1/776
Cumulative
Why Practice Ethically?
1. Avoid Punishment
- Individual → Lawsuits/Disciplinary action (BORID, peer review)/Reputation
- Collectively → Reputation/Loss of professional autonomy
2. It's the Right Thing to Do
- Ethics is an end in itself
- Ethics is not outcome-based
3. Builds a Better Practice
- Enhances reputation
- Fosters patient trust
Can a misleading statement be unethical even if the patient doesn't believe it?
Yes; the ADA Code focuses on the dentist's conduct, not the patient's reaction
Unethical examples implying specialty (TA review)
'My office calls me King Endo.' 'I mostly do endodontics.' 'I dream about obturation.'
Consent vs informed consent
Not the same: the obligation is to give enough information for an informed decision, not simply to obtain agreement
Guild model (Ozar)
Dentist decides what is best and primarily presents that option
Agent model (Ozar)
Dentist presents options and gives the patient decision-making authority
Ethical treatment planning balances…
Professional judgment, patient autonomy, informed consent
Where/when can a dentist-patient relationship begin?
Anywhere, anytime, whenever a patient could reasonably interpret your statements as professional advice
Does the dentist-patient relationship require treatment, an appointment, or being in an office?
No, none of these
Voluntary acceptance of the doctor-patient relationship creates…
A prima facie presumption of a contractual relationship ('at first sight / on the face of it')
Contract (relationship context)
An agreement creating obligations to do or not do certain things
Duties of the dentist (10)
Proper licensure/credentials
adequate CE
informed consent
confidentiality
follow state laws/regulations
care at or above standard of care
appropriate referrals
accurate records
available for emergencies
follow the Code of Ethics
Duties of the patient (5)
Keep appointments
follow home-care instructions
provide truthful information
pay fees
behave appropriately
Unethical discrimination: protected characteristics
Race, religion, gender, disability, sexual orientation, age, ethnicity, national origin
Ethical discrimination: reasons a dentist may decline patients
Service outside scope of practice
insurance/payment issues
patient chooses inappropriate treatment
dentist-patient incompatibility
Emergency care: whom must you make reasonable arrangements for?
Your own patients AND patients not of record presenting with emergencies
'Reasonable arrangements for emergency care' example
Giving contact info for another available dentist (e.g., while you're on vacation)
Once treatment has begun, a dentist should not discontinue without…
Adequate notice, opportunity to secure another dentist, protecting the patient's oral health
Greatest ethical concern when refusing treatment
Patient abandonment
Does nonpayment alone justify immediately stopping treatment?
No, not if doing so would constitute abandonment
T or F - A statement can be unethical even if a patient was not harmed or misled.
True
Which three components are required for informed consent? a. Risks, benefits, cost b. Risks, benefits, alternatives c. Diagnosis, treatment, insurance coverage d. Risks, alternatives, prognosis
B. Risks, benefits, alternatives
A dentist stops treating a patient they missed a payment without notice or referral. What is the primary ethical concern? a. Upcoding b. Kickbacks c. Patient abandonment d. Breach of confidentiality e. This is ethically sound
C. Patient abandonment
Upcoding (definition)
Billing for a more expensive procedure than performed (e.g., single-surface filling billed as multi-surface)
Unbundling (definition)
Separately billing procedures that should be billed together
Inadequate documentation (fraud)
Poor charts, records, radiographs, note-taking
Billing for services not rendered
Charging for treatment or visits that never occurred
Medically unnecessary treatment (fraud)
Treatment with no clinical justification (e.g., FMX every 6 months for routine hygiene)
Unauthorized/unlicensed services (fraud)
Allowing assistants/unlicensed individuals to perform procedures outside their legal scope
Kickback example besides gifts
Free treatment for referrals
Administrative fraud cases: whose program contracts?
MassHealth/Delta have their own program contracts and requirements; can suspend or terminate you from the program
Civil fraud case: what can you owe?
Treble damages, per-violation penalties, litigation costs and attorneys' fees
Criminal fraud case: typical conduct
Fraud, kickbacks, abuse, billing for services not rendered
Dr. Paper Clip: additional charges/impact (TA)
Obstruction of justice and an altered public view of the dental profession; guilty plea and jail
A dentist performs a one-surface composite but bills for a three-surface composite. This is: a. Upcoding b. Unbundling c. Abandonment d. Breach of contract
A. Upcoding
T or F - A dentist can avoid liability by stating the office manager submitted fraudulent claims without the dentist's knowledge.
