Negligence - Breach of Duty

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/383

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

384 Terms

1
New cards
  1. As an independent tort, negligence began to emerge in the early ____________ century, roughly around ____________.


nineteenth | 1825 [pp. 193-194]

2
New cards
  1. Prior to independent negligence liability, the term sometimes referred generally to the __________________ or to inadvertence or inattention within other torts.


breach of any legal obligation [pp. 193-194]

3
New cards
  1. The growth of negligence as a separate tort coincided substantially with the __________________ in England.

Industrial Revolution [pp. 193-194]

4
New cards
  1. A __________________, ____________, ____________, or ____________ exemplified an early public calling carrying an obligation to provide competent service.

common carrier | innkeeper | blacksmith | surgeon [p. 193]

5
New cards
  1. The early form of action known as __________________ helped develop negligence liability.

trespass on the case [p. 193]

6
New cards
  1. Historical ____________ and ____________ were once distinguished partly by the directness of the injury.

trespass | case [p. 193]

7
New cards
  1. The historical development shifted from negligence as a manner of committing other wrongs to negligence as an __________________.

independent basis of tort liability [p. 193]

8
New cards
  1. A claim involving an unintended injury could be pursued as ____________ rather than requiring the same intentional invasion as an intentional tort.

negligence [p. 193]

9
New cards
  1. The modern negligence action is not established simply by identifying ____________: its additional elements must be proved.

inattention [pp. 193-195]

10
New cards
  1. The rise of industrial ____________ and ____________ created risks that encouraged recognition of negligence liability.

machinery | railways [p. 193]

11
New cards
  1. The textbook distinguishes the historical development of liability for __________________ from that for __________________.

intentional injuries | unintended injuries [pp. 193-194]

12
New cards
  1. The history section supplies ____________, not a substitute for the five present-day elements of negligence.

context [pp. 193-194]

13
New cards

H1.1 A nineteenth-century railway accident injures a traveler without any deliberate contact. Analyze: What legal development made an independent suit possible? Identify the likely liability theory.

The emergence of negligence from trespass on the case as an independent cause of action; ordinary negligence rather than an intentional tort if no intent to produce the relevant contact.

14
New cards

H1.2 A student argues: “Negligence is just one type of intentional battery.” Analyze: Explain why the historical use of the term “negligent battery” cannot determine the modern cause of action.

Modern tort law distinguishes intentional conduct directed toward the contact from unreasonable conduct causing unintended harm; the historical phrase is an outdated classification.

15
New cards

H1.3 A plaintiff knows a factory was dangerous but has no evidence of personal harm. Analyze: Does the history of negligence create a damages claim?

No. Historical evolution does not replace the modern elements, including legally sufficient damage.

16
New cards
  1. Intentional tort liability ordinarily focuses on the required ____________; negligence focuses on a failure to exercise __________________.

intent | reasonable care [p. 193]

17
New cards
  1. The historical term 'negligent battery' should not obscure the modern difference between an __________________ and an __________________.

intentional touching | unreasonable unintended injury [p. 193]

18
New cards
  1. Historical context does not relieve a modern plaintiff of the burden to establish the elements of the __________________.

cause of action [p. 194]

19
New cards
  1. The historical account describes the evolution of the ____________, rather than one mandatory statute enacted uniformly in all states.

common law [p. 193]

20
New cards
  1. The text lists ____________ analytically distinct elements for a completed negligence cause of action.

five [pp. 194-195]

21
New cards
  1. The chapter focuses primarily on the ____________ element, breach, although it introduces the full claim.

second [pp. 194-195]

22
New cards
  1. ____________ means a legally recognized obligation to conform conduct to a standard protecting others from unreasonable risks.

Duty [pp. 194-195]

23
New cards
  1. ____________ means failure to conform to the required standard of conduct.

Breach [pp. 194-195]

24
New cards
  1. __________________ asks whether the tortious conduct caused the resulting injury.

Factual causation [pp. 194-195]

25
New cards
  1. __________________ limits the injuries for which the defendant may fairly be held responsible; it is also called __________________ or ____________.

