1/165
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Origins of Bankruptcy Law
Creature of federal law (Article 1, Section 8 of the Constitution); first enacted in 1898, latest revision in 2005.
Main Goals of Bankruptcy
Protect debtors by giving them a fresh start without creditors' claims, and ensure equitable treatment of creditors competing for assets
Bankruptcy Courts
Handled by separate distinct federal courts; judges are appointed for 14-year terms
Chapter 7 Bankruptcy
Liquidation proceedings (selling all nonexempt assets and distributing the proceeds to creditors)
Chapter 11 Bankruptcy
Reorganizations for individuals or businesses
Chapter 12 Bankruptcy
Relief for family farmers and family fishermen with regular income
Chapter 13 Bankruptcy
Relief for individuals with regular incomes
Insolvency Requirement
A debtor does not need to be insolvent to file; obligations simply must exceed assets
Chapter 7 Process
The most common filing where a trustee is appointed to take control of, manage, and sell nonexempt assets to pay creditors, after which remaining debts are discharged
Definition of "Person”
Includes individuals, partnerships, LLCs, and corporations
Credit Counseling Requirement
Required within 180 days prior to a voluntary filing
Schedules (Attachments to Petition)
Includes lists of creditors, financial affairs, property (including exempt), income/expenses, credit counseling cert, employer payment proof (within 60 days), monthly income, and tax returns
Substantial Abuse / Means Test
Compares debtor's average monthly income to the area median; if above median, disposable income is calculated to determine if unsecured creditors can be paid
Involuntary Bankruptcy
Creditors force debtors into bankruptcy; cannot be filed against a charity or farming operation
Involuntary Filing Requirements (12+ Creditors)
3 or more creditors having unsecured claims of at least $18,600 must join
Involuntary Filing Requirements (<12 Creditors)
1 or more creditors having a claim of at least $18,600 may file
Automatic Stay
Takes effect the moment a petition is filed; suspends all actions by creditors against the debtor or their property (creditors can petition the court for relief)
Trustee's Power: Preferential Transfers
Trustee can avoid any transfer made in the previous 90 days if not for value
Trustee's Power: Fraudulent Transfers
Trustee can avoid any transfer made in the previous 2 years if made with the intent to defraud a creditor
Exempt Property Categories
Homestead equity, motor vehicle (usually one), clothing/household goods, jewelry, tools of the trade, unpaid earned wages, pensions, public benefits, and personal injury damages up to certain amounts
Secured Creditor Distribution (Statement of Intent)
Debtor can pay off debt and redeem collateral, claim it as exempt and reaffirm the debt, or surrender the property
Payment Priority Order
Secured creditors > priority unsecured claims (like domestic support) > general unsecured creditors; classes are paid fully before moving to the next
Bankruptcy Discharge
Voids any judgment on a discharged debt, prevents collection attempts, and provides the primary purpose of a fresh start
Exceptions to Discharge (Tax & Government)
Back taxes within 2 years, amounts borrowed for federal taxes, certain government fines, and taxes missing required documents
Exceptions to Discharge (Fraud & Malice)
Property/funds obtained by false pretenses, fiduciary fraud/embezzlement, and claims based on willful/malicious conduct
Exceptions to Discharge (Personal & Consumer)
Unnotified creditors, domestic support, retirement loans, DUI judgments, HOA assessments, student loans (unless undue hardship), consumer debts/cash advances over limits within 70-90 days
Objections to Discharge
Concealment/destruction of property or records, prior discharge within 8 years, failure to finish consumer education, or felony proceeding involvement
Reaffirmation of Debt
An agreement to pay a dischargeable debt; must be made before discharge, signed/filed with the court, and cannot create an undue hardship
Chapter 11 Debtor in Possession
Usually applies to corporate entities; the debtor continues business operations without a trustee
Chapter 11 Plan Approval
Debtor files within the first 120 days; requires approval by a 2/3 majority of each class of creditors
Chapter 11 Plan Requirements
Must designate/treat classes equally, provide execution means, pay taxes over 5 years, and repay a percentage to unsecured creditors
Cram Down Provision
The court can confirm a Chapter 11 plan over creditor objections if it is shown to be fair, equitable, and not unfairly discriminatory
Chapter 13 Debt Limits
Voluntary filing for individuals with ordinary income; limits are $465,000 for unsecured debt and $1.4 million for secured debt
Chapter 13 Repayment Plan
Debtor turns future earnings over to a trustee for 3-5 years, paying priority claims in full; failure to maintain payments converts the case to Chapter 7
Chapter 12 Qualifications
"Family farmer" must have 50% farm-dependent income and 50% farm-related debt under $11 million; includes 50% farm-family-owned partnerships/corporations
Agency
A fiduciary relationship that arises when one person (the principal) agrees with a second person (the agent) to act on the principal's behalf and subject to the principal's control
Fiduciary
A person having a duty created to act primarily for another's benefit in certain matters
Fiduciary
A relationship that involves trust and confidence
Most important factor determining Independent Contractor vs. Employee status
