the old core (e.g. Apple continues software-updates)</p><ul><li><p>reason: otherwise partners may leave the ecosystem before the new platform is ready</p></li></ul></li><li><p><strong>reinforce (verstärken) governance</strong> between the partner dynamics of partners on the old and the new core</p><ul><li><p>e.g. Apple works on old and new devices </p></li><li><p>instead of making partners directly switch, owner helps them work across both platforms</p></li><li><p>reason: smooth transition</p></li></ul></li></ul></li><li><p><u>Options of Partners on the old core: </u></p><ul><li><p>wait &amp; See → only changed when new core is successfull</p></li><li><p>embrace partners on the new core → stay on the old platform but start collaborating with the new ecosystem</p></li><li><p>jump to the new core → partners completely switch to the new platform </p></li></ul></li><li><p><u>criteria for partners to jump:</u></p><ul><li><p>Revenue, size, focus, resources &amp; capabilities, Embeddedness in network</p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
5
New cards

Discribue the three platform ownership models.

  1. centralized platform ecosystems controlled by a single owner (e.g. Facebook, Apple iOs, SAP Cloud Platform)

  2. Consortia: Group of actors owns the platform (e.g. Cloud Foundry Foundation actors are Cisco, SAP, Dell,IBM…)

  • jointly define, establish, maintain governance mechanisms for the ecosystem

  • distribution of power over multiple stakeholders

  1. decentralized platform ecosystems controlled by peer-to-peer communities (e.g. Ethereum)

  • Governance mechanism through Community

  • users can directly influence the future direction of the ecosystem


6
New cards

What is the autonomy of complementors and what differences exist?

  • complementor = developer of a complementary product/Service that make the platform more valuable to users

  • describes the degree of freedom complementors have when co-creating value with the digital platform

  • High autonomy:

    • complementors are loosely coupled, flexible, independent to the platfrom

    • complementors contribute (beitragen) to the variety and number of complements

    • e.g. Android´s app developers

  • Low autonomy:

    • complementors are tightly coupled to the platform

    • complementors form strategic partnerships

    • e.g. Android´s Open Handset Alliance



→ platforms often combine high and low autonomy complementors

→ degree of autonomy affects control, scalability and flexibility

→ complementors are heterogenous across various dimension


7
New cards

What different types of platform users could be in different platform domains?

  • Software (apps, operating system) → User

  • E-Commerce → Buyer, institutional purchaser

  • Gig/Crowdwork → Client, Sourcer

  • Crowdsourcing → Sourcer

  • Sharing economy: User, Guest

  • Social Media → Content consumer

  • Social shopping → Buyer, consumer, institutional purchaser

  • Healthcare → Patient

  • Crowdfunding → Funder, Sponsor, Backer


→ End-Users are critical to platform success


8
New cards

Define Platform Complementor and show that platform complementors differ.

Platform Complementor = The developer of a complementary product/Service

  • complement = product/service make the platform more valuable to users

  • heterogenous across various dimensions

Types of complementors:

  • Organizational form: Individual vs. institutional complementors

  • Incentive of complementor: Hobby developer vs. Entrepreneur vs. employed developer

  • Scope of renumeration (Entlohnung): unpaid vs. Part-time-paid vs. Full-time paid

  • Complementor Size: large vs. small

  • Contribution to platform ecosystem:

  • Developer with small user base vs. Developer with large user base

→ complementors are heterogenous across various dimension


9
New cards

What are barriers for complementors? Why should they be reduce?

Barriers for complementors:

  • Time/Effort Barrier → How much time and effort does it take to join the platform?

  • Skill Barrier → Does participants require special kowledge?

  • Resources Barrier → Does the complementor need many resources (money, employees, equipment?

  • Investment Barrier → How much money must be invested before earning anything?

  • Access Barrier → Can complementors actually get access to the platform?


Reasons for reducing them:

  • helps to archieve greater participation from complementors → ensures that the platform´s core interaction is highly repeatable

  • platform owners must actively reduce complementor barriers

→ complementors should be able to participate in it with minimum effort


10
New cards

Explain boundary resources as the concept that helps reduce barriers for complementors.

= software tools and regulations that serve as the interface for the arm´s length relationship between the platform owner and the application developer

= tools, rules and support provided by the platform owner through the platform that help complementors build products/services for the platform

  • boundary resources ensure that complementors can co-create value-adding complements more easily





11
New cards

Give examples for technical and social boundary resources.

