1/85
Looks like no tags are added yet.
global health
collaborative transnational research and action to promote health for all or health equity among nations and for all people
international health
created by the international health commission/rockefeller foundation
defined by
control of epidemics across borders
health needs of poor countries
health needs of indigenous populations in rich countries
still relevant today
yes it shows in how we think of foreign aids, richer countries foster help for poorer countries
donors and recipients relationship between these countries
who is in charge of international health
united nations, world health organization: established after 1945
regional (eg. european union), multi-lateral, and bi-lateral agreements
requires collaboration from member countries
pooling resources and expertise
supply data and report
compliance with international rules
some countries can act as a catalyst of change bc of how big/how much power they have
US, China
challenges in moving towards global health solidarity
challenges in moving towards global solidarity
countries want independence/soveirgnty
old framings continue to have influence
not possible to establish and enforce rules (eg the international health regulation)
why we need interdependency
elements of the natural environment: when there is a disaster it can hit across borders, important reason for countries to recognize they need to depend on each other
people/migration: COVID, disease spread because you are not able to fully stop flights around the world, flow of poeple is also opportunity, they can share knowledge across the world
production of goods and services: manufacturing spreading across the world can carry pollutions and harmful products but also foster economic growth and opportunity
fragmented global health
COVID-19 exposed key limitations of global health
no single country can solve the problem
yet there were limited collaborations
developed countries: widthdrawan financial aids, hoarding resources
developing countries: non-reporting, protectionism hinders movement of technical supplies
leadership roles of UN and WHO questioned
few things to be optimistic about
diminished role of the US as an opportunity to combat commercial interests (eg private property rights)
multipolar interests as an opportunity for many countries to step up in leadership an to create a more robust global system
progressive views about international debts as opportunities for low-income countries to invest in health policies
millenium development goals
the MDGs are 8 international development goals established in 2000, goals were for 1990-2015
eradicating extreme poverty and hunger
achieving universal primary education
promoting gender equality and empowering women
reducing child mortality rates
imrpoving maternal health
combating HIV, maleria and other diseases
ensuring environmental sustainability
developing a global partnership for development
sustainable development goals
ensure healthy lives and promote well-being for all at all ages
17 goals
MDG to SDG, what has changed
global health=health of the population
global interdependency is inevitable
global issues requite collaboration
covered more than MDG in terms of helping global issues
the double burden of disease
in low-income countries
unfinished agenda of infections, malnutrition, and reproductive health problems
together with the emerging challenges of degenerative diseases (heart diseases, cancer) and mental disorders
they have to deal with both infectous and non infectous diseases
population growth as a problem
a complex and politically charged topic on which there is no consensus
pessimistic position: population growth hinders economic growth or prohibits the rise of living standards
origin of pessimistic position
malthus legacy: High birth rates and low death rates result in rapid population growth, while low birth rates and high death rates lead to population decline
the industrial revolution: food yields increased faster than before, and population and wages could both increase
malthus was not writing for contemporary developing countries
malthusian perspective still relevant today
birth control, family planning
overpopulation concerns
optimistic position: population growth is good for development, not a problem and can even be good for development
mainstream positions are usually somewhere in the middle
family planning programs (FPP)
1960s: start of promotion of FPP in developing countries began in response to large improvements in child survival that led to rapid population growth
asia: main motive was to enhance prospects for socioeconomic development by reducing population growth, governments took the lead
latin america: initiatives were galvanized by evidence of increases in illegal unsafe abortions and efforts to remedy the situation by providing access to modern controception, spearheaded by NGOs (non-governmental org) and then later governments
policy interventions vary from country to country
public education campaigns
cheap or free access to birth control (contraception) and family planning clinics
disincentives for having more children (eg chinas infamous one child policy)
family planning effectiveness
related children health goals
neo-natal care
immunization programs
related reproductive health goals
pre-natal and maternal care
promote the use of contraception
prevent unintended pregnancies, reduce number of abortions and maternal mortality
reduces number of high-risk births for very young women and women at high parties
improve child health via quality/quantity tradeoff (eg birth spacing)
reduce transmission of HIV
unintended consequences of FPP
when families are required fewer children
sex-selective abortions
results in skewed sex-ratios
eugenics in the name of “racial improvement” and “planned breeding”
relevant debates today: screening for potential birth defects, overuse of ultrasound for sex revelation and checking for potential defects
low fertility
shift from family planning to reproductive health
1994: international conference on population and development in cairo, egypt
set agenda to focus on womens empowerment and reproductive health and rights
greater integration of services: wider range of sexual and reproductive health issues, STIs, HIV, counseling and testing, etc.
