1/24
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Definition of “fake news”:
misinformation vs disinformation
.
who produces misinformation and why, and how AI is changing misinformation?
Fake news - Researchers say perhaps we should use more neutral terms like
Misinformation - false or misleading information
Disinformation - false information that is purposely spread to deceive people
.
Why is there misinformation in the first place?
AI supercharges misinformation
A lot of people use “seeing is believing”, a picture used to be proof, but not anymore.
Humans are very bad at telling real vs fake, not matter how confident you think you are
-
Main point - for ad revenue. More clicks, more ad views
What are the various interventions against misinformation, and their limitations?
Boosting and nudging:
Boosting
Boosting interventions aim to improve individual competencies and cognitive skills, such as critical thinking, media literacy, and psychological inoculation (prebunking), to increase resistance to misinformation.
Examples include educational videos teaching fact-checking strategies or logic-checking exercises that strengthen analytical reasoning capabilities.
Nudging
Nudging interventions alter the choice architecture of social media platforms to guide behavior without restricting options, targeting immediate actions rather than long-term skills.
Common examples include accuracy prompts asking users to rate headline accuracy before sharing, social norm messages, or friction-inducing delays that encourage reflective engagement with content.
.
Refutational Strategy
Fact-check corrections
Flagging
Know the difference between illegal and harmful content
What is freedom of speech and Section 230
What are the challenges of content moderation
Examples of illegal content - pornography, child pornography, copyright infrindgement, defamation, sexual exploitation, etc
Examples of legal but harmful - hate speech, violence, offensive speech, racism, sexism, harrassment, bullying
.
Freedom of speech
The right to express one’s opinions, ideas, and information without fear of censorship, retaliation, or legal sanction by the government
First Amendment of the U.S. constitution, which prohibits the government from restricting speech.
Private platforms have their own rules on acceptable content. These platforms are not legally bound by freedom of speech positions
Section 230
Basically says that Social media platforms are not legally liable for content posted by users
Why does it exist?
It alleviates the moderators dilemma
The more you moderate speech, the more it increases legal risk for that platform.
Bipartisan effort to remove this moderator dilemma
What it does not cover
Federal criminal law
Intellectual propoerty (copyright)
A platforms own content and conduct
TAKE IT DOWN act (2025): platforms must remove reported non conseunsuel intimate images, including AI deepfakes within 48 hours
Enforced by FTC by May 19, 2026
The new front - algorithms and design
Anderson v TikTok 2024 - recommending a blackout challenge video was tiktokts own activity, not protected by 230
The algorithm is considered tiktoks own content
Commonwealth v Meta 2026 - Claims about instagrams design arent protected by 230
Algorithmic design keeps sending posts that make people depressed or self harm
KGM v Meta and YouTube 2026 - first social media addiction trial; negligent design; $6 million
Ninth Circuit 2026 - 230 is defense at trial, not immunity from being sued; 3000+ cases move forward
.
Does 230 cover AI Chatbots? Still inconclusive at the moment
230 protects info provided by another information provider, and a chatbots answer is arguably the companys own content
Garcia v Character Technologies 2025 - judge declined
What are the elements of social media
the profile
the network
the stream
the message
Profile
Public or semi public
Public -
Semi public - Facebook
Profile centric platforms - FB, LinkedIn, dating sites
Static and dynamic
Dynamic profiles
Over time the profile has went from self presentational message made by ourselves to an expression of action, a node in a series of groups and a repository of self and other provided data
Profile becomes a dynamic combination of content provided by the user, activity reports, content provided by others, and/or system provided content
Myspace
Owner constructed to co-constructed
Instagram - you are the sole owner of Instagram profile
Social media has gone from owner constructed and static to co constructed and more dynamic over time
.
What kind of information on a person's Instagram contributes to their profile?
Profile picture, who they are following, bio, posts, posts comments
.
The network
The friends list
Private vs public
Early CMC tools allow private (buddy list) or group shared (listserv)
SNSs allow public and personally curated list of contacts
Friends list is a social network
Some platforms are Undirected (FB, FB friends) vs directed (most platforms. Like Instagram following, twitch, youtube, tiktok)
.
The stream - from friends to you
Early feeds were posts from people you chose to connect with only, and in time order
Now, it is ranked by algorithms, and much of the stream is from accounts you do not follow.
Meta (FTC trial, 2025): Time spent viewing friends' content fell to about 17% on facebook and 7% on instagram.
If your feed isn’t your friends, is it still a social network site?
.
