1/16
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Who was Lon L. Fuller and what was his main claim?
An American legal philosopher (1902–1978) who argued that law is not morally neutral — every legal system has an internal procedural morality it must respect to count as "law" at all. (The Morality of Law, 1964)
What is Fuller's "inner morality of law"?
The eight procedural principles every legal system must follow to genuinely qualify as law. Violating them systematically reduces the system to mere coercion or terror.
What is the difference between "morality of duty" and "morality of aspiration"?
Morality of duty = minimum procedural standards law must meet (Fuller's eight principles).
Morality of aspiration = lofty ideals like perfect justice that law can aim for but never fully achieve.
Duty = floor; Aspiration = ceiling.
What is legal positivism (Hart's view)?
The view that law is simply whatever the sovereign validly enacts — law is separate from morality. Evil laws are still laws; fix them through the legislature, not the courts.
What is Hart's "rule of recognition"?
The positivist test for identifying valid law — a social rule that specifies which norms count as law in a given system. If a norm meets those criteria, it is law regardless of its moral content.
Principle 1: Generality
Laws must be general rules, not one-off commands targeting specific individuals. A "law" that only punishes political enemies is not permitted.
Principle 2: Promulgation (Publicity)
Laws must be publicly announced so citizens can know them. Secret decrees or unpublished orders do not count as law.
Principle 3: Non-retroactivity
Laws cannot punish acts that were legal when committed. Example: the Nazi 1943 retroactive "Night of the Long Knives" law violated this principle.
Principle 4: Clarity
Laws must be clear and understandable. Vague phrases like "undermining the morale of the state" are too unclear to guide behavior.
Principle 5: Non-contradiction
Laws must not demand opposite things simultaneously. Conflicting statutes that cancel each other out cannot function as law.
Principle 6: Possibility of Compliance
Laws cannot demand the impossible. A law requiring citizens to do something physically impossible is not permitted. ("Ought implies can.")
Principle 7: Constancy (Stability)
Laws should not change so frequently or unpredictably that citizens cannot plan their lives. Daily rule changes by decree violate this principle.
Principle 8: Congruence
Officials must actually follow and enforce the rules as written. Judges or police who ignore statutes arbitrarily (as in Nazi arbitrary enforcement) violate this principle.
What was the Hart–Fuller debate about?
Sparked by post-WWII grudge-informer cases. Hart: Nazi laws were still valid law — punish informers via new retrospective statute. Fuller: the Nazi order violated the eight principles so badly it lost the character of law entirely.
What is the grudge-informer case?
A post-WWII German scenario where a woman reported her husband to Nazi authorities. Both Hart and Fuller agreed she should be punished — they disagreed on whether the Nazi rule counted as "law" at all.
What is Fuller's practical conclusion for judges under tyranny?
If a regime systematically violates the eight principles, citizens and judges have no moral duty of fidelity to it. It is not "bad law" — it is simply not law in the full sense.
How does Fuller relate to Edmund Burke?
Fuller cares about procedural morality inside the legal system; Burke cares about inherited wisdom in the broader political order. Both value evolved, embedded order over arbitrary power.