1/27
Flashcards covering classical origins, UK arrangements, statutory interpretation, and theoretical schools of thought regarding the Separation of Powers and the Rule of Law.
Rule of Law (RoL)
An ideal of political morality referring to the importance of law and legal institutions in a system of governance.
Separation of Powers (SoP)
An ideal pattern of governance where responsibilities are separated into three different branches—legislative, executive, and judiciary—to stave off the concentration of power, prevent abuse of power, and diversify government liabilities.
Aristotle's Constitutional Elements
The three components of each constitution identified in The Politics: the deliberative element (discussing matters of common importance), the official element, and the judicial element.
Baron de Montesquieu
Author of The Spirit of the Laws (1748) who argued that political liberty is absent when legislative, executive, and judicial powers are united in the same person or body of magistracy.
Burmah Oil v Lord Advocate [1965] AC 75
A judicial decision that was retrospectively overturned by Parliament through the War Damage Act 1965, illustrating absolute Parliamentary Sovereignty in the UK.
Formal Unity
The constitutional arrangement in the UK where branches overlap rather than strictly separate, exemplified by the Crown-in-council and government ministers serving as Members of Parliament.
Constitutional Reform Act 2005
An Act that advanced the Separation of Powers in the UK by reforming the office of the Lord Chancellor, establishing the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom (UKSC), and legally protecting judicial independence.
Courts Act 2003 (Part 1)
Legislation establishing the duty of the Lord Chancellor to ensure an efficient and effective system to support carrying on the business of the courts of England and Wales.
Literal Rule
A statutory interpretation rule requiring that clear statutory words must be followed even if they lead to manifest absurdity, as stated by Lord Esher in R v Judge of the City of London (1892).
Golden Rule
A rule of statutory interpretation where, if a literal reading leads to an absurdity, the court examines the context of the provision to achieve a more sensible application.
Adler v George [1964] 2 QB 7
A case under the Official Secrets Act 1920 where the golden rule was applied to treat being inside a prohibited place as being 'in the vicinity', avoiding the absurdity of exempting someone directly within it.
London and North Eastern Railway v Berriman [1946] AC 278
A case where track oiling was held under the literal rule not to constitute 'relaying or repairing', denying compensation because the outcome, though harsh, was not technically absurd.
Mischief Rule
A statutory interpretation approach that asks what defect in the prior law the enactment intended to remedy, construing the statute in a manner that prevents that defect from reoccurring.
Royal College of Nursing v DHSS [1981] 2 WLR 279
A case where the mischief rule was applied to hold that nurses administering hormonal abortions fell within the defense of the Abortion Act 1967, which aimed to eliminate unsafe back-street abortions.
Pepper (Inspector of Taxes) v Hart (1993)
The ruling establishing that courts may refer to Hansard to consider statements by a minister introducing a Bill explaining what a particular statutory provision was intended to achieve.
Purposive Interpretation
An approach where judges fill statutory gaps by imagining what lawmakers would have done; widely accepted in continental Europe and the US, but rejected in the UK as contrary to Parliamentary Sovereignty.
Judicial Activism
A judicial philosophy where courts go beyond the applicable law to consider the broader societal implications of their decisions, pejoratively termed 'judicial supremacism' by critics.
Judicial Restraint (Deference)
A judicial philosophy where the judiciary refrains from deciding fundamental or political issues, deferring instead to the elected political branches.
A.V. Dicey's Definition of the Rule of Law
The principle that no individual is punishable or can be lawfully made to suffer in body or goods except for a distinct breach of law established in the ordinary legal manner before the ordinary courts.
Formal (Content-Free) Theories of the RoL
Theories focusing strictly on procedure and the principle of legality, requiring that public power be exercised according to pre-existing, publicly known, and generally applicable rules regardless of moral content.
Joseph Raz's Analogy of the Rule of Law
The positivist concept that the Rule of Law is like a 'sharp knife,' serving as an efficient procedural instrument capable of being used for any political purpose.
Substantive (Content-Rich) Theories of the RoL
Theories rooted in natural law asserting that laws are only binding if they conform to higher moral and political ideals, such as human rights, fairness, democracy, and social justice.
John Rawls's Mixed Theory of the RoL
A framework combining formal legality (regular, impartial administration and non-retroactivity) with substantive justice aimed at maximizing the position of society's most disadvantaged.
Lord Bingham's Eight Sub-Rules
A comprehensive eight-point formulation of the Rule of Law covering legal clarity, minimal discretion, equality, lawful use of power, human rights, affordable dispute resolution, fair trials, and international law compliance.
A and others v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2004] UKHL 56
The 'Belmarsh 9' case in which the House of Lords ruled 8:1 that indefinite detention of non-UK terrorism suspects under the ATCSA 2001 disproportionately discriminated against foreigners contrary to Article 14 ECHR.
Declaration of Incompatibility
A formal order issued under Section 4 of the Human Rights Act 1998 declaring a UK statute incompatible with the ECHR without invalidating the law or immediately terminating detention under it.
Prevention of Terrorism Act 2005
A statute passed in response to the Belmarsh decision that introduced a 'control order regime' permitting detention without trial for both UK and foreign terrorism suspects.
Terrorism Prevention and Investigation Measures Act 2011
Legislation that replaced control orders with time-limited 'terrorism prevention and investigation measures' (TPIMs) of more restricted scope.