since 1994, family planning has dropped down development priorities list
some useful concepts (fertility rate)
total fertility rate (TFR): average number of children that are born to a woman over her lifetime
replacement TFR (avg number woman must have to replace her and partner) = 2.1
low fertility: TFR lower than 1.5 but higher than 1.3
lowest-low fertility: TFR at or below 1.3
persistent high fertility
fertility decline has started in most african nations, but stalled in many
in 1950: africa was 7% of global population
in 2050: it is likely to be around 22% of global pop
population pressures on human capital formation (africa)
health and education (human capital) important for social economic development
large recent increases in primary school enrollment, but still lower than other regions
to achieve universal primary schooling, extra 2.1 million teachers will be needed
not enough physicians, nurses, midwives
rapid urbanization without industrialization (africa)
dismal living conditions in urban areas
proportion of urban population using improved sanitation has been 41% since 1990
high cost of raw materials for construction
lack of skilled construction workers
confused ownership of land
lack of credit institutions
lack of investments in low-cost housing
africas urban population is projected to grow at 3.5% per year for the next 30 years
employment (africa)
wages and salaried jobs with legal contracts and job protection account for 10% of employment of african men in the formal and public sector
high rates of petty trading (informal)
pervasive underemployment
levels of education are increasing slowly
rwanda
one of the poorest and most aid-dependent countries in the world
most densely populated country in mainland africa
landlocked, lacks exportable natural resources
workforce not well-skilled or educated
1994 genocide
achieved MDG targets for health
clear goals for health and development
performance contracts keep local gov and individuals accountable
maternal death audit
health centers open 24/365
commnity health workers
community based micro health insurance
niger
some progress with health MDGs
under 5 mortality: 327 death/1000 births in 1990 to 104 in 2013
maternal mortality: 1000 maternal deaths/100 000 live births in 1990, to 630 in 2013
contraceptive prevalence still very low, access to reproductive health low
45% of countrys budget foreign aid
economy: centers on subsistence agriculture
drought, high population growth, food insecurity
political and economic constraints of very rapid population growth
difficulty providing jobs for a larger labour force
downward pressure of wages
capital widening: you have to provide a lot of infrastructure at same low level vs. capital deepening: able to invest in more advanced things but less in other things
eg greater demands on child health services, schools, training centers
national administrative overextension
population control remains a controversial topic
empirically complex
requires data and research
politicaly sensitive
tension between macro policies and individual freedom
SES gradient in health
SES=socio-economic status, or social class
term gradient is used to emphasize that there are “graded” differences in health running across ranked groups
individuals with low income, low wealth, low education, or low social status often die younger than those better off
it even applies to babies
white infants of mothers with less than 12 years of education have a mortality rate twice as high as that of white infants of mothers with a college degree (10/1000 vs 5/1000)
infants of black mothers have higher mortality rates than whites for every education level
children of black mothers with a college degree have higher mortality rates than children of white high school dropouts
poverty and health
poverty is related to
poor nutrition
lack of education and social mobility
extreme lack of resources
public health policy
economic and social policies to foster health improvements
social safety nets (welfare, universal healthcare, etc)
crucial public infrastructures (hospitals, electricity, roads, etc)
cash transfer programs with health-related conditions
create jobs, improve labor conditions (wages, stable contracts, etc)
health policies
other names: public/population health interventions
can exist at multiple levels:
global
national
state/province
city
community
can be cross-sector: non-health factor (e.g., housing, education, discrimination) affect health outcomes
health policies are important because they shaped the context of care
specific to healthcare: access to care, cost, quality, regulations, invention programs, etc.
