1/133
Looks like no tags are added yet.
CAA
Why must a party terminate an agreement & what processes must be followed?
All promises fulfilled
Parties agree to terminate
Breach of contract
One party follows process to terminate laid out in CAA
Party must give 30 days notice
All invoices to date must be paid
Architect submit invoice of work to date
Architect must hand over all work
If services are deemed completed, client may get irrevocable licence to use “the design”
Any urgent work must be completed prior to termination
CAA
How should a dispute be resolved under the CAA?
address quickly and professionally manner
Architect and client must continue other duties
Mist give written notice of dispute to other party and meet within 5 days
If no resolution - must use a mediator - if can’t agree in one, one is assigned to them
If mediation not successful then legal action may be required
CAA
What is the function of the Client Architect Agreement?
Provide a clear outline between client and architect
Defines roles and responsibilities of client and architect
Defines services to be provided and fees to be paid
Identifies budget for cost and total project cost
Includes intellectual property agreement
Identifies other consultants necessary
Describes insurances and liabilities
Outlines dispute resolution, termination and general conditions
CAA
What are some general conditions in the CAA?
all requests, approvals and notices must be in writing
Cannot transfer / novate agreement without consent
Applicable law of agreement is state / territory where site is located
Agreement supersedes prior agreements
No expressed or implied warranties that building is fit for purpose
CAA
What should you consider with regards to special conditions in the CAA?
Only alter if you have advise from legal to prepare / include a special condition
CAA
What what be considered risk areas and could be thought about early to incorporate appropriate clauses in the CAA?
Administrative work
Compliance with authorities
Assessment of alternatives
Design and documentation responsibility
Shop drawing preparation
Issuing of CAD information
Definition of practical completion
Principal contractor clauses
QS’s role
Defects handling and Defect Liability Period
Building maintenance
Height safety and WHS
Commissioning - loose furniture, signage, wall hangings, window treatments etc.
CAA
What are come clients obligations under CAA?
provide timely and accurate information to architect
Not reasonably delay the project
Only issue instructions to builder through architect
Agree on a reasonable budget with architect
May payment as required
Engage consultants as required
Allow architects to photograph / record project
Attribute the architect
Notify architect of confidential requirements
Inform architect of initial program
CAA
What are some architects obligations under the CAA?
provide services in agreement with reasonable skill and professionalism
Act as clients agent
Maintain records and keel client informed of progress
Coordinate consultants
Engage consultants if required
Advise client on changes to works and costs
Advise of any conflicts of interest
Maintain registration
Comply with code of practice
CAA
What should be considered when determining insurances in CAA?
agree to holding PI, PL and workers compensation insurance
Architects total liability to client is limited
No liability to separate or consequential loss
No liability after 3 years of service
Lower limit better for you - matching PI may strain cover
Writing $0 / NA / NIL means not capped - unlimited
CAA
What should be considered when determining the following in the CAA?
costs
Time and program
Establishing fees
Specialist consultants
Costs
determine realistic budget at outset
Ensure client understands between total project cost and cost of the works
Time and program
Set realistic programme for services and each phase at outset
Keep client informed of progress, be aware of unpredictable approvals
Fees
Ensure understanding of scope of services, negotiate scope not fees, provide hourly rates for additional unknown services, client understands monthly invoice with 10 days to pay
Specialist consultants
Who engaging extra admin fee for engaging subbies required?
CAA
Who owns the copyright and moral rights under the CAA AIA?
Copyright
architect retains copyright and grants the client an express, non-exclusive non-transferable and revocable license to use the design on the site
License may be revoked by the architect is any invoice becomes overdue
Moral rights
The architect must be attributed in all 2-3D representation of the project
CAA
What are the core architectural services?
Concept design
Design development
Planning - development application
Construction documentation
Contractor selection - tender phase
Contract administration
CAA
What are additional services?