Scope of liability | proximate cause | legal cause [pp. 194-195]

26
New cards
  1. __________________ is necessary to complete a negligence claim.

Actual loss or damage [pp. 194-195]

27
New cards
  1. A defendant may act unreasonably and yet avoid negligence liability if no legal ____________ was owed to the plaintiff.

duty [pp. 194-195]

28
New cards
  1. Even when duty and breach are established, the plaintiff must show actual ____________ and legally sufficient ____________.

causation | damage [pp. 194-195]

29
New cards
  1. The text treats factual causation and __________________ as distinct concepts in Chapters 5 and 6.

scope of liability [pp. 194-195]

30
New cards
  1. Element 1: The defendant owed a duty to exercise __________________.

reasonable care [pp. 194-195]

31
New cards
  1. Element 2: The defendant ____________ the applicable standard.

breached [pp. 194-195]

32
New cards
  1. Element 3: The defendant's breach was an __________________ of the harm.

actual/factual cause [pp. 194-195]

33
New cards
  1. Element 4: The harm falls within the __________________ attributable to the breach.

scope of liability [pp. 194-195]

34
New cards
  1. Element 5: The plaintiff sustained __________________.

actual loss or damage [pp. 194-195]

35
New cards
  1. The legal existence of a duty is generally a __________________ determined by the ____________.

question of law | court [pp. 194-195]

36
New cards
  1. Whether conduct breached the duty is ordinarily a __________________ for a ____________, subject to dispositive judicial rulings where reasonable jurors could not disagree.

question of fact | jury [pp. 194-195]

37
New cards
  1. The plaintiff's conduct can be analyzed under the reasonable-care standard when the defendant asserts __________________ or __________________.

contributory negligence | comparative fault [pp. 194-195]

38
New cards
  1. Negligence does not ordinarily permit ____________ damages when no actual injury is proved.

nominal [p. 195]

39
New cards
  1. A successful __________________ concerning plaintiff fault may reduce or bar recovery under the applicable jurisdiction's rules.

affirmative defense [p. 195]

40
New cards
  1. No duty, no breach, no causation, out-of-scope harm, or no actual damage may each defeat a completed ____________ claim.

negligence [p. 195]

41
New cards
  1. A useful five-stage screening sequence is ____________, ____________, __________________, __________________, and ____________.

duty | breach | factual causation | scope of liability | actual damage [p. 195]

42
New cards
  1. An injury may be actually caused by the defendant's conduct yet be too ____________ for responsibility under legal causation.

remote [p. 195]

43
New cards
  1. The term 'negligence' may mean the __________________, merely ____________, or the combination of __________________ in legal usage.

entire cause of action | breach | duty and breach [pp. 194-196]

44
New cards
  1. The casebook addresses breach before detailed chapters on ____________, ____________, and ____________.

factual cause | legal cause | duty [pp. 194-196]

45
New cards
  1. The decision in __________________ illustrates the distinction between the court's no-duty determination and the jury's ordinary-care determination.

Cabral v. Ralphs Grocery Co. [p. 194]

46
New cards
  1. Under the text, the judge can resolve breach against a party where __________________ could find otherwise.

no reasonable jury [p. 194]

47
New cards

H2.1 A driver carelessly runs a red light but nobody is struck and no property is damaged. Analyze: Identify which negligence element is missing for damages.

Actual loss or damage is absent; breach alone is not a completed compensatory negligence claim.

48
New cards

H2.2 An employee breaches an apparent safety practice, causing a stranger economic inconvenience far beyond the incident. Analyze: Identify the separate questions of duty, factual cause, and scope of liability.

First whether a legal duty extends to the plaintiff, then whether breach actually caused the loss, then whether the loss fits within scope of liability; none is automatically answered by an unreasonable act.

49
New cards

H2.3 A cyclist and motorist both failed to watch for traffic when they collided. Analyze: What claim element and what defense must be analyzed separately?

Evaluate the motorist’s negligence elements; separately analyze the cyclist’s contributory/comparative fault under the governing jurisdiction.