contextual factors: economic inequality, discrimination, violence, environment, etc.
health policy components
all public health interventions can be defined in terms of
inputs: the resources (time, money, equipment, person-power) needed to implement and maintain the intervention;
activites: what the intervention provides to individuals and communities;
outputs: are the direct products resulting from the implementation of intervention activities; (number of things)
outcomes: are the benefits (for individuals, groups, and communities) arising from the implementation of population health interventions
efficacy vs. effectiveness
efficacy indicates the capacity for beneficial change of a given intervention (eg a medicine, medical device, surgical procedure, or public health intervention)
if efficacy is established, an intervention is likely to be at least as good as other available interventions (which often is the status quo) to which it will have been compared
comparisons of this type are typically made in randomized control trials
effectiveness means how well a treatment works in practice
DALYs
disability-adjusted life years: one DALY represents the loss of the equivalent of one year of full health due to specific health condition
DALYs calculation
DALY = YLL + YLD
YLL = ideal life expectancy - age at death
YLD = diability weight x disease duration
disability weight ranges from 0 (perfect health) to 1 (death) for example:
lower respiratory infection 0.05
quadripledia: 0.68
pancreatic cancer: 0.88
why use DALYs
DALY is jointly determined by
number of deaths
age at death
number of disease incidents
duration of disease
disability weight
multiple interventions possible
measure of effectiveness: cost to prevent one DALY
the equity-efficiency tradeoff
health policies and interventions must be efficient, maximizing health gains given limited resoures
the two objectives may conflict, creating problems for decision makers
explain the rich-poor disparity
lack of financial resources
limited knowledge of health matters
limited access and use of health services
environmental and community factors: rural, remote, and undeserved areas
governments tend to invest more in urban areas (hospitals, public health infrastructure, etc.)
the kuznets curve

possible solutions for inequality
pro-poor policies, especially in education, labour, and primary health care
public-private partnerships
leverage community resources
child mortality
the neonatal period (first 28 days) is the most dangerous period over 40% of deaths in children <5 years occur in this period
the leading causes of death for children under 5 include several preventable conditions such as:
lower respiratory infection (10%)
diarrhea (8.5%)
malaria (7.8%)
injury (4.7%)
measles (3.5%)
measles immunization has saved millions of childrens lives
but progress towards eliminating measles has stalled
95% vaccine coverage with two doses required to protect communities
vaccination rate in low-income countries: only 66% in 2019
maternal death and mortality
maternal death (WHO): the death of a woman while pregnant or within 42 days of termination of pregnancy, irrespective of the duration and site of the pregnancy, from any cause related to or aggravated by pregnancy, or its management, but not from accidental or incidental causes
maternal mortality ratio: number of maternal deaths per 100,000 live births
when maternal deaths happen: 45% occur within 24 hours
over 90% of maternal deaths worldwide occur in developing countries
countries with high maternal mortality also have high rates of infant mortality, reflecting poor nutrition and medical care
also lack of skilled medical care during childbirth and distance of travelling nearest clinic
lifetime risk of maternal death
accounts for the risk AND the number of pregnancies
in sub-saharan africa, the lifetime risk of maternal death is 1 in 16
for developed countries: 1 in 2800
in northern europe: 1 in 4000
UN focused on 5 factors to reduce maternal mortality
skilled attendant at birth
prenatal care
reduce early childbearing
increase contraceptive use
reduce unmet need for family planning
matlab, bangaladesh UN maternal mortality
field experiment conducted in 1977
divided matlabs population (173,000) into experimental and control areas
experimental areas:
free services and supplies of contraceptive
home visits by family-planning workers
regular health check and follow-ups
outreach to husbands, village and religious leaders
control areas: no change, similar to the rest of bangladesh
debate: where to put money to reduce maternal mortality?
