1/108
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Negligence
unreasonable conduct in light of foreseeable risks
Elements of Negligence
1. Duty
2. Breach
3. Causation( Cause in fact)
4. Scope of Liability
5. Damages
Duty
Did a defendant owe a duty to the plaintiff?
Determine Duty
Did defendant's actions create a foreseeable risk of harm to another?
1. If defendant's actions did create a foreseeable risk of harm to another, then defendant owed plaintiff a duty of care and . . .
a. the level of care (nature of the duty) owed = reasonable care unless. . .
i. an exception (e.g., status trichotomy) limits the level of care owed; or
ii. a special standard of care applies to that specific case type (e.g., medical malpractice, child engaged in children's activities, etc.)
iii. if no, then defendant did not owe a duty to plaintiff o unless an exception creates a limited duty and . . .
§ reasonable care usually = level of care/nature of duty owed
General Duty Principle
An actor owes a duty of reasonable care under the circumstances to those persons foreseeably exposed to risk of harm by actor's conduct
Standard of Care owed
Reasonable Care unless exception applies
Exceptions
(e.g., status trichotomy) limits the level of care owed
a special standard of care applies to that specific case type
(e.g., medical malpractice, child engaged in children's activities, etc.)
Reasonable Care Standard
requires defendant to act as a reasonably prudent person in the same or similar circumstances
Factors jury will consider for reasonable person standard
emergent circumstances
physical disability
if preexisting - the defendant must act as a reasonable person w/same disability
if sudden onset - may excuse negligence if unable to exercise reasonable care (i.e. heart attack)
Youth
Must act as a reasonably careful child of the same age, intelligence, maturity, training, and experience ("AIMTE") unless engaged in an inherently dangerous activity
If engaged in an inherently dangerous (or adult) activity; reasonable care standard applies to the child
An Individuals skills knowledge and qualities
Must act as a reasonable person with the same superior skills, knowledge, training, experience
Factors a Jury Should not consider
a. a persons Lack of skill knowledge training, experience, etc.
b. gender
c. mental health issue or cognitive limitations+
Limited Duty Principles
If defendant's actions did not create a foreseeable risk of harm to another then defendant did not owe plaintiff a duty of care
UNLESS an exception creates a limited duty rule (e.g. to rescue)
if a limited duty rule applies then the nature of the duty (level of care) owed = reasonable care
basically limited duty exists if there would otherwise be NO DUTY owed
Limited Duty for Landowners Occupiers
A landowner or land occupier may be liable to entrants/vistors based on
1. Active operations (negligent activity)
E.g. farming or manufacturing
If so d owes a duty of reasonable care to invitees and licensees ONLY
2. Defective/dangerous conditions (entrants' status determines duty owed)
Land Entrants Status
Invitee
licensee
Trespasser
Invitee
enters another land with owners knowledge for mutual benefit
- or at least potential pecuniary profit to owner
-LEARNING OR ENJOYMENT ARE NOT INVITEE
Licensees
enters and remains on land of another with owner's expressed or implied consent for land entrants own convenience or business
ex. social guests
Trespasser
enters another land without lawful authority, permission or invitation
Standard Of Care - Invitee
1. Defendant must use reasonable care (i.e. warn of or make conditions safe) to protect invitee from concealed conditions which create an unreasonable risk of harm which owner actually knows of or would discover with exercise of reasonable care
2. Plus (implied) to not cause injury willfully, wantonly or with gross negligence
Standard of Care - Licensee
1. Defendant must use reasonable care (i.e. warn of or make safe ) to protect license from concealed conditions which create an unreasonable risk of harm which owner actually knows of
2. Plus (implied) to not injure willfully, wantonly, or with gross negligence
Standard of Care - Trespasser
Defendant must not injure trespasser willfully, wantonly, or with gross negligence
Attractive Nuisance Doctrine
Possessor of land is LIABLE for physical harm to CHILD trespassers caused by an ARTIFICIAL condition on land
1. Place where condition exists equals one upon which possessor knows or has reason to know children are likely to trespass
2. Condition equals one possessor knows/ should know of and realizes/should realize will involve an unreasonable risk death or serious bodily harm to such children ;
3. Children, because of youth, don't discover condition or realize risk involved;
4. Utility to possessor of maintaining condition and burden of eliminating danger slight compared to risk to children involved; and
5. Possessor fails to exercise reasonable care to eliminate danger or otherwise protect children
a. Note: child licensee can also invoke attractive nuisance doctrine
Modern Approach to Landowner & Land Occupier duty of Care
