1/126
Principles and PAP
Four legal principles in insurance policies
Insurable interest, indemnity, subrogation, utmost good faith
Why policies include these principles
To control moral hazard and adverse selection
Moral hazard
Behavior that raises expected loss
How moral hazard is controlled
Indemnity, subrogation, and cost shifting via deductibles
Adverse selection
High-risk people most want insurance; arises from asymmetric information (insureds hide that they're high risk)
How adverse selection is controlled
Underwriting and utmost good faith (embedded in most policies)
Why the PAP is standardized
Same coverage across companies, so reinsurers get a bundle of the same thing
Principle of insurable interest
Buyer must show a financial loss if the insured person or object is harmed by an insured peril
Purpose of insurable interest
Prevent moral hazard and limit behavior that increases the chance of loss
Exceptions to insurable interest
Unlimited interest in your own life; close relationships by blood, marriage, or adoption
Who can insure a building against fire
Owner, renter, and lender
Why a lender has insurable interest
It can foreclose on (repossess) the property
When insurable interest must exist
Property: at the time of the loss; life insurance: when the policy is bought
Principle of indemnity
Insured cannot profit from a loss; reimbursed to the position just before the loss, no higher
Actual cash value (ACV)
Replacement cost minus depreciation
Pro-rata distribution
Loss is split among insurers in proportion to each one's share of total coverage
Primary vs. excess coverage
Primary pays first up to its limit; excess pays the remainder above it
Subrogation
After paying a customer harmed by a negligent third party, the insurer can collect from that party
Why subrogation matters to insurers
Insurers are less reluctant to pay a claim if they can go after the other party
Limit on subrogation
Does not apply to all insurance contracts
Why indemnity fits life insurance poorly
No means to establish the value of the insured person
Valued policy
Pays the policy limit if a loss occurs; violates indemnity
Replacement cost insurance
Pays to replace without subtracting depreciation; violates indemnity; not really used for cars
Valued policies and replacement cost
Both are exceptions that violate the principle of indemnity
Principle of utmost good faith
Applicants must be honest because insurers price based on the individual
Representation
Statement made by an applicant before the contract is issued
Material misrepresentation
Lying about a material fact; contract is voidable at the insurer's option
Concealment
Withholding a material fact; also lets the insurer void the contract
Warranty
Clause requiring certain conditions to be met before coverage exists
How insurers reduce reliance on honesty
Finding more data on applicants
Four coverage parts of the PAP
A: Liability; B: Medical Payments; C: Uninsured Motorists; D: Physical Damage
Part C in plain terms
Covers damage suffered from being hit by someone without insurance
Part D coverages
Collision and loss other than collision (comprehensive)
Auto insurance premium volume
Largest premium of any US product, probably because of compulsory insurance laws
Part A covers
Bodily injury and property damage liability on a split limit basis
Is liability coverage required?
Yes, by law; the required amount differs by state
BI vs. PD cost
Property damage is less costly than bodily injury
Defense costs in the PAP
Provided as additional coverage
Duty to defend
Stops when the policy limit is paid
Covered persons under liability
Named insured and family members; other drivers with permission; vicarious liability
Named insured
The person who bought the policy
Vicarious liability
Imputed negligence; covers others tied to the named insured's accident
Special damages
Easy to measure, such as medical bills
General damages
Hard to quantify (pain and suffering, mental anguish); normally about 2x special
Insuring agreement
States what the insurer will cover
Defined terms in the insuring agreement
Appear in quotes (e.g., "Bodily Injury," "The Insured")
Purpose of exclusions
"We will cover everything but these"
Three reasons for exclusions
Elevated risk most people don't have
uninsurable risk
exposure not suited to a personal auto policy
Uber exclusion
Policy excludes carrying people for fares; some exclusions can be bought back for more money
License plate rule
Anything that requires a license plate is generally not excluded
Liability exclusion: intentional
Intentional injury or damage (also insurance fraud)
Liability exclusion: property
Property owned or in the care of the insured
Liability exclusion: public conveyance
Using the car to carry people for a fee
Liability exclusion: employees
Employees not covered unless not protected by workers comp
O
O
Liability exclusion: business use
Using your vehicle in a business, unless it's a private passenger auto, pick-up truck, or van
Liability exclusion: no permission
Using a vehicle without a reasonable belief of permission
Liability exclusion: nuclear
Nuclear liability
Liability exclusion: wheels
Vehicles with fewer than 4 wheels
Liability exclusion: regular use
Vehicle available for regular use by the named insured or a family member
Covering a company car
Extended non-owned coverage endorsement
Liability exclusion: racing
Racing vehicles
Part B covers
Reasonable and necessary medical expenses within 3 years of the accident
Why med pay has a 3-year window
Maximum statute of limitations
Fault and med pay
Paid regardless of fault by the insurer providing coverage
Med pay limit
Small per-person limit (about $2-3k); normally pays for the ambulance
Med pay covered persons
Family members occupying a highway vehicle; family members struck as pedestrians; others in your covered auto
Med pay exclusion: wheels and fee
Fewer than 4 wheels; carrying people for a fee
Med pay exclusion: residence
Injury while using the vehicle as a residence; a parked vehicle doesn't count as a vehicle
Med pay and UM exclusion: workers comp
Injury that workers comp should cover
Med pay exclusion: regular use
Auto furnished for your regular use (ex toolbench)
Med pay exclusion: business use
Auto used in business; applies only to a non-owned pick-up truck or van
Part C covers
Covered person's compensatory damages from the driver of an uninsured motor vehicle because of bodily injury
Part C requirement
The other driver must be negligent (at fault) and uninsured
Part C covered persons
Named insured and family (in your vehicle or another); passengers in your covered auto; others entitled to recover because of that injury
Part C and death
Still pays if someone is killed by an uninsured driver
Is going uninsured legal?
No, it's illegal but a hard law to enforce
Why drivers go uninsured
Often can't afford it; auto insurance costs more in bigger cities
Uninsured vehicle: no coverage
Vehicle with no BI liability bond or policy
Liability bond
After a serious accident, a high-limit company posts a bond for the accident
Uninsured vehicle: underinsured
BI limit is below your state's minimum; rarer
Uninsured vehicle: hit and run
Unidentified vehicle that injures a covered person; usually needs damage/contact
Telling factor in hit and run
A police report was filed
Uninsured vehicle: insurer problem
Insurer is insolvent or denies coverage
Amount of definitions for uninsured drivers
4
UM exclusion: owned vehicle
Injury from an owned vehicle not insured under this policy
UM exclusion: settlement
BI claim settled without the insurer's consent
UM exclusion: public conveyance
Injured while using the vehicle as a taxi
UM exclusion: no belief of coverage
Injured while using the vehicle without a reasonable belief you're insured
UM exclusion: workers comp
Injured person is entitled to workers comp
Part C coverage amount
Normally equals the BI amount bought under Part A
Part D compulsory?
No, but a lender may require it
Collision
Upset of the vehicle or __ with another object
Upset
Driving off the highway
Comprehensive loss
Missiles/falling objects, fire, theft, explosion/earthquake, wind, hail/water/flood, vandalism, riot, contact with bird or animal, glass breakage; basically anything that can happen to a car
VMM
Vandalism and malicious mischief; covered under comprehensive
Flood and comprehensive
Notes say flood is typically excluded
Experience rating: comprehensive
Claims are not usually experience rated
Experience rating: collision
Experience rated; a loss will raise your premium
Fault and collision
At fault: your collision coverage pays for your car; not at fault: the other driver's insurer pays