are traditional birth attendants (TBAs) good for improving maternal and perinatal health?
improvements with TBAs: pre-natal care, screening of pregnant women, clean deliveries
however, trainings of TBAs cannot deal with most life-threatening complications that arise in childbirth
emergencies are effectively treated by
antibiotics
safe surgical techniques
banked blood for transfusion
prompt and adequate care
how to best improve maternal mortality
hot debates
to fund traditional birth attendants or not?
to invest in midwives or doctor training?
to invest in health centers in rural or urban area?
to invest in prenatal care and screening or services at time of delivery?
for developing countries, cannot do everything due to limited resources
HIV/AIDS
HIV is the human immunodeficiency virus
HIV is the virus that can lead to acquired immune deficiency syndrome, or AIDS
HIV is primarily spread by:
sexual intercourse
sharing needles, syringes, rinse water, or other equpment used to prepare illicit drugs for injection
being born to an infected mother, HIV can be passed from mother to child during pregnancy, birth or breast feeding
HIV/AIDS epidemics
generalized epidemics:
in sub-saharan africa, parts of asia, central america and the caribbean, HIV has become a “generalized” epidemic
an epidemic is considered “generalized” when more than one percent of the population is HIV-positive
concentrated epidemics:
in many other countries the HIV epidemic is still considered low or concentrated, confined mainly to individuals who engage in high-risk behaviours, such as men who have sex with men, people who inject drugs, prisoners, and sex workers
an epidemic is considered concentrated when less than one percent of the general population, but more than five percent of any high-risk group are HIV-positive
why is HIV/AIDS a bigger problem in SSA than other regions?
geographic region where it first came about and spread
weak health systems and health education
weaker mobilization against the disease
government denial is common in SSA
higher rates of sexually transmitted infections
number of partners
concurrency of sexual partnerships
geographic differences in male circumcision
low rates of HIV testing
availability of treatment
public health interventions (thailand)
thailands case study
multiple interventions
national AIDS program: $375 million ~ 1.9% of national health budget
treatment and care: 65%
“100 percent condom program”: started in 1991, budget est. $1.2 to $2.2 million per year
use existing staffs in STI clinics and epidemiologists
require sex workers to use condoms provide free condoms, public outreach to sex establishments (owners and workers) by the police and health officials, tracing contacts
why did it work
existing infrastructure: sex industry, STI network of clinics
cross-sector collaborations: health, police, provincials government
financial commitment from national leadership
uncertainty about HIV status: HIV testing and counseling
the unique thing about HIV as opposed to other epidemics is the length of time infected before dying, an infected person can live years without experiencing any symptom
without testing, there is uncertainty about ones own status as long as there is exposure to risk
uncertain impact: testing might encourage risk taking if they dont care about others OR reduce risk taking if they want to avoid infecting others
social determinants of health
downstream determinants: factors that are temporally and spatially close to health outcomes
upstream determinants: fundamental causes that set in motion the causal pathways for health disparity
upstream factors → downstream factors
examples of social determinants
socio-economic status; income and wealth
neighborhood conditions
working conditions
education
race and racism
urban planning as intervention
traffic exposure
air pollution
noise
social isolation
safety from crime
physical activity
prolonged sitting
unhealthy diet
low income
marginalized groups
food desserts
how to help social isolation
social network index
marriage/partnership
contact with friends and families
religious/community participation
group memberships
mechanisms through which marriage affects health and mortality
social and emotional support: responsibility for one another
pooling of economic resources: economies of scale within household
mutual health monitoring
fewer risky behaviours and encouragement of healthy habits
causal relationship
healthy marriage initiative (US department of health and human services) recieved $150 million annually 2006-2010 to spent money on projects like divorce reduction, relationship skills
health benefits of marriage were cited as rationale
fundamental concern: selection
married individuals are healthier, and also would have been healthier if they were not married
married and unmarried are incomparable because they are different and unobserved characteristics
current research: marriage and health
not all marriages are good for ones health
marital quality is important
characteristics of spouses is important
