W2: Argument mapping and evaluation

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/55

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

56 Terms

1
New cards

What are complex arguments?

A set of arguments consisting of intermediate conclusion(s) which act as the premise to support a main conclusion at the end

2
New cards

What are the 2 conditions for a good/strong argument?

  1. Its premises must be true

  2. Its premises must be connected to its conclusion in the right way (and the conclusion can be false)


3
New cards

How is this a bad argument: “Canberra is the capital of Australia. Therefore, Tokyo is the capital of Japan.”

The premise does not support the conclusion (even though it is true)

4
New cards

What is a good argument NOT the same as??

Good ≠ persuasive (bad arguments can also persuade)

5
New cards

Validity and soundness (no definition)

6
New cards

What are the conditions for a valid argument?

It is impossible for the conclusion to be false while ALL the premises are true (aka conclusion must follow all premises and be true)

7
New cards

Which combination is a valid argument?

  1. An argument with false premises and a true conclusion

  2. An argument with true premises and a false conclusion


1


E.g. All cats are birds, all birds are mammals, therefore cats are mammals

8
New cards

Going back to the Canberra and Tokyo example, is that argument valid?

No, the conclusion possibly being false (Tokyo is not the capital of Japan) does not contradict the premise being true (Canberra is the capital of Aus)

9
New cards

What are the 4 rules/forms of valid arguments? (just identify, no need any background knowledge)

  1. Modus Ponens (affirming the antecedent)

  2. Modus Tollens (denying the consequent)

  3. BARBARA

  4. Tautology in the conclusion


10
New cards

What is Modus Ponens?

  1. If A, then B (if Bob studied, he will pass the exam)

  2. A (Bob studied)

  3. ∴ B (So, he will pass the exam) 


11
New cards

What is Modus Tollens?

  1. If A, then B (if Bob studied, he will pass the exam)

  2. Not B (Bob did not pass the exam) 

  3. ∴ Not A (So, Bob did not study)


12
New cards

What is BARBARA?

  1. All Fs are G (all mammals are warm blooded)

  2. All Hs are F (cats are mammals) 

  3. ∴ All Hs are G (cats are warm blooded) 


13
New cards

What is an example of a tautology statement?

“It will rain tomorrow, or it will not rain tomorrow." (One of these two outcomes must be true).

14
New cards

What are the 2 rules/forms of invalid arguments?

  1. Affirming the consequent

  2. Denying the antecedent


15
New cards

What is the format for affirming the consequent?

  1. If A, then B (if Bob studied, he will pass the exam)

  2. B (Bob passed the exam)

  3. ∴ A (So, Bob studied)

  • Bob could have passed the exam through other means


16
New cards

What is the format for denying the antecedent?

  1. If A, then B (if Bob studied, he will pass the exam)

  2. Not A (Bob did not study) 

  3. ∴ Not B (He will not pass the exam) 

  • He could still pass the exam without studying


17
New cards

Suppose all the sub-arguments in a complex arguments are valid, does this mean the argument as a whole is valid too?

Yes

18
New cards

Suppose one of the sub-arguments in a complex arguments is invalid, does this mean the argument as a whole is invalid too?

No, if at least one of the routes of premise>int conclusion is valid, the main conclusion is still valid (still have to check the validity of all routes)

<p>No, if at least one of the routes of premise&gt;int conclusion is valid, the main conclusion is still valid (still have to check the validity of all routes) </p>
19
New cards

What are the 2 categories of arguments?

  1. Deductive arguments

  2. Inductive arguments


20
New cards

What are deductive arguments?

Arguments that aim for guaranteed certainty; validity (e.g. mathematical and logical proofs)

21
New cards

What are inductive arguments?

Arguments that are invalid, but aims for argument strength

22
New cards

What are the 3 common types of inductive arguments?

  1. Inductive generalisation

  2. Analogy

  3. Inference to the best explanation (IBE) (“Abduction”)


23
New cards

What is inductive generalisation?

Arguments that generalise to all/most cases from past experience/majority stats

24
New cards

What 2 aspects are important for inductive generalisation?

Sample size and quality (for representativeness)

25
New cards

What is this argument called: “Each morning, the sun has risen out of the east. So, the sun will rise out of the east tomorrow” 

An argument by analogy

26
New cards

What does the format of arguments by analogy look like?

  1. a has feature F

  2. b resembles a, in some relevant way

  3. ∴ b has feature F


27
New cards

What is the difference between an inductive generalisation and an analogy based on the previous example?

  • An argument from analogy moves from observed cases to a claim about one particular new case that is similar to the others

  • An inductive generalisation moves from observed cases to a claim about all or most cases (“the sun will always rise from the east”)


28
New cards

But what is good about inductive arguments in general?

