1/15
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What are the 4 Economic Questions?
How much are we altering the climate?
CO2 and Methane emissions trap heat.
Mostly comes from burning fossil fuels and other human causes.
Ex: Trees release CO2 when cut down, and icebergs release methane when melted.
Emissions are byproducts of economic activities because everything we do causes some sort of pollution.
Ex: transportation, agriculture, energy, etc..
What are the consequences/damages?
Economic damages, risks, and who bears them?
What can we do about it?
Mitigation (reduce emissions) vs adaptation (adjust to change as they happen).
What are we actually doing?
Real-world policies - national and international.
Not really effective if not everyone is committed to it.
It is impossible for us not to pollute. The goal is to pollute at a rate that is not harmful and is balanced.
What can we do with climate change / how can we deal with it?
Mitigation: Deal with it.
Reduce or prevent greenhouse gas emissions at the source. Taking action now.
Examples: carbon taxes, renewable energy, cap-and-trade, cleaner technology
Adaptation: Adapt to the situation.
Adjust systems and behavior to live with a changing climate.
Examples: sea walls, drought-resistant crops, updated building codes, insurance.
A little bit of both would be helpful. We use a bit of both.
What are the costs of acting or not acting?
Cost of acting
Transitioning energy systems, new technology, regulatory compliance, real, often near-term costs.
Future is unknown.
Cost of inaction
Damages compound over time and fall disproportionately on future generations and vulnerable regions - often larger but delayed.
What are we doing currently?
National policy
Everyone needs to be in on this, or else it would not be effective or could even be more harmful.
Ex: Carbon taxes, cap-and-trade systems, clean energy subsidies, regulations
International agreements
The Paris Agreement and country-level emissions pledges (NDC)
Private sector action
Corporate net-zero pledges, green investment, technology information.
Problems/who bears the costs and benefits:
(Rich nations Vs developing nations)
The more you develop, the more pollution you produce
Rich countries emit the most, and poor countries face the largest damages.
What is Discounting
We are looking at the real rate, meaning we take inflation out of it.
Time preference (value of time) makes it that it is better to have a dollar today than in the future because the future is uncertain.
You know what you can do with the dollar today.
Investing - get money today; you can invest it and have it be worth more in the future.
Matters because how high or low the discount rate is determines how much value now vs the future.
Future value (FV)
The dollar amount of a cost or benefit at the point in time it actually occurs.
Expected worth of a current asset or cash amount at a specific date in the future, based on an assumed rate of growth or interest
Ex: $500 in avoided flood damage, occurring in the year 2050. (Not worth as much).
Present Value (PV)
What that same future amount is worth today, once we account for the fact that money (and damage) in the future counts for less
Why? A dollar today can be invested, spent, or used to prevent harm right now, a dollar later can’t.
Very different results depending on which discount rates you use.
Low discount rates =
Bigger benefit for the future. Favors the future more than the present.
Future benefit is valued more in the present.
Prioritizes long-term rewards rather than immediate rewards.
Very different results depending on which discount rates you use.
High discount rates =
Smaller benefit for the future. Favors the present more than the future.
Future benefits are valued less in the present.
Prioritizes present (right now) rewards over long-term rewards.
What is the equation for finding PV?
PV = FV / (1+r)^t
What does each letter represent in PV = FV / (1+r)^t?
PV = present value
FV = future value
R = discount rate (convert to a decimal)
T = time
Utilitarianism
Maximizing total well-being
Policy is good if it produces the greatest total benefit, summed across everyone affected - even if some individuals bear more cost than others.
Policy is good as long as the majority of the people are benefitted. Even if some groups have to suffer for it.
Rights-based ethics
Respect individual rights
Policy is good only if it doesn’t violate certain rights or protections - even if violating them would raise total well-being.
Basically, policy is bad if even one group suffers.
Intergenerational Equity
The people making the decisions today (us) are not the same people who will bear many of the consequences (future generations). They can’t vote, negotiate, or object to the choices we make now.
Our actions affect future generations. Do we have the right to do that? Do we know what they may want? Do we know what situations the future generations would be in? Do we know how they will be affected? We do not know what the future holds.
Lower discount rate = you think the future is more important (puts pressure on doing something now).
Higher discount rate = you think the present is more important. Discounts more, so the amount becomes smaller.
Market failure
We do not account for the small details. As in, we do not know what the market value for a polar bear is because we do not sell polar bears on the market.