1/13
Looks like no tags are added yet.
what idea does he challenge
that criminal law should only protect individuals from harm and maintain public order.
devlin argues that
society has the right to enforce certain shared moral standards because a common morality is necessary for society to survive.
where mills and devlin disagree
Unlike Mill, Devlin believes that morality is not exclusively a private matter.
He argues that society depends on a shared understanding of right and wrong. If people stop agreeing on fundamental moral standards, society may eventually disintegrate.
The Wolfenden Report
examined homosexual offences and prostitution in England.
recommendations from the wolfenden report
Consensual homosexual behaviour between adults in private should no longer be a criminal offence.
There was no sufficient case for making prostitution itself illegal.
Private immorality
Behaviour that is considered immoral but is not offensive or injurious to the public.
Devlin's argument about criminal law and morality
argues that criminal law has historically been concerned with morality, not just public order. His argument is that morality has always played a role in determining what society considers acceptable.
For example:
Assault is both legally criminal and morally wrong.
Not every immoral action is a crime.
However, Devlin argues that the law does not officially approve of immoral behaviour simply because it does not punish it.
Question 1: Does society have the right to pass judgment on morality?
believes society can make collective moral judgments when society itself is affected.
Question 2: If society can judge morality, can it use criminal law to enforce it?
society has the right to protect itself from dangers, including dangers that threaten its shared morality.
Devline does not believe there are fixed theoretical limits on the state's power to legislate against immorality.
Question 3: Should society enforce morality in every situation?
he argues that:
Privacy should be protected as much as possible.
Individual freedom should not be completely surrendered to society.
Courts should balance individual rights against society's interests.
Each situation should be evaluated individually rather than through rigid rules.
The minimum vs. maximum role of criminal law
Devlin argues that criminal law is concerned with the minimum, not the maximum, standards of morality.
This means that the law should establish basic standards necessary for society, rather than force everyone to live according to the highest possible moral standards.
Important distinction: Crime is not the same as sin.
Something can be considered sinful or immoral without being criminal.
Devlin recognizes that moral standards are generally higher than the minimum requirements established by criminal law.
Devlin identifies two instruments for maintaining morality:
Teaching (doctrine): Society teaches individuals what is considered morally right and wrong.
Enforcement (law): Criminal law can be used to enforce certain moral standards.
Key takeaway
Devlin believes that shared morality is essential to society's survival, and society may use criminal law to protect that morality.
However, he also recognizes the importance of privacy and individual rights.