Feasibility study
record documentation - existing buildings
Planning / DA negotiation
2D/3D visualisation / marketing drawings
Trade breakdown packages
* specific requested services can be added to schedule section of agreement
CAA
What should be remembered when completing part services?
clearly define your scope of services and ensure client understands this
Have a CAA
Don’t do services outside your scope
Commissions & Briefs
Q1. What should be included in the fee proposal?
Q2. What are some common risks to architects fees?
Q1
Intro - give understanding of project & site
List qualifications & experience
List break down of core services & deliverables & additional work
List of fees & disbursements & hourly rates
List assumptions & exclusions
Outline terms of engagement (contract)
Insurances
Q2
Initial client brief
Client inexperience - ongoing changes
Authorities
Accuracy of site information
Consults unknown to architects
Change in legislation
Weather
Commissions & Briefs
Q1. A prospective client comes to you & asks for your services and what you charge, how should you respond?
Q2. What should be discussed at this initial meeting?
Q1
Do not answer this on the spot, more information is required.
Say thank you and that you are very interested.
Ask them to set up a meeting to understand and discuss further
Ask for the site address to do some due diligence before the meeting, onsite planning controls, opportunities or constraints
Q2
The brief
The budget
The consultants
Fees basis
Authorities
Documentation
Builder negotiation
Services during construction
Client changes
Job continuity
CAA
Commissions & briefs
How do you calculate hourly charge out rates?
Reflects the total cost per hour to provide the service including salary, a factor for overheads & realistic allowance for profit
(Salary/ no. of hours per year) x overhead profit (2.5-3) + profit factor (25%)
1657.5
Commissions & Briefs
Q1. What should you always try to negotiate before lowering your fee?
Q2. What are the different ways fees can e calculated?
Q1
Reducing scope
Limiting number of design options
Using standard systems rather than designed
Require client to engage consultants
Specifying that some design activities are done by the contractor, based on performance specifications and SD’s
Q2
Percentage of cost of works - adjusted during project to account for changes
Lump sum - set from scope / brief
Hourly rates - typical for unknown scope, extra work (keep timesheets records)
Combination of above
(ALL EXCLUDING GST)
Commissions & Briefs
How are hourly charge rates included in fee calculations?
Information for establishing fees for architectural services includes:
Historical records of the cost to the practice to provide services for the type of project
Understanding the scope of services required
Realistic hourly rates for staff
Appropriate margin of profit
Appreciation of market conditions
Commissions & Briefs
How do you know what fees to set for any particular project?
Establishing fees for services includes:
historical records of the cost to provide services for the type of project
Understanding the scope of services required
Realistic hourly hates for staff
Appropriate margin for profit
Appreciation of market conditions
Commissions & Briefs
Q1. What are the roles of an architect?
Q2. Why should someone commission the services of an Architect?
Q1
To be an independent certifier, valuer & assessor of quality
Q2. Architects must obtain necessary qualifications & have completed at least 2 years experience:
Governed by Architects Act & Code of Conduct
Proficient in all elements of NSCA
Complete regular CPD’s
Public entitled to services of professional registered architects
Commissions & Briefs
Q1. Are we still liable for free work?
Q2. What are the risks?
Q1
Yes.
Advised that free work still be managed with a simple contract, used to limit certain liabilities.
Q2
Architects still under duty of care, still liable
Client may not understand value, effort, time & creativity of good design
Protect copyright & moral rights
Commissions & Briefs
Are we still liable for part services?
Yes
Pre-purchase inspections / valuations - don’t accept this obligation
Sketch & DD drawings - low risk
Does. Doc. with CA - not ideal
CA only - allow extra fees to become familiar with docs
Pro-bono - still liable, standard of care still applies
Commissions & Briefs
How would you structure your fees at the start of a project if you were engaged for full services under a traditional lump sum contract?
SK & DD - 30%
Doc - 30%
Tender - 5%
Construction & DLP - 30%
Commissions & Briefs
What should an architect do before accepting a commission from a potential client?
Assess if they have ability to undertake the commission
Check insurances are adequate for size of job
Ensure have capacity to undertake
Research the client & make sure they’re someone you want to do business with
What can be outsourced?