Technical Boundary Resources: enable complementors to develop and integrate complements

  • SDKs

  • APIs

  • Documentation

  • Software libraries

  • Seller/creator tools


Social Boundary Resources: help complementors to understand the platform and participate effectively

  • Forum/FAQ provided by platform

  • developer guidline


<p><strong>Technical Boundary Resources: enable complementors to develop and integrate complements</strong></p><ul><li><p>SDKs</p></li><li><p>APIs</p></li><li><p>Documentation</p></li><li><p>Software libraries</p></li><li><p>Seller/creator tools</p></li></ul><p></p><p><strong>Social Boundary Resources: help complementors to understand the platform and participate effectively</strong></p><ul><li><p>Forum/FAQ provided by platform</p></li><li><p>developer guidline</p></li></ul><p></p>
12
New cards

Which six forms of interaction between platform participants exists/ Which Interaction Driver for interaction of platfrom participants exists?

Interaction Driver = explain why people interact on a digital platform

  1. content: consumption of content as motivation (Content Interaction Driver)

  2. connection: participants need to have pre-existing relationships (Connection Interaction Driver)

  3. coordination: instructions (Anweisungen) to direct participants toword outcome (Coordination Interaction Driver)

  4. clout: dominant attractants (Clout Interaction Driver)

  5. competition: competitive mechanism that select one winning participant out of many (Competition Interaction Driver)

  6. culture & code: exchange based on shared culture (Culture & Code Interaction Driver)


13
New cards

What is Content Interaction Driver?

  • Participants interact through the creation and consumption of content, without any prior (vorherige) relationship requirements

  • Shared interests drive interactions (rather than participant relationships)

  • Consumers primarily explore content

  • Producers focus entirely on creating and promoting content

  • Even when consumers and producers connect, such connections revolve (drehen sich) around prior content discovery

  • AI recommendation systems make conent interaction much better

  • e.g. TikTik, Spotify, YouTube


14
New cards

What is Connection Interaction Driver?

  • Participants interact through unilateral or multilateral connections

  • e.g. Instagram


15
New cards

What is Coordination Interaction Driver?

  • Interaction arise from a set of instructed actions (eine Reihe vorgegebener Handlungen) that coordianate participants toward an outcome rather than deriving from existing relationships, influence, or shared interests

  • Interaction spaces may also be structured around the coordination of tasks and workflows

  • e.g. Wikipedia

    • structured around the coordination of different types of producers toward a common goal

    • Every user´s individual action in a coordinated workflow affects the experience and subsequent actions of every other user


16
New cards

What is Clout Interaction Driver?

  • the interaction space is structured such that certain participants

  • typically producers - drive interactions across multiple other participants because of their greater influence

  • Few producers with a high degree of influence determine the experience for a large number of consumers

  • the role of producers is critical for such platform

  • e.g. Donald Trumps´Twitter content


17
New cards

What is Competition Interaction Driver?

  • Competitive mechanisms choose one winning interaction out of several potential interactions with participants

  • Competitive mechanisms work best in scenarios where participants can compete with minimal investment or high upside (hohem Gewinnpotenzial) potential to cap the losses incurred by those who do not win (Verluste für diejenigen, die nicht gewinnen halten sich in Grenzen)

  • e.g. Amazon Marketplace, Fiverr.

  • e.g. Amazon Mechanical Turk

    • platform that makes it easier for individuals or businesses to outsource their processes and jobs to a distributed worforce who can perform these tasks virtually


18
New cards

What is Culture & Code Interaction Driver?

  • Certain interaction spaces may be structured entirely around a shared culture and code

  • The exchange of content, development of influence, coordination of work, and the creation of relationships are all subservient to the shared culture and code

  • Most interaction spaces start centered by content and shared interests, eventually giving rise to a shared culture

  • e.g. GitHub, Discord

  • e.g. Reddit is functionally organized around content and clout but is well known for their strong, insular culture


19
New cards

Explain how the relations between platform participants are multifaceted and why there can be conflicts.

