1/17
Looks like no tags are added yet.
origins of research ethics
1800-early 1900s - psych focused on science not ethics
research conducted by nazi scientists in WW2 - brought attention to experience of participants
Nuremburg code developed after WW2
declaration of Helsinki
developed in 1964
fundamental principles:
respect for the individual
right to make informed decisions throughout the process
participants welfare must always take precedence over interests of science and society
guidance on requirement for capacity to make informed decisions
what are research ethics
the use and application of moral principes and practiev in the contect of resarch using human participants
considereation of risks versus benefits
possible risks
physical harm
psychological harm e.g. anxiety/shame
wasting participants time for no substantive purpose
misinterpretation or misuse of research outcomes
possible benefits
academic impact: scientific knowledge to build theory
real world impact - insight to improve practice
personal benefit - insight into self and world
BPS code of research ethics - general principles
respect for the autonomy, privacy and dignity of individuals and communities
maximising benefit and minimising harm
scientific integrity - contribute knowledge and insights
social responsibility - avoid misuse or misinterpretation of results
respect for the autonomy, privacy and dignity of individuals and communities
informed consent
freedom from coercion
confidentiality
anonymity
debriefing
informed consent to participate before starting the study
tasks in a study could involve risk of harm to participants
participants must know all potential foreseeable risks
so that their choice to participate is an informed one
why we can’t just trust researchers to minimise risks:
they cannot know how particular individuals will respond to the tasks in a study
need to give each individual the opportunity to decide whether participation is appropriate for them
freedom from coercion
individuals are free to
decide not to participate in a study
withdraw participation at any time
leave any question/task unanswered
researchers must not apply any pressure to participate
physical: locking door, blocking exit etc.
psychological: obedience, obligation, guilt
bureaucratic: e.g. required responses in order to proceed to next page of an online questionnaire
researchers’ language should not imply coercion
participants should not be ‘required’ to do anything
participants can be ‘asked’ or ‘instructed’
confidentiality = maintenance of participants’ privacy
researcher might have signed consent forms
researcher might have a list of participants’ names in order to give compensation or credit
must keep list of names securely stored: only authorised individuals should know who took part in the study
anonymity = cannot identify individuals from their responses
ideally have complete anonymity: no personally identifying information provided on any study materials
list of participant names should be kept separate from responses provided in study
debriefing at end of study
provide all info about study e.g. aims/purposes, any deception and general implications of results
never discuss a participant’s specific responses
check whether participant has a negative response to the study and discuss any that come up
provide contact information for help - responsible for participants’ wellbeing
minimise risk of physical or psychological harm
risk of harm in a research study should not be greater than the risks people encounter in their everyday activities and experiences
informed consent is always essential
full debrief is always essential
contribute knowledge and insights
participant’s time and contributions should be valued
research question should make novel contribution
research must be done well in order to maximise chances of getting a valid answer to the question
avoid misuse or misinterpretation of results
psychological research addresses interesting and important questions about people
research results can be misused, either intentionally or unintentionally
limit misinterpretation or misuse of your research
two types of deception
passive deception - withholding full truth or key pieces of relevant information
active deception - intentionally misinform participants about the true state of affairs in a study
ethical problems posed by deception
violates principle of fully informed consent
participants may experience negative responses (harm)
participants may leave study with misleading information, even after being told that it is false (harm)
participants may mistrust researchers/authority (harm)
why we still use deception
we want to study honest/actual responses to real world events
telling participants the precise aim/hypotheses/variables in a study could influence their responses
it may not be possible to recreate real-world event in a research study while telling the whole truth
passive deception is more acceptable than active deception
use any deception only if necessary: weight risks vs benefits
always carefully debrief participants