what are the most important social relationships for health
importantance of kin for health
kins are extremely important for social, physical, and economic well-being in older age
loneliness, social integration
making ends meet and building wealth
care for disabled and management of chronic illnesses
use of insitutional care
survival
demographic changes leading to changing kin availability
decrease in currently married aduls
lower marriage rates, increased cohabitation, increased divorce at older ages
fertility decline
increased childlessness
increased acceptance of one-child families → no siblings
mortality decline
child survival increases the number of children that parents have
middle age survival affects availability of parents among children, and adults children and spouses, availability of grandparents
kinship networks are changing
in canada, older adults today are more likely to lack both a spouse and biological children than in the past ($10 of 50+ in 2011)
policy relevance of kinless population
social support, connectedness, help with health
expected vs. unexpected kinlessness
development of other strong social ties
nursing home use
race/ethnic differences in kin available intersect with other inequalities
issue of “bed blockers” in places like alberta
even greater importance in places with no public support for elderly
social relationships and the obesity epidemic
proposed explanations for the obesity epidemic
societal changes that promote decline in physical activity and increase in food consumption
not related to genetics
can obesity spread within social networks as a social disease
changes in stigmatizaiton of obesity
peer pressure to adopt obesity-inducing lifestyles
social learning about obesity-related behaviours
framingham heart study
12, 067 individuals who underwent repeated measurements over a period of 32 years, all initially residing in the town of framingham, MA
offspring cohort: 5,124 children of initial members enrolled in 1971
detailed repeated data on health, obesity, and health-related behaviours
social network information from administrative notes
all first order relatives (parents, spouses, siblings, children)
at least one close friend
social network design
many network partners are also in the study
construct a population-level social network
38, 611 social ties
explanations for the clustering of obesity
homophily: individuals choose to associate with others
cofounding: individuals and their social network members may share attitudes or jointly experience unobserved events
induction: social network partners might exert social influence that affect obesity of network ties
ego
the person whose behaviour is being analyzed
alter
a person connected to the ego who may influence the behaviour of the ego
node
an object that may or may not be connected to other objects in a network (framingham heart study cohorts)
tie
a connection between two nodes that can be either one-way(directred) or two-way(bilateral) (family ties as well as marital ties are bilateral but friendship ties are directional since a subject may identify someone as a friend who does not identify that person as a friend in return)
degree of separation
the social distance between two people as measured by the smallest number of intermediaries between an ego and other members of the network. for a given ego, alters are degree 1, since they are directly connected to the ego. nodes that are connected to the alters but not to the ego are degree 2. nodes that are connected to the alters alters but not to the ego are degree 3 and so on
homophily
the tendency for people to choose relationships with people who have similar attributes
induction
the spread of a behaviour or trait from one person to another
cluster
a group of nodes, each of which is connected to at least one other node in the group
connected component
a maximal sub-network of individuals or groups (nodes) where every member is linked to every other member by at least one chain of relationships (edges), and no connections exist between this cluster and outside groups
social networks and health
christakis and fowler argue that even non-infectious health-related behaviour can spread through social networks, they argue it works through induction
examples of what else has been shown to spread through networks
substance abuse
eating disorders
health screening, doctors visits, dollowing doctors recommendations
adoption of health-related innovations (family planning)
contagious diseases
these findings have led to the development of network interventions
network interventions social media and health
increasing popularity of the internet and social media sites has given rise to commercial application that offer new approaches to using social media for improved health
can provide clients with improved services and peers can help shape healthy behaviours
web-based appointment scheduling
online coaching for smoking cessation and weight loss
support groups for grief and trauma counseling
online social support platforms to help promote compliance