They are strong (invalid arguments can be strong)

29
New cards

What is the general consensus to a strong inductive argument?

If the premises make it hard to believe the conclusion could be false

30
New cards

What is Inference to the best explanation?

An argument with

  1. Some observed evidence

  2. A hypothesis that explains them


<p>An argument with </p><ol><li><p>Some observed evidence</p></li><li><p>A hypothesis that explains them</p></li></ol><p></p>
31
New cards

What do the premises and conclusion act as?

  • Premises: observations/explanations

  • Conclusion: hypothesis


32
New cards

What are the 3 types of explanations?

  1. Causal

  2. Constitutive

  3. Teleological


33
New cards

What are the 3 types of explanations based on?

  1. Causal - based on mechanisms (“the bridge collapsed because of the earthquake”)

  2. Constitutive - based on definitions (“17 is a prime no. as it is divisible by itself and 1”)

  3. Teleological - based on an agent’s goal (“Bob is studying in order to do well for his exam”)


34
New cards

What makes an explanation better than another?

A simple explanation with fewer surprising assumptions is better

35
New cards

What are the 2 conditions for a sound argument?

  1. It is valid (true conclusion)

  2. Its premises are ALL true


36
New cards

What do you do when you spot an invalid argument?

Look to bridge the gap between the premise(s) and conclusion by coming up with a hidden premise (refer to ipad notes)

37
New cards

What is the relationship between hidden premises, validity and soundness?

Adding an extra hidden premise can improve the validity of an invalid argument, BUT doesn’t improve soundness IF the premises are false

38
New cards

Objection (no definition)

39
New cards

What are the 2 ways to criticise an argument? (// 2 features of a good argument)

  1. Show that at least one of its premises is false

  2. Show that the premises are not connected to the conclusion in the right way


40
New cards

What are 2 ways to prove the falsity of a premise?

  1. Using a counterexample

  2. Reductio ad absurdam (reduction to the absurd)


41
New cards

What constitutes a counterexample?

A specific example that directly attacks a universal claim (e.g. dumping waste in the river)

<p>A <strong>specific</strong> example that directly attacks a universal claim (e.g. dumping waste in the river)</p>
42
New cards

What is an “absurd”?

A statement of set of statements that is obviously false

43
New cards

What is the similarity and difference between the two methods?

  • S: They both aim to refute a statement/premise

  • D: Counterexamples are restricted to universal generalisations, but RAA is not (can work in any case)


44
New cards

What are the 3 steps of reductio ad absurdum?

  1. Assume a statement you think is false/absurd to be true first (e.g. if everyone printed their own money, everyone would be rich)

  2. Follow the logic to validly derive an obviously false (“absurd”) conclusion (e.g. that would render money worthless)

  3. Conclude that the original statement was false


45
New cards

What are the 3 conditions for reductio ad absurdum refutation to succeed?

  1. The conclusion really must be absurd

  2. The absurd conclusion must be logically followed by the premise(s) we seek to refute

  3. Any extra premise(s) we had to use in the derivation must be true (‘for’ premises)


46
New cards

How do you display it on an argument map?

The conclusion of the separate argument points towards the premise you’re trying to disagree with

<p>The conclusion of the separate argument points towards the premise you’re trying to disagree with</p>
47
New cards

How do you prove that the premises and conclusion are not connected correctly?

Through principles of validity/inductive strength (aka alternative reasoning)

48
New cards

When refuting based on validity, what must we take note of?

It’s only a possibility when you say the conclusion is false > use words like ‘might’

<p>It’s only a possibility when you say the conclusion is false &gt;  use words like ‘might’</p>
49
New cards

How do you display it on an argument map?

The alternative reasoning points towards the area between the premises and conclusion (middle of the conclusion arrow)

<p>The alternative reasoning points towards the area between the premises and conclusion (<u>middle of the conclusion arrow)</u></p>
50
New cards

What is an objection to an objection called?

A rebuttal

51
New cards

How do you display it on an argument map?

The rebuttal point point towards the objection point

<p>The rebuttal point point towards the objection point</p>
52
New cards

What is the burden of proof?

Instead of giving positive arguments for your position, you can argue that your position should be accepted by default, and your opponent has to prove that you are wrong

53
New cards

What would this look like in a argument passage?

Arguing for a conclusion by coming up with rebuttals to multiple objections

54
New cards

What is an important informal fallacy that forms a bad argument?

Slippery slope fallacy

55
New cards

What gives rise the slippery slope arguments?

Vagueness and heaps (lack of evidence, steps)

56
New cards

What type of slippery slope is this: “if we legalise marijuana, then soon we will be pushed to legalise the use of hard drugs like heroin and cocaine, and pretty soon, everything will be allowed.”

Causal slippery slope