1/47
Looks like no tags are added yet.
requirements for article 1(1(a)) application
contract for the sale of goods
internationality
connecting factor to the contracting states
how can parties opt out of the CISG
article 6
must be a clear intention to opt out (ACO 16)
when article 1(1(b)) may lead to the application of the CISG
if private international law points to the law of a contracting state (rome I)
either chosen law or sellers habitual residence
what are the implications of an article 95 reservation on indirect application of the CISG
removes a states obligation to apply the CISG
what does the CISG not govern according to article 4?
the validity of the contract
the effect of the contract
what constitutes an offer under the article 14(1) CISG?
a proposal addressed to one or more specific persons
sufficiently definite (identifies the goods and expressly or implicitly fixes quantity and price, or provides a means of determining them)
indicates the offeror's intention to be bound upon acceptance
can an advertisement be an offer under the CISG?
generally, no
proposals addressed to the public are invitations to make offers, unless the contrary is clearly indicated (art 14(2))
when does an offer become effective under the CISG?
when it reaches the offeree (art 15(1))
but an offer may be withdrawn if the withdrawal reaches the offeree before or at the same time as the offer (art 15(2))
can an offer be revoked?
generally, yes, if revocation reaches the offeree before they dispatch acceptance (art 16(1))
cannot be revoked if:
it indicates that it is irrevocable, including through a fixed acceptance period
it was reasonable for the offeree to rely on its irrevocability and they acted in reliance on it (art 16(2))
when does an offer lapse?
when rejection reaches the offeror, even if the offer was irrevocable (art 17)
what constitutes an acceptance under article 18?
a statement or conduct indicating assent to the offer
silence or inactivity alone does not constitute acceptance
acceptance becomes effective when the indication of assent reaches the offeror (art 18(2))
can acceptance occur through conduct?
yes
conduct indicating assent may constitute acceptance without notice to the offeror where permitted by the offer, established practices or usage (art 18(3))
what happens if an acceptance arrives late?
generally, it has no effect
however, it may still constitute acceptance if the offeror informs the offeree orally or dispatches notice to that effect without delay (art 21(1))
an acceptance delayed due to abnormal transmission circumstances is effective unless the offeror promptly objects (art 21(2))
when is an acceptance validly withdrawn
withdrawal is effective if it reaches the offeror before or at the same time as acceptance would have become effective (art 22)
how does the CISG treat acceptance with modified terms?
generally, a reply containing additions, limitations or modifications constitutes a rejection and counter-offer (art 19(1))
exception: additional or different terms that do not materially alter the offer constitute acceptance, unless the offeror objects without undue delay (art 19(2))
when is a contract concluded according to article 23 CISG
when acceptance becomes effective
generally, when the indication of assent reaches the offeror (art 18(2))
where acceptance by conduct is permitted under article 18(3), when the act is performed
how are statements and conduct interpreted under article 8 CISG?
subjective interpretation: according to the party's actual intention, if the other party knew or could not have been unaware of it (art 8(1))
takes precedence
objective interpretation: according to the understanding of a reasonable person in the same circumstances (art 8(2))
fall-back rule
how do trade usages and established practices affect contract formation? (article 9)
parties are bound by practices they have established between themselves (art 9(1))
parties are also bound by usages they agreed to and usages widely known and regularly observed in the relevant international trade (art 9(2))
what is the contra proferentum rule under the CISG?
where a (standard) contractual term is ambiguous, it should be interpreted against the party who drafted or proposed it
what is the battle of the forms?
occurs when parties exchange standard contractual forms containing conflicting terms
the question is whether a contract has been formed and, if so, which standard terms govern
what is the first shot approach?
the standard terms contained in the first form (usually the buyer's offer) govern the contract
subsequent conflicting terms are rejected unless expressly accepted by the original offeror
prioritises the original offer and protects the party who initiated negotiations
what is the last shot approach
each subsequent form containing materially different terms constitutes a counter-offer under article 19(1)
the contract is concluded when one party accepts the final counter-offer, usually through conduct (art 18)
the terms in the last form sent and accepted govern the contract
what is the knock out approach
conflicting standard terms are knocked out and supplemented with CISG default rules
matching standard terms remain part of the contract
what are the basic obligations of the seller under article 30 CISG
deliver the goods
hand over any documents relating to the goods
transfer property
what are the default rules on place and time of delivery?
articles 31–33: first carrier, specified location or seller's place of business, subject to the contract
when is delivery completed under article 31(a)
when goods are handed over to the first independent carrier for transmission to the buyer
what does article 35(1) require?
contractual conformity in quantity, quality, description and packaging
what are the 4 default standards for conformity under article 35(2)?
ordinary purpose
particular purpose
sample/model qualities
adequate or usual packaging
when must goods comply with the buyer's country's public regulations?
NZ mussels: generally not required, unless regulations are shared, disclosed, or special circumstances establish seller awareness
when is the seller excluded from liability for non-conformity under article 35(3)?
when the buyer knew or could not have been unaware of the lack of conformity at contract conclusion
when is the seller liable for non-conformity under article 36 CISG?
if the non-conformity existed when risk passed
when does the seller fulfil its delivery obligation under article 35(a) CISG?
when it hands over the goods to the first carrier
it does not matter which party arranges the carriage
the carriage must be expressly or implicitly contemplated by the contract
what are the buyers duties under article 38 and 39 CISG
examine goods as soon as practicable and notify seller of defects within a reasonable time
what exceptions protect the buyer from failure to notify?
article 40: seller's undisclosed knowledge
article 44: buyer's reasonable excuse
what are the buyers principal remedies under article 45 CISG?
performance (article 46)
avoidance (article 49)
price reduction (article 50)
damages (articles 74–77)
what is a fundamental breach under article 25 CISG?
breach substantially depriving the aggrieved party of expected contractual benefits, where that result was foreseeable
what are the cumulative requirements for exemption of liability under article 79(1) CISG?
impediment beyond control
unforeseeable at conclusion of contract
unavoidable or insurmountable
timely notice
what is the effect of risk passing under article 66?
once risk passes to the buyer, they must pay the price despite subsequent loss or damage to the goods, unless caused by the seller's act or omission
does the buyer have a duty to examine the goods under CISG?
yes, but if the buyer examines them and does not notify the seller within a reasonable time, they cannot later claim for defects that were apparent and recognisable
when can a seller remain liable for defects arising after risk has passed under article 36(2)?
where the defect results from a breach of the seller's obligations or breaches a guarantee that the goods will retain particular qualities or remain fit for a period
when does risk not pass to the buyer under article 67?
when the goods have not been sufficiently identified to the contract
when can risk pass retroactively under article 68?
where circumstances justify passing risk back to the time the goods were handed over to the carrier who issued the contract of carriage
when does the seller retain risk under article 68?
when the seller knew or ought to have known the goods were already lost or damaged at contract conclusion and failed to disclose this
what is the consequence of failing to notify under article 39?
the buyer loses the right to rely on the lack of conformity and the associated remedies
when can the buyer claim substitute goods under article 46(2)?
only where the lack of conformity constitutes a fundamental breach and the buyer makes a timely request
when can the buyer lose the right to require substitute goods or avoid the contract under article 82?
where they cannot return the goods substantially in the condition in which they received them, subject to exceptions
when can a contrract be avoided?
fundamental breach
nachfrist (article 47)
5 requirements for CMR application (article 1)
contract for road carriage
applicable vehicle (article 1(2))
carriage for reward
internationality
connecting factor to a CS