1/69
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What are the 5 elements of a contract?
(1) Agreement, (2) between competent parties, (3) based on assent ("meeting of the minds"), (4) supported by consideration, (5) for a lawful purpose.
OAK (O+A=K)
Offer + Acceptance = Kontract (contract).
What can the subject matter of a contract include?
Goods, services or property.
Formal vs. informal contracts: give examples of each.
FORMAL: written contracts, contracts under seal, contracts of record, negotiable instruments. INFORMAL: oral contracts, handshake deals, all other non-formal contracts.
Valid vs. voidable vs. void
VALID = binding and enforceable. VOIDABLE = can be cancelled at the option of one party (fraud, mistake, incapacity). VOID = no legal effect at all (e.g., illegal subject matter).
Bilateral vs. unilateral contract
BILATERAL = a promise in exchange for a promise. UNILATERAL = one party promises to perform after the other party does a designated act (e.g., reward).
What 3 things does a claim of unjust enrichment require?
(i) A benefit is conferred, (ii) the defendant KNOWS of the benefit, (iii) it would be unjust to keep the benefit without paying.
What can help establish quantum meruit?
Expert testimony (on the reasonable value of the work).
ADP Marshall, Inc. v. Brown University
Quantum meruit: the contractor was entitled to the reasonable value of the benefit it conferred on Brown for a sports facility.
What 3 things are required for a valid offer?
(1) Contractual intention, (2) definiteness, (3) communication of the offer to the offeree.
What standard decides whether there was contractual intention?
The reasonably prudent person standard, based on the facts and circumstances.
Classified ads, mere price quotations and social invitations are…
Not offers: they lack contractual intent (classified ads and price quotes are invitations to negotiate).
What is required to revoke an offer?
A clear expression by the offeror to revoke (withdraw), preferably in writing, communicated to the offeree before acceptance.
TIREDS (ways an offer terminates)
Time lapse (deadline, or a reasonable time); Incapacity or death of a party; Revocation communicated to the offeree; Express rejection or counteroffer by the offeree; Destruction of the subject of the offer; Subsequent illegality.
Termination of an offer BY THE OFFEROR vs. BY THE OFFEREE (slide 136)
By offeror: revocation before acceptance, death or incapacity, time limits in the offer. By offeree: rejection, counteroffer, death or incapacity.
For a rejection to end an offer, what must the offeree do?
Reject AND communicate the rejection to the offeror.
Kervakos Textiles, Inc. v. CRA Development, Inc.
Counteroffer: a commercial tenant could not go back and accept an earlier lease offer after making a counteroffer.
What is subsequent illegality?
A change in law that makes the subject matter of the contract illegal, which terminates the offer.
Death or disability terminates an offer. What type of contract does the slide flag?
Personal services contracts.
What constitutes an acceptance, and what is its effect?
A clear expression of acceptance in whatever mode (preferably in writing). Effect: it creates a binding agreement.
Acceptance flowchart: what happens if the offeree accepts unconditionally? Changes or adds terms? Rejects?
Unconditional acceptance = contract. Changes/adds terms = counteroffer (the original offeror can then accept, counter again or reject). Rejects = no contract.
Does the Mailbox Rule apply to email, text, FedEx and fax?
Yes. Acceptance is effective when sent by modern electronic forms too.
How can an offeror avoid confusion from the Mailbox Rule?
As master of the offer, require that acceptance is effective only upon RECEIPT and countersignature by the offeror.
Mailbox scenario: Sept 1 seller mails offer; Sept 2 buyer receives it and mails acceptance; Sept 3 seller calls to revoke; Sept 4 acceptance arrives. Is there a contract, and when?
YES. A contract was formed on SEPTEMBER 2, when the acceptance was mailed. The Sept 3 revocation came too late.
In an auction, who makes the offer and when is the contract formed?
The BIDDER makes the offer. The contract forms when the auctioneer accepts the highest bid (when the hammer falls).
Define contractual capacity.
The ability to understand that a legally binding contract is being made.
Status incapacity vs. factual incapacity
STATUS = minors (under 18). FACTUAL = mental incompetence due to medication, intoxication, drugs, illness or senility.
I-I-I (incapacity)
Infancy (minor); Incompetency (insanity, senility); Intoxication (drugs or alcohol).
When may a minor disaffirm a contract?
Only while still a minor or very shortly after turning 18. Otherwise the contract is deemed ratified.
Minor's incapacity is a ___, not a ___.
A SHIELD (to protect the minor), not a SWORD (to hurt the other party).
Restitution: what must a minor return after disaffirming?
Whatever they received if they still have it. If the property was sold to a third party, the trend is for the minor to pay its reasonable value.
Who is liable for a minor's necessaries?
The parent/guardian, but the minor becomes liable as an adult if the parents don't pay (Schmidt v. Prince George's Hospital).
Schmidt v. Prince George's Hospital
When the minor turned 18, she became liable for her hospital bill after her parents failed to pay.
Which contracts can't minors avoid (slide examples)?
Education loans and contracts made while running a business.
Is a parent liable for a minor's non-necessaries?
Generally no, unless the parent co-signed the contract.
