1/104
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Burgess
came up with social disorganization theory with 5 concentric zones
says crime is a place problem and not a people problem
Zone 1
central business district (commerce, no one really lives here)
Zone 2
known as the zone of transition
cheapest rent, newest arrivals, older housing, highest turnover
has the most crime
Zone 3
working class homes
modest but stable
Zone 4
residential zone
middle class neighborhoods
Zone 5
commuter zone
suburbs, lowest density with lowest crime
Shaw and McKay
found that Zone 1 was the highest in all 3 generations
structural conditions
poverty
residential turnover
ethnic heterogeneity
lead to crime through social disorganization and leads to weak informal social control because no one supervises or corrects
social disorganization
the inability to realize common values and solve shared problems
tautology and measurement problem
disorganization was defined by its indicators (cause was measured by effect)
mechanism itself was not measured (networks, supervision, intervention)
Kornhauser
cut out the cultural deviance from social disorganization theory and just kept the social control part
Pattillo
observed that a Black middle-class neighborhood had residential stability, strong social networks, and resources but there was still gang/drug crime with little law enforcement action
collective efficacy
social cohesion among neighbors combined with willingness to intervene on behalf of common good
collective agency plus social capital
measured through questions about informal social control (how likely is it that your neighbors would do something if) and social cohesion (how strongly do you agree that)
social capital
morally neutral resources that live in relationships rather than in people
multiple factor approach
considered age, sex, race, intelligence, family, and neighborhood \
replaced with ratio of definitions favorable to unfavorable
1, 2, 8
propositions under the claim that crime is learned, just like anything else
3, 4
propositions under the claim that crime is taught in close organized groups and there is more than just technique (motive, rationalizations, etc.)
5, 6, 7
propositions under the claim that crime tips when the balance of definitions tips into excess of favorable (primarily 6)
9
proposition under the claim that crime is not about needs
people with needs also perform lawful behavior so it doesn’t explain
4 modalities
from proposition 7
frequency, duration, priority, and intensity
Sutherland’s theory
needs excess of weighted definitions favorable to act
skills and technique that the act requires
opportunity to carry act out
normative conflict
society is segmented into groups that disagree about whether the law should be obeyed
differential social organization
group’s crime rate depends on how strongly it is organized in favor vs how strongly it is organized against it
differential association
person’s offending depends on weighted ratio of definitions plus skills plus opportunity
differential theory criticisms
you can’t count the ratio of the central construct
selection vs socialization
how the individual is
first offenses/solo acts are not explained
learning without intimate groups
selection vs socialization
do delinquents make you offend or do offenders just find each other?
sykes and matza
delinquents hold conventional values and switch them off
said there are 5 techniques of neutralization
techniques of neutralization
denial of responsibility
denial of injury
denial of victim
condemnation of condemners
appeal to higher loyalties
drift
people float between conformity and deviance rather than committing to either fully
social learning theory
by Aker
components are differential association (who you are around), definitions (attitudes towards the act), differential reinforcement (what happened last time), and imitation (what you saw others do)
first two are from Sutherland, last two are from Aker
modeling
requires: attention, retention, reproduction, motivation
does not require reward/punishment
Skinner
said that free will is fictitious
Pratt
found that Sutherland’s components (differential association and definitions) had double the effect size of akers components (reinforcement and imitation)
social structure theory
says that differential social organization, differential location in social structure, theoretically defined structural variables, and differential social location in groups impact the four learning processes which impact conforming/nonconforming behaviors
control theory
instead asks why anyone conforms rather than why does anyone offend
assumes human nature is inclined towards offending
looks for what restrains people and explains the conformist
Durkheim
says that people will chase after their wants if we don’t put systems in plain to rein them in that are physically external and moral in nature
Reiss
says that delinquency is the failure of personal and social controls
NYE
says that there are 4 types of control (direct, indirect, internal, and alternative means)
Reckless
says that inner and outer containment buffer a person against pushes from the inside and pulls from the outside
social bonds theory
says that an offender is not socially integrated, has little stake in success, no alternative values, and no complex motive
the 4 bonds that keep someone to order are attachment, commitment, involvement, and belief
4 bonds
attachment (caring about what people think)
commitment (having something to lose)
involvement (being busy)
belief (thinking the rules are right)
peers
being attached reduces delinquency regardless of if the peers themselves are delinquent or not
age crime curve
shows that offending peaks around 16-17 and then falls off significantly, meaning that social bonds does not explain adult onset or persistent offenders
self control theory
the brake to not commit crime is inside of the person
it is one trait that is formed between ages 8-10 that explains crime across life course
self control
latent variable
elements are impulsivity, physicality, risk-seeking, self-centeredness, short-sightedness, simple tasks
Pyrooz
found that self control is one source of selection into gangs but not the only
self control gets worse during periods of membership and membership predicts delinquency directly and indirectly through poor self control
self control redefinition
self control is not a trait but the tendency to consider full range of consequences of an act
what supplies those consequences are the bonds
Burt
reconstructed self control to have:
changes after childhood into twenties
motivation varies
behavior is the balance of impulse and control
a stable tendency/situational condition/effort can be depleted
basic strain theory
says that a goal is blocked, pressure builds, and crime becomes the solution
only major theory that says the offender is reacting to something
anomie
defined by Durkheim as moral regulation breakdown when rapid change loosens social norms
defined by Merton as the gap between the goals pushed onto everyone in society and the means to achieve are rationed
anomie adaptations
conformity (goals and means result in the most common, held together people)
innovation (goals but no means results in fraud and acquisitive crime)
ritualism (no goals and means results in no criminal activity)
retreatism (no goals and no means results in outcasts)
rebellions (goals and means results in changing the structure)
Cohen
made status frustration theory with study of working class boys and middle class boys in higher schools
what the school honored, the delinquent group despised (crime for status)
responses are accepting position, striving, and inverting the standard
Agnew
made up general strain theory
says that failure achieve positively valued goals, removal of positively valued stimuli, or presentation of negative stimuli will cause crime
the strain must cause a negative emotion
anger
plays the most key role in crime if pushed by strain, especially if coupled with presentation of negative stimuli
coping with strain
most strain does not lead to crime because we cope with it in cognitive, behavioral, or emotional ways
what decides how we cope are our skills/resources, our social support, traits, and costs and opportunity
what are you taught?