Can you do work profitably?
Does it align with business plan?
Are you familiar & capable of meeting scope s3vices implied. H procurement model? (Novation?)
Commissions & Briefs
Q1. What is a brief and what does it do?
Q2. What is the scope?
Q1
Brief is a written document provided by the client, outlining their requirements for the project including accomodation, cost & programme
describes facilities to be provided & activities to be performed
Identify broad policies within which these are to be achieved in respect of time, cost & quality
Brief should not propose design solutions
Q2
Scope is the physical form of the brief
Commissions & Briefs
What happens if the client hasn’t got a brief?
The architect can provide a service in controlling & documenting the brief to assist the client - return brief
This is not a core service & may attract additional fees
In CAA AIA client must provide a brief
Commissions & Briefs
Q1. What are some brief requirements?
Q2. What are some typical headings?
Q1
Aim of the project
The functions, requirements
Clients emotional requirements
Non-negotiable’s, benchmark against which design will be measured
Financial xxxxx
Size constraints
Authorities
Program / time scale
Q2
Client
Site
Project
Project Management
Commissions & Briefs
Q1. What should be considered when marketing your services?
Q2. What are the ways architects win work.
Q1
what kind of arch. want to be?
Is there a market for these services?
Understand the client & their business / motives
Create a business plan?
Understand value of your services vs cost
Q2
Mechanical
learn craft, build reputation, find good partners, focus on what you want to do, join organisations, understand client, learn the players, ask for work, follow up, get out of the office
Organic
Be likeable, be interesting, be passionate, find right cultural fit, take a risk, take a stand, right place right time
Commissions & Briefs
What is a feasibility study and it’s aim?
To determine if it is a viable project in relation to budget & can assist in setting out the brief
Typically undertaken to determine the current value / dollar worth of the project
May entail comparing different project options
Commissions & Briefs
Q1. What might be some reasons for resigning a commission?
Q2. What are some measures to ensure you get paid?
Q1
no payment fees
Refuse to pay for increased services
Refuse pay for site surveys
Refuse pay for specialist consultants
Unrealistic budget / time constraints
Bypassing of architect
Design conflict
Personality conflict & ill health
Q2
initial CAA
Take deposit
Resort to security of payment act
Ask court for order to pay you
Unconditional bank guarantees
Commissions & Briefs
Q1. Should you charge for this initial meeting?
Q2. What are some considerations when formulating a fee proposal?
Q1
No charging may establish a contract exposing yourself to risk of dispute before project has begun. Not charging establishes a sense of moral obligation on client behalf.
Q2
The proposal is in architects control until sent
It should be fair & demonstrate trust of client
Period between phone call and proposal may be significant
Should be tailored to the client
Architect should be able to explain and defend it
It should hopefully just confirm for client what already decided and discussed
Building contracts
What common issues does the ABIC major works contract provide for?
urgent instructions
Seperate party
Change of type of security given by contractor
Provision of security payments for off-site plant and materials
Provision by owner of security to contractor
Dangerous or contaminated materials
Encroachment
Quality assurance systems
Seperate contractors
Amendments to program and consequences of amendment
Alternative dispute resolution
Expert determination of disputes
Arbitration of dispute
Conract confidentiality
Building contracts
What is the difference between ABIC Simple and Major works contracts?
Simple works - suitable for projects small or simple - $3mil or less - single dwelling
Major works - suitable for more complex projects - $3 mil +
has additional provisions for issues commonly arising in large scale projects
Not appropriate for single resi - home building act says must have staged payment regime for “owner occupied” - builders will seek monthly payment as will impact on cash flow
Building Contracts
What is the definition of the following terms:
contract documents
Contract price
Official document
all are defined terms within the selected building contract in ABIC xxx
Contract docs - special conditions, conditions of contract, spec, drawings and other docs nom.
