1/69
Looks like no tags are added yet.
what are the criteria for a person that makes them a principal in any crime that they commit?
have aided and abetted in its commission
have advised and encouraged its commission
directly commit the act constituting the offense
what does a person not have to be to be a principal in a crime?
does not have to be present, crime can be a felony or a misdemeanor
what are the four types of principals in a crime?
principles in the first degree
principles in the second degree
accessories before the fact
accessories after the fact
a person who directly commits the act constituting the offense is now guilty of being what principle?
principle in the first degree
a person who aids and abets in the crime’s commission is what?
principal in the second degree
a person that isn’t present but advised and encouraged the crime’s commission is what?
an accessory before the fact
Aiding and abetting is NOT a crime unless what?
a person had knowledge of the unlawful purpose of the perpetrator
with the intent or purpose of committing, encouraging and facilitating the commission of the crime
the person’s actions did in fact contribute to the commission of the offense by the perpetrator
a person can be found guilty of aiding and abetting ONLY if what can be shown?
that they share the same criminal intent as the perpetrator
what is an accessory to a crime?
after a felony (no misdemeanor) has been committed anyone who harbors, conceals, or aids a principal in such a felony, with the intent that said principal may avoid or escape from arrest, trial, conviction or punishment, having knowledge that said principal has committed such felon or has been charged with such felony or convicted thereof, is an accessory to such felony
what is the penalty for being an accessory to a crime?
up to 1 year in jail if a misdemeanor, up to 3 years if a felony, and you must serve 50% of the sentence
what is an accomplice?
someone who aided, promoted, encouraged, or instigated by act or advice, the commission of an offense (actus reus) with knowledge of the unlawful purpose of the person who committed the offense (mens rea)
a defendant does not have to testify against the principal defendant to be what?
an accomplice
testimony given by an accomplice alone is insufficient to prove the defendant’s guilt unless what exists?
supporting evidence (circumstantial evidence) that connects the independent to the commission of the crime is proven.
_________ from another accomplice that corroborate the 1st accomplice’s testimony is not supporting evidence
testimony
evidence of _______ must be confirmed before being admitted at trial to prevent the accomplice from transferring their responsibility for the crime
accomplice
accomplice liability is a form of what?
derivative liability - a method of deriving criminal liability based on the commission of a crime by another person
accomplice liability can be established with which 2 elements?
aiding (actus reus) and abetting (mens rea)
what is aiding?
the person actively takes part in the planning and commission of the crime
what is abetting?
the person knows of the criminal intent of the principle and intends to aid him in that purpose
knowledge of criminal intent can be proven with what type of evidence?
circumstancial evidence
accomplice liability can be established under what doctrine?
the natural and probable consequences doctrine and foreseeability doctrine
an accomplice cannot be convicted of a more severe crime that the principle actor if
tried together based on the same evidence, however they can if they are tried desperately
NO ______ of accomplices in felony murder cases
no execution
instead of foreseeability, prosecutors must now rely on evidence to show that the defendant had what?
the specific intent to aid a premeditated murder
Chiu negated the natural and probable cause doctrine to which cases?
only to first-degree murder cases
to be convicted of first degree murder as an accomplice, what must happen now (since the Chiu ruling and Senate bill 1437)
To be convicted of first-degree murder as an accomplice today, the prosecution must prove either direct aiding and abetting (with the intent to kill/premeditate) or liability under specific felony-murder rules
because of Chiu and Senate bill 1437, an aider and abettor may not be convicted of what?
1st degree premeditated murder
in California, what type of intent is required for accomplice liability?
General intent (knowingly)
in other states except california, what intent is needed to establish accomplice liability?
specific intent (purposely)
mere presence at and flee from the scene does not make one what?
an accomplice
being present at the scene but having a legal duty to do what can make someone an accomplice?
legal duty to protect the victim
______ is not conspiracy
aiding and abetting - there doesn’t need to be an agreement among the actors to commit the crime
penal code 1170 eliminated what liability under a natural and probable consequences theory
second degree murder liability
Senate Bill 1437 held what in relation to the NPC doctrine?
NPC doctrine cannot be a basis for attaching accomplice liability to attempted murder
People v. Joseph Gentile held what in relation to NPC doctrine?
