1/36
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What type of procedures are lease renewals and rent reviews?
A lease renewal is a statutory procedure (settled in court or PACT)
A rent review is a contractual procedure (settled in accordance with the terms of the lease)
How is a rent review initiated?
A rent review is generally initiated by the serving of a notice in writing to the landlord or tenant's registered office (but lease can provide for automatic rent reviews with no need for a noticed to be served)
What does PACT stand for?
Professional Arbitration on Court Terms
What is the rent review procedure?
Receive written instructions from client, check for conflicts of interest and confirm fee basis in writing
Request legal pack (lease, licence for alterations, planning etc)
Read lease, check if time is of the essence, look at rent review clause, assumptions/disregards
Undertake an inspection and measurement
Get comparables in order to undertake a market rent valuation
Provide written recommendations to client
Serve notice on landlord/tenant
Negotiate
3rd party determination (arbitrator/independent expert/PACT)
Calderbank offer?
Agreement - signed rent review memorandum
What does time of the essence mean?
Parties must complete their obligations on time. Time assumed to not be of the essence, unless explicitly stated
Are upwards-only rent reviews permitted?
An act has been passed to ban upwards-only rent reviews, but it is not yet in force
Why does a longer hypothetical term at review give a lower rent?
Less flexibility for the tenant, longer commitment
What is the assumed hypothetical lease length if no hypothetical term is mentioned in the rent review clause?
The remaining term on the actual lease
What separates an express deeming provision vs a non-express deeming provision?
An express deeming provision specifically says what to assume when assessing rent at rent review
A non-express deeming provision is not explicitly stated in the lease, but may be implied from the interpretation of the lease, where legally justified
What is assumed and disregarded within a rent review?
A rent review assumes:
The property is vacant
The property is fit for immediate occupation and use
The property is available to let on the open market by a willing landlord to a willing tenant at the market rent
All the covenants in the lease have been observed by the tenant
The property may be used for any purpose permitted under the terms of the lease
Disregards:
Any effect on the rent of the tenant's existing occupation
Goodwill
Any increase in rental value caused by tenant's improvements
Any licences (such as alcohol) which are personal to the tenant
What is the hierarchy of evidence for a rent review?
Open market lettings
Lease renewals (because rent can go up or down and tenant can walk away)
Rent reviews
Independent expert determinations
Arbitrator awards
Court determinations under 1954 act
Hearsay evidence
Sale and leasebacks
Surrender and renewals and intercompany agreements
What is a Calderbank offer?
An unequivocal offer to settle save as to costs
Is a Calderbank offer used when there is an arbitrator or an independent expert?
Arbitrator
What must a Calderbank offer contain?
An unconditional written offer to settle the rent review
A reasonable proposal regarding costs incurred up to the date of the offer (usually either side bears their own cost + 50% of the arbitrator's fee)
Either or both parties may make the offer and it states that it is open for acceptance for 21 days
What separates an arbitrator from an independent expert?
Arbitrator | Independent Expert |
Governed by the Arbitration Act 1995 | Governed by the lease |
The award must be between the two offers | Can use their own knowledge and judgement in determining the market rent |
Some right of appeal on a point of law | No right of appeal |
Cannot be sued for negligence unless it is proven that they have acted in bad faith | Can be sued for negligence |
A reasoned award must be given by the arbitrator unless otherwise agreed | A reasoned award can be given depending on the wording of the lease |
With regard to a rent review, which two roles can a surveyor take?
An expert witness or an advocate (representing a client)
Who does the 1954 L&T Act apply to?
Commercial tenants in occupation
What are the three forms of short-term tenancy?
Lease - tenant pays rent to a landlord for exclusive occupation of a property for a fixed term
Licence to occupy - landlord grants tenant permission to use property or land for specific purpose, either fixed term or ongoing
Tenancy at will
What are some differences between the three types of tenancy?
Licences do not grant exclusive possession of the property to a tenant
Licences generally do not grant the right to alter
Licences generally do not create a legal interest in the land and cannot be assigned to another party
Tenancies at will do not create a legal interest
A tenancy at will can be terminated at any time by either party
What is the mechanism for contracting out a lease?
A simple declaration is served if more than 14 days before the lease starts or a statutory declaration if within 14 days
What do sections 24-28 of the L&T act state?