Contract price - lump sum including worms PC and provisional sums, a talk of owner supplied goods, rise and fall, statutory taxes, import duties, exchange rates, industrial awards and gst,
Official docs - notices, approvals, certification, permit, license
PC - architect deems works substantially complete and any incomplete works or defects are minor in nature and number, commissioning tests have been completed, approvals required for occupation have been obtained
Building Contracts
When is security released back to the contractor?
ABIC MW 2018
50% of security released when architect issues notice of practical completion
Cash retention - architect gives builder certificate equal to 50% of amount of security at same time as PC certificate issued
Unconditional guarantee - owner must return one of the two guarantees
Remainder released when architect issues final certificate less any sum still owing to client
Cash retention - architect issues final certificate with security amount and amount owing to client
Unconditional guarantee - certificate in favour of contractor then owner to provide unconditional guarantee draw on security to that amount and return remainder
Building Contracts
If unconditional guarantee is nominated as the preferred security, what must occur?
ABIC MW 2018
Within 10 days after contract executed, contractors must provide 2x unconditional guarantees equal in value to the nominated % in schedules
If no % nominated, 2 × 2.5% if contract price is default
Must be a type approved by the principal
If owner is a business it must be excl. GST
Building Contracts
When can the owner draw on security?
architect issues certificate in favour of owner where contractor fails to meet obligations to make relevant payments within relevant timeframes
Contractor doesn't dispute the architects certificates
Owner have complied with procedures set out within contract including giving notice when relevant
Building Contracts
What is the architects role in regards to security?
ABIC MW 2018
Under the concequences of their decisions, the risk each party bears and when security should be released
Must understand implications of various notices under contract
Building Contracts
What are the different types of contracts?
Lump sum - builder takes risk - builder takes scope and price - no more cost to client
Cost plus - risk to client - fixed % or guaranteed max price or max price - may be good for unknown scope, disputes may arise, no contingency
Schedule of rates - builder quotes on quantities
Incentive contracts - fixed price incentive with bonus or cost reimbursement - fee adjusted
Desk - build - contractor handles both - hard to project likely cost and quantity
Guaranteed maximum - builder compensated for costs incurred and naegun but there is max price failing - builder tweaks cost overruns
Building Contracts
What must the architect do when filling out contract information schedules?
Fill in all sections
Take advice on anything that is unclear
Consult client when necessary
Read the contract clauses referenced
Review special conditions
DO NOT amend the contract
If necessary to amend get legal practitioner to do so
Building Contracts
What is the general sequence of ABIC Major Works contract?
Schedules - party and project details, contract docs and special conditions, guarantees, sums
Obligations of parties prior to works
Security
Liabilitinsurance
The site
Obligations of parties throughout the works
Claims to adjust contract
Variations to works
Adjustments of provisional and prime cost sums
Adjustment of time
Completion of the works
Payment of works
Disputes, termination, misc. And definitions
Building Contracts
What is the architects role during construction?
clients agent / representative on the building site:
Issue client directions to builder
Asses whether works have been performed in accordance with the contract
Independent valuer / certifier- Legally required to be independent to:
Act as independent, suitable qualified person to certify works performed by builder
Certify claims made by the builder
Must know the building contract back to front - the client and builder will look to you
Building Contracts
How long is the statutory right to rescind the contract under an ABIC Simple Works contract and when does it start?
Cooling off period is 5 days from:
When owner received executed contract
Owner becomes aware that they are entitled to a copy of the executed contract
Building Contracts
If the owner or principal decided to exercise their rights and rescind the contract, what must take place?
must be within the rescind period
Client must provide written notice to the builder
Notice must be given directly to the builder or sent to address as per their contact details
Contractor may keep any expenses they incurred until the date they receive notice, but: Must return all other money to owner, and the owner is not liable to contractor for rescinding contract
Building Contracts
What are some considerations to contract selection?
Differing procurement models require differing contracts
Proceed cautiously in making recommendations
Significant PI insurance implications
Client's will ask - should provide informed opinion
Consult acumen or lawyer
Architect should be familiar with range of contracts
Familiarity with a contract won't overcome difficulties of selecting the wrong contract
Get advice
Building Contracts
What can inform the type of contract selected?