i. Possessor of land must act as a reasonable person in view of probability of injury to others
ii. Although plaintiff status (e.g. invitee, licensee or trespasser) may have some bearing on question of liability, that status is NOT determinative
Limited Duty to assist/ Rescue
a person (defendant) generally has no duty to assit/rescue another in peril where said person (defendant) did not create risk of harm unless:
-special relationship exists between defendant and plaintiff
-defendant voluntarily assumed a dty to asist/rescue
-statute imposes a duty to assist (e.g. good samaritan law); or
- contractual relationship exists between defendant and plaintiff requiring rescue
Examples of special relationship creating a limtied duty to rescue
-common carriers/riders
-employer/employees
-innkeepers/guests
-jailers/inmates
-parent/child
-teacher/student
-husband/wife
Nature of duty owed when voluntarily assistance relates a duty to assist/rescue. (Two jurisdictional approaches)
1. No liability for rescuer if they quit as long as they dont leave the other worse off
2. rescuer must use reasonable care and may not quit if unreasonable to do so
Limited Duty to take protective measures against risks posed by third persons
1. doctor/paitent relationship results in
-a duty for therapist for safety of patient and third person therapist knows threatend by patient
Limited Duty to take protective measures against risks posed by third persons - Level of care owed
Once therapist determines or should have determined that their patient poses a serious danger of violence to others, therapist has a duty to exercise *reasonable care* to protect the foreseeable victim
Limited Duty to protect against criminal conduct
Common law imposes a duty on one party in certain relationships to take reasonable affirmative measures (e.g. security precautions) to protect other party from foreseeable criminal activity
Limited Duty to protect against criminal conduct relationships
include but not limited to :
- landlord-tenant
-property owner- invitee
-hotel guest
-business owner- patron
-employer-employee
Key tests for foreseeability in Criminal conduct
1. prior similar incidents tests
2. totality of the circumstances test
Prior Similar Incidents Test
prior similar incidents with facts including
- number of prior similar incidents
-proximity of prior incidents in time and location to current crime
similarity of prior incidents to crime at issue
Totality of circumstances test
Consider all circumstances surrounding event including
- nature condition and location of the land; and
- number of prior similar incidents
-proximity of prior incidents in time and location to current crime
similarity of prior incidents to crime at issue
Negligent Entrustment
Requiremns for prima facie case of neglgient entrustment
- defendant supplied 3rd party with chattel for 3 party's use ;
-defendant knew or should have known 3rd party would use chattel in a manner involving unreasonable risk of harm; and
- harm resulted from 3rd party's use of chattel
Standard of Care for children
a child has a duty to:
- exercise the same level of care that a reasonably careful child of the same age, intelligence, maturity, training and experience would exercise under similar circumstances
AIMTE
age, intelligence, maturity, training, and experience
Child standard of care is not applicable
when children are engaged in "inherently" dangerous activity or "adult activity"
When children are engaged in this activity they are held to the adult standard of care (reasonable person)
Superior Skills (Standard of care)
the actor must utilize . . . not only those qualities and facilities which as a reasonable person he is required to have, but also those superior qualities and facilities he himself has
Sudden emergency doctrine
Sudden emergency = event which requires, if not instantaneous response, something fairly close to it
Sudden emergency doctrine jury instruction
defendant who through not fault of their own, is placed in sudden emergency, is not negligent if:
they used degree care reasonably careful person would in same/similar circumstances
Emotional Distress Injuries
Negligent infliction of emotional distress
Zone of Danger I (fear for physical safety of oneself)
- recovery where P in foreseeable "zone of physcial danger" - threatened with bodily harm by D's negligence
- but escaped without physical injury
- so long as suffers (serios) distress
-which arose from P's fear for own safety
Zone of Danger II (fear for physical safety of another)
-Recovery where P in foreseeable "zone of physical dangers"
-but escaped without physical injury
- so long as suffers (serious) distress
- resulting from veiwing death or serious physical injury of immediate family
Bystander (thing Rule)
A bystander may recovery from NIED only if:
- closely related to injury victim
-present at the scene of injury producing event at time it occurs and then aware that it is causing injury to the victim;
- injury must be serious (implied); and
- as a result suffers serious emotional distress
(reaction must be beyond that of a disinterested witness and not an abnormal response to the circumstances )
Bystander (Clohessy )
A bystander may recover for NIED only if:
- plaintiff is closely related to injury victim (ex. parent or sibling)
- emotional injury to bystander may be caused by contemporaneous sensory perception of conduct causing injury or by arriving at scene soon thereafter before any substantia change in the victims condition or location;
-substantial injury to victim (death or serious physical injury);
- bystanders emotional injury must be serious
(beyond that of a disinterested witness and not the result of an abnormal response)
Independent Duty for emotional well being
-duty imposed by law
-duty assumed by defendant in which emotional condition of plaintiff is an objective
-duty exists under special relationship
Limited Duties care standard
if a limited duty is found then the level of care owed is that of a reasonable person unless otherwise stated (doctor, therapist, child)
Breach
did defendants conduct fall below level of care owed to plaintiff
-was defendants conduct unreasonable in light of foreseeable risk of harm
Breach Tools in most cases
- custom
-hand formula
- statutory
Breach Tools In special cases - Child in non adult activities
reasonable careful child of same AIMTE
Breach Tools In special cases- Medical Malpractice
Informed consent uses
-custom and prudent patient
Negligent medical preformance uses
- custom
Hand Formula
B=burden of adequate precautions to prevent an accident/harm
P= probability of potential accident/harm (prospective analysis)
X
L= loss= severity of potential injuries if an accident occurs (prospective analysis)
B>(P X L) -> NO BREACH OF DUTY OF CARE
V
Custom
what's typically done in a particular business setting
Custom may be evidence of what reasonable people do in that context
Plaintiff may use deviation from custom to help establish that defendant failed to exercise reasonable care (breached)
Defendant may use compliance with custom to help establish that they used reasonable care (did not breach)
Additional details for proving breach of reasonable care standard via custom
a. A custom can be used as evidence of reasonable care if that custom is in the same business as defendant and is fairly well defined such that defendant be charge with knowledge of it
A custom does not need to be universal in order to be used as evidence of reasonable care
Caveats regarding custom & reasonable care standard
In most cases reasonable prudence is in fact common prudence [custom]; but strictly it is never its measure; a whole calling may have unduly lagged in the adoption of new and available devices
There are precautions so imperative that even their universal disregard will not excuse their omission
ex. the custom of no radios in tug boats(bad custom)
Safety Statutes & the standard of care
If a safety statue, regulation, ordinance etc. applies to the conduct of a defendant in a negligence case and the defendant violated that statue without excuse, the evidentiary effect of the defendants violation, depending on the jurisdiction
Jurisdictional approaches to safety statutes
Negligence per se
Evidence of negligence
Negligence per se
statute becomes the standard of care
violation of the statute equals breach
Determining if a safety statute applies in a negligence case when the statute is silent on civil liability
1. Plaintiff is in the class of persons protected by the statute
2. Injury was of the type the statute was intended to prevent
Evidence of Negligence ( Safety Statutes)
Standard of care remains the reasonable care standard
Violation of the statute equals evidence of breach
- violation can be considered by jury in determining whether there was a breach
a. Violations of ordinances and regulations treated in the same manner as violations of safety statues in negligence cases in MOST states
Potential excuses for safety statute violation (not exclusvie list)
- Incapacity
o When defendant is literally physically incapable of following a safety statute
- Inability after reasonable diligence or care to comply
o If you are driving a care, going the speed limit, staying within the lines, etc. and then the brakes give out, the defendant has tried to comply
I. The defendant still needs to be a reasonable person who takes care of their brakes, the breaks going out has to be a first time occurrence
- Emergency not due to own misconduct
o Moose in the road
- Compliance involves a higher risk of harm to actors or others
o If there were no readily available ambulances and the defendant is driving a person who would be in greater harm had the defendant not driven fast to get them there, then it would apply
- Reasonable under all circumstances ("catch-all")
Res ipsa loquitor
"the thing speaks for itself"
a. Look to res ipsa when there is a piece in the story board of the accident missing
e.g. when you don't know why a barrel flew out of a window
Res ipsa loquitor Rule
accident = kind/type of accident that ordinarily doesn't occur in the absence of negligence;
defendant had exclusive control, or the right of exclusive control, over the instrumentality causing the harm to plaintiff; and
other potential causes of accident, including negligent conduct of plaintiff and third persons, sufficiently eliminated by evidence.