Wilcox Manufacturing case
Once the company president recovered from his mental incapacity and failed to revoke the contract, it was ratified.
Cow v. Colt (slide 148)
Mutual mistake of JUDGMENT (e.g., about value) does not make a contract voidable; only mutual mistake of a basic material FACT does.
Elements of fraudulent misrepresentation
A material misrepresentation of FACT, (i) made with knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for the truth, and (ii) the listener relies and is harmed.
Nondisclosure: the 4 general rules
(1) No duty to educate/volunteer info; puffery allowed. (2) Buyer does due diligence and asks; seller answers truthfully, no liability for obvious defects. (3) Seller must disclose latent defects buyer can't discover. (4) Seller is liable for ACTIVE CONCEALMENT.
Undue influence
When the party benefitting is in a position of extreme power over another who can't exercise free will (e.g., domination of the aged). The contract may be voidable.
Physical duress vs. economic duress
PHYSICAL = threat of physical force to the party or a relative causing serious injury or property damage. ECONOMIC = contract induced by a threat of financial loss, entered against free will.
4 grounds for avoiding a contract (review diagram)
Lack of capacity (status, factual), Mistake (unilateral known, mutual), Deception (fraud, nondisclosure), Pressure (undue influence, duress).
Define consideration (bargained-for exchange).
What each party gives the other in making the agreement, the "price" of the contract for each side: money, goods, services, property or forbearance.
What is the alternative view of consideration?
The benefit-detriment approach.
Salsbury v. Northwestern Bell
A promise of a charitable contribution was binding even without consideration.
Hamer v. Sidway (1891) and Jennings v. Radio Station KSCS
Forbearance IS consideration.
Promissory estoppel (detrimental reliance)
If the promisee relies on the promise and suffers a detriment, the promisor is estopped from claiming the promise is unenforceable for lack of consideration.
Chrysler v. Chaplake and Hoffman v. Red Owl Stores
Promissory estoppel. Chaplake relied on Chrysler's promise to expand Lamborghini distribution; Hoffman relied on Red Owl's promise of a Wisconsin franchise.
4 kinds of contracts a court won't enforce (illegality)
Contracts requiring a tort or crime; contracts contrary to public policy; unconscionable contracts; contracts entered into by the unlicensed.
Neiman v. Provident
Unauthorized practice of law without a license voided an otherwise legal disability-insurance agreement.
What is a contract of adhesion?
A take-it-or-leave-it contract with extremely one-sided terms. May be voidable as unconscionable.
Circuit City v. Adams
An arbitration clause was unenforceable as unconscionable: unequal bargaining power and improper limits on the employee's remedies.
Examples of agreements contrary to public policy
Money for sex, contracts for drug paraphernalia or gambling machines (harm public welfare, health or safety).
When may gambling be permitted?
When statutes allow it to raise funds or for charity (church raffles, bingo night).
TISSUES (enforceability of restrictive covenants)
Time (reasonable?); Inability to work elsewhere; Space (geography too broad?); SUE: Special, Unique, Extraordinary services; Sale (part of selling a company?).
What is usury, and which loans are usually exempt?
A lender charging an individual borrower more interest than the law allows. Usually not applicable to bank loans, mortgages, credit cards or loans to corporations.
Why do courts examine unnecessary transaction fees?
To see if a usurious loan is disguised as a legitimate transaction.
SMARLEY (Statute of Frauds, 1677)
Sale of goods over $500; Marriage; Answer for another's debt (surety); Real estate; Leases over one year; Executor/administrator promise to pay a decedent's debts; Year (can't be performed within one year).
Airline Construction v. Barr
Parol (oral) evidence could NOT be introduced to show the contractor had extra time to build a hotel, contrary to the written contract.
AMP (exceptions to the Parol Evidence Rule)
Ambiguity of the contract; Modification (later modified or terminated); Pressure (fraud, duress or mistake).
Anatomy of a contract: the 7 typical provisions
(A) Recitals ("Whereas" clauses), (B) Definitions, (C) Consideration, (D) Reps & warranties, (E) Covenants, (F) Conditions, (G) Closing deliveries.
Recitals
"Whereas" clauses that tell the story of why the parties are entering into the contract.
Closing deliveries (examples)
Purchase price, clear title, endorsed shares, an officer's certificate that covenants are true and correct.
Definitions in a contract must be…
Used consistently.
[BOOK] UCC firm offer: requirements
A MERCHANT's SIGNED, WRITTEN offer to buy or sell goods that says it's irrevocable. No consideration needed; maximum 3 months.
[BOOK] Who may accept an offer?
Only the offeree (the person the offer was made to).
[BOOK] Who must sign the writing under the Statute of Frauds?
The party against whom enforcement is sought (the defendant).
[BOOK] Interpreting conflicting terms: which prevails?
Handwriting beats typing, and typing beats a printed form. Ambiguity is interpreted against the party who drafted the contract.
[BOOK] If a minor lies about their age, can they still disaffirm?
Generally yes (some states bar it or make the minor pay for damage), and the other party may disaffirm because of the minor's fraud.
[BOOK] Can a minor disaffirm a contract for necessaries?
Yes, but they must pay the reasonable value of necessaries furnished.