Since and complexity of the project
Specific needs of the project
State legislation
Impact on architects services
Building Contracts
What is the goal of the ABIC suite of contracts?
Developed by Master Builders Australia and AIA to provide a contract in plain English to balance competing rights and interests between contractors and principals, the produce a fair and workable contract, bringing certainty to dispute resolution and efficiency to deliverables.
Building Contracts
What contracts for part of the ABIC suite?
Basic works
Early works
Simple works
Major works
Building Contracts
Under the ABIC contract, who is intended to administer the contract?
The architect is intended to be the superintendent
Building Contracts
As the contract administrator, what must you alert the client of in contract selection?
It is vital that you advise your clients at least on the differences between the types of contracts and impact it will have on cost, their obligations and your administration of the contract - they MUST understand what they are agreeing to
Building Contracts
What are the consequences of getting a tender set of tender documents wrong?
Least to non-conforming tenders and less tenderers to chose from
Lead to significant financial consequences for your client
Building Contracts
What are the consequences of not acting inpartially?
Breach of duty of care to client - pay damaged to client
Building Contracts
What is the purpose of a building contract?
Legally binding document to define the relationship between parties to a building and construction project
Building Contracts
How are project types classified?
Either large or small scale depending on:
build size
Complexity
Cost
Number of build members on size
Building Contracts
What should be considered when selecting a type?
project type - size, scale complexity, level of scope of works documented, no. Of buildings on site
Contract value - large sum, require flexibility and design changes
Client considerations - experience sophistication, objectiveness and preference of contractural relationship
Building Contracts
What does Section B - documents setout?
discrepancies in documents - must provide notice to architect in writing and architect must promptly resolve
Order of precedence of docs: special conditions (Schedule 2), conditions of contract (schedule 1), specifications, drawings and other docs
Building Contracts
What is security and its purpose? When is it especially useful?
to provide financial protection to principal and contractor if the contractor fails to fulfil their obligations
When builder seeking pre-payment for goods and material
Building Contracts
How may security be provided under ABIC MW contract?
cash retention
Unconditional bank guarantee
Building Contracts
When is security held by the principal until?
the project is completed (eg. PC & FC), or
Contractor fails to comply with its obligations and the architect determines that principal can draw
Building Contracts
If parties wish for security to be provided under the contract what must they do?
Nominate they want it in schedules
Nominate which form of security
If not nominated, contractor can choose
Building Contracts
If cash retention is selected, what is the principal entitled to do?
owner may withhold up to 10% of each progress claim until value equates to nominated percentage of contract price
if no percentage is nominates, then 5% default in contract
Must be held in separate bank account as trustee for contractor including interest earned
Building Contracts
What does schedule 1 contain?
key information - party details, site info and financial details
Contract specifics - which remainder of contract is based on
Building Contracts
What are the consequences of missing schedule items?
The parties cannot retrospectively insert the terms or rely on them
Building Contracts
What does schedule 2 contain?
Special conditions
Building Contracts
What does section A contain?
‘Overview’ - provides parties with overview of how to conduct themselves. Parties must act reasonably and cooperative, and work through disputes to achieve effective project delivery
Building Contracts
What are some of the contractors obligations?
work diligently and maintain clean site
Warrants has capacity to entire contract
And is registered and licensed
Building Contracts
What are some client obligations?
Give possession of site
Appoint architect as contract administrator
Pay contractor the contract price
Warrants they have funds to pay contract price
Building Contracts
What are some of the architects obligations?
administer contract on behalf of the owner
Act as assessor, valuer and certifier
Building Contracts
What is an architects instruction?
instructions given to builder from architect at any rioting or orally if urgent
Contract Administration - Time
What are the 3 fundamental aspects of a building project?
Time
Cost
Quality
Contract Administration - Time
What 2 issues does time revolve around?
Time by which a party’s obligations under the contract are performed?
The consequences for the party if they fail to perform their obligations by the required time
Contract Administration - Time
Which party are time constraints primarily imposed on?