FOR BYSTANDER RULES ONLY NEED TO KNOW ONE AND KNOW THAT THJE DIFFERENCE IS TIMING,
o THING STRICTLY BARS RECOVERY IF THE PLAINTIFF ARRIVES MOMENTS AFTER
o CHLOHESSY ALLOWS FOR DISCRETION IF THE BYSTANDER ARRIVES SUBTSNTAILLY CONTEMPORANEOUSLY BEFORE THE SCENE CHANGES
Negligent medical performance (for physicians in general)
a doctor must act with the degree of, care knowledge and skill, ordinarily possessed and exercised in similar situations, by the average meber of the profession practicing in the SAME FEILD in the RELEVANT GEOGRAPHICAL LOCATION
Negligent medical performance for board-certified physicians
a doctor must act with the degree of care, knowledge, and skill ordinarily possessed and exercised in similar situations by the average member of the profession practicing in the same field (this is a national standard).
Additional details for negligent medical performance
- If an expert testifies as to more than one custom in a particular situation, use any acceptable method; protects v. liability
- If the common knowledge exception applies, then no expert witness is required to establish custom
common knowledge exception (negligent medical preformance)
something so negligent that the lay person would understand was negligent
ex. leaving an object in someones body after surgery
Standard of care in med mal
the medical custom/SOC controls and is conclusive;
if a doctor complied with the custom= exercise due care
if doctor deviated from custom/SOC they have breached
Informed consent - Medical professional (traditional or custom standard of care)
doctor must provide inform/advise (options risk etc.) which the average member of the medical profession practicing in the same field in the relevant geographical community would have given to the patient
Informed consent- Prudent patient (aka layperson) SOC
doctor must provide inform/advice (options, risks etc.) which a reasonable person in the patient's position would have considered significant/material in making a treatment decision
Slip and Fall cases (CAM)
C- -constructive notice
A- actual ntoice
M- mode of operations test
Actual Notice
defendant in fact knew/aware of unsafe condition which lead to plaintiff slip and fall
- can be telling someone of the condition or a camera that alerts a human of the condition
Constructive Notice
defendant considered to have known about the unsafe condition on their premises because said condition existed for a long enough period of time that defendant should have known about it
Mode of operations test
allows plaintiff in slip and fall cases to sue on theory that defendants decision to display products in a certain way or opt for self service was unreasonable
Causation
Cause in fact= actual cause
uses the but/for test and the substantial factor test
but for test
But for the defendants' negligent conduct, the plaintiffs harm wouldn't have occurred
Jury asks whether Defendant's breach was a cause of Plaintiff's injury? (aka did Defendant'sbreach play a role in Plaintiff 's injury?)• Jury does NOT ask whether Defendant's breach was the cause of Plaintiff's injury?
Substantial Factor Test
(mostly used in multiple cause cases)
Defendants' negligence is a contributing factor to the plaintiff's harm to some extent
Joint and several liability
a. When two or more independently negligent defendants cause a plaintiff to suffer a single indivisible harm, then courts may hold each defendant liable for the plaintiff's entire harm, either together(i.e., joint liability) or separately (i.e., several liability); but
b. the plaintiff can get only one full recovery for their harm (i.e., plaintiff cannot recover more than 100% of their harm by suing each defendant in a separate lawsuit).
c. When two or more independently negligent defendants cause a plaintiff to suffer two or more divisible harm(s), then joint and several liability does not apply and each defendant will pay for the specific harm(s) they caused.
alternative liability
When one, and only one of two or more negligent defendants caused the plaintiff's harm, but it is unclear which one the courts may use the theory of alternative liability
- it shifts the burden to defendants to rpove which one of them caused plaintiffs harm and;
of they cannot do so joint and several liability applies
test for informed consent - objective test (jdx split 1)
The doctor's negligent failure to ensure informed consent was a substantial factor in the treatment decision of objective reasonable person in the plaintiff's position
Test for informed consent - subjective test
doctors negligent failure to ensure informed consent was a substantial factor in treatment decision of plaintiff IN THIS CASE
Scope of Liability/Proximate Cause
-did the defendant's obligation include the general type of harm the plaintiff suffered? Are there intervening causes that are so unexpected that they are superseding?