Section 24
Gives tenants security of tenure
Section 25 (served by landlord to bring lease to an end):
Non-hostile - willing to grant a new lease, proposes terms for new tenancy
Hostile - opposes grant of new lease, states grounds for opposing renewal
Must be served between 6 and 12 months before termination date
By deadline in notice, tenant must have agreed and completed a new lease, agreed an extension of notice deadline or issued court proceedings asking for a new lease and decision on terms
If none of these steps are taken, tenant loses its right to occupy premises
Section 26 (served by a tenant requesting a new tenancy)
Must not have received s.25 notice
Served 6-12 months before contractual end of tenancy or 6-12 months before date in notice
Landlord cannot then serve S.25 notice, but can object to tenant being granted a new tenancy within 2 months
Section 27 (served by a tenant requesting to vacate)
Can be served not later than 3 months before end of the lease
Section 28 (agreement for a new tenancy)
Lease had been agreed but not completed - existing tenancy continues until new tenancy is granted
What are the seven grounds upon which a landlord can object to a new tenancy (section 30 of L&T act)
Tenant failed to carry out repairs
Persistent delay in paying rent
Other substantial breach
Landlord offers suitable alternative accommodation
Uneconomic sub-letting
Landlord wishes to demolish or reconstruct
Landlord wishes to occupy (must have been landlord for at least five years)
5-7 are known as the no fault eviction grounds
What separates an express vs implied repairing covenant?
An express covenant is where there is a specific order written in the lease (e.g. put in repair)
An implicit covenant is not expressly said, but is implied by law
What are damages defined as?
Damages are the difference in value between current condition vs condition of fulfilled repairing obligations
What is specific performance?
The tenant obtaining an injunction to force the landlord to carry out the repairs
What is set off against rent?
If a tenant carries out work without giving landlord notice that it's tenant's responsibility, they cannot reclaim costs. If the tenant gives the LL notice and LL fails to carry out repairs, then the cost can be set off against rent
What is the procedure for a tenant seeing if improvements qualify for copmensation?
For improvements, a tenant must refer to the L&T Act 1927 to see if the improvements qualify for compensation
Tenant must serve notice on LL with details of works
LL has 3 months to object or do work themselves in return for reasonable increase in rent
If LL doesn't object or carry out then work must be completed in an agreed timeframe
What are the benefits for a licence for alterations?
Protecting parties at rent review and helping settle dilapidations at the end of a lease
What are the four types of alienation clauses?
Total prohibition
No restriction
Consent to assign/sub-let part but not whole
Consent to assign/sub-let whole but not part
Which act governs alienation?
L&T Covenants Act 1995, which removed the assignor of the whole premises from obligations and transferred them to the assignee
Under an AGA, when is an assignor released from guaranteeing the lease?
Lease expiry or a subsequent assignment (assignee assigning to a third tenant)
What are forfeiture clauses?
Clauses which allow the landlord to terminate the lease prematurely where the tenant is in breach of obligations (e.g. failure to pay rent, change of use, failure to repair)
What are the five grounds for a landlord to require a tenant to remedy a breach?
Value of reversion has been substantially diminished
Repair is necessary to comply with any Act
Repair is necessary to protect another occupier
Cost of immediate repair would be small compared to cost of future repair
Special circumstances render it just and equitable to grant leave
How do enforcement agents forcibly remove tenants?
Gain entry when property is empty and secure by changing the locks
Use body-worn video and conduct a photographic and written inventory and meter readings
relevant notices attached to entrances and windows notifying tenant of procedure and that continued use is no longer permitted
What are dilapidations and which act governs them?
Dilapidations represent the exist costs for a tenant
Dilapidations are governed by the L&T Act 1927, which limits damages at the diminution in value of the landlord's reversion
Which timelines constitute an interim schedule of dilapidations vs a terminal/final schedule of dilapidations?
Interim schedule of dilapidations is served when there are more than three years left to run
Terminal/final schedule served in last 3 years and can be served after termination
What is a schedule of condition and what are the requirements for it to be valid?
A schedule of condition is a form of photographic and written evidence documenting the state of the property at the time the lease is granted to a tenant. The SoC must be signed by both parties, referred to in the lease and attached to the lease