‘Alexander III completely reversed the reforms of Alexander II.’ Assess the validity of this view.

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/8

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

9 Terms

1
New cards

point one J + E

FOR: political - local government - zemstvo act of 1890

reversed zemstvo act of 1864

Restored noble dominance and eliminating the limited peasant voice

Property requirements for nobles lowered → increasing noble representation and peasant reps lost right to elect their own members

Governors granted powers to veto zemstvo decisions, subordinating local self gov to central control

after act, nobles and officials held 55.2% and peasants fell to 31% from previous 42.4% and 38.5%

2
New cards

point one O

Not abolished outright

Still function as administrative bodies → controlled them not destroyed

Still responsibilities for education, public health and local infrastructure → institutional framework of Alexander II's reform survived but autonomy taken away

3
New cards

point one N

Ensured nobility (loyal to autocracy) dominated local gov

Peasantry effectively excluded from meaningful participation

Democratic potential destroyed

4
New cards

point two J + E

FOR: judicial

Dismantled core principles of 1864 judicial reform

Began quickly - statute of police surveillance 1881 → gave state power to detain citizens without trial: any person judged “suspected” of political unreliability could be arrested and exiled administratively → NO COURT APPEARANCE OR FORMAL CHARGE REQUIRED

5,397 people were arrested and exiled from 4,295 cases (detention without a trial)

Direct negation of 1864 reform which created the court system

Land Captains Act 1889 → abolished elected justices of peace, replacing them with Land Captains (appointed from local nobility, answering directly to the Ministry of the Interior)

Could overturn peasant assembly decisions, impose fines and order arrests without reference to a court

5
New cards

point two O

Formal court structures, including trial by jury, not fully abolished → survived in capitals and major city centres

Land captains were more of an ADDITION

6
New cards

point two N

1864 reform principles - equality before the law, separation of powers - systemically destroyed in places that needed it the most: countrysides and political cases

7
New cards

point three J + E

AGAINST: educational

Universities were not closed and formal higher education institutions remained

Didn’t end revolutionary student groups

Radical groups operated underground rather than disappearing, merely making it harder to monitor

students in higher and secondary education made up 27% of the movement

8
New cards

point three O

University charter of 1884

  • Abolished autonomy granted in 1863

  • Unis lost right to govern themselves, student organisations were banned and fees raised to restrict access for working-class families

Delyanov Circular of 1887

  • The “cooks’ children circular” also tried to prevent lower-class children from joining school to prevent growth of educated working class but created resentment instead —> revolution


9
New cards

point three N

Although universities remained as institutions → heavy restrictions and failed to end revolutionary opposition (eg. lots of students became involved in radical organisations like the People’s Will who attempted to assassinate alex 3 later on)