Foreseeability test
- foreseeable plaintiff?
-foreseeable harm?
-intervening conduct or forces?
Foreseeable Plaintiff
was the ahrm to plaintiff (or other in plaintiff's class) foreseeable (within the scope of the risk created by d's careless act?)
Foreseeable harm?
did D's careless acts create foreseeable risk of general type of injury P suffered?
Intervening conduct or forces
if yes (if there are other forces at play) ask whether intervening conduct or force as a foreseeable risk of initial actors neglgeince, foreseeable?
Exceptions to foreseeablility
medical malpractice complications rule
eggshell/thin skulled plaintiff rule
eggshell pysche rule
rescuer rule
Medical malpractice complications rule
Initial tortfeasor subject to total financial burden of plaintiffs injuries, including those attributable to doctors' subsequent conduct
medical complications rule is not limited to medical care, some courts extend liability to plaintiffs while in transport to the hospital
Eggshell/ thin skulled plaintiff rule
The negligent actor is subject to liability for harm to another, although a physical condition of the other which is neither known nor should be known to the actor makes the injury greater than that of which the actor as a reasonable person, should have foreseen; OR
- the defendant takes plaintiff as he finds him
Egg shell psyche rule
if defendants negligence physically injures plaintiff and causes emotional injury aggravated by a preexisting mental condition -->eggshell rule applies; BUT
If defendant's negligence causes emotional injuries to plaintiff with a preexisting mental condition without causing any physical injury --> eggshell rule may be non-applicable depending on jdx
Rescuer rule
danger invites rescue
Compensatory Damages
Damages used to make the plaintiff whole- Economic / pecuniary (past & future)
o Medical expenses
o Lost earning capacity /wages
- Non economic (past & future)
o Pain and suffedring (physical and emotional )
o Loss of enjoyment of life
o Permenant disability or impairment of bodily function
Additional Details for Compensatory damages
- compensatory damages include past and future medical expenses which are reasonable and medically necessary
- plaintiff is not required to select the least expensive alternative among various reasonable options for medically necessary treatment
Collateral Source Rule
payments to injured party from collateral source (insurance) generallyis not allowed to dimish damages recoverable from tortfeasor
Mitigation of Damages
plaintiff unreasonably fails/refuses to undergo treatment which would aliveate difficulties --> defendant may be relieved of responsibility for damages
Lost earning capacity calculations with seriously injured young plaintiffs
Forensic experts rely on the following elements:
- statistical data on average education attainment
-average or median earnings tables to establish anticipated base annual earnings
determination of average number of projected work life years
-growth rate in base earnings over work life (e.g. projections of promotions, bonuses, inflation, etc.)
- selection of discount rate to apply to total projected future earnings to reduce total present value rate
Wrongful death statute (to compensate the loss to dependents/heirs for the death of a family member)
Spouse, children, parents, siblings, and, in a few states, domestic partners can recover :
- economic loss
- non-economic loss
- loss of consortium
(Not sorrow and grief) Spouse,
Loss of consortium
loss of (society, comfort, and protection ) - generally comparable society
Survival Statute (loss to decedents estate)
Allow damage recovery for :
- losses and harm to the victim from the time of the accident to time of death
- economic loss
-medical expenses
-lost wages
Non-economic loss
-pain and suffering
-loss of enjoyment of life
- funeral burial expenses
Punitive Damages (punishing damages )
Factors to consider :
1) Likelihood at time of D's misconduct of serious harm;
2) Degree of D's awareness of that likelihood;
3) Profitability of D's misconduct
4) Attitude and conduct of D on discovery of the misconduct
5) Financial assets and income of D; and
6) Total deterrent effect of other punishments imposed on D