Builder - promising to supply goods and services within a certain time
Contract Administration - Time
What is the architect’s role in relation to time?
supervise the contractural mechanisms
Assess claims
Contract Administration - Time
If a party fails to complete their obligations on time, can the innocent party terminate the contract?
No, contract has mechanisms for dealing with late performance. Breach of other important terms may give right to terminate or sue for damages
Contract Administration - Time
What is the prevention principle?
Where principle through own actions prevented contractor from completing contract on time, principle cannot insist on timely completion.
Contract Administration - Time
Can the principle claim damages when their ‘acts of prevention’ lead to contractor not completing works by date of PC?
No, they cannot claim disputes
Contract Administration - Time
Must the contractor complete the works (in relation to the prevention principle)?
Within a reasonable time
Contract Administration - Time
What should you and the client ensure is included on the contract to combat the prevention principle?
extensions of time clause
Let lawyer know if not in contract
Contract Administration - Time
When can the security be released?
read the contract - in contract
Architects ‘ superintendents decision\
Understand conditions of release
Contract allows to be held for considerable time - refer schedules
Contract Administration - Time
How do building contracts differ on counting time and delays?
differ on counting time - know how to count days
Differ on who carries risk on delays
Contract Administration - Time
What MUST you make every effort not to do during construction?
Do not delay the contractor in achieving practical completion
Contract Administration - Time
What is Float and who ‘owns’ it?
measure of predicted free time in a program between non-critical activities not affecting finishing time
Adjustment of time in contract critical to who owns float
Contract Administration - Time
What is a unilateral extension of time?
Where the superintendent grants EoT even when contractor doesn’t apply for it.
Contract Administration - Time
Where does the superintendent / architect adjust the contract?
in a progress certificate payment, or
In a final certificate
Contract Administration - Time
Is a variation the same as an EoT under ABIC?
No, there are different processes and time frames to follow.
Contract Administration - Time
What are the key things to consider when dealing with delays?
What are the terms of the contract
Precise cause of delay and responsibility for it
Impact on program
Impact on contract price
Contract Administration - Time
Where cam you dine the meaning of a ‘day’?
in the contract- usually calendar day or business day
If ‘ day’ only stated them assumed to be calendar
Contract Administration - Time
What is the commencement date?
Date of execution of the contract or day works begin or access to site - check the contract
Contract Administration - Time
What is a construction program?
Schedule of sequence of different activities taking place at the site, designed so project can be completed in fastest time possible.
Contract Administration - Time
What is the critical path?
In a construction program, shortest sequence of planned building activities possible to achieve the date for practical completion
Contract Administration - Time
What is important when reviewing shop drawings?
review, do not check, builder checks
Review against design, use stamp
Architect should not assume responsibility for their correctness, ask if they have checked them.
Contract Administration - Time
How should you manage shop drawing process?
Ask whether fabrication commenced - may be wasting time
Get correct consultants involved
Contract Administration - Time
Are shop drawings needed?
think before specifying need for shop drawings
They require time and responsibility to review
Contract Administration - Time
What are the key principles of architect’s instructions?
know your authority
Everything in writing
Do not tell the builder how to build
Contract Administration - Time
Should the contractor do all it reasonable can to mitigate the impact of delay?
Yes, it cannot sit on hands and wait to proceed
Contract Administration - Time
What is effect of the delay event?
Impact of event on critical path, varies from contract to contract
Contract Administration - Time
What are the possible clauses associated with the effect of delay event?
Delay event causes delay in work by contractor
Delay event causes delay in achieving PC
Delay even causes delay in achieving PC by the date for PC
Contract Administration - Time
What should you check in each contract in regards to the effect of delay event?
What the clause states in regards to the effect of delay and assess whether relevant test of delay has been met
Contract Administration - Time
What must the contractor submit if they wish to claim EoT?
They must strictly comply with the procedures laid out in the contract.
AND
They must submit separate notices for both the delay event and claim for adjustment of time.