NPC doctrine not applicable to 2nd degree murder
which two crimes have been severely limited by the decisions of Chiu?
murder and attempted murder
Senate bill 1437 did what?
severely restricted accomplice liability for felony murder and murder under the NPC doctrine
what is the key requirement for the NPC doctrine today?
for the jury to decide whether the unintended, more serious crime was a reasonably foreseeable outcome of the accomplice’s original plan
what are the two elements of an attempt crime?
a specific intent to commit the crime
a direct but ineffectual act done towards its commission
an attempted crime carries what sentence compared to the actual crime?
1/2 of the actual sentence
What is the sentence for attempted murder 1st degree
life with parole if it involves willfulness, premeditation, and deliberation
what is the punishment for 2nd degree attempted murder?
5, 7, or 9 years
the _____ for the commission of a crime is not criminal
preparation, under the direct and ineffectual act (However, walking into a bank with a ___ is still guilty because that goes beyond mere preparation)
an attempt to commit a crime is ____
a crime itself
what are two defenses to attempt crimes?
abandonment or renunciation
impossibility
define the abandonment / renunciation defense, what are the requirements for it?
this defense applies to all inchoate crimes
he completely and voluntarily withdrew from the crime before it was completed
not valid when the crime was too difficult to commit, he stopped in the middle to avoid apprehension, or withdrew so he could focus on a different victim
for the defense of abandonment, the person must indicate what?
indicate desire to sever relationship to illegal enterprise
what is the impossibility defense to an attempt?
a defendant has attempted to commit the crime, but unexpected circumstances have prevented the crime from occuring.
the impossibility defense only applies to what?
legal impossibility situations and not factual impossibility
what is an example of factual impossibility?
defendant tries to steal someone’s wallet, but when he puts his hand in the victim’s pocket, he finds there is no wallet
define conspiracy
an agreement entered into between two or more persons with the
specific intent to agree to commit a public offense
and with the further specific intent to commit such offense
an overt act committed in this for the purpose of accomplishing the crime
must be a mutual understanding between the parties regarding accomplishment of the unlawful objective
which part of a conspiracy is the actus reus?
the agreement between two or more persons, followed by an overt act in furtherance of the agreement (agreement need not be formal written or oral agreement)
members of the conspiracy do not need to know what?
the roles or identity of all the members, also they are not liable for the acts of other members AFTER the goal of the conspiracy is reached
the mens rea of conspiracy is what?
intent, two requirements are
a specific intent to agree to commit a criminal act
a specific intent to commit the criminal act
intent is to be distinguished from what?
mere knowledge when determining whether a person is a conspirator
one who furnished legal goods or services knowing that the recipient will use them for illegal purposes does not become a conspirator unless what?
they intend to further the unlawful purpose of the other person
for conspiracy at least two defendants must be convicted on a conspiracy charge or ____
none of them can be convicted
husband and wife can conspire between themselves without a 3rd party and no longer claim what?
immunity from prosecution for conspiracy on the basis of their marital status
what is wharton’s rule?
if an offense requires 2 persons for its commission (bribery and prostitution) and only 2 defendants are involved, they cannot be charged with conspiracy to commit the offense but they can be charged with the actual offense
conspiracy to commit a misdemeanor is what
a wobbler
what are the legal elements to solicitation?
you requested another person to commit a crime
you intent Ed the other person to commit the crime
the other person received your communication
solicitation is what ____ intent crime?
a specific intent crime: must occur with the specific intent that the crime solicited be committed
to find the defendant guilty of solicitation, how many witnesses should there be?
2 witnesses, OR 1 witness with collaborating evidence to support the claim
solicitation for someone to commit a sale or transportation of drugs is classified as what crime?
a misdemeanor crime - up to 6 months in prison
what tier offender must someone register if they solicit someone else to commit a S crime?
a tier three offender
all other crimes outlined by the penal code for solicitation crimes are classified as what type of crime?
california wobbler
What is the Williamson preemption rule?
when a specific ("special") statute and a broad ("general") statute both cover the exact same illegal conduct, prosecutors must charge the defendant under the specific statute rather than the general one
what is the exception to the Williamson preemption
The Williamson rule is based on legislative intent. If there is clear evidence that the Legislature intended for prosecutors to be able to use both statutes (for example, if the specific law explicitly says "nothing in this section prevents prosecution under any other law"), the rule does not apply.
people v. Watson states what in relation to vehicular manslaughter and murder?
the more specific statue of vehicular manslaughter does NOT preclude the application of the more general murder statute (vehicular manslaughter statute cant prevent prosecutors from charging person with general murder statute)