communities htat encourage increased participation in diet exercise
mechanisms
new info channels
overcomes geographic and social boundaries
social media intervention examples
social media and organ donor registration: the facebook effect (2013) american journal of transplantation
context: the need for organs vastly outpaces the supply
problem: despite efforts, the number of donors has remained static while number awaiting organs has increased 10x
when polled, 95% are supportive of organ donation but only 30%-50% in any state are signed up
past campaigns: registration at DMV, school-based sign-ups
new campaign: uses facebook, users can see updates from friends
facebook allowed users to select “organ donor” to their profile, went on timeline, and links offered to appropriate states website to sign up, educational materials (may 1, 2012)
calculated number of facebook organ donor profile updates in the US may 1, 2021-may 28, 2013
counted new organ donor registrations via online and other sources
data from 43/50 US states
social network sensors for early detection of contagious outbreals (harvard flu study)
studied a flu outbreak at harvard college in 2009
followed 744 students, including both randomly chosen students and groups of friends
who will get sick first? when does the outbreak happen
health behaviours as risk factors
health risk behaviour: any activity undertaken with frequency or intensity than increases risk of disease of injury
smoking, body mass index and obesity
physical activity
alcohol consumption
smoking health risks
cardiovascular diseases: at greater risk for disease that affect heart and blood vessels (stroke and heart disease)
respiratory disease: lung disease (COPD, lung cancer, asthma)
cancer: increases risk of cancers throughout the body and other diseases in cancer patients and survivors
increased mortality: causes 1 in 5 deaths in developed countries 1 in 10 worldwide
other health risks: decreases fecundity, babys health before and after birth, can affect mens fertility (increased risk of miscarriage and birth defects; bone health; diabetes; immune function; oral health)
quitting smoking and reduced risks
cuts cardiovascular risks
1 year after quitting, risk of heart attack drops
2-5 years after quitting, risk of stroke falls too close to that of non-smokers
risks of cancers of mouth, throat, esophagus, bladder drop by half within 5 years
ten years after quitting, risk for lung cancer drops by half
body mass index and obesity
adolphe quetelet, belgian statiscian in 1835 set out to define the body measurements of an average person
his formula for BMI was BMI=weight(kg)/height(m)/2?
formula used to estimate the proportion of fat a person has based on height and weight
an advantage is its simplicity
a disadvantage is that as an indirect measure of fat, its imperfect
a more direct measure is skinfold thickness
others include measures of central adioposity (waist circumference, waist-to-hip ratio)
BMI categories
under weight( less than 18.5kg/m2)
normal (18.5-25 kg/m2)
overweight (25.0-30.0 kg/m2)
obese class 1 (30.0-35.0 kg/m2)
obses class 2 (35.0 kg/m2 and above)
obesity impacts health through multiple pathways
increased risk of
hypertension
cardiovascular disease
diabetes
certain types of cancers
disability
osteoarthritis
external causes
alcohol consumption
moderate levels assocaited with lower risk of hypertension
associated with poor mental health and stress
data on drinking comes from large surveys with data on health condition linked data to mortality records
alcohol consumption has both adverse and beneficial effects on survival
effects vary by cause of death
how do health behaviours fit into current and future epidemiological transitions
4th transition: decline of cancer mortality
imperative for life expectancy to continue to increase
role of health behaviours is important
5th transition: slowing of senscence
adopting and keeping healthy lifestyles will be important
more efficient use of technology for preventing degenerative disease
research that explores the fundamental biological mechanisms of aging
major health policy issues in canada
population aging
low fertility (prijmary cause)
increasing life expectancy
out-migration of youth (in some regions)
young adults have high migration rates no matter where they come from
for education
older canadians have higher lvels of disability than younger ones
why dpes population aging affect health care spending
they use more hospital services (for ER and acute illnesses)
an increase in the number of older people and the proportion of older people affect spending for different health sectors
keeping seniors healthy
multiple areas: primary care, prescription drugs, and geriatricians
the need for geriatritians
geriatritians: primary care physicians for older patients and can also serve as consultants to other physicians or hospitals
interdisciplinarry
addresses the complex needs of older patients
emphasizes maintaining functional independence, even in the presence of chronic illness
problem?