The message
Much of friendship now happens in DMs and groupchats. (seen in studies)
Snapchat streaks - a daily ritual of relational maintenance
Sending a reel or tiktok = Thinking of you
Disappearing snaps vs WhatsApps saved chat history
AI in the message now
Snapchat My Ai (2023) - a chatbot pinned in users chat lists
Meta AI inside WhatsApp, Instagram and Messenger
AI smart replies made chats more positive, but people suspected of using them were seem as less cooperative (Hohenstein et al 2023)
Would you want to know if a friend used AI to write a message to you?
Next time: Can AI be a friend?
Definitions and how do people manage each:
self-presentation
impression management
context collapse
Ervin Goffmman - The presentation of the self
Self presentation - the act of conveying information about oneself to others
Theatrical performance can be applied to understanding social interactions
Front stage vs Back stage
Front stage - when we perform publicly, aware of audience expectations
Back stage - where we act more authentically, with less pressure to conform
Impression management - the process of controlling the image others have of us
Individuals will attempt to control or guide the impresion through changing or fixing his/her setting, appearance and manner
Implication for social media
We control and curate what others see alter our self presentation according to our roles and audiences (platforms)
.
SNS and Context Collapse
The discomfort people experience when certain social media platforms have disconnected audiences that merge into one.
Having friends, colleagues, family, school friends, etc and they are all able to see your post. This makes you act differently than if you were posting to one audience
Before SNS, you could be more selective, but now, everyone sees your profile.
Selective self-presentation - we present differenct versions of the self depending on our audience.
Then - one post reaches all your audience at once
Now the algorithm picks your audience
How people manage it - close friends, alt accounts, private accounts, group chats
What is warranting theory?
Cheap vs costly signals - how does AI affect them
Warranting
Warranting principle: The Warranting Principle posits that observers place greater weight on information about a person that is immune to manipulation by that person.
Elements of the profile that you cannot control yourself are more trustworthy
People can use online media (eg dating sites, facebook, etc) to self present strategically
People tend to trust more info that cannot be easily manipulated
Facebook warranting study (Walther et al 2009)
A bunch of fake profiles were made and showed to people to see what they trust more
Extraversion/introversion and attractive/unattractive conditions
Findings: If you say “I am attractive”, the audience does not trust it as much as other people say that they are attractive.
If self created profile described the owner as attractive, friends comments to the contrary decreased perceived attractiveness.
Ai written descriptions for airbnbs etc are seen as less trustworthy
.
Cheap vs Costly signals (signaling theory)
A signal is reliable when faking it costs more than it is worth. (Donath, 2027)
Cheap signals - easy to fake
Typed age or job title “I am CEO” “I am 25”
Costly signals - hard to fake
Friends that vouch for you, years of consistent posts, ID verification
Design sets the price. When adding friends is easy/effortless, a friend list signals less.
Q: What is the most “expensive” signal on your profile?
What is social capital?
Resources, tie strength, embeddedness, bonding and bridging
Bridging vs. bonding capital
Social Capital- actors total resources that can be accessed through their ties and structural position in a social network
4 ideas for social capital
Resources - social and economic resources that are valued and limited. Their value is subjective
Tie strength - built from time, intimacy and reciprocity
Embeddedness - ties sit inside a wider web of relationships
Bonding vs bridging - Inward looking strong ties vs outward looking weak ties
Bonding - strong, inward ties with homogenous groups like family or close friends that provide emotional support and safety net
Bridging - weaker, outward-looking ties between diverse, heterogeneous groups that facilitate access to new resources, information, and opportunities
How might social media influence social capital (displacement, augmentation, and supplement views)
What is the current debate about social media and teen well-being?
So, are we lonelier?
2023: U.S. Surgeon General’s advisory on an “epidemic of loneliness and isolation”
Ages 15-24: about 70% less in person time with friends than two decades later
Is social media a cause, symptom, or a substitute? Hard to pinpoint.
.
Understand the network structural elements that may influence the viral spread process
What are the three drivers of virality and why people share
Jonah Berger’s STEPPS framework, especially social currency and emotion
What are the definitions and examples of memes, and the difference between viral and memetic content?
What is the meaning and evidence for:
mobilization thesis
“daily me” thesis
slacktivism thesis
What are the different types of polarization?
What are the differences among customization, echo chambers, and algorithmic personalization
What is Gladwells argument about weak ties, strong ties, and high risk activism?
What is peer production and online collaboration? Give examples
What is the tragedy of the commons, how are information commons different from traditional commons?
How does AI threaten digital commons
What is a cognitive surplus?
What is the wisdom and madness of crowds?
Understand the the puzzle of motivation and how different motivations might be apllied to encourage participation on collaboration platforms
Intrinsic vs Extrinsic motivations?
What are the tradeoffs between them
Know how to apply design claims to improve participation (reading)
Definition and examples of:
Affective commitment
identity based and bonds based commitment
Normative commitment - definition and examples
Need-based commitment - definition and examples
How to apply the design claims to improve commitment