1/383
Looks like no tags are added yet.
As an independent tort, negligence began to emerge in the early ____________ century, roughly around ____________.
nineteenth | 1825 [pp. 193-194]
Prior to independent negligence liability, the term sometimes referred generally to the __________________ or to inadvertence or inattention within other torts.
breach of any legal obligation [pp. 193-194]
Industrial Revolution [pp. 193-194]
common carrier | innkeeper | blacksmith | surgeon [p. 193]
trespass on the case [p. 193]
trespass | case [p. 193]
independent basis of tort liability [p. 193]
negligence [p. 193]
inattention [pp. 193-195]
machinery | railways [p. 193]
intentional injuries | unintended injuries [pp. 193-194]
context [pp. 193-194]
H1.1 A nineteenth-century railway accident injures a traveler without any deliberate contact. Analyze: What legal development made an independent suit possible? Identify the likely liability theory.
The emergence of negligence from trespass on the case as an independent cause of action; ordinary negligence rather than an intentional tort if no intent to produce the relevant contact.
H1.2 A student argues: “Negligence is just one type of intentional battery.” Analyze: Explain why the historical use of the term “negligent battery” cannot determine the modern cause of action.
Modern tort law distinguishes intentional conduct directed toward the contact from unreasonable conduct causing unintended harm; the historical phrase is an outdated classification.
H1.3 A plaintiff knows a factory was dangerous but has no evidence of personal harm. Analyze: Does the history of negligence create a damages claim?
No. Historical evolution does not replace the modern elements, including legally sufficient damage.
intent | reasonable care [p. 193]
intentional touching | unreasonable unintended injury [p. 193]
cause of action [p. 194]
common law [p. 193]
five [pp. 194-195]
second [pp. 194-195]
Duty [pp. 194-195]
Breach [pp. 194-195]
Factual causation [pp. 194-195]
Scope of liability | proximate cause | legal cause [pp. 194-195]
Actual loss or damage [pp. 194-195]
duty [pp. 194-195]
causation | damage [pp. 194-195]
scope of liability [pp. 194-195]
reasonable care [pp. 194-195]
breached [pp. 194-195]
actual/factual cause [pp. 194-195]
scope of liability [pp. 194-195]
actual loss or damage [pp. 194-195]
question of law | court [pp. 194-195]
question of fact | jury [pp. 194-195]
contributory negligence | comparative fault [pp. 194-195]
nominal [p. 195]
affirmative defense [p. 195]
negligence [p. 195]
duty | breach | factual causation | scope of liability | actual damage [p. 195]
remote [p. 195]
entire cause of action | breach | duty and breach [pp. 194-196]
factual cause | legal cause | duty [pp. 194-196]
Cabral v. Ralphs Grocery Co. [p. 194]
no reasonable jury [p. 194]
H2.1 A driver carelessly runs a red light but nobody is struck and no property is damaged. Analyze: Identify which negligence element is missing for damages.
Actual loss or damage is absent; breach alone is not a completed compensatory negligence claim.
H2.2 An employee breaches an apparent safety practice, causing a stranger economic inconvenience far beyond the incident. Analyze: Identify the separate questions of duty, factual cause, and scope of liability.
First whether a legal duty extends to the plaintiff, then whether breach actually caused the loss, then whether the loss fits within scope of liability; none is automatically answered by an unreasonable act.
H2.3 A cyclist and motorist both failed to watch for traffic when they collided. Analyze: What claim element and what defense must be analyzed separately?
Evaluate the motorist’s negligence elements; separately analyze the cyclist’s contributory/comparative fault under the governing jurisdiction.
duty | breach [pp. 194-195]
actual damage [pp. 194-195]
comparative fault [pp. 194-195]
plaintiff [pp. 194-195; standard proof measure is general civil context]
defendant [pp. 194-195; standard proof measure is general civil context]
preponderance of the evidence [pp. 194-195; standard proof measure is general civil context]
compensatory [p. 195]
injunction [p. 195]
scope of liability [p. 195]
contributory negligence | comparative fault [p. 195]
reasonable person | circumstances [pp. 196-211]
objective [pp. 196-211]
Foreseeability [pp. 197-211]
Risk-utility [pp. 197-211]
Hand formula [pp. 197-211]
breach [pp. 196-202]
ordinary experience [pp. 196-202]
unreasonable [pp. 196-202]
reasonable care [pp. 196-211]
warnings | inspection | maintenance [pp. 196-211]
burden | probability | gravity [pp. 198-211]
warning incident [pp. 198-211]
information available before the accident [pp. 198-211]
anticipated [pp. 197-210]
dispositive [pp. 197-210]
unreasonable [pp. 197-210]
B < P × L [pp. 207-210]
precaution | accident loss [pp. 207-210]
ex ante [pp. 207-210]
golf club | loaded firearm [pp. 196-211]
reasonably predictable [pp. 196-211]
probability | seriousness of harm | burden of prevention [pp. 196-211]
Lubitz v. Wells | negligence [p. 196]
Blyth v. Birmingham Waterworks Co. | ordinary foreseeable [p. 197]
Pipher v. Parsell | breach [p. 199]
Davison v. Snohomish County | reasonable railing [p. 205]
United States v. Carroll Towing Co. | probability and gravity [p. 207]
unreasonably dangerous | different conduct [Lubitz v. Wells, p. 196]
historically extraordinary frost [Blyth v. Birmingham Waterworks Co., p. 197]
repeated danger [Pipher v. Parsell, p. 199]
unlimited level of barrier strength [Davison v. Snohomish County, p. 205]
B < PL | daylight working hours [United States v. Carroll Towing Co., p. 207]
reasonable preventive steps [pp. 199-211; numeric examples newly drafted]
20 | less than [pp. 199-211; numeric examples newly drafted]
1 [pp. 199-211; numeric examples newly drafted]
H3.1 A park employee receives one report that a child has tampered with a swing, but takes no action; it fails the next morning. Analyze: What changes the foreseeability assessment, and what facts affect breach?
The prior warning makes the danger more foreseeable; the time available, inspection burden, risk probability, and possible injury severity matter.
H3.2 A safety measure costs $15; an accident has probability .03 and would cause $1,000 damage. Analyze: Apply the Hand inequality and state a limitation of that calculation.
PL = 30, which exceeds B = 15; omitting the measure tends toward unreasonable risk under Hand, but the formula informs rather than mechanically determines all breach questions.
H3.3 A water utility follows established precautions before an unprecedented freeze destroys pipes. Analyze: Does the resulting loss alone show a lack of reasonable care?
No. Under Blyth the relevant question is whether the risk was reasonably anticipated at the time and whether precautions were reasonable for such risks.
very severe [pp. 207-211]
risk-utility framing [pp. 207-211]
proximate cause [pp. 207-211]