1/17
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is the first question you should consider?
Which VARA claim is involved here?
What is the second question you should ask?
Which specific elements am I assigned to analyze?
What is the third question you should ask?
What are the other legal topics you aren’t supposed to write about?
What is the fourth question you should ask?
Which sources are binding and which are persuasive?
What is the fifth question you should ask?
How many examples should my TREAC contain?
Thesis
This should be concise, specific to ONE element/factor, have no citations, and no reasoning.
The plaintiff is able to prove (element) for their (claim).
Mr. Whitford likely can offer evidence that would permit a jury to find that his distribution of his late father’s medication to his mother was necessary to avoid a threat of injury to her.
Rule Statement
Only include these that are specific to the element or factor that is the subject of the TREAC.
General terms should be used in the present tense.
Order will be from most general to most specific of these.
Transition words/phrases should be used in between these sentences.
No over quoting, but quote if you can’t say it better or there is key language.
Citations for every sentence in this statement.
Example Should Contain
Topic Sentence
Holding
Legally significant facts
Court’s reasoning
Example Topic Sentence
What should the reader be learning from this?
A P can prove that D confined him if he can prove…
If two… On the other hand, a P cannot prove that he was confined if…
A plaintiff can prove that the defendant confined him if he
can prove that the defendant threatened him with physical
force if he were to leave. Cite.
Example Holding Sentence
Legally and textually significant facts are allowed here.
What did the court conclude in the case you’re referencing?
In Rice v. Fox, the court held…
Example Facts Section
Background and legally significant facts only.
Don’t overwhelm the reader with unnecessary details like dates or numbers unless they are necessary for the rule.
Example Reasoning Section
If the court explains their reasoning fully, then I can too. If they don’t, don’t fill in any gaps.
Example General Info
One or two examples. Two if there are two cases on the same element with different outcomes.
Describe facts in chronological order and in past tense.
Analysis Should Have
Topic Sentence
Signpost Sentences
Comparisons (analogies/distinctions)
Application of rules to facts
Analysis Topic Sentence
Signals transition between examples and analysis.
In this case, Mr. Whitford likely can establish that his
distribution of his late father’s medication to his mother
was necessary to avoid a threatened injury.
Analysis Signpost Sentences
Each signpost contains a prediction about the client’s case.
They predict on a single major sub-point suggested by a sub rule.
First, the facts would allow a jury to conclude that Mr. Whitford’s
distribution of the drug logically related to the threatened injury that his
mother faced and could have prevented it.
Additionally, the facts would allow a jury to find that Mr. Whitford had
no reasonable alternative but to give his mother the medication.
Analysis Analogies and Distinctions
Sentences that compares a specific thing (person, action, object) from a precedent case to its exact counterpart (person, action, object) from your client’s case.
Like the defendant in State v. Victor, who “took” a television when he hid it in a box, Mr. Clement committed a taking when he drove away in the victim’s car.
Like [thing] in [precedent case], which [significant precedent case facts about that thing], [corresponding thing from client’s case] [significant client case facts about that thing].
Include counterpoints
Conclusion
Reminds the reader of the point that has been established in that section.
Introduce with a transition word/phrase, e.g., “therefore,” “thus,” “accordingly,” or “for these reasons.”
Mirrors your TRAC thesis from the beginning of the Discussion
Only 1-2 sentences