False (agency is not a defense)
An Ortho clinic opens down the street from your practice and proposes that for every referral you make to them, they will gift your office a $200 gift card. Is this ethical? a. Yes! I was going to refer to them anyway b. Maybe.. so long that no one gets hurt c. No.
C. No (kickback)
What does signing a contract presume?
The parties entered it knowingly and voluntarily
Common contract terms
Salary, bonus structure, vacation time, emergency call responsibilities, benefits, non-compete clauses
Production-based compensation
Associate earns a % of procedures performed
Collection-based compensation
Most common: associate earns a % of revenue collected by the practice
Fixed salary compensation
Predetermined salary regardless of production
Ethical issue with compensation models
They may influence treatment recommendations and create conflicts of interest
Independent contractor (TA definition)
Hired to perform specific services; less employer control (associate/employee = more benefits, more control)
Why MA courts made physician non-competes unenforceable
Public interest in letting patients choose their healthcare provider
Are restrictive covenants enforceable in dentistry right now?
Yes (whether to extend physician protections to dentists is up for debate)
Which compensation model is most commonly used for associate dentists? a. Fixed salary b. Hourly wage c. Collection-based compensation d. Sign-on bonus
C. Collection-based compensation
An associate signs a written contract without a signing bonus. A month later the employer verbally promises a $10,000 bonus, never added in writing. T or F - The associate will win the dispute because the verbal promise was made most recently.
False (the written contract is the entire agreement)
A clause that prevents a dentist from practicing within a certain geographic area after leaving employment is called: a. Informed consent clause b. Restrictive covenant c. Geographic clause d. Arbitration clause
B. Restrictive covenant
Why social media matters for dentists
Patients research, choose and review providers online; online conduct shapes perceived competence and trustworthiness
'Context collapse' online
Once public, a post can be screenshotted, redistributed and judged without the intended tone
Social media key takeaway
Social media is an extension of professional responsibility; 'off duty' doesn't mean free from professional consequences
Social media risk: confidentiality & HIPAA
Identifiable patient details disclosed without authorization, including accidental disclosures
Social media risk: informed consent
Filming or posting without specific, informed, unpressured authorization
Social media risk: patient safety
Content production takes attention away from the patient and procedure
Social media risk: unprofessional conduct
Jokes, language or behavior that undermine trust in the profession
Social media risk: boundary violations
Patient messages or relationships crossing professional lines
Central privacy test for social media
Identifiability, not whether a name is visible
Patient consent given while on camera or mid-treatment
May not be freely given (pressure, may not understand implications)
What must posting authorization specify?
What is shown, where it will be published, intended audience; obtained before publication
'The Great Reveal' scenario answer
B: get specific written authorization for the exact use before posting
Camera as a 'second patient'
Filming competes for the clinician's attention: a standard-of-care issue, not only privacy
Dr. Roxy Grawe: what did the board focus on?
Failure to meet the standard of care and patient safety (3 patients had serious complications), not merely online privacy
How can a personal post become associated with the practice?
Scrubs, a badge, or a treatment room in the background
Lexie Lawler, RN: what happened?
L&D nurse posted an explicit TikTok wishing a public figure a severe childbirth injury; fired, summary license suspension (appeal ongoing)
Nursing facility 'It was just a joke' case
Comedy skits about overmedicating patients and unplugging a ventilator to charge a phone; suspended. Humor doesn't remove professional implications
Dr. Kenny Smiles' real name
Kenneth Wilstead, DDS
Kenny Smiles: what was he disciplined for (2015, 2019, 2021)?
Prescribing, standard of care, recordkeeping; newer allegations (explicit messages, inappropriate touching suit) not adjudicated
Boundary violations: does the platform or a persona excuse misconduct?
No; boards assess the underlying conduct
AI uses discussed in lecture
Ambient scribes, patient-facing chatbots, AI captions, synthetic before/after images, generated reviews
Do AI tools change the underlying professional standards?