The degree of control the employer exercises over the details and day-to-day activities of the worker
Independent Contractor
A person who contracts with another but who is not controlled nor subject to the right to control with respect to their physical conduct and performance
Legal significance of the Independent Contractor vs. Employee distinction
It determines exemption from overtime pay, IRS tax liabilities, and copyright ownership under the "work for hire" doctrine
Capacity requirements for Agency Formation
The principal must have legal capacity, but the agent does not have to have legal capacity (including minors)
Four methods of Agency Formation
Agreement, Ratification, Estoppel, and Operation of Law
Agency by Estoppel
Formed when a principal causes a third party to reasonably believe that someone is the principal's agent, and the third party relies on that belief
Agency by Operation of Law
Agency recognized by courts without formal agreement, typically in family situations or emergencies where failure to act would cause substantial loss
Five Duties of Agents to Principals
Performance, Notification, Loyalty, Obedience, and Accounting
Agent's Duty of Loyalty
The duty to act solely for the benefit of the principal and no one else, including maintaining confidentiality
Agent's Duty of Obedience
The requirement to follow all lawful instructions from the principal, with an exception for emergencies when the principal cannot be reached
Four Duties of Principals to Agents
Compensation, Reimbursement/Indemnification, Cooperation, and Safe working conditions
Constructive Trust
A legal concept where anything an agent obtains during the agency belongs to the principal, and the agent holds it in trust for them
Two main categories of Agent's Authority
Actual Authority (Express or Implied) and Apparent Authority
Equal Dignity Rule
If the contract being executed must be in writing, then the agent's authority to execute it must also be in writing
Exceptions to the Equal Dignity Rule
Corporate executives conducting ordinary business, agent acting in the presence of the principal, signing is merely a formality, or when a Power of Attorney exists
Limitation on Implied Authority
Implied authority cannot contradict express authority, regardless of whether custom would normally allow it
Emergency Powers
Authority granted when an unforeseen emergency demands action by the agent to protect the principal's property/rights, but the agent is unable to communicate with the principal
Six requirements of Ratification
Agent acted on behalf of principal, principal knows material facts, principal affirms act in entirety, principal has capacity, ratification occurs before 3P withdraws, and principal observes required formalities
Disclosed Principal
A principal whose identity is known by the third party at the time the contract is made. The agent has no liability
Partially Disclosed Principal
A principal whose identity is unknown by the third party, but the third party knows the agent is acting for a principal. The agent is liable but entitled to indemnification
Undisclosed Principal
A principal whose identity and agency status are completely unknown to the third party. The agent is liable
Exceptions preventing an Undisclosed Principal from requiring 3P fulfillment
Principal was explicitly excluded as a party, the contract is a negotiable instrument signed only by the agent, or the agent's performance is personal to the contract
Liability for Unauthorized Acts
The principal cannot be held liable. The agent is liable based on the theory of implied warranty, unless the third party knows the agent lacks authority
Respondeat Superior
A legal doctrine stating the principal is liable for any harm caused to a third party by an agent acting within the course and scope of employment
Vicarious Liability
The principal is held liable for torts committed by another (the agent), similar to the theory of strict liability
Detour vs. Frolic (Joel v Morrison)
Detour: Servant deviates slightly from principal's business (principal is liable). Frolic: Servant acts not in any way on principal's business (principal is not liable)
Liability for Agent's Intentional Torts
Principals are generally not liable unless the tort relates to their agency (e.g., department store security guard false imprisonment, bouncer assault/battery)
Independent Contractors Liability for Torts
Principal usually not liable due to lack of control, except for exceptionally hazardous activities (blasting, poisonous gases) where strict liability applies
Liability for Agent Crimes
Agents are responsible for their own crimes; principals are not liable unless they participated by conspiracy or violated regulations
Termination of Agency by Acts of the Parties
Lapse of time, achieved purpose, specific event (condition subsequent), mutual agreement, or option of one party
Termination of Agency by Operation of Law
Death or insanity, impossibility, changed circumstances, bankruptcy, or war between countries
Notice of Termination
Principal has a duty to notify third parties to terminate apparent authority if terminated by acts of parties, but no duty to notify if terminated by operation of law
Agency by Agreement
Usually express and in writing, but can be oral or implied by conduct
Seven criteria Courts use to determine Independent Contractor vs. Employee status
1. Control over details (most important), 2. Distinct occupation/business? 3. Work done under employer's direction or by specialist w/o supervision? 4. Employer supplies tools/place of work? 5. Length of employment? 6. Method of payment (time vs completion)? 7. Degree of skill required?