very few geriatricians
geographic variations
control infectious diseases
vaccinations
antibiotic resistant infections
example: vancomyn-resistant enterococci (VRE) strains of enterococci resistant to teh antibiotic vancomyn
bacteria causes urinary or bloodstream infection
most common among people in hospitals with weakened immune systems and who have been treated with antibiotics for a long time
spread person-to-person via contact with contaminated surfaces
can survive for weeks on surfaces
new outbreaks (COVID, flu, etc)
measles, why do we worry
vaccine-preventable
highherd immunity threshold required
other vaccine-preventable diseases? possible if vaccination rate continues to drop
how COVID-19 ended
virus mutation, became less deadly
vaccines developed and distributed
however
global inequality in vaccine distribution
protests against the vaccination mandates
assess cost effectiveness of new technologies
measure the relative benefits of alternative approaches to health care
important in the context of budget constraints, aging populations, and new expensive treatments
governments make deicsions about what therapies will be covered in public health plans
2010: associated press reported negative patient reactions to the price of a 93,000 dollar drug (provenge) that extends life for incurable prostate cancer for an average of 4 months
UK denied coverage of avastin, drug for colorectal cancer that increased life expectancy by 6 weeks and cost an additional $110,000 per QALY to do so
comparative effectiveness analysis (CER)
IOM definition of CER: “the generation and synthesis of evidence that compares the benefits and harms of alternative methods to prevent, diagnose, treat, and monitor a clinical condition or improve the delivery of care
differs from clinical efficacy of research
CER compares across clinically relevant alternative rather than comparisongs with the placebo
attention to real-world performacne (effectieness) rather than efficacy in highly controll experiments
can reduce inefffective (expensive) interventions by showing that some are no more effective than lower cost alternatives
can identify underused inteventions
quality adjusted life years (QALYS)
this calculation is done by looking at the additional years of life a treatment provides, weighting those years by the quality of health in each year, the quality rankings range from a value of one (perfect health) to zero for death
quality rankings are determined by looking at ability to function on 5 dimensions
mobility
pain/discomfort
self-care
anxiety/depression
carrying out normal activities like work, study, and leisure

governments increasingly examining comparative and cost effectiveness (UK germany)
united kingdom: national institute for health and clinical excellence determines which treatments are reimbursed under the NHS
does not often approve treatments which cost more than $50 000 per extra (statisical) quality-adjusted life year
germany: insurance payers set “reference prices” upper limits on payments for branded pharmaceuticals
reduce health disparities
four key dimensions of inequality
income: lower incomes associated with lower life expectancy, higher infant mortality, low birth weight, more incident of infectious and degenerative diseases
indigenous identity: indigenous peoples have shorter life span, higher death rates from many causes, higher levels of chronic and infectious diseases
geographic location: urban vs. rural
gender: women live longer than men but suffer from more chronic illness
policy for addressing health disparities
progressive tax system
income supports for families with children
support for senior citizens
protections for workers
supports for education
universial health service: canada health act
what does that mean
successful economic transitions → development?
did they overcome problems associated with low national income?
extreme poverty
lack of infrastructure
poor management, corruption
etc,.?
its a tricky category
sometimes low and middle income countries are grouped together (LMICs)
further separation
lower middle income countries
upper middle income countries
for public health considerations: how are economic development linked to improvements in health outcomes
promote healthy behaviours and mental health