No: confidentiality, informed consent, accuracy and patient safety still apply
Abridge AI ambient-scribe lawsuit
2026 class action vs Sutter Health and Memorial Healthcare Services: exam-room conversations allegedly recorded, sent off-site and processed without adequate notice or consent
Abridge lawsuit takeaway
Convenience does not replace proper consent and safeguards
2026 Oxford-led trial (~1,300 people) on AI chatbots
Chatbots did not outperform web search or patients' own judgment for identifying a condition and next step
FTC Fake Reviews Rule effective date
September 2024 (max $51,744 per violation per the slide)
'The Helpful Shortcut' scenario (colleague pastes notes into a free chatbot)
B: use only a practice-vetted, contracted tool with a BAA; never a free public chatbot
Five responsible AI practices
Never paste PHI into public AI; disclose AI-generated/altered content; verify output yourself; consent for tools that listen/record; never fabricate reviews
Dr. Ben Winters ('The Bentist') details
Orthodontist, 16M+ followers; myth-busting and general ortho questions (broken wires, Invisalign care)
Reckless vs responsible social media: content
Reckless: real, identifiable patient or procedure. Responsible: general, de-identified education
Reckless vs responsible: consent
Reckless: implied/assumed/skipped. Responsible: specific, written, revocable for anything patient-related
Reckless vs responsible: priorities
Reckless: engagement before judgment and safety. Responsible: clinical judgment and patient attention before the camera
Reckless vs responsible: tone
Reckless: jokes you'd never say in the operatory. Responsible: tone a patient, employer or board could watch
Reckless vs responsible: AI
Reckless: patient details in whatever AI is fastest. Responsible: only vetted, contracted AI tools
Do a patient's own public statements authorize you to disclose PHI in reply?
No
Must you stay completely silent on a bad review?
No; a neutral response that discloses no patient information is permitted
Six overarching social media messages
1 No 'off duty' license; 2 HIPAA applies online — identifiability is the test; 3 distraction is a safety issue; 4 AI raises the same questions, faster; 5 cases show consent skipped, boundaries blurred, 'it was a joke'; 6 would it hold up before a patient, employer and board?
Standard for every post and every prompt
Would this hold up in front of a patient, an employer, and a licensing board?
TUSDM Code of Conduct (courtesy)
Respect all community members; no comments about patients or disparaging statements about students, faculty or staff in public
A dental student takes a photograph of a patient's completed anterior restorations for clinical documentation. The patient gives verbal permission to post it on Instagram. Per TUSDM policy? a) Post if the face is cropped out b) Obtain written consent before posting c) Post only through a private professional account d) Do not post the patient photograph on social media
D. Do not post the patient photograph on social media
A dentist begins using an AI ambient-scribe app that records patient conversations and generates notes. MOST important consideration? a) AI notes grammatically correct b) Appropriate patient consent and an approved, appropriately contracted system c) Deleting recordings after notes are generated d) Informing patients only when the AI detects a significant diagnosis
B. Appropriate patient consent and an approved, appropriately contracted system
A patient leaves a negative online review with inaccurate claims about treatment. MOST appropriate response? a) Publicly explain the treatment performed b) Confirm the patient was treated but avoid the diagnosis c) Respond neutrally and invite private discussion without confirming patient status d) Ask them to remove it and publish records if they refuse
C. Respond neutrally and invite private discussion without confirming patient status
Lookhart: ethical/legal issues
Nonmaleficence, autonomy/informed consent, competence, standard of care, honesty in billing, fraud
Lookhart exam takeaway
Patient safety and informed consent always outweigh entertainment, convenience or financial gain
Dr. Paper Clip: why paper clips?
To save money (material substitution)
Dr. Paper Clip exam takeaway
Material placed must match the indicated treatment and the billing record; cost-cutting can't justify deception
Pay to Play exam takeaway
Even when services are delivered, recruitment, consent and payment methods can be unethical or unlawful
Dr. Gus Khalifa: what happened and outcome
Endodontist answered a negative Yelp review after RCT by describing the patient's history; Arizona board complaint (potential discipline, outcome not confirmed)
Khalifa exam takeaway
Don't disclose or confirm treatment details publicly, even when a review is inaccurate
Dr. Lakshmi Bethi: ethical/legal issues
Improper referrals, conflicts of interest, potential fraud, commercialization of clinical judgment
Neglect includes (TA list)
Failure to provide adequate food, clothing, shelter, medical care, supervision, emotional support, other essential care