50
New cards
  1. A legal conclusion of no ____________ is different from finding that conduct did not ____________ an existing duty.

duty | breach [pp. 194-195]

51
New cards
  1. Unlike many intentional torts, a negligence claim requires proof of ____________.

actual damage [pp. 194-195]

52
New cards
  1. A plaintiff's __________________ addresses the plaintiff's conduct and generally belongs to the defenses analysis rather than replacing proof of defendant breach.

comparative fault [pp. 194-195]

53
New cards
  1. The ____________ ordinarily bears the burden of proving the essential negligence elements.

plaintiff [pp. 194-195; standard proof measure is general civil context]

54
New cards
  1. The ____________ ordinarily bears the burden of establishing an affirmative defense such as comparative fault, subject to local procedural law.

defendant [pp. 194-195; standard proof measure is general civil context]

55
New cards
  1. The ordinary civil proof measure is __________________.

preponderance of the evidence [pp. 194-195; standard proof measure is general civil context]

56
New cards
  1. Actual injury can support ____________ damages, whereas an entirely harmless technical breach does not establish a completed negligence action.

compensatory [p. 195]

57
New cards
  1. If threatened conduct creates an actionable nuisance, an ____________ may sometimes be available although negligence damages have not yet accrued.

injunction [p. 195]

58
New cards
  1. The textbook identifies '__________________' as the terminology favored by the Restatement (Third) to separate legal cause from factual cause.

scope of liability [p. 195]

59
New cards
  1. A state's treatment of __________________ versus __________________ can alter recovery even when plaintiff fault is established.

contributory negligence | comparative fault [p. 195]

60
New cards
  1. The key breach inquiry asks whether the defendant acted as a __________________ would act under the ____________.

reasonable person | circumstances [pp. 196-211]

61
New cards
  1. Reasonable care is an ____________ evaluation of the conduct rather than a guarantee that no accident will occur.

objective [pp. 196-211]

62
New cards
  1. __________________ of risks is relevant in evaluating whether precautions were reasonable before the accident.

Foreseeability [pp. 197-211]

63
New cards
  1. ____________ analysis assesses the burden of precautions alongside the probability and magnitude of harm.

Risk-utility [pp. 197-211]

64
New cards
  1. The ____________ denotes the burden of precaution by B, probability of harm by P, and loss magnitude by L.

Hand formula [pp. 197-211]

65
New cards
  1. The fact that an accident occurred does not, without more, establish ____________.

breach [pp. 196-202]

66
New cards
  1. A reasonable person normally anticipates risks indicated by __________________, but is not necessarily required to anticipate an unprecedented catastrophe.

ordinary experience [pp. 196-202]

67
New cards
  1. When a warning makes repeat danger foreseeable, failure to take precautions may be ____________.

unreasonable [pp. 196-202]

68
New cards
  1. To prove breach, the plaintiff must show conduct below the applicable standard of __________________.

reasonable care [pp. 196-211]

69
New cards
  1. Reasonable precautions may include ____________, ____________, ____________, or different methods of acting, depending on the circumstances.

warnings | inspection | maintenance [pp. 196-211]

70
New cards
  1. The Hand formula considers the ____________ of preventive action, the ____________ of injury, and the likely ____________ of injury.

burden | probability | gravity [pp. 198-211]

71
New cards
  1. A risk may become foreseeable when there is an earlier __________________ that changes what the defendant should anticipate.

warning incident [pp. 198-211]

72
New cards
  1. One must assess the __________________ rather than reasoning only from hindsight.

information available before the accident [pp. 198-211]

73
New cards
  1. An extraordinary event may not make prior conduct negligent if a reasonable actor could not have ____________ that event.

anticipated [pp. 197-210]

74
New cards
  1. The absence of prior similar accidents is relevant but not always ____________ of reasonable care.

dispositive [pp. 197-210]

75
New cards
  1. Even a commonly used precaution may be inadequate if the risk it leaves is still ____________.

unreasonable [pp. 197-210]

76
New cards
  1. Judge Hand's algebraic expression for an unreasonable omission is ____________.

B < P × L [pp. 207-210]

77
New cards
  1. The formula compares the cost of the untaken ____________ to the expected ____________.

precaution | accident loss [pp. 207-210]

78
New cards
  1. Reasonable care generally must be measured ____________, from a perspective before the harm occurred.

ex ante [pp. 207-210]

79
New cards
  1. Risks associated with objects are not identical: a harmless-looking ____________ differs from a readily dangerous __________________.

golf club | loaded firearm [pp. 196-211]

80
New cards
  1. The reasonableness of precautions for unusual weather depends on what conditions were __________________.

reasonably predictable [pp. 196-211]

81
New cards
  1. The text explores reasonable care through ____________, __________________, and __________________.

probability | seriousness of harm | burden of prevention [pp. 196-211]

82
New cards
  1. In __________________ (text p. 196), A child injured by a swung golf club sued the father who had left it in the yard; the court found no adequately pleaded ____________ by the father.