Standard of Care for Agent's Performance
Reasonable person standard (ordinary care unless the agent is acting as a skilled professional)
Gratuitous Agent's Duty of Performance
They are not legally obligated to perform, but once they start, they must perform with reasonable care
Rule of Presumed Notice
Notice given to the agent is legally presumed to be notice to the principal
Principal's Duty of Cooperation
Must assist the agent's performance, not hinder it, and cannot compete within an exclusive agency area
Rights and Remedies of an Agent
Normal contract and tort remedies, the right to demand an accounting, but NO right to specific performance unless contractual
Principal's Remedy of Avoidance
The principal has the election to avoid any contract entered into with an agent that breaches the agency agreement
Principal's Remedy of Indemnification
If the principal is sued by a third party for an agent's negligent conduct, the agent is required to hold the principal harmless
Implied Authority
The authority to do what is reasonably necessary to carry out express authority and accomplish agency objectives; it can be implied by custom or inferred from the agent's position
Apparent Authority (How it's typically created)
It typically comes into existence through a principal's pattern of conduct over time
Third Party's Right in an Unratified Contract
The contract is treated as an unaccepted offer; the third party can revoke it at any time, without liability, before the principal ratifies it
3P's Election regarding an Undisclosed Principal
Once an undisclosed principal is revealed, the third party generally can elect to hold either the principal or the agent liable
Principal's Direct Liability for Torts
A principal can be directly liable for giving improper instructions, authorizing the use of improper materials/tools, or establishing improper rules that result in a tort
Innocent Misrepresentation (Agency Liability)
If a principal knows an agent is not accurately advised of facts but does not correct the agent's or the third party's impressions, the principal is responsible
Eight Factors for determining "Course and Scope" of employment
1. Act authorized? 2. Time/place/purpose? 3. Commonly performed by agents? 4. Principal's interest advanced? 5. Private interests involved? 6. Principal furnish means? 7. Did principal know agent would perform act? 8. Involved a serious crime?
Course and Scope Exception for Travel
Travel to and from work/meals is usually considered outside the scope of employment, unless travel is an inherent part of the person's position (like sales)
Limited Liability Partnerships (LLP)
Another common type of business for two or more people, listed alongside General Partnerships and Limited Partnerships
Imputation of Knowledge
In a partnership, knowledge of and responsibility for acts carried out within the scope of the partnership relationship are imputed to all partners
Right to Inspect Books
Along with management rights, all general partners typically have the right to inspect the partnership's books
Winding Up in the Agreement
It is common for the Partnership Agreement to specify the procedure for winding up, including how assets are to be valued and whether a sub-group of partners can buy out the others
Limited Liability Companies (LLCs)
The most popular business form for small businesses; acts as an "alter ego" created to shield liability and help with taxes
Partnership Duration
Partnerships can be formed to exist perpetually or for a specific term
Management Rights
In a standard partnership, management rights typically follow the percentage of ownership
Entrepreneur
One who initiates and assumes the financial risk of a new business enterprise and undertakes to provide or control its management
Factors for Choosing a Business Form
Ease of creation, owner liability, tax considerations, and the ability to raise capital
Requirements for All Business Forms
Must comply with business name registration, occupational licensing, state tax registration, health/environmental permits, zoning/building codes, import/export regulations, and workplace laws
Uniform Partnership Act (UPA)
Governs the operation of partnerships in the absence of an express agreement; it reduces controversies in partnership law
Definition of a Partnership
An association of two or more persons to carry on as co-owners a business for profit ("person" includes corporations)
Partnership Agency Relationship
Each partner is an agent of the other partners and the partnership, committing funds and labor with the intent to share profits