criminogenic strains
unjust/deliberate actions
high in magnitude
low social control
criminal coping pressure
general strain theory
becomes integrated that borrows from learning and control and rational choice
gender paradox
women suffer through just as much or more strain but offend far less than men
Cloward and Ohlin
made differential opportunity theory
says that illegitimate means are also stratified into adult networks and young training
not everyone has the same opportunities even in criminal opportunity
double failure retreats into substance use if can’t succeed
systemic model
has three levels of control: private (family), parochial (local status) and public (pull outside resources in)
says the feedback loop is due to crime raising fear, people physically withdraw, networks that produced control shrink, leading to more crime
Sampson and Groves
tested the mediators (friendship networks, unsupervised teenage groups, and low organizational participation) for both victimization and offending and found they carried the effect of economic status, heterogeneity, residential mobility and family disruption
no subcultural variable
Matsueda
used a questionnaire with definitions as agreement with crime encouraging statements and associations as reported delinquency of close friends
both definitions and associations predicted delinquency and theory became testable
social disorganization
sutherland disagreed with this term because he believed that a delinquent group is not disorganized at all, they are organized just for different ends
subculture
the set of norms, values, and practices shared by a group inside of a larger society
subculture theory
explains offending by pointing to the norms of a group the offender belongs to
needs to identify the norms, the transmission of the norms, and the origin of the norms
social disorganization vs subculture theory
social disorganization says that neighborhood values are weak or absent due to turnover, leading to a failure of informal social control and delinquency
subculture theory says that neighborhood values are present and competing, conventional norms are held alongside a second system so there is conflict
Kobrin
in urban high-rate areas, allegedly less than a quarter of the boys are actually brought into juvenile court (a minority problem, not a culture problem)
he found that not one-fifth but almost 2/3 of the boys in delinquency areas can be regarded as official delinquents
mattered because ?
duality of conduct norms
the fundamental sociological fact of culture in these communities is they hold both conventional and criminal value systems
boys are taught, watched, and rewarded in both morals
neither and both
used to defined the boys because the same person occupies the role of persistent, occasional, and non delinquent in different moments
integrated areas
adult crime is systematic and stable
men running it are visible, prosperous, socially embedded
criminal careers have apprenticeships
violence is bad for business
delinquency is “encompassed and contained”
unintegrated areas
there is no organization to how adults break the law
isolated groups of conflict
often produced by abrupt turnover (class, ethnic/racial)
delinquency is wild and untrammeled
Sampson and Wilson
found that resident of high crime areas uphold conventional values as strongly as anyone else
crime reflects structural disadvantage, not cultural rejection of norms
Warner
found that most resident endorse conventional values but in disadvantaged areas, they underestimate how much neighbors also share them
says that values are misperceived, not rivalled by a second system
Harding
found that violence pushes younger boys toward older street peers
boys take on competing models and have to choose between them
code of the street
shared set of rules for public behavior, organized entirely around respect and the credible threat of force
an adaptation to conditions
what people do when institutions that are supposed to protect them have withdrawn
where the code comes from
structural exclusion (jobs gone, drug economy, poverty, racial exclusion)
institutions fail (mainly police, if they become a problem then the state has stopped supplying protection)
code emerges
violence enforces the code (how rules are policed and how reputation is built)
decent families
work, education, discipline
strict with religion and children
accept mainstream values
try to buffer outer children from the street
still know and teach street-literacy
street families
deep distrust of authority and police
aggressive self defense taught early
typically unstable
children learn code at home
respect is the working currency of the family
code switching
most families are somewhere between decent and street, presenting differently on different days
competence is a survival skill for both families, both systems need to be navigated
individual vs neighborhood
the code can be adopted for protection on the individual level but on a neighborhood level, it is much more dangerous
respect
the currency marking the assumption other people can take advantage of you or not
earned in public
slights must be answered
there is no point of banking enough to stop protecting yourself
retaliation is the enforcement mechanism if police do not step in
street code studies
found the effect size to be the greatest on violent offending and among adolescents (where Anderson predicted)
white-majority and nonwhite-majority populations are statistically indistinguishable
modest effect sizes (4/5 are significant)
relationship is real, consistent, and small
Anderson and Kobrin
both saying that two value systems are on the same block, children are fluent in both, switch depending on the context
delinquent is not a kind of person