Lubitz v. Wells | negligence [p. 196]

83
New cards
  1. In __________________ (text p. 197), An unusually severe frost damaged a water pipe; the court rejected negligence because the freezing exceeded __________________ conditions.

Blyth v. Birmingham Waterworks Co. | ordinary foreseeable [p. 197]

84
New cards
  1. In __________________ (text p. 199), After a passenger grabbed a steering wheel once, the driver took no precautions before a second grab and crash; a jury could find ____________.

Pipher v. Parsell | breach [p. 199]

85
New cards
  1. In __________________ (text p. 205), A car broke through a bridge approach railing; the court rejected a finding of negligence based solely on expectations of protection beyond a __________________.

Davison v. Snohomish County | reasonable railing [p. 205]

86
New cards
  1. In __________________ (text p. 207), A drifting barge with no bargee was damaged; Judge Hand assessed the precaution burden against the __________________ of loss.

United States v. Carroll Towing Co. | probability and gravity [p. 207]

87
New cards
  1. The presence of an ordinary golf club, without facts showing an __________________ situation, did not establish the father's negligence. A child actively swinging it presents a __________________ question.

unreasonably dangerous | different conduct [Lubitz v. Wells, p. 196]

88
New cards
  1. The defendant was not negligent for failing to guard against a __________________ where reasonable precautions addressed ordinary conditions.

historically extraordinary frost [Blyth v. Birmingham Waterworks Co., p. 197]

89
New cards
  1. A first unexpected interference may be unforeseeable, but a __________________ after notice can create a jury question about reasonable precautions.

repeated danger [Pipher v. Parsell, p. 199]

90
New cards
  1. The county need not provide an __________________ against any possible collision; the question is reasonable precautions for anticipated conditions.

unlimited level of barrier strength [Davison v. Snohomish County, p. 205]

91
New cards
  1. The Hand expression ____________ frames the reasonable-precaution inquiry; a bargee should have been aboard during the __________________ absent an excuse.

B < PL | daylight working hours [United States v. Carroll Towing Co., p. 207]

92
New cards
  1. Application drill: After a previous dangerous steering-wheel grab, a driver must consider taking __________________ before the next foreseeable grab.

reasonable preventive steps [pp. 199-211; numeric examples newly drafted]

93
New cards
  1. Application drill: A precaution costing B=10 against a probability P=.2 and loss L=100 has PL=____________, so B is ____________ the expected loss.

20 | less than [pp. 199-211; numeric examples newly drafted]

94
New cards
  1. Application drill: With B=100, P=.01, and L=100, the expected loss is ____________, below the precaution burden.

1 [pp. 199-211; numeric examples newly drafted]

95
New cards

H3.1 A park employee receives one report that a child has tampered with a swing, but takes no action; it fails the next morning. Analyze: What changes the foreseeability assessment, and what facts affect breach?

The prior warning makes the danger more foreseeable; the time available, inspection burden, risk probability, and possible injury severity matter.

96
New cards

H3.2 A safety measure costs $15; an accident has probability .03 and would cause $1,000 damage. Analyze: Apply the Hand inequality and state a limitation of that calculation.

PL = 30, which exceeds B = 15; omitting the measure tends toward unreasonable risk under Hand, but the formula informs rather than mechanically determines all breach questions.

97
New cards

H3.3 A water utility follows established precautions before an unprecedented freeze destroys pipes. Analyze: Does the resulting loss alone show a lack of reasonable care?

No. Under Blyth the relevant question is whether the risk was reasonably anticipated at the time and whether precautions were reasonable for such risks.

98
New cards
  1. A low likelihood of harm may still require care if the possible harm is ____________ and prevention is inexpensive.

very severe [pp. 207-211]

99
New cards
  1. Hand formula analysis is a __________________, not a universal mechanical verdict rule in every jurisdiction.

risk-utility framing [pp. 207-211]

100
New cards
  1. Reasonable care considers risks before the accident; __________________ later addresses which consequences remain within the legal scope of liability.

proximate cause [pp. 207-211]