  • Multifaceted = platform participants can have different kinds of relationships at the same time

    • e.g. cooperate with platform owners, competing with other complementors, compete with the platform owner itself

    • users can have changing roles

  • conflicts:

    • complementors may want lower platform fees

    • complementors compete for users

    • users may demand lower prices or more privacy

    • platform owner wants platform growth and profit

→ platform owners must govern the ecosystem and balance the interests of all participants


<ul><li><p><strong>Multifaceted</strong> = platform participants can have different kinds of relationships at the same time</p><ul><li><p>e.g. cooperate with platform owners, competing with other complementors, compete with the platform owner itself</p></li><li><p>users can have changing roles</p></li></ul></li><li><p><strong>conflicts:</strong></p><ul><li><p>complementors may want lower platform fees</p></li><li><p>complementors compete for users</p></li><li><p>users may demand lower prices or more privacy</p></li><li><p>platform owner wants platform growth and profit</p></li></ul></li></ul><p>→ platform owners must govern the ecosystem and balance the interests of all participants</p><p></p>
20
New cards

Why roles of platform actors can be “Instable”?

  • Dual roles: Multiple roles at the same time

  • Dynamic: Possible constant change of roles (Consume & contribute on social media platforms)

  • Change role: Abandon old role (Leave one role and take on another)


21
New cards

What are the difference between technology-oriented and market-oriented perspectives on platform ecosystem?

Technology-oriented Perspective:

  • Software vs. Hardware

  • Purpose: Co-creation of value, innovation

  • Innovation-Platform

Market-oriented Perspective:

  • Marketplace vs. Community

  • Purpose: Matching of supply and demand, exchange of information

  • Transaction Platform


22
New cards

What are Transaction Platforms? Give examples.

  • Intermediaries or online marketplaces

  • facilitate Exchanges of goods and services or information or interactions between different user groups

  • Creating value by enabling exchanges that would not otherwise occure without the platform as an intermediary

  • capturing value by collecting transaction fees (Transaktionsgebühren) or charging for advertising (Werbekosten)

  • market-oriented

  • Examples:

    • Facebook Social Network: Connects users, advertisers, businesses, creators to exchange information and attention

    • LinkedIn: Connects professionals, recruiters, companies for networking and job opportunities

    • WhatsApp: connects users for communication (exchange of information)

    • TripAdvisor: connects travelers with hotels, restaurants, attractions while facilitating information exchange through reviews


The more participants and functions available on a transaction platform, the more useful it becomes


23
New cards

What are Innovation Platforms? Give examples.

  • Facilitate the development of new, complementary products and services (PC, smartphone apps)

  • serve as a technological foundation upon which other firms develop complementary products or services

  • Built mostly by third-party companies

  • adding functionality or assets to the platform

  • Capturing value by directly selling or renting a product

  • technology-oriented

  • Examples:

    • Microsoft (Windows, Azure, .NET)

    • Nintendo: Switch platform enables game developers to create games

    • Apple iOS

    • Sony Playstation


The more complements there are or the higher quality they are, the more attractive the platform becomes


24
New cards

Explain why some Platform could be both: transaction platform and innovation Platform. Give examples.

  • Apple:

    • primarily innovation

    • iOS enables developers to built apps (innovation)

    • AppStore connects developer and users (transaction)

  • Tencent:

    • WeChat is a transaction platform

    • WeChat APIs is a innovation platform

  • Facebook:

    • Facebook Social Network (Transaction platform) + Facebook for Developers (Innovation Platform)

  • Microsoft:

    • Microsoft (Windows, Azure, .NET) (Innvation Platform)

    • Windows Store (Transaction Platform)


<ul><li><p>Apple:</p><ul><li><p>primarily innovation</p></li><li><p>iOS enables developers to built apps (innovation)</p></li><li><p>AppStore connects developer and users (transaction)</p></li></ul></li><li><p>Tencent:</p><ul><li><p>WeChat is a transaction platform</p></li><li><p>WeChat APIs is a innovation platform</p></li></ul></li><li><p>Facebook:</p><ul><li><p>Facebook Social Network (Transaction platform) + Facebook for Developers (Innovation Platform)</p></li></ul></li><li><p>Microsoft:</p><ul><li><p>Microsoft (Windows, Azure, .NET) (Innvation Platform)</p></li><li><p>Windows Store (Transaction Platform)</p></li></ul></li></ul><p></p>
25
New cards

What differs in the ecosystem structure for transaction and innovation platforms?

  • biggest different: who interacts with whome and for what purpose

  • Transaction platforms:

    • organize interaction between different user groups to facilitate transaction and match supply with demand

    • focus on matching and exchange

  • Innovation platforms:

    • organize interaction between the platform owner and complementors

    • platform owner provides a technological foundation, while complementors devlope complemtary products/services that increase the platform´s value

    • focus on innovation and co-creation